the discipline of using COBOL on show
A language that forces thought about data, intentions and ordered code produces a mindset that is usable elsewhere.
Whodathunk ?
The CIO of Australia’s taxation office (ATO) is letting administrative staff use Microsoft’s Copilot for everyday activities, in the hope it pays off by helping them to develop skills, and ideas, that eventually improve its core services. “We are getting AI into the hands of as many workers as possible to build the muscle,” ATO …
Is it "the discipline of using COBOL" on show here, or simply that COBOL is so well defined and simplistic that it's easy to convert most COBOL programs to some other language?
I have written a number of transpilers to convert from one language to another. They work brilliantly so long as the source is within the transpiler's constraints. Otherwise update the transpiler or simplify the source.
It's been so long since I had to deal with COBOL the only thing I remember about it, which elicits a smile every time, is the classic -
PERFORM SEX UNTIL EXHAUSTED
No COBOL conversion was performed here. As the original commentant pointed out: the ability to specify a problem in a form that permits the writing of a COBOL program also permits the creation of a specification that can be I’m-lamented in a different langauge.
Remember an AI prompt is just a specification written in a way an AI code generator can parse. The writing of specifications is something Imsuspect many older programmers did and do, but many code junkies have avoided doing…
Since I started letting AI assist me in understanding, improving and extending existing code that I sometimes have to work on on my own, I have learned a lot, not only about that specific code, but also about best practices for all kinds of tasks that I hadn't been aware of. For me, it's more like a search engine, or like what search engines should have been for some time, because after all I'm just searching for existing knowledge that can help me in what I'm doing. Or like asking coworkers who know more than I do about the project and the frameworks and libraries used. Being a fairly seasoned developer myself, I also can easily judge whether an AI answer is good or not.
In the 70's, Australian tax forms were two sides of a foolscap piece of paper, which was mostly just one side -- the other side just a few lines for typical tax payers. So maybe two pages of A4 or Letter, and maybe 30 minutes to complete. (Faster after you'd done it a couple of times).
Then they decided to make them "easier" by expanding the forms out into booklets. So much "easier" that they took hours to complete.
Then they added a couple of extra taxes, that they didn't call taxes for political reasons, which made the booklets thicker, but it was the "easy" format, adding pages of explanation to read and search for the data entry fields, which gave us the golden age of tax agents.
Shades of the W4 rollout in the USA in the mid-late 80s.
The W4 is used to set payroll withholding levels. In 1985 it was a simple form, maybe 1/3 of a sheet of letter/A4 in size, and many of us consultants used it to adjust our withholdings so that the end-of-year sums came out right but our start-of-year in-pocket cash was higher. One could fill it out in two shakes of an accountant's pen.
Then it was decided to "simplify" it and one page of maybe a dozen fields grew to four pages of nonsense.
IIRC it was a deputy that rolled it out while the boss-taxman was on vacation, and that worthy had to come home to deal with the furor.
Then there was the time they changed the tax mainframe system by firing up the new hardware, finding it didn't work, and realizing that throwing away the *old* hardware might have been a teensy bit of foot-shooting. We all got some extra weeks to fill out the forms that year. Oh how we laughed.
Brazil taxes are automated since the 90's because you HAD to.
(As anecdote, a company that hired 3 accountants worldwide needed 157 in Brazil. ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY SEVEN or such. Yes, it was that complicated. Still is.)
Back then, you needed to install a program from a floppy. These days, you get online forms, but it didn't get any easier.
Taking a WEEK to fill the forms is not unheard of.