The Register Home Page

back to article China marches towards re-usable rockets with successful first-stage landing

Chinese space startup LandSpace has landed a first-stage booster on land, the first time a Middle Kingdom company has achieved the feat. LandSpace flies rockets called Zhuque and has built three generations of the craft. Zhuque-1 only flew once, in 2018. Zhuque-2 became the first liquid oxygen-methane vehicle to reach orbit when …

  1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

    Congratulations LandSpace

    Even as this stuff becomes more standard, it's still difficult to get right but competition is good for all of us.

    1. Lon24 Silver badge
      Coat

      Re: Congratulations LandSpace

      Not everybody can get it right at only the second attempt - without chopsticks too!

      1. Charlie Clark Silver badge
        Thumb Up

        Re: Congratulations LandSpace

        Indeed, but even though the Chinese market is protected, capital is in short supply when compared with the US. This imposes the financial discipline that drives the current hypercompetitive market: whatever you make has to be cheap, and failures are expensive. I don't think sufficient attention is paid to how good this makes the companies that survive, we just tend to think of them as benefitting from subsidies, whereas most of them don't beyond the usual kind of tax breaks given elsewhere in the world.

        1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          Re: Congratulations LandSpace

          So the brutal efficiency of the dog-eat-dog communist system is catching up to the infinite free money-tree of American capitalism ?

          1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

            Re: Congratulations LandSpace

            Don't take my word for it: look at the bond markets.

            1. retiredFool Silver badge

              Re: Congratulations LandSpace

              Yep, and Bessent buying 4B of long term bonds is laughable in an environment of 40T debt (0.01%), and 2T of new debt every year at the moment. A reckoning is coming. And it isn't just the fed's and AI co's issuing the debt. I buy some muni's, and there is a tsunami of local/state debt this year as well.

              1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

                Re: Congratulations LandSpace

                America is 40 Trumps in debt ?

              2. Charlie Clark Silver badge

                Re: Congratulations LandSpace

                I also like the attempt to justify the intervention because tech companies have issued so many "investment grade" bonds themselves, crowding out the market. Difficult to consider Meta's bond issues as "investment grade" let alone Oracle's.

              3. VoiceOfTruth Silver badge

                Re: Congratulations LandSpace

                That debt is about $115,000 per capita in the USA. Every baby at birth already has a debt of $115,000 which they will have to pay as they become adults.

                The USA will have to live within its means. But it shows no sign of doing so. Instead it wants another credit card.

                1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

                  Re: Congratulations LandSpace

                  That number alone means little as long as there still people prepared to buy the debt. As we saw after the collapse of Bretton-Woods and the oil crisis: there are always people prepared to buy American debt (and by extension other assets). Well, there were. The rotation out of treasuries thus far is small (there aren't that many better alternatives), but the Chinese are the most notable in switching from treasuries to gold whenever the gold price drops. And it's also very slowly managing to grow its own bond market – not a good fit for international investors but if you trade a lot with China and perhaps want to avoid American controlled financial exchange systems…

                  1. retiredFool Silver badge

                    Re: Congratulations LandSpace

                    This should be our (US) greatest concern. China is becoming the producer to the world. So if I'm the UAE or any supplier of a commodity like oil or iron or ..., selling it to China, and then buying a China manufactured end product, why use dollars? You have to go from your currency to dollars to yuan and back. Seems simpler to just trade direct with China. China has slowly been implementing this. I don't see it happening overnight, just a chipping away at the dollar trade. And eventually especially with technology, it seems everyone could trade direct, be it china to australia or eu to uae. I think the US using economic sanctions routinely isn't helping either. You've got all those dollars and then wham, they get sanctioned and you can't use them. Gold on the other hand... Or platinum or palladium or any high value commodity is a different story.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Excellent

    More crap in space.

  3. Jellied Eel Silver badge

    Who's your daddy?

    Just landing a first stage is, however, mightily impressive as only SpaceX and Blue Origin have previously achieved the feat.

    So did-

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_DC-X

    which both Musk and Bezos claimed were inspirations. But DC-X got caught up in the usual politics, defunded and then we had to wait for SpacX and BO to reinvent the wheel.

    1. IGotOut Silver badge

      Re: Who's your daddy?

      Remind me how HIGH it got?

      1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: Who's your daddy?

        I believe the first flight reached an altitude of 150 freedom units, or for the rest of us, slightly more than 2 Brontosauruses

      2. Jellied Eel Silver badge

        Re: Who's your daddy?

        Remind me how HIGH it got?

        Pie high? Or 3.14km. Or perhaps like Musk, progressively higher with each test. But I don't recall SpacX sticking the landing first time either.

        1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          Re: Who's your daddy?

          >But I don't recall SpacX sticking the landing first time either.

          And that was their principle advantage.

          A failed NASA launch would mean a decade long stop in operations while there are congressional, presidential and HOA investigations all of which cost many times the total SpaceX development budget.

          Hopefully the Chinese company is also allowed to fail and iterate without all launch operations being dictated by how many sons of provincial governors they have on their board

          1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

            Re: Who's your daddy?

            Guaranteed financing was the principle advantage…

          2. Jellied Eel Silver badge

            Re: Who's your daddy?

            A failed NASA launch would mean a decade long stop in operations while there are congressional, presidential and HOA investigations all of which cost many times the total SpaceX development budget.

            I get the sense that there was some factional politics involved, ie one camp wanted another reusable space plane to replace the Shuttle. And to a degree, I can't say I blame them, especially for manned rockets. Space planes at least have some control over where they land, especially with long, wide runways. VTOL just seems riskier with the final approach being a lot more final.

            Hopefully the Chinese company is also allowed to fail and iterate without all launch operations being dictated by how many sons of provincial governors they have on their board

            China has a lot of billionaires and private money investing in space, giving the Chinese supplier diversity. They also caught another booster recently using a barge with a cage & wires to catch it, which was quite neat & speculation that could reduce landing stresses with a more gradual deceleration. But it's neat watching Scott Manley's summaries. Rocket launches used to be rare, now there's multiple countries and companies launching and innovating. Not convinced there's a market for all of them, but competition is driving innovation.

            1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

              Re: Who's your daddy?

              The USA is a democracy, so every NASA mission is dependent on representatives from 50 states all putting the good of science and the nation above short term concerns of their own voters and their chances of reelection

  4. BasicReality Bronze badge

    Congrats to them on successfully stealing American technology.

    The world really needs to step up and end the Chinese government and military.

    1. wolfetone Silver badge

      Quite right. It's disgusting that the Chinese are bombing Iran, kidnapping Venezuelan presidents, blockading Cub.....

      Wait, what?

    2. Charlie Clark Silver badge

      What do you think they have stolen? The technology that America initially stolen the scientists from Nazi Germany for?

      1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        >What do you think they have stolen

        Landing rockets on their tailfins is obviously stolen from a 1930s cover of "Astounding Stories"

        1. Charlie Clark Silver badge
          Happy

          Not Jules Vernes?

          1. FrogsAndChips Silver badge

            Nope, his ideas of space travel involved bullet-shaped rockets launched from huge cannons, not much in terms of reusability.

            1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

              Sound perfect for sending Musk to Mars… Where can I sign up?

              1. FrogsAndChips Silver badge

                I don't want to shatter your dreams, but (spoiler alert!), in the novel they come back to Earth alive and well (minus a dog).

    3. frankyunderwood123 Silver badge

      Americans need to really wake up and end what is rapidly resembling a fascist leadership structure in their own country!

      1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        America isn't a fascist administration. They can't even make the trains run on time

        1. IGotOut Silver badge

          Neither did Mussolini.

          1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge
            Coat

            That's a common misunderstanding.

            Concerned that the Royal Navy could blockade Italy's coal imports he wanted the railways to use locally available wood instead

            In the south of Italy, the only trees available were small shrubs and herbs.

            In fact he wanted the trains to run on thyme.....

      2. This post has been deleted by its author

      3. DS999 Silver badge

        Hey some of us are trying, but all the uninformed hordes who support the mentally declining pedophile grifter keep voting for more of his hollow promises.

        By 2029 we'll either have put MAGA in the dustbin of history or I'll have permanently left, desiring to escape before MAGA has a civil war over whether to rename the ruins of America as Gilead or Trumpistan.

      4. BasicReality Bronze badge

        We've been working on it. We've seeing less democrats elected these days. The government is doing well at removing criminals who don't belong here, the border has been closed off pretty well, crossings are far below where they used to be. Gun rights and religious rights are being upheld. We have a ways to go yet, but I'm confident in the direction of the country. Get Vance or Rubio after Trump and we can keep the progress going.

        1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          >Get Vance or Rubio after Trump and we can keep the progress going.

          After Trump ?

          Traitor. How can you consider a government existing beyond the eternal rule of the Great Leader !

          Persecute the heretic, kill the unbeliever

          1. BasicReality Bronze badge

            > How can you consider a government existing beyond the eternal rule of the Great Leader !

            Easy, I’m not a Democrat.

            1. Casca Silver badge

              No, you are a maga who dont know shit about history

        2. Casca Silver badge

          If you really believe that then you are truly lost.

        3. Charlie Clark Silver badge

          No mention of the national debt and the budget deficit, I see. And you're clearly not a farmer struggling with higher costs and declining demand. Or an industrialist struggling to replace expensive imports with – well nothing really because no-one in America makes what they need. Or a housebuilder who can't find skilled immigrant labour. Healthcare is getting more expensive and coverage is declining.

          Still, you've got a broken reflecting pool, a partly demolished White House and the Kennedy Center under a tarpaulin so it's not all bad.

          1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

            Trump is a man if the people. His followers see a half demolished house, an abandoned renovation project that started with no plan and ran out of money and a torn paddling pool and think of Sweet Home Alabama

            All it needs is a couple of former AirForce Ones on bricks rusting on the lawn.

          2. BasicReality Bronze badge

            Oh the debt is its own problem. You wouldn't like my solution though. I'm fully in favor of eliminating most government spending and paying off all the debt. Once that's done, lower taxes for everyone.

            I'd put Social Security and Medicare/Medicade on a 20 year plan to shut down entirely. No, we can't cut off people who rely on it now, but wind it down over a period of time.

            Government isn't your parent, you should never rely on it to live off of. Any type of welfare program, gone. I did have a friend recommend a compromise that was interesting. Keep the welfare programs available, but a hard lifetime limit on them. You can collect for a period of perhaps a year or two, any time for any reason, but after the lifetime limit reached, no more.

            But overall, people need to be responsible for themselves, not depend on the government to take care of them.

            1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

              Defund the Police. And the army, and the fire service and the roads, and any regulatory agency beginning with F

    4. VoiceOfTruth Silver badge

      Rockets were invented in China.

      America invented the hot dog. And there's debate about that.

      1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

        I think people missed the irony…

  5. Sam Shore
    Flame

    One step closer to making Firefly a reality!

  6. The man with a spanner

    Beautiful landing. Straight out of Thunderbirds.

  7. Gene Cash Silver badge
    Coat

    Waking you up at 3am

    Trust me, you don't want this... you'll have landing rockets making big sonic booms at 3am 2 or 3 times a week. There outta be a law!

    1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

      Re: Waking you up at 3am

      If your rocket breaks the sound barrier while landing you are likely to have bigger problems than a boom

      1. geoff61

        Re: Waking you up at 3am

        The first stage is supersonic when it re-enters the atmosphere. At some point one of the burns it makes on the way down takes it subsonic, but until that point its supersonic flight generates a shockwave that is heard on the ground as a sonic boom. In fact for Falcon 9 it is a triple boom - see https://www.spacelaunchschedule.com/news/sonic-boom-rocket-landing/.

        1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          Re: Waking you up at 3am

          I assumed that the sonic transition would be high enough that you wouldn't hear it on the ground and that people would be kept far enough from the landing site, for safety, that any low altitude noise wouldn't be an issue

          Then I remembered what agency was in charge of public safety.

  8. FrogsAndChips Silver badge
    Stop

    Huge constellations of broadband satellites

    Oh please, do we need to pollute our night sky even more? During the latest Perseids shower, I could spot twice as many satellites as shooting stars!

    1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

      Re: Huge constellations of broadband satellites

      If all these systems go ahead you will be able to watch a meteor shower every night

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon