The Register Home Page

back to article Google's search revenue Ferrari hits an AI-powered speed bump

Google is paying a higher price for its bet on AI than even Alphabet's $51.4 billion in Q3 capital expenditures suggest. The biz appears to have traded its high-performing search advertising business for the mediocre monetization of AI Overviews and AI Mode, a misstep that contributed to investor concerns as Alphabet lost …

  1. Press any key

    Ha-ha

    Is what I said when I heard about this on the (radio) news this morning.

    Foot meet high speed projectile.

  2. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
    Coat

    "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

    "so it's clear that Search usage isn't declining."

    But who is requesting those searches, or more to the point, what ?

    If it's model training that's responsible, then that's AI sucking on its own… well you know what I mean… although bit of a mouthful, I admit.

    The few searches I have made with Google bave been from within applications with Google hard coded and have been seriously crap, reminiscent of Talkie Toaster in its suggestions I might wish to complement my query with a purchase of something totally unrelated.

    Adding insult to injury the results of the query are often plain wrong or at best, irrelevant.

    Bugger the turtles, it's now shit all the way down.

    1. Dan 55 Silver badge

      Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

      I suspect it's repeated searches, because for some reason people aren't happy with search results telling them to glue pizza and eat rocks.

      1. Gene Cash Silver badge

        Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

        Exactly. My deep fryer died, so I went to Amazon, and they gave me trash like breader bowls, meat tenderizers, and funnels.

        I went to Google and didn't get anything better. I finally had to go to the brand sites by hand.

        It's like it's 1995 all over again, except Altavista and Yahoo internet directory was actually better.

        1. Bran Muffin

          Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

          The Amazon search is now, and has always been, horrible.

        2. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

          Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

          "except Altavista and Yahoo internet directory was actually better"

          I don't know about Yahoo but I'm not sure Google ever matched Altavista. It's all been downhill since that expired.

      2. BoHu
        Windows

        Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

        Yeah, I've switched over to DDG (yuck) since Google's AI (so-called) summaries became so invasively intrusive. DDG's news wrapped in MSN fluff and real slow-to-load Apple maps are doggone terrible, but at least they don't induce the same symptoms of seasickness that roundabout AI summaries do to me at present.

        ISTM that in current Google search, all the good links are buried deep inside AI summaries, playing hide-and-seek with completely useless links, and the text links that follow are even dafter -- much more so than before the new wondrous tech. In savory old days, Google named its Androids Eclair, Ice Cream Sandwich, Nougat and the likes, and if current AI search summaries followed this trend, they may be called Baba Au Rhum (rum baba), but not in a good way imho -- they'd be like a rhum baba buried under a foot of spray-on whipped cream and a thick helmet of maraschino cherries -- you'd need weeks of digging-in to get to the minuscule rum-infused sponge cake buried deep at its yummy core, with only the most queasy-resistant meatbags ever making it all the way through ... if any. Kinda like hot-dog eating contests, they could have championships to find who can get to the baba the fastest without getting a full-on stroke.

        They'll have to figure some less passive-hypertensive-inducing way of presenting their search results (the few good ones) to win me back over I say!

    2. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

      Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

      "That means people spend more time than ever looking for information" ... and not finding it because the ads and sponsored results keep getting in the way.

      1. cbri

        Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

        And let’s not forgot AI slop SEO-d webpages.

    3. Rameses Niblick the Third Kerplunk Kerplunk Whoops Where's My Thribble?

      Re: "Search query growth rate [was] the highest it has been in the last five years in Q3,…"

      "reminiscent of Talkie Toaster in its suggestions "

      Howdy Doodly Do! Would you like some toast?

    4. DS999 Silver badge

      Query rates are increasing because of AI slop

      The quality of traditional searches decline the more AI generated slop links there are in the results. So you need to search more / refine your terms more if you want to use traditional search.

      That's why I'm pretty much using AI for searches (duck.ai via DuckDuckGo) now as traditional search is become more and more slop infested - and that's true whether I use DDG or whether I use !g to see what Google says.

      So I'm more focused on what duck.ai returns, and have been tailoring my queries more directly at it. Because a lot of the time when I'd use search I had a specific question in mind that wasn't a simple fact like "when was Ben Franklin born" but was either a more complex question or I was looking for a process or product or whatever and would in the past use iterative searches to (eventually, hopefully) get there. Now I can often just ask the question, and even if it doesn't get me exactly what I want on the first pass it either points me in the right direction or I can iterate a bit to drill down to what I'm looking for.

      I think what Google ignores in their hope that they can monetize AI searching as much as traditional search (beyond the fact that they have way more competition because Google doesn't have an AI monopoly like they have a search monopoly) is that people search VERY differently with AI once they get used to using it instead. If used correctly, it requires a lot less iteration and a lot less clicking - so a lot less opportunity to show ads. And they can't just crank up the number of ads in their AI search, because that'll just push people to other alternatives.

  3. PhilipN Silver badge

    Everything online tends towards commoditisation

    Email went there. Streaming is there already. Cloud is moving there. Next - AI. Oh, dear - how sad - never mind.

    1. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Everything online tends towards commoditisation

      That's true, but it is possible to maintain islands that are at least somewhat exempt from commoditization. PCs became commoditized because of IBM clones, but Windows and to a somewhat less extent Office have avoided it. Android is deliberately "mostly" commoditized, but iPhone isn't - though I suppose you could argue that's hardware and if you're talking about "online" meaning only software then Windows/Office are the best examples I have for holdouts. Though perhaps it is because it predated the internet that it was able to stay outside it?

      All that said, I agree that AI will be commoditized. The "race" for spending endless money seems to be that they all assume that they if they can achieve a clear lead then they can be the one AI that can charge prices able to justify multi trillion valuations (or in Musk's wet dreams, tens of trillions) even if the rest of the field is a commodity.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Anybody else always ignore the "AI summary" in favor of the real results?

    n/t

    1. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Anybody else always ignore the "AI summary" in favor of the real results?

      You mean the increasingly AI generated slop links that make up the "real results" these days? Nope, I am explicitly looking for duck.ai to resolve my query so I don't need to look at the links, other than following the links it shows where it got the info if I want to double check or read further.

      And before you say "wait a minute, if you think the links are AI generated slop why do you want to look what duck.ai says, isn't that also AI generated slop?" I will say the two aren't comparable.

      The slop links are AI generated by people who are feeding them prompts to generate content that triggers a high page ranking. They don't care what it says or if it even makes sense, they just want it to reach the first page on Google for as many variations of search terms around its subject as possible so that they can serve ads to the suckers who click on it. The SEOs have been replaced by AI, who can do the SEO job 1000x faster and thus create 1000x more pages of useless crap. That SEO problem has been with us for two decades, but AI has supercharged the process of its creation. And it is making traditional search increasingly useless.

  5. juice

    Expected consequences are expected

    Google's traditional business model revolved around two key things.

    First, there were the consumers: people who wanted to find things - information, goods, news, etc. And so, they'd ask Google where to find said things.

    Then, there were the people who had the things. And Google was willing to direct the consumers over to these people. And if these people - these customers - were willing to give Google some money, then Google would be more likely to direct consumers to them.

    Nice, simple and everyone wins. Google makes money out of their customers, their customers make money out of the consumers, and the consumers get what they were looking for.

    And a key point here is that the consumers didn't directly pay Google. Sure, they got a few more adverts thrown at them on the customer websites, and/or the prices of the goods were a little bit higher, but the direct/visible cost to them was zero.

    Google's LLM "walled garden" breaks this model, at least when it comes to services. Because if the LLM can find answers for a consumer, then that consumer doesn't need to go to the customer's website. And that means that - assuming they don't go bankrupt - the customer doesn't have a reason to pay Google.

    And there's little to no chance that Google will be able to persuade the consumers to pay. Not least because Google has spent the last 30 years providing their services for free to them.

    Anecdotally, I've been using Google's LLM for various bits and pieces, such as checking to see if an Android tablet's screen is big enough to render an A4 page at full size, or what combination of SAS card/cables/HDDs will work with my main workstation, as well as researching what the most powerful CPU is that can be paired with my existing DDR4 ram.

    And that's all stuff that would have sent me trekking around various websites, potentially for hours. Now, I get the answers in seconds, and I don't need to visit any other websites. Great for me, but it sucks for the websites. And by extension, that sucks for Google as well.

    As own-goals go, that's quite a big one.

    1. Jellied Eel Silver badge

      Re: Expected consequences are expected

      And that's all stuff that would have sent me trekking around various websites, potentially for hours. Now, I get the answers in seconds, and I don't need to visit any other websites. Great for me, but it sucks for the websites. And by extension, that sucks for Google as well.

      It'll be fine. Various websites will probably be down because they've been DDoS'd by AlphaGoo's army of creepy crawlers. So you do a search "Who has the cheapest widget?". The response will be delayed by a few milliseconds while AlphaGoo run an auction and select the highest bidder.. Who may not have the lowest price, which may not be compatible with consumer law. Or selllers try to game the system by offering a low price, telling users it's out of stock, but their 'partner' will flog you the widget for only a few dollars more.

      But such is politics. AlphaGoo is one part of the $4tn 'AI' capex committment. Most of the techbros are all following the same 'strategy' and debt. Cashflow isn't keeping up with capex, borrowing costs are increasing, but it's a $4tn bet based on FOMO. And it'll all be paid for by adverts, ad spend is declining as advertisers realise they're wasting money, and users just hate adverts.

      But if you want an own-goal, the techbros will probably try to get you to buy a $20 goal net from China. Who are still making a lot of money from physical products, not chasing an ever more expensive and shrinking pot of 'services'.

  6. Tron Silver badge

    Dissenter searching for downvotes.

    I don't mind the Google AI search bit. Like the basic results, it is sometimes correct and sometimes way off. It's still free (I wouldn't pay extra for it) and each AI bit culled from a page has a clickable citation. The stuff I search for I almost always click on the page link anyway. Sometimes that doesn't work. Amusingly, using pocket WiFi, I got blocked by age authentication from an entirely benign hobbyist site, some sites are geoblocked, and others fall foul of Chrome's insanely restrictive demands for 'security'. Yes, Google search results have declined across the board and have been doing so for years, but it remains better than the alternatives. I don't click on ads and barely see them nowadays, without blocking them. My eyes just scan past them. Maybe more people are now doing that.

    Outside the billionaire's bubble, normal people are financially screwed at the moment, globally, and more so in the UK. Plus governments are charging higher fees to order stuff from abroad, even if it cannot be purchased locally, to bilk money from people on fake premises. The EU have just implemented even more charges. So people have less cash across the board. This means most companies will struggle to maintain their financial stats. Market sentiment on company growth figures is usually BS (because they have no idea what is really going on internally) but drives share prices. The retail economy is in decline and this is not likely to change as governments cut supply chains, raise interest rates, and find new ways to make up for lost tax revenue.

    People off this forum ('civilians'? 'norms'?), including people who hate AI as a job thief, seem to find the natural language interface acceptable. It's a pity they didn't just run with that. Perhaps what most of us hate is the scam element, that AI is magic and intelligent and the future. It's generally just computing with a natural language interface and a higher allowable margin for error, working on everyone else's stuff. It's not as revolutionary as it is being sold as. Which I'm sure we all find persistently annoying.

  7. This post has been deleted by its author

  8. 897241021271418289475167044396734464892349863592355648549963125148587659264921474689457046465304467

    My customers are not happy - traffic has dropped off a cliff since the AI sucked the life out of their websites. Buying ads doesn't help - those appear further down the page where very few potential customers look, neither does conventional SEO. Unconventional SEO can change the answers of the "AI" by a smidge or so, but that's all. It's a bloody disaster for small business websites. Many formerly thriving forums are now tumbleweed strewn ghost towns. Google have shot a lot of businesses in the head while shooting themselves in the foot.

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I find ChatGPT provides better answers than Google and with lot less ads to sift out. I can then follow up the query better as well. I suspect Google will never catch them. Google's main strategy has always been to keep other engines from reaching users. This approach will not work any more. Many are already paid customers of other AI's like ChatGPT. The paid models are quite amazing. I could not imagine trying to tutor my teens through high school without them. My kids are also quite good at learning on their own with it. Stuff like Calculus, they don't even need a tutor for as ChatGPT explains it quite well. Any problems in any subjects they don't understand, all they do is screeshot it into the paid account and everything the problem is explained very clearly. My kids are getting over 90% in their subjects with their new learning buddy. $25 per month is much cheaper than any tutor on a monthly basis.

  10. Scepticat1st

    Google Search? The 1990's called and what their search engine back....

    What a waste of time. Google Search is like the Swiss watch industry with the introduction of quartz watches in 1969. It took a few years but ultimately the industry all but disappeared. Bye Bye Google Search. You are no longer relevant.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon