The Register Home Page

back to article Oracle wants to bill you for every AI task, not just every seat

Oracle expects to earn more from existing application customers as it embeds AI in its enterprise software suite. Speaking at Big Red's investor day on Wednesday, Chris Leone, executive veep of application development, said Oracle will layer usage-based revenue on top of its subscription model. “The more work that gets done by …

  1. usbac

    "Our large remaining base of on-premises customers are going to start to adopt this technology quite quickly. When we move customers from on-premises to cloud, we see a multiple increase in revenue,"

    Becomes...

    Our large remaining base of on-premises customers are going to start to adopt this technology quite quickly. When we move customers from on-premises to cloud, they will see a multiple increase in costs.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      more more likley:

      "Our large remaining base of on-premises customers are going to stay where they are until they need to move. When customers move from on-premises to cloud, we see multiple migrate to another product,"

    2. EricM Silver badge

      As if anybody would have needed more red flags warning them of using Oracle ...

      1. Munchausen's proxy
        Big Brother

        I think companies and universities should start immediately to take a hard look at their VirtualBox exposure. Without even the benefit of AI, I predict that Oracle is going to decide that every downloaded copy is a customer, with all that entails.

  2. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Amateurs

    They should bill for every breath drawn when using software.

    In fact, they should just require to be added as joint account holder to customers' bank accounts.

    1. DS999 Silver badge
      Devil

      Wrong!

      They should bill for every breath drawn when using software

      What about people who hold their breath while using it? That's taking money out of Ellison's pocket!!

      You have to bill for every beat of the user's heart, and with a minimum of 60 beats per minute so that people who are fit don't get a discount!

      1. EricM Silver badge

        Re: Wrong!

        > so that people who are fit don't get a discount!

        ... and even dead people can no longer steal from Larry ...

    2. The Man Who Fell To Earth
      FAIL

      Re: Amateurs

      Their long-term plan is to bill for every molecule of oxygen their customer's employees breath. The employees only use those molecules temporarily and send them back "sooty" with a carbon atom attached.

      1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

        Re: Amateurs

        I meant to say almost the same thing/sentiment...

        "Oracle wants to bill you for every AI task, not just every seat [breath]"

        Only consolation is, Larry can't take it away with him when the Grim Reaper catches up with him. Not for what of trying by tech bro billionaires who are pumping money into being immortal.

  3. boblongii

    Oracle is doomed. It might make it to the end of this year; it won't survive 2027. They have hitched their entire business to someone else finding a way to make AI not just profitable but the most profitable thing that has ever existed in just 5 years.

    If you have shares, sell them.

    1. Herring`

      The numbers make it look that way. Who will mourn its passing?

      1. DS999 Silver badge
        Mushroom

        I just hope

        That all his and his son's holdings like the superyachts, mansions, and Paramount/Skydance have been financed via borrowing on Oracle shares so that when Oracle goes under they lose everything. Couldn't happen to a more deserving pair of cretins!

        1. Tim99 Silver badge
          Devil

          Re: I just hope

          Generally, when the very rich finance their lifestyle on borrowing against "assets" it is to avoid paying taxes.

          The "buy, borrow, die" strategy lets wealthy investors hold appreciating assets, borrow against them instead of selling, and pass assets to heirs at death to reduce taxes.

          Loans are treated as debt, not income; the rich can finance their lifestyles or investments without liquidating their holdings, which normally would incur taxes. Using assets as collateral also allows fo lower interest rates compared to unsecured loans. This makes borrowing more attractive. Borrowing against appreciating assets provides liquidity.

          Personally, I started writing stuff with Oracle V4 (MS-DOS). Being a slow learner, it wasn't until version 8 that I started to deliberately avoid using and recommending "One Rich Arsehole Called Larry Ellison".

          1. DS999 Silver badge

            Re: I just hope

            Yes I've long thought that taxing such debt is the way to tax the very rich, rather than the ridiculous and unwieldy solutions of taxing their assets. The debt they use is akin to the salary regular people take. If someone has assets of $1 billion but lives in a modest home ala Warren Buffett borrowing a mere $100K a year then fine tax them only on that $100K. But if they live on borrowing $100M a year they should be taxed as if that $100M was income.

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: I just hope

          As you know, he hooked up CBS and CNN (within skydance) just to play Israel and Trump propaganda. CBS ain't doing well as a result.

          I hope you're right!

          anti-democratic, anti-patriotic SOBs

    2. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
      Devil

      "If you have [Oracle] shares"

      Examine your soul.

  4. Rameses Niblick the Third Kerplunk Kerplunk Whoops Where's My Thribble?

    Where is the money coming from?

    So if as was reported last week, all the billionaires are convinced AI will help all us little people work a 4-day or even 3-day week for the same money, or allow families to once again survive on one income, how are our organisations going to afford to pay us like this when AI providers are screwing them for fees and charges? Hmm?

    (For clarity, this is exactly what I expected, I'm not naive enough to think they all suddenly came over all philanthropic!)

    1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

      Re: Where is the money coming from?

      > all the billionaires are convinced AI will help

      They need adrenochrome. Families will be required to sacrifice a child once a year to have their expenses covered.

    2. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Where is the money coming from?

      Yes yes just like Musk saying that AI makes saving for retirement unnecessary. They know if that people start thinking too closely about what happens if AI is as big of a thing as Musk et al want to believe that there are going to be far fewer jobs. And that when you have a lot fewer jobs and people are hungry they will bid down the price they're willing to take so it'll be more like a 6 day week for half the money just to scrape by sharing a small apartment with another family.

      No way any of these billionaire sociopaths who dream of becoming trillionaire sociopaths has any intention of sharing even a single penny with the rest of us. They wouldn't all be building bunkers if they weren't worried about people coming at them with torches and pitchforks.

      1. Sub 20 Pilot

        Re: Where is the money coming from?

        That day can not come soon enough. These fucking parasites need to be eliminated and their wealth put to good use.

        They have had it good for too long, I really do hope this happens in my lifetime as by now their insane fucking greed has become intolerable.

        When they were making billions and the rest of us rumbled along it was almost tolerable but now they have gone rogue- they dont want more money they want ALL the money.

        Either change the system, stop these greedy fuckers or let there by a French 1790's style revolution. We can not let billionaire parasites become trillionaire parasites while the rest of humanity is struggling or dying.

        Enough is enough.

        1. That Badger

          Re: Where is the money coming from?

          Look into what caused the 1789 French Revolution and who profited off it.

          1. T. F. M. Reader Silver badge
            Coat

            Re: Where is the money coming from?

            Look into what caused the 1789 French Revolution and who profited off it.

            Cause: some American capitalist smugglers who didn't want to pay any taxes and started an insurrection evolved into a war that the French elites supported on "moral" (read: political) grounds to the extent that the exercise completely bankrupted France? Profit: one ambitions Corsican and a few of his friends and relatives, including - but of course! - the King of Sweden whose descendants own that country to this very day?

            Oh, well ---------------------------->

          2. Sub 20 Pilot

            Re: Where is the money coming from?

            I am well aware of the history of the French revolution thank you. I said in my post ''a French style revolution'' which was supposed to convey that the parasites in charge were dealt with back then. It was not an ideal solution and indeed there is never an easily implemented solution to most world problems. If I have to explain the context then you obviously have not understood the problem facing the economies of a lot of countries today.

            What is glaringly obvious to me and a lot of other people who are not beholden to the billionaire class is that this can not continue. There has to be a point where the ordinary, hard working tax paying populations in most of the Western world will decide that they have been shafted enough. Year on year, normal people's costs go up, their taxes go up and their quality of life gets more difficult to maintain. At the same time a few thousand people in the world pay less tax and accrue billions more.

            If you can not understand this you are part of the problem.

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Where is the money coming from?

          Did you see the South Park episode? The OG billionaires complaining that the new billionaires are flaunting their money and stupidity and getting them generally hated. It was quite on point

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billionaire_Weenietown

        3. StewartWhite Silver badge
          Flame

          Re: Where is the money coming from?

          Aux armes, citoyens. Formez vos bataillons.

          Much as I dislike the tendency of the French to think of themselves as superior to denizens of every other country, I do hold a grudging respect for their rejection of Yankee cultural imperialism and they certainly know how to conduct a proper riot (see icon) even in the age of "social" media what with it being the new opiate of the people and all that.

          1. Roland6 Silver badge

            Re: Where is the money coming from?

            The 2-part film “De Gaulle” is worth viewing, part 2 we found particularly riveting and showed both the American and English political class in a poor light.

            What is particularly noteworthy is how the vitally important role the Free French played in the North Africa campaign has been massively down played by both the America and British accounts of events.

            Also what is interesting, the US, without consulting the French had drawn up a post war partitioning of France - effectively removing France as a country… what the US is doing with respect to Ukraine has many parallels…

          2. Sub 20 Pilot

            Re: Where is the money coming from?

            Marchons, marchons !

            Qu'un sang impur

            Abreuve nos sillons !

      2. xyz Silver badge

        Re: Where is the money coming from?

        Let them eat tokens.

  5. macsimski

    why do you call them customers. everybody knows oracle only takes hostages. have been doing that for years.

  6. IGotOut Silver badge
    FAIL

    Revenue..

    ..not profit.

    Revenue.

  7. Bitsminer

    We don't have to add more seats in order for us to now generate more revenue...

    Every customer will roll over and pay without complaint.

    Just like VMware.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Every customer will roll over and pay without complaint.

      That's what Oracle C-Level Execs are forecasting. A lot of VMWare customers have stopped using it and moved elsewhere.

      Oracle is not the only system in the world.

      As for moving from on-prem to cloud... I know for sure that one customer told them to get lost when they tried to get them to move to cloud some years ago. The data in their system is classified. The sales droid tried and tried but the answer was still no. He was let go soon after.

      Oracle are a shite company as the people still struggling in Birmingham City Council will verify.

      1. gryphon

        Re: Every customer will roll over and pay without complaint.

        I remember a few articles on here about how well paid Oracles sales people were paid.

        One woman had sued because she only got a $300k bonus rather than the $million she was expecting or something along that line.

    2. NoneSuch Silver badge
      Go

      Re: We don't have to add more seats in order for us to now generate more revenue...

      Sorry mate, we dumped VMWare faster than a hound dog with his tail full of cactus needles.

      1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: We don't have to add more seats in order for us to now generate more revenue...

        Have Oracle been in touch about their new "not using VMWare license"?

        It's a new monthly fee for any computer that doesn't use an Oracle product. Charged per CPU

        1. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
          Angel

          "A new monthly fee for any computer that doesn't use an Oracle product"

          If that fee applied to all the devices in the enterprise, it would pay for itself in mere months. ;)

  8. Tron Silver badge

    Always a good idea...

    ... to publicly announce that you are going to bilk your customers for as much as you can, and squeeze them until the pips squeak.

  9. M.V. Lipvig Silver badge

    Neat

    They charge per task, then have the AI generate its own tasks to complete. Combine that with helpfully ignoring all spending controls by boosting them when you hit 90 percent and there you have it - put AI in your business this month and the AI owns the business next month.

  10. AgentGreen

    Broadcom?

    Has Hock Tan picked up on this brilliant money-squeezing scheme yet? I'm sure he'll have his people adding AI to VMware post-haste if he thinks he can then charge his whales for AI work.

  11. Gavsky

    With competing AI services (at least until several companies go bust/get taken-over), the competitive market should see price wars. But the insane investment & further money to keep firms afloat until profit, means squeezing every penny out of everything. Even then, there'll need to be a huge take-up by users willing to pay - & keep doing so.

    1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

      > there'll need to be a huge take-up by users willing to pay

      Don't forget also those unwilling to pay, but paying anyway - aka tax payers thanks to wine and steak loving ministers.

  12. DrXym Silver badge

    Shouldn't have to be said

    But signing a contract with Oracle is like letting a mental patient shave your balls with a razor blade.

    1. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
      Devil

      "signing a contract with Oracle"

      I would have thought the blood - yours - in the pen would have been a dead giveaway.

      Heaven knows Larry himself could easily be cast at any time as Faust's tempter.

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    AI was built with one task in mind

    To locate a profit.

    Nothing yet…

  14. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Just go bust already

    Oracle, trump-sucking anti-democratic fascists, now controlling CBS and CNN.

  15. Blackjack Silver badge
    Happy

    I think Oracle is going to find the hard way they do not have a Monopoly on AI

  16. w-b-r-d

    Eat all the food

    Then promise to solve global hunger

  17. Locomotion69

    Oracle wants to bill you for every AI task, not just every seat

    FTFY

  18. Omnipresent Silver badge

    seems fair

    making the russians pay more for the data they steal seems fair to me.

  19. StinkyMcStinkFace

    OMG they are actually serious?

    Oracle? I keep forgetting they exist.

    Microsoft once tried to bully their users into giving up their rights and dragging everyone at gunpoint to the cloud. The result is we got rid of EVERY SINGLE bit of microsoft software. (almost, we are almost there).

    Have fun Oracle, we'll keep you in our dreams.

    Actually, we forgot about you years ago.... Bye.

  20. X5-332960073452
    Happy

    @ 17:25 (UK) on 1st Nov 26 - 566 upvotes, 3 downvotes

  21. Groo The Wanderer - A Canuck Silver badge

    It's just the Americans on a feeding frenzy; what you're getting is what you deserve for contributing to their rapacious "business" all these years - YOU convinced them your budget was nearly infinite by doing so.

  22. teebie

    How timely

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon