The Register Home Page

back to article MFA-optional banks leave safe doors (and accounts) wide open for thieves to pillage

OPINION I write a weekly column called PWNED, about how poor security practices can lead to serious damage. Usually, there’s something funny in the malfeasance, like a CEO who kept every employee’s password in an Excel file on his desktop. However, I wasn’t laughing back in May when professional thieves invaded my 84-year-old …

  1. kurios

    Passkey issue

    As I understand passkeys, they are device-specific and are not restorable from device backups to other devices.

    Suppose the only smart device I have is my phone. If that phone breaks, or is lost or stolen, I cannot access passkey-protected sites from another device. Payments for mortgages, routine living expenses, etc. - missing those will have profound negative effects on my routine life and credit rating. That's too much risk for me.

    I recognize the password shortcomings listed by the author. And while some mitigation could be found in legislation to better protect financial victims, I'm in the U.S., where "That's a long wait for a train don't come". So I don't have an answer to the increasing attack surface and hacking tool effectiveness. It makes me long for the days of cash under my mattress and gold coins in the garden.

    1. steelpillow Silver badge

      Re: Passkey issue

      The passkey we use at work is not device-dependent. However it is user account dependent. When my lappie broke, they issued me with another and the key still worked fine. But don't expect someone else logging in to my lappie to be so lucky, they have to bring their own. Can't say if it's Yubikey, though.

      1. steelpillow Silver badge

        Re: Passkey issue

        To clarify, other users have to bring their own key.

        (Sorry, no Edit toy: Reg website hates old LTS browsers).

      2. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

        Re: Passkey issue

        Devices, phones, passkeys, whatever can be stolen. SIMs can be swapped. Somebody intending to commit a crime has no qualms about committing another crime to aid it.

        My approach is to use a unique email address for every service which involves money with a password manager generating passwords that look like line noise and, of course, storing them encrypted. At least my bank uses proper IDs instead of email addresses.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Passkey issue

          I used that email technique too, but recently discovered my ISP discloses the actual sending account in X-headers in the email. I have yet to receive an answer why.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Passkey issue

            To prevent and detect spam, most likely. It lets the recipient trace the REAL sender.

        2. Joe Gurman

          Re: Passkey issue

          Welllll…. My passkeys can only be authenticated with my ugly mug or fingerprint (as stored, encrypted, in vectorized form in secure enclaves on my devices). Not perfect, nothing is, but a lot better than anything involving passwords.

    2. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Passkey issue

      Last I read about a year ago this was being addressed and there will be (maybe already is?) along with some other shortcomings of passkeys like being able to have one device attest for another (i.e. have your PC talk to the phone on behalf of your PC's browser to get the passkey needed)

      Hopefully soon the objections and difficulties for passkeys will be behind us and we can also put passwords for websites and apps behind us.

      1. HereIAmJH Silver badge

        Re: Passkey issue

        being able to have one device attest for another (i.e. have your PC talk to the phone on behalf of your PC's browser to get the passkey needed)

        This may be what you are thinking about; I never access my banks via my phone. When I log into one of them with my laptop, I select a 'other device' option on the login. Name/password, enter and get a QRCode. I then have to pull out my phone, scan the QRCode and then my laptop browser session proceeds to be authenticated.

        Personally, the whole process pisses me off. There are two passkeys on my phone, one works and one doesn't, but they have the same name so just guess and try again. I don't like the QRCode because I have no clue what it is doing, and I just have to trust them. And now both my phone and my laptop are linked (I can't use the same process to log in from my desktop). If either of them fail I need a new passcode which basically appears to be a lost password process.

        1. DS999 Silver badge

          Re: Passkey issue

          The QRcode solution is a half measure not a final solution. It should be done via bluetooth without any intervention on your part aside from glancing at your phone to unlock it to authorize the transfer.

    3. sindrelspec

      Re: Passkey issue

      I don't get the big deal about passkeys, they are still just passwords, just really long ones.

      “OTP is just another password. So it’s a shorter-lived one, but it really is just another password,”

      I'd rather have a short password (OTP) that changes every 30 seconds over a long one that changes every 2 years (passkey).

      I wish my bank would implement a OTP that I can use on auth apps, they still do the less-preferable SMS OTP.

      1. doublelayer Silver badge

        Re: Passkey issue

        A passkey isn't just another password because the private part doesn't have to be known by the external service, only by you. You've probably used SSH keys before, no? It's like that.

        Some risks are the same. If someone can copy the key content off your computer, then they've got it too. Other risks are not, if they make a fake page and convince you it's real, the passkey won't work on their page and wouldn't provide a replayable mechanism anyway. They have many problems, but not the one you're suggesting they do.

  2. Pascal Monett Silver badge

    "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

    Sorry, but you can't go blaming banks for not using MFA there. Different passwords would already have been a major hurdle to overcome.

    But okay, she was old. An unfortunate consequence is that managing one's online life gets very complicated, especially for someone who hasn't spend their adult lifetime dealing with the Internet in general.

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

      Nope, you can blame that MFA is non mandatory. If she would have gotten a notification to agree on a money transfer the bells would have instantly rung. Just 'cause someone is over 80 years old says not much about the mental state. And the bank contacted her, she instantly checked and fought against that fraud. That is not a sign of someone being senile.

    2. nobody who matters Silver badge

      Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

      "Sorry, but you can't go blaming banks for not using MFA there. Different passwords would already have been a major hurdle to overcome"

      Agreed.

      Whilst MFA or use of a passkey would have effectively stopped the fraud in its tracks, using the same (or very similar) passwords across all the accounts, particularly as one of those accounts and its password had already been compromised is just asking for trouble. Not re-using the same password is about the most basic level of online security, and it is shocking the number of people who continue to do this (and/or use inadequate passwords) despite the amount of shouting about the pitfalls of doing so that is done. Continuing to use a password (or a passsword similar to it) after it has been compromised is plainly asking for trouble. Anybody should be able to comprehend this regardless of age and possible mental shortcomings..

      I wouldn't be using gmail for communication/sign-in for financial accounts either (or indeed for anything important - or most probably anything at all!).

      1. Neil Barnes Silver badge

        Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

        One reason for the repeated use of passwords on different accounts is likely the preponderance of sites that unnecessarily require accounts and passwords...

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

          The sites that unnecessarily require an account, or that have info/control that I really don't care if someone gets ahold of, all get the same password. Anything important (email, banking, communications, etc.) all get unique passwords.

        2. nobody who matters Silver badge

          Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

          "One reason for the repeated use of passwords on different accounts is likely the preponderance of sites that unnecessarily require accounts and password"

          Whilst I agree with you regarding general websites, that really doesn't hold for financial accounts where re-using passwords is really dumb.. .

    3. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

      But you can blame Banks for only caring if they are the one's losing.

      eg. They refused the option for a photo on card's because it would cost them.

      eg. For years it was impossible to claim that your card had been cloned. Because the banks said I couldn't happen.

      1. Mongrel

        Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

        I have a hazy memory of them testing photos on cards by using a picture of a gorilla, the results were unsurprisingly poor

    4. sindrelspec

      Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

      I'm still trying to convince my parents to use a password manager instead of a notebook they keep next to their computer. :(

      1. Richard 12 Silver badge

        Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

        That notebook is more secure than a password manager, because it requires physical presence to access. A remote attacker cannot read it, even if they have a root account.

        The downside is that it's difficult to back up, and therefore recovering from a theft or destruction will take a long time and a lot of effort.

        1. AndrueC Silver badge
          Happy

          Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

          And if you couple that with personally known rules it can be secure even it's stolen.

          I can tell you that the reminder for one of my passwords (least secure, unimportant online forums) is 'poly'. No-one can possibly use that to guess the actual password without being able to read my mind or without them having an incredibly deep and accurate understanding of how my mind works.

    5. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

      Anyone who is an adult will have been dealing with ‘on-line’/call-centre, security stuff since … lets draw a line in the sand at 1990. (PIN numbers since 2003, mandatory in the UK since 2006).

      That’s 36 years.

      I’m not technical not really an option any more , well except for project managers, and ‘Merican Freedom PED’a with swipe/dip/contactless and sign.

      —

      That being said, any bank without MFA, should have their banking licence be under the threat of revocation.

      1. Aladdin Sane Silver badge
        Headmaster

        Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

        PIN, not PIN number.

        1. intrigid

          Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

          No, a PIN is what you use for sewing. A PIN number is something you type into an LCD display when you're accessing an ATM machine.

          1. This post has been deleted by its author

          2. nobody who matters Silver badge

            Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

            Why would I refer to a 'Personal Identification Number number' ?

    6. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

      My mum who is getting on a bit had her phone number compromised. Some bright spark at the 2 letter mobile phone network (2LMPN) agreed to transfer her mobile number to an esim without doing any of the necessary checks to confirm her ID etc. So once they had control of her mobile phone number they could compromise her email on TalkTalk (yes yes i know).

      The reset password did have MFA but you had to enter a code sent to you by sms. Once they had control of her phone number and then her email that was that they could see the code. They then ordered several expensive mobile phones from her 2LMPN which were thankfully stopped from delivery by staff at her local store.

      She only found out this had happened because she said someone had sent her an email she never received. She noticed that she had had no new emails for a day or so and tried to get into her email on her phone only to fimd that it was saying her password was incorrect. She tried to call her phone from a landline and it didn’t work, just went straight to voicemail despite the phone being switched on.

      She contacted her 2LMPN who happily told her they’d transferred her number and less happily admitted they’d done so apparently with no checks. This was bloody stupid and downright dangerous and she told them so in language peppered with four letter words

      Once 2LMPN had transferred her number back onto a new sim card for her, I could regain control of her email. I checked and whoever it was had setup a rule and all incoming emails were being routed to a gmail account they obviously controlled. Killed that rule off and sent an email explaining what I would do to them if I found them. We then set up an outlook account and a rule forwarding from her old account mails from her important contacts.

      When I spoke to a 2LMPN store about this with the correct identification the bloke there could not have been more apologetic despite it not being his store that had done the transfer. I asked how someone had agreed to transfer her number without identification. I’m on PAYG and she’s on a contract, I pointed out that to swap my existing sim for a smaller one when I bought a new phone I had to provide a driving licence or passport in person.

      Bloke apologised and said somone goofed up which was an unfortunate and massive understatement. I said if it had been a regular sim then this would have been better than an esim. He didn’t understand and I mentioned that someone would either have to collect the sim and therefore be on the store’s camera doing so, or have it delivered somewhere which again might compromise who they were. Fortunately all her banking has MFA and it isn’t tied to her phone number. To be on the safe side however the bank insisted she needed new bank cards, and new passwords on everything just in case.

      None of the nefarious and criminal activities could have happened if the 2LMP network hadn’t given her number to some random stranger.

      1. Ian Johnston Silver badge

        Re: "she used the same or similar passwords on all of her accounts"

        The Co-op Bank allowed a caller to change both the email address and phone number associated with my account without, as I would have thought would been bloody obvious, sending any notification to my original address and phone number that this was being done.

        It took me two hours on the phone to sort and I had to replace my debit and credit cards.

        The very next day they did the same again. I don't bank with them any more.

  3. steelpillow Silver badge

    Biometrics?

    How many of us here would not be seen dead allowing our biometrics anywhere near our IT?

    remember, this should be about about the user's personal security and privacy, not the service provider's financial security and insurance premiums.

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      Re: Biometrics?

      This isn't biomentrics. A token generator, with QR scanner, or an USB device with a button to show the transaction before clicking OK (+ App for second MFA factor for both important banks).

      If they can deduct money so easily without her getting a notification is a system problem. EU has MFA for such stuff mandatory for years, and some members for 20+ years. (And some banks for 40+ years with paper-token for online transaction, Postbank for example...)

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Biometrics?

        >> How many of us here would not be seen dead allowing our biometrics anywhere near our IT?

        > This isn't biomentrics...

        TFA> Passkeys are typically what security folks mean when they say "phishing-resistant MFA." They replace passwords, and instead use cryptographic key pairs with the public key stored on the server and the private key – such as the user's face, fingerprints, or PIN – stored on the user's device

        Whilst PIN is one option, providers do like the "convenient option, to make the consumer's life easier" of biometrics. It is so much "better" for the User (and cheaper for the supplier) to avoid having to post out a token generator or USB device, or a little calculator thingie to just tell us to use the webcam we nust already have (nope!) or the fingerprint reader built into every laptop/phone/tablet (nope)... And for anyone replying "nope", well, those are things every User *has* to have nowadays, your fault entirely for not having them, so go and spend your money. Now. Before we lock you out of your account.

  4. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

    First though "Huh? Must bei USA..."

    Though there may be other countries which make MFA NOT mandatory for money, here consumer protection to be exact, USA was candidate number one "first in everything". USA has scammer protection, not consumer protection. The Wikipedia entry for Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) is enlightening, and I am not surprised Elizabeth Warren proposed and pushed for this, and it gets a different treating under Trump obviously. (Yes, me being German, know who Elizabeth Warren is, should have been president right after Obama, or at least after first Trump term...)

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: First though "Huh? Must bei USA..."

      Yes the CFPB that was utterly shamefully largely completely closed down by Trump & DoGE … yet seems Phoenix like reborn. No agency closedown has had odour hanging around it like protecting big finance from ripping customers off or helping people with student loans messes.

      https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/05/cfpb-vought-court-cutbacks-00985183

  5. Alumoi Silver badge

    I'm all for MFA as long as:

    1. it's a separate hardware device which NEVER connects to the internet

    AND

    2. it works as God intended: the site supplies a PIN/passkey/password/token (call it whatever you like it), I manually input that on the device and it generates a PIN/passkey/password/token which I then manually enter on the site.

    Where's the icon for luddite?

    1. Richard 12 Silver badge

      I had one of those for a while

      Was a nice little calculator-looking thing, branded with the bank logo but nothing else.

      I was somewhat worried about what would happen when the battery expired, but HSBC stopped using it after about a year so I never found out.

      1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

        Re: I had one of those for a while

        You replace the battery. Had that with one of my MFA's, Worked on like nothing happened, 'cause the state is stored in flash.

        1. Paul Crawford Silver badge

          Re: I had one of those for a while

          Or use one from another bank...

          I found with two of the banks that used to supply them that I could swap readers and no issue, saved getting a replacement when one's LCD display went horribly unreadable.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: I had one of those for a while

        > but HSBC stopped using it after about a year so I never found out.

        Stand your ground, people. I still use one of those widgets, from HSBC. When the battery died in 2025 it took a bit of faffing with their website & teller, but they finally admitted they had lots of fresh ones in stock, posted one out, and I'm still using it today.

  6. ChoHag Silver badge

    US banking is stuck in the 19th century. New at ... well I guess we just had it.

    Do Americans know that there are these things called "computers"?

    1. EnviableOne Silver badge

      ffs they still signing for card transactions

  7. HereIAmJH Silver badge

    ATM cards and PINs

    The bank doesn’t let you transact without a password, and it doesn’t issue you an ATM card without a PIN, because it knows that there has to be a required minimum level of security.

    PINs are only needed in special circumstances. In person transactions. In the US, ATM cards are almost exclusively Visa debit cards. If you are accessing your account via an ATM, you need the PIN. If you are buying something at a local merchant, you need the PIN IF you are doing a debit transaction. Visa debit cards can be processed as credit cards, no PIN required. And if you are purchasing online, no PIN is required.

    And as far as MFA, banks use it as a revenue generator, not essential security. Rather than doing something simple, like using Google Authenticator, they roll out an app so they can push additional services to you. I had one bank tell me last fall that they were rolling out an app and that it would be the only way to access my account going forward. I, and many others apparently, told them that when the app was required I'd close my account. I won't make my phone less secure by loading everyone's special app just so they can send me notifications of their latest marketing scheme. They backed off the app requirement and still allow web access, with no MFA.

    And on the whole app craze; I don't want to load apps for businesses that I use rarely. That includes some of my banks. And it also includes a new one, pre-check-in to confirm a doctor's appointment. I have worked in large corporations, I know their security is sloppy. I do not trust them to install secure apps on my phone or QR codes that can take you to any website on the internet.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: ATM cards and PINs

      I don't load apps for businesses. Period. If you need me to give you some level of access to my phone to do business with me, then I'm not going to be your customer.

  8. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

    "Phishers can also trick you into giving up your OTPs by creating a fake website that looks like your bank’s login page."

    And here is one place where banks and others who should know better (including my local council) by sending out emails with embedded links to their sites.

    They should (a) not do this and (b) in every email explain that an email that appears to come from them but has such a link must be a forgery and it is extremely dangerous to click such a link.

    Don't train users to be phished, train them NOT to be phished.

    1. Richard 12 Silver badge

      The trouble is that the alternative is for everyone to Google or Bing it, and follow a random URL hallucinated by the LLM du jour.

      So they're somewhat stuck.

      What irritates me is that these companies use huge numbers of domains. Pick one, that way I can remember it.

      If they're going to change the domain, then they should need to advertise that new domain out-of-band - meaning billboards, TV, cinema, and newspapers. Never by email.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      I store my passwords in my browser, so if I ever get a login page without the browser trying to auto-fill it, it's a HUGE red flag. Note I do *NOT* use any cloud storage for passwords, including that offered by any browser!

      1. EnviableOne Silver badge

        How easy is it to get your browser to disclose all your accounts?

        Edge loaded them all in memory in plain text

        Chrome is nearly as easy

        Firefox and Safari are a little harder, but are doable

        A standalone password manager is the only way to go.

        I would suggest storing them in a cloud with a key that you control, but there are solutions to keep everything offline if you can be bothered with the hassle of maintaining access on all your devices.

  9. DS999 Silver badge

    This is why I'm glad my 88 year old mother

    Does not trust computers at all for anything important. Her bank, her retirement account, her credit cards, she never signed up for online access to any of it and always refuses when they offer to sign her up.

    She knows she can ignore any emails she gets regarding anything financial because they do not have her email address. I've told her if she ever gets a call from one of them claiming some sort of an issue that demands immediate action, that the minute they ask the first question she should tell them she's going to hang up and call them back on the number she already has/knows so she's certain she's actually talking to who claims to be calling her.

    She still has people trying to scam her occasionally - she owns a vacant lot next to her next house with an assessed value of around $40K but its actual market price in that neighborhood would be in the $200-$250K range. She had someone call last year talking about how they really love the neighborhood and would be willing to offer her $50K for it. I think they were hoping they found some old widow whose husband handled the finances (correct so far) and didn't know that the assessed value of an unbuilt lot in that city is far below its actual value (wrong, she used to be a realtor there lol)

    1. Paul Crawford Silver badge

      Re: This is why I'm glad my 88 year old mother

      she should tell them she's going to hang up and call them back on the number she already has/knows so she's certain she's actually talking to who claims to be calling her.

      Make sure she hangs up for at least 5 minutes so they can't keep the line open and intercept the next call. Or get her to use a 2nd phone.

      1. DS999 Silver badge

        Re: This is why I'm glad my 88 year old mother

        Not sure where you live that your phone system is broken enough that it would be possible for a calling party to keep a line open after the other party has hung up for more than a few seconds.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: This is why I'm glad my 88 year old mother

      I’d put a UGreen slim AirTag compatible tracker in her purse/wallet too.

  10. Ensign Nemo

    Educate me please

    A passkey is tied to a physical device. If I lose that device, I need to be able to create a new one on a new device. Isn’t that just “forgot your password?” in another form? There would have to be some set of question/response steps that I and my account operator would go through, where they ask questions and I give the answers that are pre-registered on their system. Why is that considered any more secure? If I’ve been socially engineered to give away my first pet’s name etc, is there basically no more protection?

    If my device is stolen, how do I revoke that device’s passkey quickly?

    If the device is snatched from my hand whilst unlocked, is there ever a situation where the passkey can be accessed without further secret knowledge?

    Thank you.

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      Re: Educate me please

      Germany: Such a passkey/token device/etc is not just "sent to you", you have to prove your identity to activate it, bound to your account. Usually physically being the one getting it, having your passport or driver license ready. There are other official ways to prove the identity which are difficult to forge. The device has a unique id, and while I wrote "activate and bound to your account" so easily above, that second step is protected by a procedure as well.

      For lost / stolen: You can dial 116116 in Germany (maybe already Euorpe-wide?) to report stolen credit cards or bank passkeys, so they can be blocked as fast as possible. Your call there, that time is legally binding for the bank. Any deduction after that is on them. If the card got stolen, the time from "stolen" to "116 116" it is limited to 60€ deduction, everything above is on the bank. But if you take too long to notice it got stolen if counts as your neglect, and then it is on you. There is no fixed time frame for the latter, since it might get stolen in an airport and your flight takes 10 hours + 2 hours to get home and notice, for example. Whereas in other situations, where you instantly notice it and don't call within 30 minutes, it counts as neglect.

      1. doublelayer Silver badge

        Re: Educate me please

        I think they were talking about passkeys as suggested by the article, user-generated cryptographic tokens.

    2. doublelayer Silver badge

      Re: Educate me please

      Some of your questions have clear answers, whereas others depend on the procedures at the organization. Taking them in order:

      "A passkey is tied to a physical device.": It doesn't have to be. Passkeys are portable and you can export them. You have to remember to do it and this only helps against device failure, not theft, but you can copy passkeys for that situation. Ideally, the service allows you to create multiple ones when you set up so you can have individual ones and revoke any, but there is no guarantee whether they will allow that or only let you have one.

      "Isn’t that [replacing a passkey] just “forgot your password?” in another form? [...] If I’ve been socially engineered to give away my first pet’s name etc, is there basically no more protection?": This depends on their procedures, but it is indeed a weak point. They could require you to show up in person with identification to do it, which would make it more secure but significantly less convenient.

      "If my device is stolen, how do I revoke that device’s passkey quickly?": The ideal way is to have a second passkey on that account but not on the same device, log in with that, and revoke the previous one. I have some passkeys stored in a secure location for that reason. Unfortunately, that's more thinking ahead which makes passkeys more difficult for others to use. If you only have one, then you probably have to contact the organization and ask them to revoke.

      "If the device is snatched from my hand whilst unlocked, is there ever a situation where the passkey can be accessed without further secret knowledge?": This depends how you store them. Those passkeys I can access from my phone require me to reauthenticate to open the app, so someone who steals my phone when unlocked but doesn't know the unlock code (in my case, a different one, though the normal unlock code is more often the requirement) won't be able to get at them. That's the default on some applications, and on others you can use OS features to make it happen anyway.

  11. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Passkeys are a complete garbage system. They’re completely unnecessary. And we need more places leaving two factor authentication optional instead of making it mandatory.

    Simply by using a password manager and different passwords for each of the sites, her issue could have been completely avoided. It doesn’t need 2FA to be solved.

    I am glad she recovered everything.

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      So you WANT anyone anytime large money deduction to be without you agreeing? 'cause this is what the article is about. Unless you pre-authorized an institution or company to deduct from your bank account, i.e. mutual trust, there should be no way to deduct such large sums.

      There are things where "Freedom of choice to have NO security" is wrong. Similar for seat belt and a few other things. Too many humans are too dumb or too young to understand, and as such the nation should enforce it. Not only for "We the people", but very often for the cost on the national level. That includes thinking so far ahead that healthy people, which includes not only less broken bones and necks, but less "having to defend yourself for everything, literally everything, since the country does not give a shit", are more productive and help the whole nation to prosper. Look at Uber in USA for a more recent example, where you are told ahead "your drive will cost 99$", but then deduct "149$", from you might get about 10% to 20% back if you complain if you have German "that is not correct" genes, but not the whole 50$ fraud - That is the reality in USA, confirmed by many in the USA. In European Union the bureau of consumer protection of each country (or the EU wide one for big cases) kicks in. Tons of other USA-only "invented extra fee, which has not been told ahead" are the same, including the grocery "price tag is without sales tax and other local area taxes". And all our EU prices must include the local tax and fees, so you see the "what you will actually pay" ahead of the purchase.

      In case of USA the sentence "We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America." is not applied thoroughly, 'cause "general Welfare" is going down, and "domestic Tranquility" is spiraling down since ~1970s. And mandating MFA for large money transfers (i.e. above 60€ currently here), so you don't have to be in high alert that anyone anytime can steal from your bank account, should be part of "insure domestic Tranquility" and "promote the general Welfare".

      Woah, that got a bit longer here than expected...

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        I did not push for no security. I'm pushing to leave this 2FA security theater as an option, and not make it mandatory. Strong randomly generated passwords, a different one on every site, are perfectly fine. Two factor authentication is not needed, and just a hassle to deal with in most cases.

        Passkeys on the other hand, are complete garbage. They're a solution looking for a problem, and a bad one at that.

        And no, no one should be able to access your bank account without your permission. Where the hell do you even think my initial comment supports that?

  12. LikeAStone

    The right way to do MFA today is with a passkey ???

    Absolutely not!

    The right way to do MFA is with a hardware security key running FIDO U2F. Do not confuse that with FIDO-2.

    U2F tokens are designed to do second factor auth and only that. Then somebody -MS- decided that it could be "improved" by adding biometrics so that they could replace the whole authentication method (and be used to log-in to Windows). And FIDO-2 was born.

    And then somebody thought... well, how about replacing passwords with this. And Passkeys was born (out of FIDO-2).

    But then, that is not really MFA, is it?. Well, let's add "first factor" back into the equation... with a stupid PIN.

    So you go from a HW token that can be used with an unlimited number of websites, and where you can still have a real password (backed with a password manager) to a HW token that can only store a small number of passkeys, where the real password is gone and replaced with a small PIN... or what the "general public" is supposed to use: an app on their phone and a mug shot or fingerprint... on devices that can be easily lost or stolen; or being pretty much always logged in on their "authorized" computers.

    The only advantage of Passkeys is for the website owners, not for the users. For the user is a step back security wise (or at least, it could be a step back. For the mybank123 crowd, anything is an improvement) For the website... well, no more dealing with passwords that apparently they cannot secure.

    So no: reject Passkeys and ask for real U2F.

    And BTW, no thanks. Mandatory whatever is not the way to go. Even if you have one user which is very close to your heart, that is not a good reason to force everybody else to use a given technology. And that comes from someone who switched financial institutions precisely because they decided to make passkeys mandatory (without offering real U2F)

    PD: the real issue with banks is that more often than not (at least in the US), they will happily fall back from MFA to "your mother maiden name" when asked nicely over the phone.

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      Re: The right way to do MFA today is with a passkey ???

      > PD: the real issue with banks is that more often than not (at least in the US), they will

      > happily fall back from MFA to "your mother maiden name" when asked nicely over the phone.

      Which is what is different here (EU): You have a predefined or self set phone-banking-PIN. Mandatory. Introduced exactly for that reason about a decade (or more?) ago.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: The right way to do MFA today is with a passkey ???

        I dealt with this recently. Had to call my company benefits line to assist with something. They wanted my phone PIN, which I'd never heard of before, since I've never had to call them. So instead of helping, they'll generate a new PIN and physically mail it to me. Call back in a week when I get it.

        I informed the person of what a useless piece of sh!t they were, I needed something dealt with now, not later. Wasn't a very pleasant call for them I imagine.

        These kinds of mandatory "security" systems are a terrible idea.

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    EU's PSD2 regulation solved that ages ago

    The EU's PSD2 regulation has legally required SCA for all online payments since December 31, 2020 for all financial institutions involved in online payments - meaning mostly but not only Banks. So, a Bank not having MFA hasn't been a thing here for at least 5 years now. Isn't there some similar regulation in the US? And judging by some of the comments above - what's with the UK? Even in the UK, it was mandated by law since - *checks Google* - since 2022.

    There are some exceptions: Merchants can opt out of SCA at their own risk - which is why if you shop on Amazon for example, and you have your card details saved, checkout is immediate without them waiting for your card provider bank verification.

    But the general rule is that if the customer is accessing their account online, SCA is mandatory. I'm puzzled that the US wouldn't have something similar. OTOH, it's the US, I guess things work differently there

    1. X5-332960073452
      FAIL

      Re: EU's PSD2 regulation solved that ages ago

      SCA - strong customer authentication.

  14. Sproggit Silver badge

    I Know This Is Pedantry, But...

    ... what is being described in this article doesn't strictly meet the definition of MFA.

    To clarify, MFA - Multi-Factor Authentication - means that in order to prove your identity the the bank's infrastructure, you would have to provide at least two of the following things:-

    1. Something you Know [like a Password or Pin]

    2. Something you Have [like a Physical Device - such as a token that generates OTPs]

    3. Something you Are [i.e. is derived from your physical being, such as a retina pattern.

    When we see discussions of "MFA" that include e.g. a Password, but then combined with a PIN or value sent to an email address, this IS NOT MFA... It's two instances of Single-Factor Authentication [something you know]. That's "better than nothing", but as this article then goes on to explain, it's far too easy for an attacker to compromise an email address. It's also far too easy for them to write an inbox-filter that pushes emails from a legitimate bank email address to a waste bin [or somewhere else].

    Another dimension to the challenge here is that because mobile phones can receive both emails and SMS messages, it means that the handsets themselves represent a significant single point of failure in the authentication process.

    Finally, it's worth noting that there are viable solutions to this - such as returning to the original type of physical RSA tokens. Even better, technology has reached the point where a physical token generator could be embedded in something with the dimensions of your credit or ATM card, if - *if* - the banks wanted to.

    There's a reason that they don't - and it's cost. Basically, the calculus that the bank performs is to look at the cost of rolling out something like a credit-card-based token-generation MFA solution and compares that cost with the amount of actual card fraud they have to pay for. Note that this is not the same as the total amount of account or card fraud - because of course banks are getting better and better at side-stepping liability for breaches - using, can you believe it, their terrible history at preventing card fraud as illustrative of why customers should be more cautious.

    The key point to remember here is that there are viable, reliable, effective solutions available today. The fact that they haven't been implemented it is simply because regulators are happy to turn a blind eye and not force the banks to eat in to their outrageous profits* in order to tighten up on security.

    * JPMorgan net profit for 2025 - NET profit - was $57 billion. That's over a billion a week, in *profit*.

    Citigroup net profit for 2025 was $14,3 billion.

    HSBC net profit for 2025 was $23.1 billion.

    So that's just shy of $100 billion in net profits from just 3 banks... yet they can't afford secure remote authentication for their clients? Pull the other one, cough, cough, it's got bells on...

  15. Taliesinawen Bronze badge
    Terminator

    How the crims got into accounts :o

    > We don’t know for certain how the crims got into my mom’s accounts ..

    Most probably a phishing email. It is extraordinary in this day and age that the email vendors don't provide end-to-end encryption and digital signature. Or that you need the skills of a cyber-security-professional in order to safely navigate the Web from your industry standard desktop.

    1. doublelayer Silver badge

      Re: How the crims got into accounts :o

      Surely, if those problems are as easy to solve as you claim, you could solve them for us? If you try, one problem you'll run into is that the things you've identified as the problem are not the problem. Digital signature on email? It almost certainly had that; it's called DKIM. It proves the email came from the server that it did come from, not that the server was trustworthy. E2E encryption isn't on email by default, though we could probably extend the CA process to make it easier, but once again, that would only prevent interception, not prove trustworthiness.

      As for safely navigating the web, you're asking for the technical equivalent of the entire world not to have anything dangerous in it. It didn't work for the physical world, where hazards and crime continue to exist, and you can't manage it on the web perfectly, nor even do much of an imperfect job without lots of consequences.

      We can do plenty to try to improve this. We can write filters to try to catch impersonation and warn users more actively, for example, though it will definitely alert incorrectly sometimes and users will still have to handle that. If you think it's possible for someone to make email perfectly safe and they're just not bothering, you don't understand the problem and won't be able to make those improvements that are possible until you do.

      1. Taliesinawen Bronze badge

        Re: How the crims got into accounts :o

        > Digital signature on email? It almost certainly had that; it's called DKIM. It proves the email came from the server that it did come from

        But it doesn't prove the email is legit or that nefarious types are not reading it.

        > If you think it's possible for someone to make email perfectly safe and they're just not bothering, you don't understand the problem

        The problem being that the nefarious types can't read your emails or sell your confidential information on to the business sector.

        1. doublelayer Silver badge

          Re: How the crims got into accounts :o

          Now you're making my point as if it disagrees with me making the same one. A digital signature proves that the email came from where it says it came from. It doesn't prove that where it says it came from is a person you should trust. A digital signature mostly can't do that. And yet that was what you were certain we didn't have and needed, both of which were incorrect assumptions.

          "The problem being that the nefarious types can't read your emails or sell your confidential information on to the business sector."

          No, that's a different problem. Encryption helps with that problem, but if your emails are being sold, it's probably not interception of unencrypted data that's doing it. But the problem you originally complained about and that the article and all these comments is talking about is that criminals can phish people for bank details, and the ideal solution is either to make it impossible for them to phish (which is exceedingly unlikely) or to prevent them from being as successful even if their phishing messages work. I'm not convinced you understand the elements of the new problem you've switched to, but it's also not relevant to what you or anyone else was talking about earlier.

  16. Boris the Cockroach Silver badge
    Unhappy

    Passkeys

    MFAs security this and security that.

    Next week DNA scans (defeated by a severed finger... that also does the fingerprint scanner)

    And now for a little observation.

    I'v been down the bank more than once to sort out problems (I dont do phone or on-line bankings due to the identification problem) and have seen the staff serve me in their partitioned off office

    "Yes sir Mr Roach, the money has been transferred from retirement fund #1 to retirement fund #2, just sign here " and then the staff have departed back inside the bank via the security door. via a key fob and a passphrase typed into a key panel , I did ask what happens if they typed in the wrong number, and it turns out to be wrong number twice and the bank gets locked down.

    Now, if the banks can implement that sort of system for their own staff, why can they not implement it for us plebs who keep money in them? or better yet for us computery types who like on-line banking. a read only USB stick that boots your PC with a custom OS that only lets you log into the bank, and will do new key pairs every session for keeping the communications secure.

    1. doublelayer Silver badge

      Re: Passkeys

      "Now, if the banks can implement that sort of system for their own staff, why can they not implement it for us plebs who keep money in them?"

      They can. But check the existing comments to see the reaction to much simpler methods of security and what some of us tech people, assuming every commenter in these forums is one, think of that. If people refuse to use simple MFA methods, how do you think they'd react to better but more complex ones? Extend that to most customers of a bank who are even less technical. If too many people prefer convenience to security, then convenience is what they'll get.

      If you support forcing all customers to use the more secure method, I agree with you in principle but it's unpopular and they don't want to lose customers. That means the best we can hope for is that higher level of security as an optional feature, and some banks do offer that. If you want a challenge-response MFA token login system as separate hardware, you can get it, but you probably have to shop around until you find a bank you like which offers it. More do that via mobile app than do it with custom hardware.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon