The Register Home Page

back to article New motherboards, old RAM, plenty of life left in yesterday's PCs

Gigabyte recently announced new motherboards that use DDR4 RAM, a standard that launched in 2014, and other vendors support even older standards in brand-new kit. Earlier this year, AMD released a Ryzen 7 5800X3D anniversary edition to mark ten years of AM4. For AM4 processors, Gigabyte offers the new B450M H ARGB, with two DDR4 …

  1. pig

    This is not progress

    This is the rest of the world (non major AI vendors) having to "go Cuba style" and do all we can to keep old systems working as we no longer have the money, or ability, to buy new tech.

    At an unprecedentedly massive scale.

    Scary, and depressing, times indeed.

    1. Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

      Re: This is not progress

      > This is not progress

      Progress is often overrated, TBH...

      1. breakfast Silver badge
        Windows

        Re: This is not progress

        Given how much of the Reg comment section is generally consumed by grumbling about Kids These Days, complaining things Aren't Like They Were In My Day, and old men yelling at the cloud, I feel like the community here broadly agrees on this.

      2. Sub 20 Pilot

        Re: This is not progress

        Progress is defined by the profiteering companies and the ones pushing all this endless fuckery.

        For me progress is something that improves my working life or any other aspect of my life and makes my job or anythinh I am trying to achieve, easier to accomplish.

        It should never be defined as having to spend on ever more powerful systems that are no better in real terms than I had back in 1998.

        I write this on a 15 odd year old laptop that ran Windows 7 and has since been superseeded by Linux Mint.

        Does everything I need and hardly ever has the fan running. On W7 the fan was always running, things ran sluggishly or intermittently and there was always an urgent demand to update something or other, none of which ever improved the running of the system, only added cruft, bloat and shite to an already burdened system.

        For work, I am still hampered by needing MS, requiring it's turgid OS for cad and several niche applications related to engineering and the like which will not run in any emulator- believe me I have tred so many times over the years. Anyone who comes up with a system that lets me run these in a purely Linux environment I would pay thousands for. To me that would be progress. As I will be faced with having to run W11 on my next work pc when the current one dies, a payment of any sort for a working system that avoids the need to do this is a no brainer for me.

        For info, I have bought a few devices from Morgan Cumputers over the years but in the last two years or so they never seem to have anything useful in stock. Loads of things on the website but nothing that is in any way useful for me. Just looked now and they have a load of laptops with a 256 or 512 gb SSD, nothing bigger, all running Win11. What the fuck can you install on a device like that after windows has taken it's toll?

    2. Smartypantz

      Re: This is not progress

      Fortunately we don't need basic digital technology to evolve much further for it to be the useful tool that it has been for a lot of decades.Peak productivity was probably 20 years ago!. The Insane AI craze is born out of the need for growth in the digital sector. Growth that has become a cancer instead of progress.

    3. Adair Silver badge

      Re: This is not progress

      Good enough is ... good enough! The hard part is having the wisdom to know when good enough is good enough,

      1. jgarbo
        Angel

        Re: This is not progress

        You mean buying a Mack semi to do my local shopping is not progress?

    4. Fido

      Re: This is not progress

      A decision was made not to upgrade last year because the price of memory had gone up. Now I'm troubleshooting a Xeon scalable server that's getting ECC errors on 6 out of 12 DIMMs. Today prices are even greater than last year.

    5. ecofeco Silver badge

      Re: This is not progress

      Efficiency is not progress?

      Can you even hear yourself?

      1. Eric 9001 Bronze badge
        Black Helicopters

        Re: This is not progress

        When it comes to newer hardware, typically there is only an attempt made to match the power consumption of the previous model - there really isn't an attempt made to reduce it (power consumption is the same between high-power, medium-power and low-power hardware of most hardware generations) and each time new hardware is manufactured, that is a significant energy and resource expenditure that seems to possibly be higher than continuing to use decently power efficient old hardware 8 hours a day, for another 10 years.

        Sure, maybe the newer hardware can get more operations done with the same amount of power, but it seems proprietary software just keeps getting slower and needing more cycles - with the end result being more power consumed, not less.

        Power-efficient old hardware exists and works just fine.

      2. Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

        Re: This is not progress

        > Efficiency is not progress?

        > Can you even hear yourself?

        I can hear the sound of the angry rants of someone who hasn't factored in the externalities.

        You *must* consider the total energy and resource budget of the whole lifecycle of the machine.

        1. Acquiring, extracting, and refining the materials it's made from.

        2. Fabricating it, from components to assembly.

        3. Shipping and selling and quite possibly shipping again.

        4. Actual use.

        5. Decommissioning -- which tends in our business to mean simply scrapping.

        6. Occasionally, passing on to a new user, which means shipping again, but possibly in more efficient form with less packaging. No new plastic peel-off film, leaflets never studied, etc.

        7. Recycling, if at all possible, which -- spoiler alert -- for highly-integrated electronics it's usually not.

        You are trying to argue the toss about 1 out of 7 stages. Although often the longest, it is the single *least* energy intensive stage.

        It is the *ONLY* stage where greater efficiency matters *at all* and it's usually squandered on less-efficient software.

        I call bullshit. I think you're shilling for computer makers here.

        Buying new kit because it's more efficient than older kit which is still working is dramatically, many times over, _worse_ for the environment than keeping on using old kit until it can no longer do the job.

        Want to be green? Don't buy a new computer. Ditch your OS and replace it with a more efficient one.

        1. MonkeyJuice Silver badge

          Re: This is not progress

          And having 70% of your chips go straight from the end of the production line into the bin because they failed is not particularly efficient either... There's a lot to be said for older, well trodden architectures we know how to produce at scale with high yeilds.

        2. DoctorPaul Bronze badge

          Re: This is not progress

          Totally agree.

          Trying to remember when I last bought a new computer and I just can't think when it was, maybe it was even the BBC Micro that started everything for me in the early 80s or maybe you could include some Shuttle XPCs that I assembled in the 90s. A second hand HP business machine or similar is more than adequate for pretty much anything and, unlike the only cheap Chinese case I tried, doesn't draw blood from razor sharp edges. Oh and many happy memories of trips up Tottenham Court Road to visit Morgan Computers!

          On a similar note, I'm now in my mid 70s and have never bought a new car in my life. Have you seen how much they depreciate the moment you drive them off the forecourt?

          1. andy gibson

            Re: This is not progress

            2015 was the last time I bought a PC. Core i7, 16GB of RAM. Still working fine today, albeit I've changed to a fresh SSD during each OS upgrade (7, 10, 11 - even though 11 isn't officially supported, but thank you to RUFUS)

        3. Electronics'R'Us
          Thumb Up

          Re: This is not progress

          I design high reliability electronics for a living (see handle) which includes the occasional computer and various types of memory and I completely agree.

          A properly designed electronic system should last for decades (the biggest killer is heat).

          The primary reason for 'upgraded' systems is to deal with code bloat (which has been around for decades - I remember ESR advocating that cycles and RAM were cheap over 25 years ago) or artificially imposed limitations (I am looking at you Microsoft). That decision (Windows 11 system requirements) was one of the worst acts of ecological vandalism I have ever seen because it had the potential to cause enormous amounts of perfectly ok hardware to go to a landfill.

          I get that we can't optimise to the last machine instruction as a practical matter in complex software but the various practices used simply generate enormous amounts of code for no good reason other than the developer(s) are using some framework or other that has ridiculous system requirements. I personally call that being lazy as I come from a time when every byte counted (and still does in some of my designs).

          That doesn't mean 'inefficient' languages are bad - if you have a script that runs once a week and takes 15 minutes, I don't care if the language was inefficient; at kernel level that argument goes out of the window.

          Using old but perfectly well operating electronics is the best thing to do for numerous reasons and that is what I do (my cell phone supplier wishes otherwise).

      3. Fonant Silver badge

        Re: This is not progress

        If you want an efficient computer, get a second-hand Psion Organiser. They were massively optimised for efficiency. A Series 3 could run for a month of daily use on a pair of AA batteries. Instant-on too, the CPU clock speed could go down to zero Hz.

        As modern hardware has become more powerful, software has become less efficient. There's no point optimising code to save a few kbytes, or clock cycles, these days.

        See also: "AI" - the most inefficient thing human beings have ever invented by a few orders of magnitude!!

      4. hri

        Re: This is not progress

        Robustness is real progress ... functions always / anywhere / anytime / anyhow. Humble Pie says that sounds analogue or ASIC ... eh? While efficiency is an investor affectation ... as if "they" have a right to greater profits W/O generating a better product. So much money / time / effort / talent concentrated in such a small value footprint remains shocking. If it were a "cancer cure" no rather than a mechanical Turk I could understand.

    6. jgarbo
      Happy

      Re: This is not progress

      Horses for courses. My 10yr old lappies run Linux fast enough for office and engineering work, leaving more budget for business. That's progress for me.

    7. Filippo Silver badge

      Re: This is not progress

      Sort of. It's progress in another direction. If restrictions on better hardware continue (and the AI bubble will have to burst eventually), then we will start seeing progress on software efficiency. And God knows we need that, far more than we need more gigawhatevers.

    8. Eric 9001 Bronze badge
      Black Helicopters

      Re: This is not progress

      "Cuba style" is continuing to use hardware that works just fine, just as fast as the day it was made, that doesn't wear out like a vehicle does, that often doesn't have as many bugs or digital handcuffs as newer hardware?

      What maintenance is commonly required beyond re-pasting once a decade (or not bothering) and replacing failed storage mediums or failed power supplies?

      Sure, defective motherboards and RAM and other components can fail too, but you just replace what fails with another used part.

      To make a bad analogy, it's like if a few car companies released vehicles that have 1TW of power output, with a fuel efficiency of 1 million km/L and that on average could need easy maintenance every 10 years (replace the failed part with a spare part) and people were to consider that not enough, as it became popular to drive around hauling bigger and bigger boulders - with newer models of course having more power, but handcuffing you to the seat (can't have you carrying out unauthorized actions can we).

  2. Gavsky

    "Psst, over 'ere, Guv. You look like the kinda gentleman who needs some...components - if ya get me drift? 'Ow about this 16K RAMPACK, then? Fell off the back of a Sinclair ZX-81 - despite the velcro. No questions asked.

    No? Okay - Amiga trapdoor memory expansion, then? I've got several varieties, all genuine - none of yer foreign rubbish, mind"....

    1. MiguelC Silver badge
      Coat

      I have an Itanic I can sell you - for a fair price, that is

  3. Tron Silver badge

    Back to the future.

    If all you need is a works package, media player and browser, you can dodge all the AI BS and overreach-into-your-PC by sticky-fingered techbros with earlier kit.

    As long as it is modern enough to have a USB port it should be fine.

    My first PCs were built from bits obtained from companies including Morgan and Tier1, who advertised in MicroMart.

    I've just bought a £50 laptop on ebay. When I have the time I'll stick Mint on it. If it works acceptably, I'll bump up the 4Gb to 8 or 16Gb of second hand DDR3. I don't play games or use AI, so it should be fine.

    1. Bent Metal

      Re: Back to the future.

      Indeed - my media player consists of an old Lenovo Yoga laptop, a USB dock (for the convenient power button on the Thinkpad dock, also powers the laptop) and the PSU. Mostly sits out of the way on a shelf above the screen. I think the laptop was £70 on eBay some years back, as the touchscreen wasn't working, but it stays closed all the time anyway...

    2. ComicalEngineer Silver badge
      Pint

      Re: Back to the future.

      A few years ago I bought a used Fujitsu Q520 i7 with no HDD and 4GB of RAM. I had another 4GB RAM chip that took it up to 8GB and a spare SSD in the drawer. I think the total cost of this was about £150 at the time. A copy of Linux Mint installed and it's been happily chugging along as my work machine for several years. Other than a particular CAD package that won't (at least I can't get it to) work under Wine I have almost no need for Windows other than for the occasional customer who wants / needs native Word / Excel / Powerpoint files, for which I have a W10 laptop and an aged W10 desktop to run the CAD package.

      I also have my daughters' old Lenovo Yoga (she has a work laptop and an i7 HP something book), so the Lenovo might be getting a copy of Linux installed.

      Unless you absolutely need W11 then I can find no need to upgrade to new and expensive PCs.

    3. DoctorPaul Bronze badge

      Re: Back to the future.

      My media server is a Compaq-HP Elite that I bought almost a decade ago. Runs Mint with Plex and Jellyfin from an SSD and, thanks to a 4 way PCie SATA adapter, runs six 6Tb hard drives piled inside the case - I always run my machines with the side panel removed.

      I must admit to some trepidation as to whether the PSU would survive the power-on surge from all that spinning rust the first time I fired it up, but it looks like not all the disks spin up immediately. Backup is courtesy of a great big pile of old hard drives and a USB caddy.

  4. Stephen7Eastern

    Old kit is still cost effective

    Realize this article is about new kit featuring older tech bandages. But, buying all old kit is still a very cost effective way to purchase tech. I make my living in a VM that runs on a fourteen year old Lenovo W520 ThinkPad. Bought that W520 used-like-new back in 2011 for $650. Today we could buy a W520 for $120~. So while the AI bubble grows ever larger, old kit remains a great way to navigate around the techbro bubble without getting scorched.

    1. PhilipN Silver badge

      Re: Old kit is still cost effective

      I'll see your Thinkpad and raise you a Mac Cheesegrater

    2. J.G.Harston Silver badge

      Re: Old kit is still cost effective

      My main programming machine over there (points) is a WinXP machine I bought 16 years ago. I won't let any upgrades touch it as they would kill my development tools that I rely on.

      This little lappy I'm typing this on is a Win11 system that refuses to run a lot of the software I depend on. Though I continue to be very pleased that PaintShopPro 4 continues to work on anything I run it on.

    3. Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

      Re: Old kit is still cost effective

      > a fourteen year old Lenovo W520 ThinkPad

      There's one right next to me this second. I replaced its keyboard with a UK layout one from eBay and it doesn't feel as nice, and I may switch it back, and on the to-do list is replacing its data-only spinning HDD with a second SSD and putting a 3rd SSD in the optical bay. It doesn't like a pair of 8GB SO-DIMMs I bought, so has 24GB instead of the 32GB I was aiming for, but it's fast and totally stable.

      I think currently it runs Win10 LTSC, Ubuntu, Debian, Pop OS, and a couple of others, but to be fair, the OSes change a lot except for Ubuntu 22.04 which is my "get stuff done" OS on it.

    4. andy gibson

      Re: Old kit is still cost effective

      I buy ex-NHS Dell PCs for my work environment for a fraction of the cost of new. Have done since around 2009.

      One year a batch of HPs I bought still had a bit of the 3 year HP warranty left on them!

      Even though they come with a 2 year warranty from the reseller, parts failures just don't happen these days.

      1. J.G.Harston Silver badge

        Re: Old kit is still cost effective

        You *BUY* ex-NHS PCs? When I was last working for the NHS in IT support, the PC disposal involved dropping them into a skip.

  5. IGotOut Silver badge

    This is brilliant news.

    Time to flog off all my 1,2and 4Gb sticks of Ram I gave laying around.

    I'll take £50 a Gb, 40 if cash.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: This is brilliant news.

      I was just about to send some servers away to be scrapped. Too old to get any money for them, either from the recycler or any of the used kit resellers.

      But took the RAM out and sold it for a pretty good sum on ebay.

  6. Pete 2 Silver badge

    Going way back

    > Keeping older hardware in service is welcome

    Up to a point. I was recently harking back to the days of Sun3 workstations. A multi-thousand £/$ (no € in those days) industrial scale computer. Used by all the cool people to produce cutting edge graphics. At the time, with it's 68020 CPU it was the sign that a programmer or graphics artist had made it to the top table.

    Someone then brought me back to reality by asking how it compares with a modern day ESP32-P4 board, that retails for £15. Now there are certain, obvious differences between a fully fledged graphics workstation and a bitsy little embedded board that kiddies use to flash a LED and that grown-ups use for some pretty serious real-time work.

    It turns out that the ESP blows the socks off the Sun3. In terms of raw processing power, memory and (with an SD card), storage too. I have a sneaking suspicion that an SD card wouldn't be that much slower than a 1980s hard disk, either. Maybe about as reliable, too.

    1. C R Mudgeon Silver badge

      Re: Going way back

      "I have a sneaking suspicion that an SD card wouldn't be that much slower than a 1980s hard disk, either. Maybe about as reliable, too."

      My sense is that the SD card is dramatically faster, though I haven't measured. It's certainly a lot higher capacity; the number of 5 MB [sic] disk images you can put onto a 64 GB card is ... enough to let you get seriously confused as to what they all are if you aren't careful. Ask me how I know :-(

      I don't know whether an SD card is more reliable than an 80s drive was back in the 80s, but it's absolutely more reliable than that same 80s drive is now!

      The safest thing you can do with one of those old drives is to image its contents and then emulate it. I know how to do that for MFM drives. I don't know about other drive interfaces (SCSI, ESDI, etc.), but I assume emulators exist for those too.

    2. Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

      Re: Going way back

      > how it compares with a modern day ESP32-P4 board

      I think you're missing the point here.

      It's not really about the performance of the hardware. Can it do the job it was built to do and do it well? Then it is fast enough.

      An ESP32-P4 is not and cannot be a Unix workstation. It's an embedded MCU. How fast it is is irrelevant: it's not the tool for the job.

      The real question here is that now a 68020 and its FP-DRAM aren't made any more, and nobody is maintaining an modern 68020 Unix anyway -- NetBSD needs a 68030 or above I think – and there are no pro graphics apps for it, what is the modern replacement?

      Is anyone making a modern minimalist 32-bit workstation and modern minimalist GUI OS for it and pro level tools for it?

      The closest thing, genuinely, is probably a Raspberry Pi 4 running RISC OS.

      It's not a grown-up pre-emptive multitasking OS, but it is a currently-maintained OS, for inexpensive widely-available hardware, it can talk to Wifi and IPv6, it can run a modern web browser, and yes there are pro-grade apps for it.

      Any comparable Amiga or ST thing involves layers of emulation; RISC OS doesn't.

      Any FOSS Unix-like for relatively old low-end kit doesn't have the apps.

      It's not really about the bare hardware or performance thereof. It's about whether there is some suitable complete stack of software to go on top of it.

      1. Pete 2 Silver badge

        Re: Going way back

        > An ESP32-P4 is not and cannot be a Unix workstation

        You are correct, but not for the reason you think: It's an embedded MCU that is merely a pigeon-holing.

        The thing that holds this particular RISC-V board back is the lack of RVA23 compliance (which is for 64 bit architectures, the P4 uses a 32 bit RISC-V architecture) Although there is nothing to stop some enterprising individual from porting some Unix-like OS to it. If they had the motivation. After all, many unlikely platforms have Linux implementations, even if they are only "show" systems, rather than practical solutions. And my post was entirely about the performance improvement between a 40 year-old $15k workstation and a $15 modern board.

        Plus in fact, there is at least one limited Linux implementation for the ESP32-P4.

  7. Blackjack Silver badge

    Literally running a 17 year old PC using Linux and yes Steam does run on it.

  8. Henry Wertz 1 Gold badge

    25 year support timeframe

    I've been using Linux since 1993 (originally Slackware), and saved a fortune over the years keeping hardware that lost Windows support (there was a lot that had Win9x drivers but none for the Windows NT-based 2000/XP/etc.), no forced retirement due to requirements of 7, 10, or 11.

    The last 2 or so years they've begun shedding support for hardware.... I was using back in the 1990s. They seem to have settled on a minimum 25 year support timeframe. If (foir Intel/AMD), you have a 64-bit system and 2GB RAM Kubuntu will limp along on it, although 4GB is VERY MUCH recommended. That's it, your hardware will be supported.

    The crazy thing is, there's 3D drivers for 18 year old Intel and 22 year old AMD/ATI GPUs. Not some old driver they just haven't dropped suoport for yet. Fully modern Mesa Gallium 3D drivers written in the last 5 or so years, fully supported and up to date using modern driver standards.

    1. Pete 2 Silver badge

      Re: 25 year support timeframe

      One thing that matters is how energy efficient these old computers are. I used to reckon that the electricity costs for something running 24*7*365 was about £1 per Watt per year. So a thing that consumed 100 Watts would cost about £100 a year.

      That cost has now more than doubled. Using Ofgem's average price, that electricity bill is now around £230 per 100 Watts. Sure there are cheaper tariffs but the principle is still the same: the cost of running old, inefficient, kit soon adds up. At that rate, it is worth calculating when to toss the old kit and replace it with new boxes that are cheaper, and will therefore pay for themselves with the savings in energy bills.

      1. Eric 9001 Bronze badge
        Black Helicopters

        Re: 25 year support timeframe

        Solar and battery load shifting can help reduce those costs, allowing you to keep using perfectly good old hardware without extra costs.

        Sure you'll end up spending more over the short term, but spending more not to pay those who don't deserve it is worth it.

        Newer hardware tends to be full of digital handcuffs, that cryptographically prevents you from replacing the malware and backdoors with free software - £460/year is not that much of a price to pay, to be able to run hardware that can run fully free software.

  9. BinkyTheMagicPaperclip Silver badge

    Obligatory 'buy second hand kit' post

    My 'best' workstation is still an Ivy Bridge dual Xeon with 64GB DDR3 and a load of expansion cards, bought when the motherboards were still (just about) produced. The system I actually mostly use is a power sipping Optiplex 3000 thin client (fanless), but I was fortunate to get that off ebay and upgrade it before component prices went silly, so it now has 32GB DDR4 and a 1TB NVMe stick in it.

    'Needed' another system in my quest to move off my main workstation off Windows, so a separate system capable of running at least two graphics cards (for PCIe passthrough), a beefy PSU, working BIOS, and a fair bit of memory, so I could re-image it at will to test configurations.

    Just over 200 quid for a ten year old HP workstation with two processors and 32GB DDR4 RAM. The 16 cores/32 threads are not particularly fast, it will consume more power than a modern system, and the PSU is proprietary but it works. Stuck in an SSD I already had, added a half decent AMD bus powered graphics card for under 100 quid, works really well, it's extremely quiet.

    Also tried getting some enterprise SSDs from CeX, that was a little less successful. They both *work* but the DC3600 has known firmware issues, one drive flatly refuses to upgrade, and its stats are very odd. The other upgraded just fine and it has plenty of life left.

    Lounge gaming PC is an older Dell Precision with a vaguely recent Xeon in it and a full priced 4070 Super that I spent more than I wanted to on, but the 5070 (12GB) is surprisingly pretty much the same price, still and offers similar performance. It's an unbalanced system, but it's quiet, runs VR fine, and ran Indiana Jones and the Great Circle at an almost constant 60fps in full detail (path tracing off) at the 720p my rather old TV supports, so in general it's a success.

    1. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
      Windows

      "My 'best' workstation is still an Ivy Bridge dual Xeon with 64GB DDR3"

      The curious thing here: until about two years ago you could pick up a Xeon based workstation box from a refurbisher for a couple of hundred AUD ie a lot cheaper than the equivalent or lower spec'd PC.

      I could only put that down to the fact that unlike the PCs, they shipped without Windows (no firmware OEM key ?) Workstations usually have high end graphics cards (typically NVidia) that even years later aren't too shabby although the SAS controllers might be a problem for some (need extra SAS/SATA breakout and power cables.)

      With the exception of the micro and SFF PCs, my systems are all refurbished Xeon workstations ecc DDR4 32/64Gb and run Linux etc like the clappers.

      Several years ago just for a lark I picked up an aging dual Opteron 2RU server for a song so that I would have a box sporting hundreds of Gb of RAM albeit DDR3. Actually pretty fast but far too noisy in a domestic or office environment. Ran RHEL7 but with RHEL8, RH dropped support for the SAS controller chipset but Alma AL8 (I think) reinstated support.

  10. that one in the corner Silver badge

    Morgan Computers

    I miss wandering around their shop near Centre Point. They used to do cameras.

    1. Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

      Re: Morgan Computers

      > I miss wandering around their shop near Centre Point. They used to do cameras.

      Me too. A great place.

      Just FYI, that business got bought out by a new one about 15 years ago, but they continue to run the same used/depreciated/cast-off kit business, under the same name, by mail-order only. I have found them helpful, cooperative, and fast. I have bought about 3 or 4 PCs, screens, and printers from them.

  11. DS999 Silver badge

    Nice to see more places to use DDR4

    Since I've had some DDR4 RAM laying around for a few years, that I've been figuring I'll put on eBay when it looks like the market for it has topped out.

    1. PRR Silver badge

      Re: Nice to see more places to use DDR4

      > more places to use DDR4

      DDR-4 ??? Warn't so long ago (well, 11 years) I bumped my main PC from 4GB to 8GB of DDR-3. Kingston 4GB 240-Pin DRAM DDR3 1333 Desktop Memory $22.99 8/24/2015 Runs 23.99/7 and hardly ever holds me up. I have 16GB and 32GB(!) machines in the wings. But is non-trivial to move my workflow and toys to other machines.

  12. BenMyers

    Windows 11 Security??? Whuzzat?

    Windows 11 was announced, touted and shipped with security being its raison d'etre. Quietly, it was also the version to attract gamers, as we learned with early updates to enhance gaming. But the bottom line is that Windows 11 security is as wobbly as ever, as witnessed by the plethora of bugs fixes this most recent Patch Tuesday. Windows 11 is inordinately complex, as Microsoft continually adds features, and EXEs call DLLs which call DLLs, which call DLLs, ad infinitum. Windows 11 is too complicated to be secure, and a long way from Dave Cutler's lean and mean Windows NT.

  13. LessWileyCoyote

    If we're mentioning trusted suppliers in the UK, I feel obliged to mention Scan Computers (https://www.scan.co.uk/) who have been a go-to source of components for me over many years.

    1. Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

      > I feel obliged to mention Scan Computers

      Scan is great and the "today only" page often has bargains -- but it's all and only new kit, AFAIK.

      I did mean to mention CeX -- https://uk.webuy.com/

      Founded by a friend of mine, the late Bobby Durdani. He asked me to run the first shop, on Whitfield Street in Fitzrovia. I declined. Instead, my friend Paul Farrington took the job, sadly now also dead. Another mate of mine from back then, Charlie Brooker, designed the logo and the original artwork. Yes, the TC Go Home/Black Mirror/Screen Wipe chap, before he got famous.

      1. Rob Daglish

        CeX used to be great, but now is decidedly less so I feel - what they pay for stuff has gone down, they downgrade from A to B to C seemingly at a whim, and the price they want for stuff has gone up - my local one has a B-grade logi mouse for 12 quid. The same one, brand new in Argos is £13.

        I do enjoy a wander on a Saturday morning while I'm waiting for the kids in the hope I'll spot a bargain, but a quick check on the internet reveals most stuff is vastly overpriced.

        I do miss the Morgan stores in London and Manchester though.

        1. Maurice Mynah

          On the other hand CeX do offer a 5-year guarantee (I suspect more of the "your money back" sort than replacement), and I've never had a problem taking back stuff that didn't work to them (the shops will also take back on-line ordered items). I'm buying less than I used to because we're on the upward side of the bath-tub curve on prices at the moment.

  14. Groo The Wanderer - A Canuck Silver badge

    I'm perfectly happy with my 16-core AMD4 platform system. It's got a beefy 128GB of memory, because DDR4 was cheap for fat DIMMs at the time. I figure I'd have to come up with five grand to replace it with "modern" hardware that really wouldn't do much except give me more VRAM for running games and LLMs.

  15. blu3b3rry Silver badge

    Most people don't need cutting edge hardware

    My main daily driver and travel machine is a 5th gen i5 HP laptop. Maxed it out with 16GB DDR3 and a 1TB SSD, its more than enough for web browsing, documents and other office stuff. Bought it two years ago for about £45. It replaced a Core2Duo machine that still works fine, but the modern web is starting to make it struggle a bit these days.

    For any big workloads I've got the gaming rig I built in 2021 (and since upgraded). Ryzen 5800X3D, 32GB DDR4 and a RTX 3060, plus two 2TB SSD's. Hopefully it remains reliable as I wouldn't want to imagine the cost of replacing RAM or SSDs at the moment. It runs modern games just fine even if I can't max out all the settings.

    I've also repurposed a HP T630 Thin Client as a silent streaming box, and in a pinch it even works fine for general desktop PC duties.

    Laptop and gaming rig run Linux Mint, got no complaints with their stability. The gaming rig feels far quicker than it did running Windows 10, too.

  16. Eric 9001 Bronze badge
    Black Helicopters

    If only people realized

    That hardware hasn't really practically become that much faster since at least 2015, unless you really overpay.

    What has rather happened is that garbage proprietary software continues to become dozens, to hundreds to thousands of times slower on a schedule.

    As a result, if you use such garbage software, yes, regular hardware upgrades are needed to have a computer that keeps getting slower at a limited pace, rather than more rapidly.

    It seems that a lot of modern development techniques result in almost every single operation being a memory read or write and billions of operations to do something that actually need like 100 at most?

    Unfortunately, DRAM really hasn't become much faster - on a clock-for-clock basis, there are no significant latency differences between, DDR3, DDR4 & DDR5 (latency actually is slightly worse each newer generation, but at the highest clocks the latency is the same or slightly lower).

    Newer revisions make up for the latency increases with bigger burst transfers, allowing maybe a 50% speedup of bulk transfers, but that won't help much with a program that say goes and fetches 40MB from RAM and makes a bunch of changes to the bytes, to have the effective result of setting one boolean or int and then stores that back into RAM, dozens of times a second (good luck fitting that in cache).

    It seems to most recent technique is to throw almost 100 megabytes(!) of power hungry SRAM at the problem, allowing much of the wastage to fit in cache (clocks must be reduced, actually slowing the CPU down, to stay in the power budget), which makes such software only run slow, as well many of those r/w's are hitting cache instead of RAM (there will of course a way found to make software run slow, with 1GB of SRAM).

    Any decent CPU made since the Core 2 Duo era is incredibly fast (considering how those are clocked at billions of Hz and most computers came with at least a billion bytes of memory, but often 2, 4, 8 or 16) and thus if you have performance issue with a Core 2 Quad you found dumped somewhere, the problem is not the hardware, it's the software.

  17. Rattus

    It does depend on your use case

    I am quite happy on old hardware, I have been using 2nd hand laptops for years, only upgrading when the hardware finally fails. (ok I am currently running on a thoroughly modern T14 gen 6 but only because it was the value proposition when my T220 finally died earlier this year)

    However I do feel the need to upgrade my firewall box, because it's lack of cryptographic acceleration is already limiting transfer speeds for the ssh tunnel end points I use. Even without the cryptographic acceleration the box still struggles with sustained throughput of more than 300Mbps, this does add quite a noticeable latency to by day to day work and long delays whenever I run test suites (10-15min per job). This is because I am maxing out the available DDR3 bandwidth.

    Again I'll buy 2nd had kit, but given I would like a 10-15 year in-service window that means that I need to be on DDR5 (the power budget for running a bigger CPU with more lanes of DDR4 doesn't add up in my use case)

  18. Daniel Pfeffer

    When a new computer is needed*, my rule of thumb is to buy the best computer that one can afford, and keep it for as long as possible. IMO this balaces between cost and utility.

    * Either because the old one has died or because the feature I need is not available for my old computer

  19. The Bobster
    IT Angle

    What's the IT angle?

    "The Reg FOSS desk is based in the British Isles, close enough to order stuff inexpensively from the UK."

    Unless the stuff you want to order is a nice greybeard-style fleece from Berghaus, who have inexplicably decided to not send to IM postcodes any more, despite what their delivery webpage says.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon