The Register Home Page

back to article BOFH: Vibe-coded solutions arrive for problems nobody has

Official BOFH logo (red rotary telephone with devil's tal and devil's horns) BOFH logo EPISODE 10 Sigh. The Boss has written an app and is quite pleased with himself. The higher-ups are even more pleased because it apparently saves us money. They're so pleased, in fact, they're mandating that it be installed on Company phones …

  1. blu3b3rry Silver badge
    Pirate

    Another boss defenestrated

    Serves him right for achieving an unholy triumvirate:

    -AI

    -Vibe coding

    -Phone app

    1. Evil Auditor Silver badge
      Thumb Up

      Re: Another boss defenestrated

      Although, I'd argue a more ferocious exit was more than justified.

      1. Xalran

        Re: Another boss defenestrated

        I would have gone for the room with the massively reinforced door at the lowest level of the underground carpark (under the office building) that contains all the failed (rampaging) robotic experiments built over the years. I think there's also a pit with some nasty stuff in it in the same area, it could have also been an option.

        But a window sill jumping boss is a classic.

      2. BebopWeBop Silver badge
        Angel

        Re: Another boss defenestrated

        Yup, the boss should have taken advice on functionality - that window catch warning feasture might have proven very useful.

  2. frankvw Silver badge
    Pint

    Best. Summary. Ever.

    "...the synergy of deep technical knowledge and plain speaking is essentially what AI claims to be after you add a layer of obscurity, some hallucinations, and a touch of mental illnes..."

    This must be the best, most complete and to-the-point definition of all that's wrong with the AI hype that I have ever seen.

    Simon, have a few of these. You've more than earned it! ----->

    1. chivo243 Silver badge
      Thumb Up

      Re: Best. Summary. Ever.

      I've had all of those in my lifetime... I've been obscure, had hallucinations, and we all have a touch of mental illness, or we wouldn't in tech...

      1. Ken Hagan Gold badge

        Re: Best. Summary. Ever.

        You missed out "deep technical knowledge" but you're definitely 75% of the way there.

  3. Terry 6 Silver badge

    Ahh

    I have a tiny (very tiny) bit of sympatry for Boss here.

    My working years were punctuated by people (ironically usually bosses) who'd focus in on an example and treat it as the substantive issue.

    Like when I was running an off-site literacy class and in one of the interminable churns of Local Authority organisation we weren't allocated a budget.

    I emailed the new boss.

    I told her that we needed a budget for materials for the class.

    "Without a budget", I explained, "I can't so much as place an order for tissues for the classroom".

    I was young and innocent and just thought this a good example of how dire the situation was.

    Said Boss sent a long email about why we needed tissues, couldn't these 7 year old kids bring their own etc.

    Which a) most importantly, ignored the fact that we still needed a fucking budget. and b) showed a dismal understanding of small children or the complexities of bringing them to an off-site classroom.

    (She was by the way the Principle Educational Psychologist . )

    1. GlenP Silver badge

      Re: Ahh

      who'd focus in on an example and treat it as the substantive issue

      Our management team were doing some business risks analysis, the highest risk by far was staff retention and potential loss of knowledge. Instead of addressing this the board decided we needed to focus on the risks of the MD being kidnapped on a business trip! Of all the people in the business the MD was the one who'd least be missed in the short term and since we don't have a presence in South America or southern Africa his kidnap was very unlikely.

      1. Anonymous Custard Silver badge
        Trollface

        Re: Ahh

        The true BOFH response of course would have been "challenge accepted..."

      2. Terry 6 Silver badge

        Re: Ahh

        This sounds like one of Parkinson's Laws. Not the most famous one, work expanding etc..

        There's one in which the amount of time spent considering an item is inversely proportional to its significance. He instances spending 10 minutes deciding on a nuclear power station then an hour on a new bike shed.(or something to that effect)

        1. the spectacularly refined chap Silver badge

          Re: Ahh

          All right, Mr. Wiseguy, you're so clever, you tell us what colour it should be.

          1. Anonymous Coward Silver badge
            Mushroom

            Re: Ahh

            and should it be fitted nasally?

        2. Tim99 Silver badge
          Unhappy

          Re: Ahh

          If only it was only an hour.

      3. Evil Auditor Silver badge

        Re: Ahh

        ... the highest risk by far was staff retention...

        Must be a terrible hiring process if the risk is that staff retains. SCNR

      4. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Ahh

        there are many companies where a kidnapped MD would improve the business!

    2. doublelayer Silver badge

      Re: Ahh

      I don't have much sympathy either for you or the boss. It is annoying when people take an example as the only important part, but generally it means that the example was a bad example, which the boss's definitely was and yours might have been, at least your new boss thought so. The solution to that is to either provide another example or a set of them which make the point more clearly or to describe the purpose in general terms which explain the need for it. I'm sure you could have listed many more things you might have to buy which would have justified a budget, whether or not tissues were important. Perhaps you tried, and I'd have more sympathy with you if, after providing more examples, your boss continued to focus only on tissues.

      In the case from the article, the boss had a chance to provide any example he pleased about how his app would be useful. He failed. He then got an opportunity to defend his example. He failed. He then got an opportunity to provide more examples. He failed. In my opinion, this doesn't count as hyperfocusing on the first example.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Ahh

        Quick everyone! Pass me the net! We've found the middle manager!

  4. Michael H.F. Wilkinson Silver badge
    Coffee/keyboard

    Faulty window latches?

    The first mention immediately spelled doom for the boss.

    "It's got AI in it!"

    "So have the words failure, and painful, and brainless"

    Hilarious, I must use that the next time anyone says "It's got AI in it!"

    Great episode once more.

    1. Alumoi Silver badge

      Re: Faulty window latches?

      "blind leading the blind" to "incompetent leading the blind – through a minefield. In the dark. On pogo sticks."

      Best definitionf of MBAs I've heard in a long time.

      1. CA_Diver
        Flame

        Re: Faulty window latches?

        >>> Best definitionf of MBAs I've heard in a long time.

        Sound like a project manager with an MBA

        1. Xalran
          Devil

          Re: Faulty window latches?

          Did you mean a project mangler with an MBA

    2. David Harper 1

      Re: Faulty window latches?

      Damn, I need that on a T-shirt!

  5. Korev Silver badge
    Thumb Down

    No BOFH on the front page.

    BOFH is one of the highlights of the Register, why doesn't it have a heading on the new front page?

    1. Anonymous Custard Silver badge
      Pirate

      Re: No BOFH on the front page.

      Because in a wonderful case of synchronicity, the whole mess of a redesign on this site looks like it's been vibe coded by the boss?

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: No BOFH on the front page.

        Ah there had been a redesign .

        I was wondering why it became so hard to find the comment section

    2. Anonymous Anti-ANC South African Coward

      Re: No BOFH on the front page.

      I was wondering about that myself... Told myself something felt off, but could not quite place it...

      Luckily I sniffed out the Bastardly article and had a good laugh at the end.

      Some vibe coding indeed. Wonder if this will go in another Who, Me? episode...

      1. LybsterRoy Silver badge

        Re: No BOFH on the front page.

        When BOFH no longer seemed to be shown in the normal notification headlines I added a filter just for him and now I don't miss any.

        1. Anonymous Custard Silver badge
          Headmaster

          Re: No BOFH on the front page.

          I'd also highlights the useful alerts feature of the website.

          You can use that to send you a notification email (with a direct link) for whenever an article with the given criteria is posted.

          It can do keywords and (optionally) author, but unfortunately not tags (at least explicitly).

          I have one for posts by Simon, and so routinely get a link to fresh BOFH articles (and very occasionally others when he posts them) in my inbox.

          Used to do the same for Dabbsy and Lester, both sadly no longer appearing here for various reasons.

          1. Korev Silver badge
            Alien

            Re: No BOFH on the front page.

            I use the RSS feeds for the same reason

            1. thosrtanner
              Thumb Down

              Re: No BOFH on the front page.

              Which they have completely broken. https://forums.theregister.com/offbeat/bofh/headlines.atom is still there but the dates are wrong and the article links are broken.

              1. Mimsey Borogove Bronze badge
                FAIL

                Re: No BOFH on the front page.

                Which they have completely broken.

                Someone suggested the new look was vibe-coded, and I think this proves it.

        2. David Hicklin Silver badge

          Re: No BOFH on the front page.

          I also had to add a filter for BOFH when it dropped off the daily digest , although it does sometimes false positive

    3. msage

      Re: No BOFH on the front page.

      And why doesn't /Week work as well any more :(

      1. Anonymous Custard Silver badge
        Pint

        Re: No BOFH on the front page.

        I invite you to pour yourself your favourite liquid refreshment and enjoy what the commentards think of the redesign.

      2. KittenHuffer Silver badge

        Re: No BOFH on the front page.

        Use the Archive instead!

      3. KarMann Silver badge
        Boffin

        Re: No BOFH on the front page.

        It didn't for some part of the first day, but it seemed to be fixed reasonably quickly. Works For Me at the moment. Have you tried again lately? (My bookmark has a final slash, '/Week/', but it seems to work either way. And in at least some cases, pun intended, capitalisation seems optional, at least in the case of the On Call tag.)

        1. that one in the corner Silver badge

          Re: No BOFH on the front page.

          /week/ works on my desktop, but on my Android tablet it gets redirected to /archive/ !

    4. Xalran

      Re: No BOFH on the front page.

      It if was just the BOFH...

      The new Mangled Enshitified Vulture Central made it extremely difficult to find the On Call, Who, Me?, Borkborkbork! and a few more that used to be easy to find when a new post appeared...

      I won't even talk of the way articles are shown from the latest to the oldest (top down, and not left to right) because I would end up saying bad things ( there's a few languages that are written that way... English is not one of them.)

  6. Anonymous Custard Silver badge
    Pint

    I am so "borrowing" this response!

    "It's got AI in it!" the Boss whines, after the PFY and I express our doubts.

    "So have the words failure, and painful, and brainless," the PFY points out.

    That one is definitely going into the "to use at work" store...

    Definitely one of these for such a sunny day ------------------------->

  7. BartyFartsLast Silver badge

    I'm all for vibe coded AI phone apps ony work phone.

    That'd be the phone that's been locked in my shit cupboard for nearly four years, uncharged and unconfigured.

  8. Boris the Cockroach Silver badge
    Devil

    Your BoFH is

    far more tolerant that I am

    I would have got about 1/2 way through that conservesation with the boss before reaching for the window catch and a swift running jump into oblivion (well that we'd tell the police anyway) he was very depressed we'd say, especially after all those death threats. no we dont know who sent them or why they seemed to be timed stamped 5 minutes after he jumped....... it was a good tuck and 1/2 pike before impact though

  9. Blackjack Silver badge

    salt and vinegar crisps and marmalade sandwiches? Someone here been watching a plushie bear interacting with cartoon characters.

    1. WolfFan Silver badge

      President Xi, the Orange One, and the Muskrat?

      1. Blackjack Silver badge

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5L68isWXVc

    2. BigKev

      If he thinks that is good - wait until he tries hot buttered toast with marmite and marmalade on - it truly IS the food of the gods!

  10. goblinski Silver badge

    ... through a minefield. In the dark. On pogo sticks...

    In all fairness, a pogo stick would be the very best way to cross a minefiled in the dark.

    Or a minefield - period, as dark or not shouldn't make a difference in a well laid out minefield :)

    Orders of magnitude smaller contact surface, and fewer number of steps per distance covered, on the other hand...

    1. druck Silver badge

      Just replace the foot pegs with a large armoured disk to stand on, then if you happened to trigger a mine, the blast would propel you to the other side of the minefield.

  11. DS999 Silver badge
    Pint

    You've invented a mansplaining app

    If I drank coffee I would have spit it over my keyboard. Bravo!

  12. Luiz Abdala Silver badge
    Headmaster

    Times New Roman article.

    I like it. Or Chrome is having a seizure JUST on the BOFH article and missing HTML tags. This comment page is Arial or whatever, as usual.

    Considering the entire BOFH list of articles has the same font, I assume it is proposital, and a neat detail that I missed for far too long.

    Edit: forget that, some articles are Times New Roman, some are Arial. Is that AI messing with page generation?

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon