The Register Home Page

back to article Weak security means attackers could disable all of a city's public EV chargers

Developers of rented internet of things infrastructure – stuff like public EV chargers and shared e-bikes – are prioritizing user convenience over security, and leaving themselves exposed to wide-scale denial of service attacks on their services. That frightening thesis was the subject of a Friday talk at the Black Hat Asia …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    EVs in a war

    It'a a good thing that Tanks, Ships, Planes etc still use conventional fuel systems.

    Imagine the warfield with soldiers stuck at home base due to lack of charging....

    1. Androgynous Cupboard Silver badge

      Re: EVs in a war

      The article is about public charging networks, not the drive system itself.

    2. DS999 Silver badge
      Facepalm

      Re: EVs in a war

      Good thing that gas pumps are completely immune to hacking, now and forever in the future, simply because they distribute gasoline rather than electricity!

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: EVs in a war

        Do you believe that the majority of fuel pumps are internet connected for some reason ?

        When did that happen exactly.

        1. druck Silver badge
          Go

          Re: EVs in a war

          Petrol - no App needed.

        2. DS999 Silver badge
          Facepalm

          Re: EVs in a war

          internet connected for some reason

          Yep nothing that doesn't need to be connected to the internet ever is. That's why we never see hacks of water plants, dams, etc.

          How exactly do you think credit cards are processed by gas pumps? Maybe you live somewhere that you still have to go inside and tell them "turn on pump 3" or whatever then go back inside to pay but most of us live in the modern world where we can pay at the pump with a credit card or Apple/Google Pay which means that pump is connected to the internet.

          Now sure they COULD have an intranet connection directly to their payment processor rather than traveling on the open internet, but most convenience stores etc. that pump gas just use their ordinary internet connection without a VPN. Just SSL encoded transactions over the open internet.

        3. Swedish Chef

          Re: EVs in a war

          Electronic payment.

        4. An_Old_Dog Silver badge

          Re: EVs in a war

          @AC

          Do you believe that the majority of fuel pumps are internet connected for some reason ?

          I'll presume you live in an area where the answer to your question is not bleedin' obvious.

          Around here, pretty much everything is IoT-infested.

          I've seen convenience stores closed, with a hand-scribbled note taped to the inside of the glass door stating they are closed because their "computer is down." (computerised cash register?) I've seen convenience store slushie machines and coffee machines unable to dispense their drinks (in the case of the slushie machines, I was able to use their touch-screen panel to access a diagnostic display which indicated an Internet connection failure; I backed out of the diags screen and left it as I found it). I've seen black-background/white fixed-font error messages indicating no IP on bus arrival display panels and on advertising panels. I've seen fast-food order-taking touch-panel displays down; in the case of Taco Bell, a taped-on note directed customers to place their orders with staff at the front counter.

          Megacorps love IoT display panels because they can quickly and easily have their images and messages revised, issued from the exalted central Headquarters Building (execs love the illusion they 'have control'). Similarly with IoT product dispensers; they can get 'instant' information on product reservoir levels, get status displays ('dashboards'), and such.

          But the execs which buy these things are enamoured by the shiny-factor (I saw a [working] touch-screen IoT milkshake dispenser with a curvey, swoopy body-shell adorned with the Pininfarina logo!), and don't understand/don't care enough about end-to-end reliability and security.

        5. EnviableOne Silver badge

          Re: EVs in a war

          Israel knocked out all of Iran's fuel infrastructure recently.

          https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/25087670/israeli-hackers-cripple-iran-petrol-stations-revenge/

          In previous incarnations, I have worked with large fuel station providers, and the pumps are all online for monitoring, flow control and payments.

  2. Chewi
    Mushroom

    Long live Lemons!

    1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge
      Coat

      Lemons?

      Forget public charging infrastructure and Lithium batteries - just drive up to your local greengrocer and fill the boot up with Lemons, for your Lemon/Copper/Zinc battery!

      1. Inventor of the Marmite Laser Silver badge

        Re: Lemons?

        No, just don't go there.

        There will be some YouTube or ThickTock arsehole who will buy (or otherwise appropriate ) a lorry load of lemons, miles of copper and zinc foil and try to run a Tesla on it. You just know it'll happen.

        1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge
          Alert

          Re: Lemons?

          A Lemon* running on Lemons?

          *Cybertruck

  3. DrXym Silver badge

    Well yeah

    These companies are basically racing to a finished product, before the funding dries up and things like security take a backseat.

    It doesn't help that security is *hard* and has to be done in depth and distributed systems like e-bikes / chargers are probably using cloud services. There are plenty of potential attack vectors when things are up in the cloud and if they are not locked down properly then somebody will figure out what the endpoints are and start poking around.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    No shit, Sherlock.

    The researcher tested 11 apps published by European providers of shared bikes and scooters, and found similar problems - suggesting his findings will be applicable elsewhere.

    All the European (& everywhere else) providers junk is made in China, so of course if it works in China it will work in Europe (& everywhere else).

  5. Tron Silver badge

    Governments will learn from the convenience trade off.

    And introduce three factor authentication for the purchase of sweets, biscuits, chocolate and alcohol.

    You could end the viability and use of most internet services by simply demanding authorisation so secure that nobody could be arsed to jump through all the hoops.

  6. Smartypantz

    Gravity

    I like EV's and also own one, but i like the fact that the only way to hack my old BMW motorcycle from 1981 is to hack gravity ;-)

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon