So life is older than Earth
Sounds entirely expected. Also means life was inside Earth during formation.
Scientists have found that all five of the substances that make up DNA and RNA in samples from Ryugu, the asteroid Japan’s Aerospace Exploration Agency visited in 2020. As outlined in a paper titled “A complete set of canonical nucleobases in the carbonaceous asteroid (162173) Ryugu” that appeared in the journal Nature …
The earliest signs of life on the planet are still a few hundred million years after its formation. These molecules themselves aren't "life" and the conditions inside Earth, or even just on its surface, during its formation would have dissociated them anyway.
Any water in the primordial Earth would be super-heated and under immense pressure which would disassociate organics just as well as dry heat. There is compelling evidence that the Earth's water was delivered by comet express during the late heavy bombardment.
Just because nucleotides are found in space that does not mean they couldn't also form on Earth (see Miller Urey) so finding them is space does not necessarily mean the Earth was seeded from space.
No only could have, but likely would have, and although cryometeors tend to smash into lots of pieces on impact, they also tend to still be frozen when they do so, thawing later.
The odds are that a fair amount of the chemical prerequisites for life could have been delivered this way, in a frozen, abiotic state, and once thawed could have started reacting in ways that would lead to the evolution of life. The implication is that life could just as well have arisen elsewhere in the universe by the same sort of process. This isn't to say we should be looking for little green men and bug-eyed monsters all over the place, or that the bloke with the weird hair is right about alien visitations throughout history, but more that there's a fair chance that if we looked under the ice on Europa, we might expect to find some sort of organic goop there, living off the energy gradients between its volcanic core and thick layer of ice above.
"Just because nucleotides are found in space that does not mean they couldn't also form on Earth (see Miller Urey) so finding them is space does not necessarily mean the Earth was seeded from space."
Or both. It's not a experiment one can run. Finding examples in Sol system might be hard too. Perhaps in Venus' atmosphere or tucked away on Mars and that's about all the hope there is.
Interestingly, though, evidence for the existence of life on Earth goes back about as far as we can measure, in some of the oldest bits of crust that are still about (subduction means most of the Earth's surface is much younger), so there's a strong argument that life formed very early on, in any tiny niche it could find. Whilst panspermia is still a bit of a stretch, it's also worth remembering that most meteorites, when they land, are still very cold, and that atmospheric entry, whilst it causes extreme temperatures, really only does so on the surface of meteoritic material. Anything inside a meteorite, if it survives the shock of impact, certainly doesn't tend to get cooked in the process. Whilst it's not very likely that anything could have survived on the Earth's surface during the Hadean, it's not impossible that life here could have arisen around the time of, or even a little before the late heavy bombardment, or even arisen elsewhere in the solar system, where conditions at the time were more conducive (perhaps Mars) and arrived during it. We make assumptions that the entire surface of the Earth was hostile at the time, as well, and although it's a fair assumption, it is still an assumption nonetheless. The thing is, it's really hard to actually know what was going on 4+ billion years ago, and most of what we do know with any certainty is derived from the meagre evidence that remains, most of which itself comes from bits of space rock floating around out in the depths of the Solar System, that are largely unchanged from the time.
"These molecules themselves aren't "life" and the conditions inside Earth, or even just on its surface, during its formation would have dissociated them anyway."
It took over 500M years before the comet bombardement era ended. It is questionable whether there was liquid water all the time as a few 1000km comet hits shroud the earth in molten rock. When a 100km comet hits the earth, there will be little organic material left from that comet.
But a rain of smaller debris can rain organic material down. That will add up over the hundreds of millions of years.
"and the conditions inside Earth, or even just on its surface, during its formation would have dissociated them anyway."
Research shows that this may have happened a few times in Earth's beginning where conditions swung from unfavorable to favorable several times. The raining down of precursors such as amino acids would kick start processes once conditions were right. It's a version of Panspermia on a more basic level. That's not to say that it isn't possible for completely home-brewed life getting stamped out by something being introduced. This is why looking at Mars samples is appealing.
That date has been pushed back over time, and the further back we go the more difficult it is to get broad agreement that what is seen in rocks is the result of life. It also becomes harder to find older rocks still accessible to us.
I'm not saying that life is older than Earth, but the fact we only have evidence of life several hundred million years after the Earth was formed doesn't in any way rule out the possibility that life is older than Earth. Life would have to be delivered to Earth after it had cooled sufficiently that there would be suitable locations for it to become established.
I think it goes without saying it took time after Earth was formed before life could establish itself. We just don't know how long of a period it was before conditions became suitable for life to survive long term. This is true whether or not it originated here (maybe more than once and it was destroyed in impacts or volcanic activity the first few times before it was able to become established and thrive) or it came from somewhere else and is older than our solar system.
The more we learn the more it seems that basic life is the easy part, and the hard part was the transition to multicellular complex organisms. Because simple life seems to be able to thrive almost anywhere on Earth or under it or above it, and now we see its building blocks in asteroids. But complex life seems to have taken several billion years to arrive. The universe might be teeming with life, but almost all of it is equivalent to bacteria or viruses, and stuff like grass or trilobites - let alone humans - is extraordinarily rare.
"The more we learn the more it seems that basic life is the easy part, and the hard part was the transition to multicellular complex organisms. "
Multicellular life requires a highly efficient energy cycle. That required free oxygen on earth.
In other words, life had to change the chemistry of the outer layer, atmosphere and hydrosphere, from reducing CO2 + CH4 to oxydizing O2.
That did require a lot of time.
"The ingredients of life are not themselves alive."
If we have chocolate cake on the counter and all of the ingredients for chocolate cake in the pantry/fridge, we can make some predictions that chocolate cake didn't arrive via a miracle. Adding a baker and oven to provide the right conditions is what needs to be shown.
A chocolate cake on the counter in my house has all of the conditions present for the extinction of chocolate cake. Lather, rinse, repeat.
In the 1960s astronomers were finding plenty of simple radicals, including some with carbon - CH CN - although the big stuff was around hydroxyl, as it was found to be creating natural MASERs in at least two wavelengths. And IIRC some silicon radical MASER as well?
By the end of the decade we were finding interstellar water and ammonia; I think also formaldehyde but that may be into the 70s by then? Methanol and ethanol abound, but we were still getting excited about that in 2006 (Astronomers spy 288bn mile cloud of alcohol: "Make mine a double" says Register.
Later on we detected some emissions from amino acids, so working the way up the chain, but not sure it's safe to claim we've found the nucleotides as yet.
We've just had our astro soc meeting, but hopefully I'll remember for next month, Fred will know all about it.
We've known since the 1950s Miller-Urey experiment that the sort of conditions that would have prevailed on the early Earth could synthesise the ingredients of that famous primordial soup. Whether they're also available in asteroids is interesting but far from essential for biogenesis.
The trick steps are assembling RNAs from ribonucleotides. doing it reproducibly by copying, linking it to protein synthesis, doing so with reproducible base-sequence to amino acid mapping and having the proteins catalyse the copying. You need to add on doing it so as to have the proteins catalyse other functions such as harnessing environmental energy sources in a way that can transfer the energy in useful sized quanta for these processes. Then you need to be able to wrap the whole thing up into packages and have the proteins catalyse the various steps to produce the packaging materials. You need to regulate all these operations within the packages. And all that's before we even introduce DNA (all the critical bits of protein synthesis are RNA based: messenger RNA, transfer RNA and ribosomal RNA).
It's pretty much a guarantee that almost every atom inside your body that isn't hydrogen originated in an exploding star, simply because we don't tend to contain any helium, and the abundance of all the other elements after lithium, immediately after the big bang, was essentially zero. The odds are that some of the lithium atoms inside you (which only account for 24 atoms out of every billion) may have originated in the big bang, but most will also have come from stellar nucleosynthesis.
Given that hydrogen apparently accounts for about 9.5% of body mass, and your lithium content is negligible, you are therefore approximately 90.5% star-dust by mass. A bit more if, like me, you keep forgetting to drink your two litres of water a day, since most of that is accounted for by your body's water content.
Beryllium and Boron are not created by stellar nucleosynthesis but by spallation of heavier elements. People have 0.7ppm boron and 0.0004ppm beryllium (by mass) - not a lot but you'd miss it if it weren't there.
"Exploding star" could cover a lot of things, in fact exploding massive stars (aka supernovae) hardly produce anything heavier than Rubidium (37), exploding white dwarfs top out at Zinc (30).
All the naturally occurring elements above 40 are created in merging neutron stars or low mass stars coming to a sad end, neither of which are really explosions, supernovae are too quick for the really heavy stuff to form.
Yeah, I did start writing a follow-up, and then decided that I might have been going into too much depth.
Technically, a lot of the lighter elements could have been produced pre-supernova in stars reaching the end of their lives, as they switch from fusing hydrogen to sequentially heavier elements, at higher energies, and contract at each stage, blowing off their outer layers. Nothing heavier than iron can be created by stellar nucleosynthesis, due to the energetics of fusion (iron is the peak nucleon energy), and iron (and elements up to that) can be produced by fusion in a star before it explodes (I believe the path is the fusion of silicon). As you say, heavier elements are more likely produced in mergers of stellar remnants, and "exploding stars" is a massive oversimplification (point of order: a white dwarf is the remnant left after a supernova, and doesn't explode itself; a type 1a supernova involves accretion onto a white dwarf, but that's a special case). Stellar remnants, especially neutron stars and black holes, also tend to have very strong magnetic fields, due to conservation of momentum when they contract, and these result in jets of material being accelerated to relativistic speeds. I'm not familiar with the exact physics involved here, but those slamming into clouds of material certainly sound like the sort of thing that would create conditions for exotic physics.
I have to concede that I don't know a lot about the specific physics involved in nucleosynthesis during supernovae, so I'll take you word that these don't generate heavier elements than zinc; that does sound plausible. I guess the difficulty in knowing the exact processes comes from the fact that we can't exactly easily observe them as they happen, or conduct experiments, so a lot comes down to theoretical models, which themselves are often simplifications (spherical cow in a vacuum kind of things) and model things that are on the edge of known physics.
This is why new astrophysical discoveries are often fascinating (at least to me), as they are one of the few things that are at the boundary of known science, and we almost always learn something new from them. I'm just waiting to see if Betelgeuse goes up in my lifetime, if nothing else because it will be pretty.
Hi Here's the current state of understanding of the origin of each element:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nucleosynthesis#/media/File:Nucleosynthesis_periodic_table.svg
This is, and I quote "a first-order simplification of an active research field with many open questions." so it may and probably will change in time. In fact this graphic has changed since the last time I looked at it a few years ago.
Congratulations … you're setting out from New York to Los Angeles, and this discovery means you've just traveled the first inch. Finding the five nucleobases (in a form that would be unusable in the prebiotic Earth, which they didn't mention) is like finding a single bolt when you're tasked with building the Empire State building. There are many other "basic ingredients" and thousands of other processes that need to be explained.
"I have all the materials for building a house on site."
One would hope that in less than a decade the right conditions will arrive (workers) and the mystery of how all of those materials turn into a house will be revealed.
The millions of years of waiting for life to emerge from some building blocks is a wee bit harder to wait for and notice.
It is also possible that some supernatural entity created life on Earth and the component parts have been leaking into the Cosmos for the last 6006/13.8 billion years, surely?
I'm not saying it's likely, but the direction of travel for these molecules has not been established, not have the prerequisite conditions for their formation.
Things like isotopic composition demonstrate prove pretty comprehensive evidence that most space rocks formed in space, at the same time as the Earth and didn't originate here; not to mention the physics involved in launching something into space and then decelerating it into a stable orbit, especially since most of the material in the solar system isn't on an orbit that coincides with Earth's.
Short answer: no.
That doesn't preclude the possibility that amino acids formed on the earth and in other parts of the primordial solar system disk.
The proposal that amino acids formed in the disk and were brought to earth by comets and asteroids has not been proven.
I liked Rudyard Kipling's Just So stories as a child, but nobody ever told me they were "scientific".
We found some stuff at point A and point B does not imply that this particular stuff at B had to all come from A.
No, it doesn't. It does preclude the suggestion that they formed first on Earth, and then spread into the rest of the solar system from there. Just getting something up to escape velocity takes a lot of energy, and the process of doing it by smashing lumps of rock into space would be far from 100% efficient, thereby cooking whatever you're trying to fling into space. And by "cooking", I do, of course, mean absolutely incinerating, and subjecting to the sort of G-forces that flatten any sort of nascent life, if it wasn't already on fire.
If you believe in some sort of mysterious hand of a creator, then you already believe that this creator must have magical powers that don't have to obey the same laws of physics as everything else. The belief in any sort of "magic" powers that transcend natural forces and physical rules implies that those rules simply don't apply; since by definition magic doesn't follow rules, the belief in any magic implies everything must be subject to magic. This in turn implies that all human knowledge, experience, and wisdom is false. You might like to believe you live in a magical universe where everything is possible if you just wish it hard enough, but this isn't borne out by any evidence; ergo creationism is bollocks; sorry to break it to you.