The Register Home Page

back to article Make crappy moves around AI and face voter backlash, govts warned

Britain's government faces a public backlash against AI unless it can show ordinary people that they stand to benefit from its push to inject the technology into every area of the UK in the name of growth. London, England, UK - February 28, 2026: Protestors hold a banner during the March Against The Machines Protest Editorial …

  1. colinhoad

    First thing's first

    "Governments need to become more interventionist in steering AI towards delivering clear public value"

    Well, for starters they'll need to *find* something AI can do which delivers value, of any kind.

    1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

      Re: First thing's first

      This is same old.

      Politician says AI needs to be regulated

      Airs some draconian ideas

      AI companies dazzle them with bling and wine and steak

      Politician goes into a freebie coma

      Forgets about regulation or creates regulation against competition of the most generous freebie givers.

    2. Philo T Farnsworth Silver badge

      Re: First thing's first

      I've been hearing about fears of "automation" for about as long as I've been aware of the world in general, and I grew up in the era of tube-powered monsters that a four-banger calculator puts to shame, so these scary stories strike me as just that, scary stories.

      On the other hand, if your job can be done by a chatbot, it's probably a pretty mind numbing exercise in tedium and box checking.

      Of course, keep that in mind when you read my putative "thoughts" that when I first heard from a radio engineer colleague about "cellular networks" back in the the late 1970s, I immediately thought "Having an upstairs extension1 is bad enough. Who on Earth would want to lug a portable phone around with them?"

      _____________

      1 Ask your grandparents. They probably still have one.

      1. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
        Windows

        Re: if your job can be done by a chatbot

        Unfortunately even in the case of the "mind numbing exercise" jobs, chatbots are giving only the merest appearance of "doing the job."

        Mostly just 2020s version of the phone voice menu mazes of yore (but without the ** option.)

        Even now (and the worst is yet to come) it's nigh on impossible to get anything done by anything fronted by chatbots.

        Humans being the eternal optimists forget that most tech in the past turned out to be pretty useless or a bloody silly idea from the kickoff or at best unneeded — 3D television is a fairly benign example (of the first or third?)

        The dystopia that the UK faces is that an opportunistic Reform runs a populist anti·AI line and you end up with Project UK 2030 and President Faredge. The Starmer government seems about as popular as the proverbial bacon butty at a Bar Mitzvah.

        1. This post has been deleted by its author

        2. PeeKay

          Re: if your job can be done by a chatbot

          "Mostly just 2020s version of the phone voice menu mazes of yore (but without the ** option.)"

          I repeat the phrase "I want to speak with a human"

          It gets there eventually.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Which Type of AI?

    I wished there was more clarification about the sort of AI being discussed. Some AI, such as pattern spotting seem to have some real worthwhile applications, such as detecting cancerous cells in an image of a sample. However I get the impression that when AI is mentioned, it is in relationship to LLMs, which seems to be of far less use considering the resources they require.

    1. IGotOut Silver badge

      Re: Which Type of AI?

      It why proper companies using the tech tend to use ML to distinguish themselves from the slop makers.

    2. Rich 2 Silver badge

      Re: Which Type of AI?

      I find it utterly infuriating when all I read is AI AI AI… but nobody ever says what the application is. One may as well talk about “electric powered…” without saying what the thing is!! It drives me nuts. Can you imagine popping into a shop and asking to “buy some” (and then waving your arms vaguely at the contents of the shop)?

      Add on top of that the tendency to call it AI at all, when it most definitely is NOT “I” in any way at all - like many, I can’t wait for this house of cards to come crashing down

  3. Tron Silver badge

    It's a moral panic jam.

    The moral panics over civilisation-ending smartphones and civilisation-ending social media have not yet seen comprehensive bans, although the Aussies are doing their best. We can't start another moral panic over civilisation-ending AI before at least sorting out some of the previous ones.

    Luckily, AI is simply not good enough to do what all the sensationalist claims by AI-pushing con artists and hacks say it will. It may hammer its own industry, tech (moral: be careful not to invent yourself out of a job, oh, you have!), and will speed the inevitable decline of customer services, but apart from levelling the playing field in exams, allowing those disadvantaged by being thick to get grades as good as clever people, it is, generally, pants. It forces people who did jobs to spend the same time monitoring AI doing their old job, badly, whilst they check it, probably for less money. And it is really crap at building houses and digging up turnips. It's not a magic bullet. It is a dodgy tool to add to the toolkit, but not a viable one, as it costs more than it will save. So expect it to cause a big fuss and then fade away into niche product status.

    Politicians are grasping for it because they like to be seen doing something. This is usually political theatre. Most of what they promise never happens. And when it does happen, it usually fails. There is not enough money/energy and the tech is naff.

    Management want to use it as a magic bullet to replace meatbags, but it doesn't actually work well enough. Hence the sackings and then the re-hirings. Of course, it might be quite good at management. And AI may even be a better alternative to our politicians. But I'm pretty sure that won't happen.

    And yeah, everyone distrusts it and hates it, as if it was a smarmy politician.

    So quit worrying about AI. You are more likely to be sacked because governments are breaking all the things that the global economy depends upon. Blame AI if you want, but the real fault lies with the people you elected.

    Just try to space the moral panics out a bit. We have an oil-shock-food-rationing-3-day-week one to squeeze in.

    1. IGotOut Silver badge

      Re: It's a moral panic jam.

      Yes and no.

      Company needs line go up. Line go up because company sacks workers. Company needs to look good, so says it's due to AI. Line go up more. More money for the ones that could easily be replaced by AI (LLM).

      So no, while AI isn't taking as many jobs as they claim it will, it's a convenient excuse to get rid of workers and pay less money to those left

    2. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
      Facepalm

      "Management want to use it [AI] as a magic bullet to replace meatbags,…"

      " but it doesn't actually work well enough."

      Ordinary bullets would likely be more effective but that more displace than replace.

      Obviously magic bullets could only be effective against magic entities such as unicorns and other equally fabulous creatures.

      The whole agentic AI lunacy is a layer of glistening unicorn diarrhea painted over a pretty obvious scam - pixie dust...no more than that. When that shit finally dries the shine will have evaporated and will look just like shit … and stink.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    On the other hand

    High energy cost and low grid capacity might put the dampeners on this… unless AI data biz is happy with the burning tiki torches and pitch forks

    1. doublelayer Silver badge

      Re: On the other hand

      That is why they're constantly lobbying to have governments and/or utilities pay for expansion, all with the promise that the AI companies will be making so much money they'll pay that investment back with interest. In their defense, if they actually ended up completing the plans they want that extra power for, they would usually do exactly that, but since they're not going to because those plans are incredibly expensive and not profitable, the public who either understands it or assumed in the correct direction aren't very keen on being the backstop.

  5. wiggers

    "Who controls the bots controls the narrative"

    This is the biggest issue in my opinion. What are the bots being trained on, all points of view and opinions or just those of the owning organisations?

  6. DS999 Silver badge

    If we get AI wrong

    This thought exercise written from the perspective of a possible future in 2028 shows what might happen:

    https://www.citriniresearch.com/p/2028gic

  7. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    If you want to get regulators involved then point out that the LLM product companies are using predatory pricing to subdue/prevent competition in their market.Of course this will only work where the regulators do actually regulate.

  8. may_i Silver badge
    FAIL

    Wrong plug

    Why are a bunch of UK protesters holding up a sign with US plug sockets on it?

    1. takno

      Re: Wrong plug

      Because that socket (which looks to me more like one of those weird hybrid shaving sockets) has the advantage of looking a bit like a sad face. The British plug would have to be upside to carry the same symbolism, and using British plugs upside down is a crime almost akin to flying the union flag upside down.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon