So I suppose the next bit of enshittification will be to stop us turning AI search off.
Google struggling to make AI Mode searches pay
Shares in Google’s parent company Alphabet dived by almost ten percent on Wednesday, after the web giant admitted AI-powered searches earn it less money than it earns by serving ads with its old-school search engine. Alphabet on Wednesday reported its Q3 results, which included news that its year-over-year search query growth …
COMMENTS
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:05 GMT Piro
It's tempting and easy to crap on Gemini, especially now we've been forceably downgraded on the free tier from Flash to Flash-Lite, and it of course gets things wrong, but if you know how to use it, and you're always aware that any answer can be wrong, it can actually be useful. It's also interesting to ask it how many resources it thinks the session is currently using, and how that's handled. It doesn't have the back-end data, but it can make estimates. You might be quite surprised how many resources you can waste, for free. No wonder Alphabet loses money on it.
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 21:28 GMT Piro
Yup. Predictable, really; I was well aware it would be the case. I was also in the "head-in-the-sand" camp for the longest time, but that's mostly because I saw the terrible face of GenAI - slop videos and trashy websites filling the net.
Turns out, that's the worst and most worthless part of the current wave of AI as it stands, and thoroughly deserves derision. I want to throw up when I see community posters using all the same generic AI art style. But, coding tasks, parsing websites, analysing datasets; you can get a crazy amount done that you might not have attempted previously.
I generally hope it all pops and we get back to sane hardware prices, but whether you use it or not, it's here anyway right now.
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:43 GMT MachDiamond
"So I suppose the next bit of enshittification will be to stop us turning AI search off."
That's easy, just don't use Google. It's next to useless these days anyway with an emphasis on "pay to play" results. Search for a real estate inspector and the first page of results will be the franchise brokerages as they've paid to be top-listed any time somebody types "real estate".
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 17:23 GMT Dinanziame
So I suppose the next bit of enshittification will be to stop us turning AI search off.
Well, no... Apparently, they think they have to show the AI front and center, even if they make less money by it — so if you explicitly say you don't want it, they can save the expensive AI query, and maybe even show you a few more ads! For them, it should be win-win
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 19:02 GMT doublelayer
No, they'll keep giving you that option until they've completed the revenue-making part of AI search. Right now, it tries to answer your question. They need to modify its prompt so that it sells you things, then get advertisers to bid for what it sells, and then they'll make everyone use it so they can dupe people into trusting an even less trustworthy answer.
I think this is definitely the next step for most LLMs. Instead of passing the question "Which washing machine brands or models are most repairable?" through to websites and trying to summarize what comes back, they can silently replace it with "Which of these washing machine models are somewhat repairable? Sort by a combination of their repairability and their numeric sort key in the list [based on amount paid]." The LLM can also create that prompt. The result is that people who trusted LLM output will now be served answers that conveniently respond to their question with the answers that were most valuable to give. LLM companies have few resources, but one they do have is a list of people who trust LLMs strongly who should be valuable targets.
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 03:32 GMT tinpinion
Another One
"CEO Sundar Pichai was full of optimism for future AI revenue, noting that Google’s Gemini app has won a billion users faster than any other product in the company’s history, and praising the performance of its models."
Translation: "We're so proud of Gemini's potential usefulness to consumers that we're going to discontinue it in a few years for consistency's sake because it makes us feel both powerful and virile when we yank services away from folks who have deeply incorporated them into their personal and professional lifestyles."
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 20:12 GMT MachDiamond
Re: Another One
"Say what you will, but many aspects of this AI craze are extremely illogical."
That depends a lot on your assumptions. There's a huge disconnect between the stock price and the value at many companies. It's a mechanism for making money through manipulating money. There's no value being generated. It hasn't been this good for the pumpers since the dotcom boom. The pitch was the rise of the digital era and every new company planned to make money by selling ads, carrying ads, etc. A tactic that rhymes are the EV startups and even legacy makers that introduce a high-end expensive vehicle first and see how it goes before they design, build and sell something the bulk of the market will want and can afford. When everybody is doing that, the pool of people that want an EV and can foot a $100,000+ price gets stretched very thin and they all lose money.
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 10:48 GMT heyrick
Re: Another One
First thing I did was turned the damned thing off. After asking it how to do so. It's still lurking, impotent, if I leave my finger on the home key for too long, but I've disabled all the permissions. I can't reassign the home key action, my phone lacks a setting to do so, I presume because "Thou Shalt Not Refuse AI".
What they mean is "our sugar daddy wants to pillage all your data (are belong to us)".
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:45 GMT MachDiamond
Re: Another One
"noting that Google’s Gemini app has won a billion users faster than any other product in the company’s history, and praising the performance of its models."
A classic demonstration of measuring the wrong thing. If you lose money on every user, the last thing you want is the most users.
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 17:16 GMT Charlie Clark
Re: Another One
Yes, but it's also what made Google the most successful ad vendor because it had all those lovely queries to mine. At the moment, the fight on mobile is to be the "goto AI" tool. Get beyond the slop that most people want to do because they're bored and there are likely to be things that either people will pay to do, or other people will pay to know.
-
Sunday 1st November 2026 01:42 GMT Chet Mannly
Re: Another One
"Google’s Gemini app has won a billion users faster than any other product in the company’s history"
Only because it is compulsorily installed on basically every new Android phone and is included in basically every major Android update. That isn't winning customers any more than Copilot is winning customers when MS makes it a default install on windows and Office.
-
Tuesday 3rd November 2026 13:32 GMT Elongated Muskrat
Re: Another One
"Won" is doign a lot of heavy lifting; more "forced onto everyone who has an Android phone"
I think it's past time for anti-competition authorities to break "Alphabet" up and prevent bundling of thier "AI" onto people's phones without any real choice. Remember the browser wars and what happened with Microsoft and IE? That.
By all means, allow its install for "convenience" if people want it, but it's actually pretty difficult to opt out and disable this if you don't want it, and that is definitely a problem.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 21:57 GMT Anonymous Coward
'Coz it's too fuckin' 'ard
The abbreviated "because", whichever spelling, and the abbreviated "fucking" need their apostrophes as much as the abbreviated "hard" deserves its; putting in one but missing out two, oh dear.
And "too" would like its missing "o" back as well.
As for "that don't know shit" (congratulations on the apostrophe, by the way), the double negative can allowed to slide, iff you apply the full vernacular and use "what don't know shit".
-
-
Monday 2nd November 2026 10:15 GMT Anonymous Coward
Ali G mode? Abbreviations from 1999?
You think that 'coz, 'ard, or "what don't know shit" originated with Ali G?
Just 'cos that was when you first 'eard 'em don't mean shit 'bout when they was first in the vernacular! You is out by at least one hunnered years, matey. More, only writin' were too posh to 'clude common talk 'fore den.
-
Tuesday 3rd November 2026 13:47 GMT Elongated Muskrat
I saw someone dressed as Ali G for Halloween when I was out on Saturday. My immediate response was "oh look, It's Richard Madeley," which is as good an argument as any for why we shouldn't be doing Ali G impressions, quite apart from the issue that mimicing satire is missing the entire point of it in the first place.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 09:11 GMT lglethal
Re: There's only one way this can go
Oh its even better then that!!!
Soon Advertisers will be able to use AI to create Ads for google to show. Then google will create bots to view those ads for us, and collect money from the ad firms for the viewing. No humans required!
It's bots serving ads for bots! They'll earn millions!
-
-
-
Saturday 31st October 2026 14:14 GMT Albert Coates
I'd forgotten that particularly weird phrase in the excitement of the comments. Still haven't looked it up, I may never. I will probably go around for months, years even, before someone gratuitously uses it again. Or it might just become an everyday expression which no-one understands, like "ping me", to which I usually reply "RFC 792 has a lot to answer for, eh?" Dude, that is just sooo upper funnel.
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 07:58 GMT mark l 2
How long before companies can pay to have their business link come up in an AI search result since Google have admitted they aren't making as much money now?
I bet in another year or two you will do a search for something like 'What is the best way to loose weight doing 15 minutes exercise per day' and the result will be - According to FITNESSFIRST.COM they recommend if you want to loose weight with 15 minutes exercise you should sign up for a 12 month gym membership on their website (sponsored)
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 10:02 GMT David 138
It could drive sales
I have been using it to drill down on products specs and comparisons, check prices. Adverts would be ok there. A paying company could do tailored adverts which allow it to do dynamic pricing to capture busines or offer coupons. I would probably check it out. As long as it doesn't deliberately exclude competitors, then the results would become useless.
It must be a hard job ATM, spending billions on a product most people are unwilling to pay for.
It's all going to be a very expensive race to the bottom, if only someone would as AI to makes itself vastly more efficient.
-
Tuesday 3rd November 2026 13:54 GMT Elongated Muskrat
Re: It could drive sales
Would you choose a product based on its advertising over the specs and comparisons to similar products? I don't know about you, but advertising in this context (and pretty much every other context, to be honest) just signifies that a product can't compete on its own merits, so they have to employ flashing colours and psychological manipulation techniques to try to sway you instead.
The only cases where I think adverts ever work is where they make you aware of a product that you otherwise weren't aware of, and that product is something that you want or need. The modern advertising industry is so far from this in most instances, that it provides nothing but industrialised deception, and as such, can fuck entirely off.
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 08:38 GMT WSWS
This is hardly surprising; I don't know how much compute Google needs for a standard search, but the AI one is inevitably going to use more because it still has to do a regular search plus feeding the returned information from that into the AI. It might need to make *multiple* traditional search calls depending on how it's set up.
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:13 GMT vtcodger
But ...
"the AI one is inevitably going to use more ..."
Exactly. In my experience, the AI search works quite well. Good answers almost always. And it saves me the aggravation of having to fight through Captchas and such to extract the information from the web sites the regular search identifies. It also gives me references to the sources it used should I chose to pursue the subject further.
All well and good. BUT Google probably needs to moneterize its increased effort, and I have no idea how it is going to do that and what money/aggravation that is going to cost me. If I were running a business, I think I'd be hesitant to embrace the technology, unless and until I know what it is likely to cost me next week or year whenever Google gets around to making it wildly profitable.
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 13:11 GMT Anonymous Coward
Re: But ...
The other side effect is that the sources it drains ad revenue from by (ab)using their published content will eventually starve for lack of revenue.
Google search is still just an indexer, it doesn't create original content itself. By starving the content creators of income it is effectively committing a slow form of suicide, but hey, the shareholders have made their money so they don't care.
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:32 GMT Dr Dan Holdsworth
Standard Google searching is pretty much just keyword or phrase searching, using a vast distributed network of small databases. AI adds a statistical element to the search using the LLM technology.
At some point someone is going to have to address how best this might all be done in pure hardware and actually design and build dedicated Google subunits. The other step that needs doing along with this is to work out how to drastically reduce the power consumption of these systems, since it is the power consumption and heat transfer that costs money and wears the things out more quickly than would otherwise be the case.
That would give a slightly slower Google search at the benefit of greatly reduced hardware costs.
The next trick that needs doing is to integrate datacentre tech into urban and suburban heating networks. That would mean putting in both the heating transfer network and lots of extremely good fibre optic cabling into suburbs, meaning that suddenly you don't have as much of problem with getting rid of datacentre heat as you used to have (save in hot weather) and you have lots of consumers of Internet services pretty much next door to your distributed data centre.
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 12:11 GMT cyberdemon
Heat networks?
No thanks..
I don't want my heating to be dependent on the AI bubble not bursting.
And the amount of heat that can actually be used from a datacentre is pretty minimal.. They don't want their coolant temps going much over 50C since anything too hot would reduce the lifespan of their stinkingly expensive chips. They would need a heat exchanger since they don't want their primary coolant going off-site as it could return contaminated. And the lower the temperature, the fatter the pipes need to be, and large-gauge insulated pipes are extremely expensive
Fibre optic cabling? We already have plenty of that in the ground.. I already get 1Gbps.. I don't really need much more than 100Mbps
And as for search - I DON'T WANT "statistical search", except perhaps by way of a spam-filter on my boolean query.
-
-
Sunday 1st November 2026 23:50 GMT Random as if !
LMGTFY
The 24-Hour Resource and Financial Bill
If we multiply that daily global volume of 2.3 billion queries by the "half-a-penny" footprint (£0.0052) detailed previously, the collective daily impact is staggering:
• Daily Financial Cost: ~£12 million spent every day purely on computing power and cloud operations to serve these responses.
• Daily Electricity Bill: ~27.6 million kWh of energy consumed globally every 24 hours. (For context, that is enough to power roughly 3.4 million average UK homes for an entire day).
• Daily Water Impact: ~600,000 litres (132,000 gallons) of water vaporized in data centre cooling towers to keep the heavy server clusters from overheating.
This immense multi-million-pound daily cost explains exactly why tech giants are scrambling to find more efficient ad models; at billions of queries a day, the cash burn adds up incredibly fast.
Would you like to see how this daily data centre energy usage compares to the generation capacity of major renewable energy projects, or explore how companies are trying to shrink the cost per query?
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 16:23 GMT Doctor Syntax
"and advertisers don't worry about people they rile"
I think it depends on who you mean by "advertisers". The marketing people who spend advertising budget don't care because they're paid salaries to buy advertising. They're complicit. The shareholders should car on two grounds: 1, It's shareholders' funds being paid to Google (possibly you overlooked that point but as you're A/C it's entirely possible you're an advertising industry shill) and 2. Some of those pissed off were potential and possibly former customers (in the past I've certainly boycotted brands I found annoying) and the one thing worse than paying for something that doesn't work is paying to lose business.
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 10:29 GMT Bebu sa Ware
I misinterpreted the article's image
It looked for all the world like an Alphabet Chocolatier astride a tree limb attempiting to shoot with a rifle the wolves snapping at the corpoarate heel.
Of course the recoil would throw him out of the tree into jaws of the wolves. The same effect would also follow once the actual hand saw cut through the branch.
-
-
Friday 30th October 2026 04:49 GMT Jamie Jones
Well, if you have petabytes of storage free, and a fast link, you can download pre-indexed datasets already, so that will save you needing to crawl!
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:08 GMT Anonymous Coward
So will personalized advertising finally start to actually work? Or will I STILL just see:
Ads for stuff I've already bought and don't want more of?
Ads for stuff I've already bought but at a higher price?
Ads for stuff I've already looked at and decided I don't want?
Ads for stuff I've taken a look at to see what the advertiser was on about?
Ads for stuff where I tapped the wrong bit of the screen?
Ads that are a bit like what I bought (but only in the coke addled brain of a marketing professional who understands the product as well as Harold Shipman understood healthcare)
Ads for stuff OTHER PEOPLE bought along with what I've just bought. (as if that's somehow relevant to me)
Ads for stuff OTHER PEOPLE bought next (so actually totally irrelevant)
Ads for stuff that's "trending" (as if I have a shit).
"Gamified" selling strategies
A pound to a penny'th of pigshit nothing will change.
This does seem apposite: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=T4Upf_B9RLQ
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 11:52 GMT nohatjim
AI - money down the drain
I use and pay personally for ChatGBT. I find it useful in the same way I found spell checkers useful when they first were added to word processing software (yes I am old enough to remember when that wasn't a given).
I can see real value in the tools but I can't see anyway the amount of money being spent on infrastructure will result in a return on investment. It feel so much like the first dot com boom - I remember I was working in a DC at that point and I remember the sheer amount of very expensive Sun hardware being purchased by boo.com - I was told one £10k box was purchased to manage the fans on the rest of the cluster. I was there when it arrived and was still there in 2000 when the kit got turned off and taken away.
I see alot of very expensive compute being sold off for pennies on the pound. However like the internet we have now their will be a future for AI and it will remain part of our lives but lots of people are going to lose a lot of money
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 22:39 GMT Gavsky
Re: AI - money down the drain
It's tulip bulbs & dot coms, all over again. On the plus side, there'll be a lot of cheap kit for sale when firms realise they don't need quite as much infrastructure, especially when some go bust/are taken-over. There's a serious shakedown a-coming!
Boo.com was a classic lack of business acumen story. Very expensive London HQ; a too complex & resource-hungry website - when many customers were still on dial-up; crazy IT spending, as you say. An anonymous, cheap unit on an industrial estate should have been their HQ, for starters!
-
Friday 30th October 2026 19:39 GMT Roland6
Re: AI - money down the drain
>” I remember the sheer amount of very expensive Sun hardware being purchased”
That’s reminded me of Worldport datacentre in Dublin, fully fitted out with Sun kit in anticipation of the dotcom boom, only for it to be shuttered etc.
I suspect those behind the many applications still in the planning queue when the dotcom bubble burst were glad they hadn’t incurred the expense of build and kit out.
The bursting of the AI bubble is going to have a similar effect, a side benefit will be the clearing of planning queues and so reducing delays…
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 13:42 GMT Zaphodikus
Spends next 10 minutes reading and upvoting
Google has discovered something all of us could have told them, about 10 years ago. And all this tells me, is that bullshit still sells if you have enough of it. It still stinks as a product, but someone is growing mushrooms, and so the only winner is a fungy
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 15:47 GMT Wiretrip
Oh the irony
They are single-handedly killing a lot of the internet, to the point that you can only be seen if you pay Google.
Interestingly, governments are already taking the view that their ai overview is original content, which makes google a publisher in law. If that catches on then this facility is doomed, and not a moment too soon.
-
-
Sunday 1st November 2026 05:11 GMT doublelayer
Re: Oh the irony
If it is true that the AI summary is being considered original content and Google a publisher, and I have not seen proof of that, the result would be that Google is liable for errors it contains. Previously, they weren't responsible because they could say "someone else said that, we just showed you the place where they said it". By being considered a publisher, they can be sued for libel if it insults somebody and for a few other things if the output is dangerous and someone came to harm as a result. They aren't guaranteed to lose, but they would have less of a shield.
-
Wednesday 4th November 2026 23:31 GMT M.V. Lipvig
Re: Oh the irony
I see. That makes sense, and I'd like to see the Googler get its feet held to the fire over that. It would be extra cool if people could publish content with the intent of getting the Googler's nuts in a vice on purpose when several sites are correlated - where each site only has an unactionable piece of the puzzle that generates the squeeze.
Not sure why asking a question earned me a thumb down though. I didn't get it then, now I do. I even came back to see what the answer might be.
-
-
-
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 18:35 GMT DS999
There's no way AI doesn't crush Google
Today most people go to Google (or have it as the default search in their browser) for web searches. That's how they get such a big chunk of overall searches, and thus overall search revenue.
With AI yes when people use Gemini instead of traditional Google Search then Google is still in there making money. But what about the people who instead ask ChatGPT, or Claude, or Copilot, or Siri, or Alexa? A lot people who were using Google Search will now be using those other things, because they have become used to ChatGPT thanks to its early publicity, or because Copilot/Siri is built into their Windows/Apple device, or because they have an Alexa in their kitchen.
Even if Google can eventually recover 100% of what they were making on Google Search in cases where people use Gemini to search, that won't matter because they'll never have the same near monopoly status on AI they enjoyed with Search.
Apple will probably take a hit too. That $20 billion a year they are getting in free money from simply making Google the default search in Safari (even though it is trivial to change) is going to decline when renewal time arrives because fewer Apple users will use the Safari search bar to look for stuff but over time increasingly use Siri or ChatGPT.
-
Thursday 29th October 2026 21:39 GMT that one in the corner
Google’s Gemini app has won a billion users
And that is all because Gemini is so great, yes? And nothing whatsoever to do with how every damn bit of Google is pushing it at you: one slip of the finger, one accidental miss of the tiny "not now" button* and ding! Congratulations, you are now a satisfied user of Gemini!
* and note, they all say "not now" (so you know they'll be back tomorrow) instead of "no, just no, go away, if I ever do want you I'll come looking"
-
Friday 30th October 2026 18:27 GMT TheMaskedMan
I've never used Google's AI search. I do find the AI overview to be somewhat useful, at least as a starting point for further research - naturally, I wouldn't trust it without checking!
But what of the independent sites that used to provide useful information in exchange for AdSense or affiliate revenue? Their traffic must be decimated by it.
This isn't just that Google wants to be your gateway to the web, and show you some ads along the way. This is Google wanting to BE the internet, the soul source of information for everything. That's dangerous.
Try searching for a laptop name and model review - an exact match for, say, an Amazon product page title. Yo will get a blizzard of sponsored links, an AI overview that admittedly isn't all that bad, and links to YouTube videos and big box stores.
You will find no, or hardly any, small sites offering independent views on that laptop. Granted, many of them were mere Amazon affiliate sites with nothing useful to say, but they weren't all like that. Now you will find links to other laptops above exact matches for the one you're searching for. The first couple of pages are totally devoid of anything useful whatsoever.
The web as it was just a few years ago is dying, and may never recover. Even if small sites continue, they are buried under page after page of irrelevant crap. Not good at all.
-
Saturday 31st October 2026 02:25 GMT frankyunderwood123
the internet is dying
Google may be losing money on AI search, but we all know it’s here to stay and another nail in the coffin of the open web will be hammered home. Before AI search, results were already distorted, now there’s hallucinations baked in too.
The other thing that’s been killing the internet is fragmentation by way of apps. Now apps that should be websites get additional features that the web version doesn’t get. People are pushed to these apps so more of their data can be slurped up.
-
Sunday 1st November 2026 23:49 GMT Random as if !
Lets ask AI how mu....fuuuu%k , who pays that?
The 24-Hour Resource and Financial Bill
If we multiply that daily global volume of 2.3 billion queries by the "half-a-penny" footprint (£0.0052) detailed previously, the collective daily impact is staggering:
• Daily Financial Cost: ~£12 million spent every day purely on computing power and cloud operations to serve these responses.
• Daily Electricity Bill: ~27.6 million kWh of energy consumed globally every 24 hours. (For context, that is enough to power roughly 3.4 million average UK homes for an entire day).
• Daily Water Impact: ~600,000 litres (132,000 gallons) of water vaporized in data centre cooling towers to keep the heavy server clusters from overheating.
This immense multi-million-pound daily cost explains exactly why tech giants are scrambling to find more efficient ad models; at billions of queries a day, the cash burn adds up incredibly fast.
Would you like to see how this daily data centre energy usage compares to the generation capacity of major renewable energy projects, or explore how companies are trying to shrink the cost per query?