The Register Home Page

back to article London cops hail fixed facial recognition cams after suspects collared every 35 mins

London's Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) is giving its six-month trial of static live facial recognition (LFR) cameras credit for helping it secure an arrest every 35 minutes. The Met's LFR chief said the results show why LFR is "such a powerful tool" for coppers, who, across 24 operations between October 2025 and March 2026, …

  1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Stranger things

    The arrest count is the part everyone repeats and the part that means least. 173 collars across 24 deployments is a fine number, but the question the Met carefully declines to answer is what fraction of those bodies would have been picked up anyway through, you know, policing. A woman wanted since 2004 for assault did not become un-findable for 21 years through some impressive feat of fugitive craft. She presumably had a National Insurance number, a GP, and an address the whole time. Read one way, the LFR success story is also a confession that the force had filed her case in the drawer marked "later" and forgotten which drawer.

    The same applies to the 37 breaches of conditions. These are by definition people the state already knows: electronic tags, SHPO registrations, bail addresses. Locating a man on a tag does not normally tax the investigative imagination. If the Met needed a camera on the High Street to do it, the interesting headline is about case management, not facial recognition.

    "One arrest every 35 minutes" is the other line that does heavy lifting and means nothing. Spread 173 arrests across 24 operations of a few hours each and the suggestive cadence appears. Spread them across the actual six months between October and March and you get roughly one a day, which is less of a press release and more of a Tuesday.

    Then there is the accuracy theatre. "470,000 walked past, one false positive" sounds magnificent until you notice most of those 470,000 were never matched against anything, because they were not on the list. The denominator that matters is matches generated, of which we are told precisely nothing. A system that flags one innocent passer-by per million and one per fifty matches are very different propositions, and only the latter tells you whether being stopped on the strength of an LFR ping is a coin toss or a near-certainty.

    "Crime in this area is down by more than 10 percent" arrives without a control group, a baseline period, a displacement analysis, or anything else a GCSE statistics candidate would ask for before signing the press release. National crime trends, seasonal variation, and high-street footfall after the cameras went up are all left as exercises for the reader.

    Step back from the individual numbers and the piece reads, to anyone hunting for the awkward figures, as the shape of a conclusion already reached with the evaluation written to fit. Every metric on offer points the same way; none of the obvious follow-ups are entertained; the comparisons that would make the headline numbers meaningful are unaccountably absent. The overall tone is that of an organisation strikingly uncurious about its own results, apparently satisfied with knowing that 173 people were arrested and apparently uninterested in knowing how many would have been arrested without the cameras, or whether any of the alerts that did not result in an arrest should have been alerts in the first place. That posture matters, because the case for continuing to install permanent surveillance infrastructure rests on questions the operator declines to ask.

    1. Andy The Hat

      Re: Stranger things

      Obvious and probably a very important question - were the 469,827 images, which didn't give a hit, all immediately deleted from the database or are they stored for future reference?

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Stranger things

        They will have been used as AI training data and as we know from the AI companies, the AI systems don’t retain the original images…

      2. NoneSuch Silver badge
        Joke

        Re: Stranger things

        All 469,827 images were retained, save for the 1,278 that captured politicians leaving sex clubs. Those were deleted immediately by the Chief Constable.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Stranger things

          ... save for the 1,278 that captured politicians leaving sex clubs. Those were deleted immediately by the Chief Constable.

          Right ...

          But why the 'Joke Alert'?

          .

          1. collinsl Silver badge
            Joke

            Re: Stranger things

            Legal reasons.

            For legal reasons this post is also a joke.

        2. anothercynic Silver badge

          Re: Stranger things

          Surely the 'deleted' should be in quotes... because they weren't deleted deleted, but just... deleted/moved to external media for future... reference. Right?

          Am I cynical? You bet your ass I am.

    2. Evil Auditor Silver badge

      Re: Stranger things

      Maybe there's an opportunity for extending the "blade runners'" business...

      1. TimMaher Silver badge
        Terminator

        Re: “blade runners”

        I was more going for Minority Report.

        Must get my eyes changed.

    3. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Stranger things

      the question the Met carefully declines to answer is what fraction of those bodies would have been picked up anyway

      More importantly, how many people were stopped, or worse cuffed and hauled down to the police station, before they figured out the camera got it wrong? I don't think anyone is really against improved ways for the police to arrest guilty people, but not at the expense of unnecessary harassment (or worse) of a lot of innocent people.

      1. Graham Cobb

        Re: Stranger things

        And, more importantly, how many innocent people get hassled more than once? If the camera pings for the same wrong person every time they walk down a public street then that is clear harassment. How does the process handle that so the same innocent person never gets hassled again?

        1. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: Stranger things

          "How does the process handle that so the same innocent person never gets hassled again?"

          That can be really difficult as these systems are proprietary and the way they operate opaque. With AI, nobody may know why a match was made and no way to find out. It just does what it does. It could be the same way that melanoma is detected from images, the photos with the ruler in show melanoma. No ruler, no cancer. That took time to sort out as there wasn't insight into what was being analyzed.

    4. MachDiamond Silver badge

      Re: Stranger things

      Does the plod have the resources to collar and process an arrest every 35 minutes. A FTA on a traffic citation is an offense, but they often get ignored until there's contact again usually through another traffic stop. If somebody doesn't show up to pay or fight a citation, it should be easy enough to consider that an admission of guilt and recover the fine through tax filings, holds on any benefits or when an employer runs a check on a new hire to see if they are eligible to work. If you've ducked out of something and find yourself blocked from getting a bank account, tax refund or anything else such as a car loan, that might encourage some to get things settled so they can get on with their life.

      For more serious offenders, FR is a tool and has to be cross-checked. It's wrong enough times that it can't be taken as incontrovertible fact. There are plenty of stories around that and many are so full of stupid that the cops should be very embarrassed. I recall one instance where there was a robbery and the lady the FR identified was almost due to deliver a child while the CCTV showed a rather skinny woman just days prior. They still had her locked up for days. The lady arrested did have a prior record which was why she was in the system, but basic police work should have eliminated her straight away.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    The tech … was deployed in Croydon as part of the Met's first trial of fixed LFR cameras.

    Given the Met Police have been using networked digital cameras since circa 2006 across London’s West End, I suspect this is only the first publicly announced trial of LFR technology.

    By the way, “fixed” does not mean non-mobile. A feature of the 2006 wireless infrastructure rollout was given the small size of the digital cameras they could be readily relocated to give better views of places of interest…

  3. Evil Auditor Silver badge

    Among those 173 arrests was that of a 36-year-old woman who had been wanted by the police after failing to appear at court for an assault in 2004.

    So, she was... 14 years old at the time of the assault. Should we really consider this a success?!

    1. NoneSuch Silver badge

      The cops do.

    2. Roland6 Silver badge

      Assuming that to be correct, that would suggest not only are the police using LFR they are also using AI assisted age regression and progression algorithms.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    The Gestapofication will continue until morale improves. Next up: showing your passport to enter Tesco.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Nope wont happen, the various victim groups will claim that that's unfair for illegal immigrants.

  5. teebie

    "We are arresting lots of people" isn't an acceptable reply to "this tool makes you more likely to arrest the wrong person.

    This may be the first time I have seen the police give a hint towards numbers of guilty people caught, rather than just arrests.

    I count 6 arrests that look to be for good reason, which, given the Met's record for honesty, we can extrapolate to around 4 arrests of guilty people out of 173 arrests.

    "Thirty-seven of the total 173 arrests related to those who had breached their court-imposed conditions"

    What does 'related to' mean here? Was it 'they were the same colour as the suspect' again?

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Show me the numbers

    I'd love to know what percentage of the people nabbed by this tech had no right whatsoever to be in the UK in the first place. Enforcing a Western country's borders is often one of the most efficient ways of driving down serious crime, without having to trample all over the civil liberties of the law-abiding through diabolical schemes like blanket facial recognition.

    Of course, we all know that a totalitarian surveillance state is the real end goal, which is precisely why our leaders push for open borders. Manufacture a crisis and offer a ready made "solution"!

  7. Pete 2 Silver badge

    No rest for the wicked

    > suspects collared every 35 mins

    That's 41 times a day. They must be getting pretty sick of it.

    1. Excused Boots Silver badge

      Re: No rest for the wicked

      Which reminds me of the old joke,

      A person is injured on the roads every 25 minutes......the guy must be made of iron!

      1. MachDiamond Silver badge

        Re: No rest for the wicked

        "A person is injured on the roads every 25 minutes......the guy must be made of iron!"

        As an engineer, I want to know how "being injured" is defined. If I find my thumb with my hammer, that's an injury, but if I was setting a nail as opposed to driving it home in one go, there might only be some cussing for a few minutes rather than a trip to A&E.

    2. Roland6 Silver badge

      Re: No rest for the wicked

      That rate doesn’t leave much time for the paperwork or tackling other crime, or even just sitting in a car drinking coffee and watching the world go by…

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Walking around with an offensive wife

    Constable Savage was ahead of the game.

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Manufactured by…

    Did I miss it, or does the article not mention the manufacturer's name?

    Not that it would mean anything to you even if you heard it but, unless they have a competitor, this is being developed by an Israeli company closely associated with another infamous local outlet. Remember NSO, the creators of Pegasus? Same people.

    Thoroughly tested on the Palestinian population of course, like the rest of Israel's arsenal (if you've ever attended an arms convention, it's their selling point, that's one of the reasons why they always find an excuse to launch yet another operation).

    Source: an acquaintance of mine works there.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon