back to article How hackers are fighting back against ICE surveillance tech

While watching us now seems like the least of its sins, the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) was once best known (and despised) for its multi-billion-dollar surveillance tech budget. Clever hackers and digital privacy advocates are fighting back against the snooping activities of Kristi Noem's masked agents. The …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
  1. John Robson Silver badge

    So...

    We put the "tiny" adversarial bits on every car in every car park we visit, and visit lots of police stations...

    1. Blazde Silver badge

      Re: So...

      Benn Jordan's weird tech/sound/data adventures are incredible by the way. I highly recommend them.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: So...

      Make up spray cans of the stuff…apply generously but anonymously.

      Plausible deniability for the registered owner? Or will they be shot in the face? Hmmm.

      1. Roland6 Silver badge

        Re: So...

        From the look of the film overlays, it should be possible to create an engraved ink roller to print the pattern.

        Obviously, just need the ink to be of a similar composition to tyre rubber and road tar so that analysis is consistent with plausible deniability claims.

        1. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: So...

          "Obviously, just need the ink to be of a similar composition to tyre rubber and road tar so that analysis is consistent with plausible deniability claims."

          There's law and then there's enforcement of that law. If the overlay is not obvious, the chances of being cited for it is low. I see smoked perspex covers on license plates all the time and it doesn't seem like enforcement of that is reducing the incidence of people doing that. Those covers, while illegal, are easily available on Amazon along with exhaust cutouts and other illegal mods.

          I often see tinted windscreens and side window tint beyond limits. If the window is cracked, it's easy to smell the pot smoke too.

          I don't think that the fine for a "defaced" number plate is too much to pay for the privacy it may afford. Perhaps there's enhancements for doing it to evade, but that's harder to prove and a prosecutor would have to bring those charges. In the US, one can fight a traffic citation and being an "infraction", it's only heard in front of a traffic court judge. An enhancement to a misdemeanor would need a representative of "the state" to argue the charges and the defendant would have a right to legal representation. That's likely too much to bother with and the charges would either be dropped or reduced to an infraction.

          1. Blazde Silver badge

            Re: So...

            Here (UK) it's pretty common for 'nice' cars to do away with especially the front license plate entirely, on the grounds that it spoils aesthetics of the car from it's most photogenic angles.

            The fixed penalty fines are merely a vanity cost I suppose. £100 first offence. Cheaper than a decent wax job.

            I'm not sure how common fines are but at least in my parts the police are much focused on the street racing some of the same cars are involved in, since that's lead to some nasty deaths and - as far as I'm aware - failing to present a license plate properly to an ANPR never has.

            1. nobody who matters Silver badge

              Re: So...

              Those 'nice' cars often carry a vanity registration though; the right to assign it to the car often bought by the owner for a significant sum of money. They often seem also to alter the spacing to make it look like their name or spell a word.

              One of the penalties that can be (and often is) imposed for registration number abuse is that DVLA take away the right to assign that number and re-register the vehicle on a standard format age related number. Losing something that may have cost them several thousand pounds might have more impact than the fine.

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: So...

          What about a coating that repels dirt, but leave holes where the adversarial bits need to be? Sorry officer I must have driven through a puddle, let me wipe it off.

    3. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: So...

      Yeah was gonna say, what stops you from putting that on your car and then feigning innocence if you're caught? It was probably my ex wife, or the neighbor down the street who has it out for me, or the guy competing with me for the promotion at work.

      Buy a pack of 20, put the rest on cars owned by your neighbors (especially ones who have had Trump signs in the past) and random co-workers.

      1. TimMaher Silver badge
        Facepalm

        Re: So...

        Yeah but… they will have you on film from all the Ring doorbell cameras.

        1. Roland6 Silver badge

          Re: So...

          Must live in a low crime neighbourhood, round here the scallies like to rip off the cameras, but you can leave the door unlocked without any problem…

        2. DS999 Silver badge

          Re: So...

          The footage will show a dark shadowy figure wearing a mask (because covid normalized that) so they can prove SOMEONE did it, but no way they can link it to me.

          1. rcxb Silver badge

            Re: So...

            Yes, a dark shadowy figure with your exact same skin tone, height, build, shoes, trousers, etc., appearing from your front door and disappearing back there, too after messing with your car.

          2. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: So...

            The dark shadowy figure wearing a mask..... But, Your Honour, it was clearly an ICE agent that applied it to my license plate as you can see from the video

      2. Pascal Monett Silver badge
        Stop

        Sorry, help protecting those who elected a known criminal ?

        No. They can deal with the fallout of their own decisions.

    4. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

      Re: So...

      There are a few optional extras on this which should help...

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QXCWW--DlY

  2. Michael Hoffmann Silver badge
    Trollface

    Kristi Noem's masked agents...

    ... I have no problem with masks, if it hides the hideous Mar-a-Lago Face.

  3. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Same old

    Funny how this all sounds familiar.

    There was a time when people learned which streets to avoid, which neighbours talked too much, and how to make themselves uninteresting to men who travelled in unmarked vehicles and preferred anonymity. They called it survival, not “counter-surveillance”. The technology was cruder, but the logic identical: if being seen gets you taken, you learn how not to be seen.

    Back then it was knocking on doors at dawn. Now it is ALPR logs, data brokers, face searches, and agents hiding behind masks like they are ashamed or just allergic to accountability. Same fear, better bandwidth.

    The uncomfortable part is not that hackers are building tools to evade this stuff. The uncomfortable part is that they have to. When people start sharing maps of watchers, building alert networks, and printing adversarial noise to stay invisible, that is not clever activism. That is a population adapting to power it does not trust.

    History usually gives this phase a name later, once everyone agrees it was bad. At the time, it is always sold as necessary, legal, and for your own good.

    Still, reassuring to know that in 2026 the answer to creeping authoritarian surveillance is the same as it was in the 1940s: know where the eyes are, warn each other quietly, and hope the lawyers catch up before the boots do.

  4. Dan 55 Silver badge

    Another normal day in a normal country

    r/ICE_Raids and r/ICE_Watch.

    Well the US tourist office has got their work cut out for them this year.

  5. that one in the corner Silver badge

    ANPR that can be fooled by adversarial noise indetectable by humans

    Using an expensive and fragile modern "AI" to do ANPR and opening yourself up to being defeated by these adversarial noise stickers is a demonstration that people like Flock should not be allowed to work without adult supervision.

    ANPR systems have been around for donkeys years now and are pretty robust, using boring old image manipulation algorithms. And if they are being installed, rather than trying to jury rig a tap off a feed that wasn't designed for the purpose, you can even use light outside the visible range, which can be a help.

    But no, no, use the latest fashion, no matter how expensive or easily fooled (adversarial noise attacks on these systems have been known about for years now). If somebody dares to come up with a way to embarrass you, make sure you use the law against them instead of admitting your system is worse than what came before:

    > screen printing "tiny bits" of adversarial noise and putting the sticker on your license plate. These "abstract invisible license plate overlay patterns … cannot be detected by humans but make license plate recognition systems utterly shit the bed," Benn Jordan said on his video. We'll note that this is illegal in California

    >> A casing, shield, frame, border, product, or other device that obstructs or impairs the reading or recognition of a license plate by an electronic device operated by state or local law enforcement, an electronic device operated in connection with a toll road, high-occupancy toll lane, toll bridge, or other toll facility, or a remote emission sensing device, as specified in Sections 44081 and 44081.6 of the Health and Safety Code, shall not be installed on, or affixed to, a vehicle.

    > Jordan also uncovered a massive Flock security snafu involving hundreds of misconfigured Flock cameras that exposed non-password protected admin interfaces to the public internet

    Like I say, don't let Flock out without adult supervision. FFS stop giving them more money and contracts (although, hopefully it is difficult to find competent people who are willing to sell out to these sortes of surveillance contracts).

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Regardless of one's views…

    …on immigration, or the irony of a bunch of Europeans that showed up on boats now claiming the land as "theirs", it seems clear that this is what the collapse of an empire (albeit a very short lived one) looks like.

    1. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
      Thumb Up

      Re: Regardless of one's views…

      …on immigration, or the irony of a bunch of Europeans that showed up on boats now claiming the land as "theirs", it seems clear that this is what the collapse of an empire (albeit a very short lived one) looks like.

      Shame they didn't get their arses handed to them by the Skraelings as I think Leif Erikson's was in Vinland much earlier.

      When a majority cease thinking of themselves as American — first and foremost — the collapse will be rapid, possibly rivalling that of the former USSR. I suspect the Roman Empire endured partly because it was fundamentally inclusive which the US, despite the mountains of bullshit to the contrary, is not.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Regardless of one's views…

        > which the US, despite the mountains of bullshit to the contrary, is not

        To be frank, the US seems the archetypical example of a class struggle.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Regardless of one's views…

          Industrial Workers of the World, Civil Rights, LA Riots, Occupy Wall Street, MeToo ... (started in US, spread worldwide)

          Hopefully, the tools, techniques, and determination to fight back against the "boot stamping on a human face - forever" also spread successfully! ;)

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Regardless of one's views…

            > started in US

            Beg pardon?

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: Regardless of one's views…

              No, seriously. Does anyone really think that the US invented popular protests?

              1. Anonymous Coward
                Anonymous Coward

                Re: Regardless of one's views…

                > Does anyone really think that the US invented popular protests

                Of course.

                Didn't you see the accompanying quote from the famous US author? "Boot stamping on a human face - forever" and all that?

                Hang on a minute...

        2. Alan Brown Silver badge

          Re: Regardless of one's views…

          It's not just a class struggle

          The USA is essentially 12 different countries overlaid on each other whose inhabitants don't interact with and are fearful of inhabitants of the others

          When I say overlaid, I mean that it's not like X city and Y city don't get along. You'll find the same 12 countries in EACH city

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Regardless of one's views…

            So what are those twelve different countries, and why would that lead to struggle (cf. Singapore, Switzerland, etc)?

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Regardless of one's views…

        > Shame they didn't get their arses handed to them by the Skraelings as I think Leif Erikson's was in Vinland much earlier.

        As I recall (and I might be wildly wrong, if so I apologise), the Viking settlements did not survive due to their inability to sustain themselves not due to external attack.

        Also, they were not a conquering force but simply the rough equivalent of a trade mission. This involves a combination of raiding and sacking on the one hand, and trading on the other. I do not recall that there was any evidence of widespread conflict between Norsemen and North American natives in the archaeological record.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Regardless of one's views…

          Is the down vote intended to indicate an inaccuracy in my post? If so, I would appreciate a correction, thank you.

          1. trs

            Re: Regardless of one's views…

            I believe the downvote is an indication that the OP read your comment

      3. DoctorPaul Bronze badge

        Re: Regardless of one's views…

        There's a point of view that the Roman Empire didn't disappear, it just changed its name to the Catholic Church.

    2. abend0c4 Silver badge

      Re: Regardless of one's views…

      the collapse of an empire

      Given that the fundamental motivation seems to be based on a desire for merely relative superiority, the concern is the amount of damage that might be inflicted on everyone else in order to remedy a status diminished in absolute terms.

      1. Jason Bloomberg Silver badge

        Re: Regardless of one's views…

        Looking at how Iran's fascist dictatorship is faring now I can't help thinking it is perhaps where America's will be in a few years time.

        1. Alan Brown Silver badge

          Re: Regardless of one's views…

          The primary reason places like Iran still have their administrations in place is BECAUSE of external USA posturing snd sanctions

          Everyone hates the local government, but they all band together to fend off the external threat

          Which brings up the point that in order for any authoritarian to survive, there must be an external bogeyman to point to in order to keep the populatrion pliant

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Regardless of one's views…

            China!

  7. Winkypop Silver badge
    Flame

    Orange Nero is fiddling*

    While Rome 2.0 burns

    * We all know what he’s fiddling with.

    1. Gary Stewart Silver badge

      Re: Orange Nero is fiddling*

      With sincere apologies to The Who

      "I'm your wicked Uncle Donny, I'm glad you won't see or hear me, As I fiddle about, fiddle about, fiddle about"

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Happy to help here from the UK

    We can all play our part

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Happy to help here from the UK

      > We can all play our part

      Why not do so by addressing the problems and injustices in your own country first? Is your post a reflection of the wider UK populace having uncritically assumed their position as a US colony?

      1. Roland6 Silver badge

        Re: Happy to help here from the UK

        Nigel, (the Kremlin’s latest parrot backed by US donations) has assured us everything will be okay, as we got our “sovereignty” back from the EU and he is good mate’s with Trump.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Happy to help here from the UK

          > Nigel

          Are you referring to Mr Garage? That's nothing to do with Russia (what does the UK have that Russia might want, in your view?) but, AFAIK, with a loose group of old school ties of whom he is their devoted jester. As the product of a second / third tier public school that's the closest association with Etonians that he can aspire to.

          He, at least in his public persona, I haven't met him, is embarrassing in his lack of self respect and the way he fawns around those he sees as occupying a higher station in life.

          But, be that as it may, he is a product of the remnants of the British empire, not of some Kremlin conspiracy.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Happy to help here from the UK

            Nathan Gill?

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: Happy to help here from the UK

              > Nathan Gill?

              Care to expand?

              1. Anonymous Coward
                Anonymous Coward

                Re: Happy to help here from the UK

                Not particularly, no.

          2. Roland6 Silver badge

            Re: Happy to help here from the UK

            >” Are you referring to Mr Garage? That's nothing to do with Russia (what does the UK have that Russia might want, in your view?)”

            ” Farage accused of ‘parroting Kremlin lines’ after remarks on UK troops in Ukraine”

            Remember the UK and France are (or is it were?) the two biggest European contributors to NATO. Divide Europe and NATO is no longer a threat…

            So it’s not so much what the UK has as to what it could contribute to a united NATO and European defense…

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: Happy to help here from the UK

              > Divide Europe and NATO is no longer a threat

              That is indeed a sensible answer. Ironically, that is Russia's own worry (the West trying to break it up to gain access to its oil, mineral, and agricultural resources).

              Just like during the cold war days (yes I'm that old :( ) when each side was worried about the other side invading.

              Still, Garage is not controlled by Russia, at least not directly, but by a cohort of UK (and possibly US?) ultra conservatives with more money than sense or ethics. It is all fairly well documented from the Brexit and Cambridge analytics (IIRC) days.

              As for the Grauniad article (which I managed to read without accepting cookies), it is just a standard political accusation, the usual theatre.

              Re. expenditure, just for info, according to their 2025 report, aside from the US the biggest spenders in absolute terms are Germany (~94B), UK (~84B), and France (~64B). Italy follows with (~35B).

              Edit: down vote not mine. I wish people would leave an explanatory note when they do that.

          3. Alan Brown Silver badge

            Re: Happy to help here from the UK

            Knockoff Nigel can be both the Jester and the Useful Idiot

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: Happy to help here from the UK

              > Knockoff Nigel can be both the Jester and the Useful Idiot

              Fair point!

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Happy to help here from the UK

        > Why not do so by addressing the problems and injustices in your own country first?

        An approach for which the US has long been a beacon to the rest of the world, eh?

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Happy to help here from the UK

          > An approach for which the US has long been a beacon to the rest of the world, eh?

          I'm not sure what you're implying. Care to explain?

          I'm the AC you're quoting, and my comment is a reflection on the extent of US influence and control over European societies and public opinion, which appears to me to be more attentive to whatever happens across the Atlantic (in the metropolis, if we're using colonial terminology) than in their own countries. That reinforces, not weakens, the power of the colonial overlord (and by implication, of whoever is ruling the metropolis).

  9. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

    Meanwhile I suppose HM's diary is suddenly looking too crowded for the visit to the US that was being talked about in recent weeks.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      > Meanwhile I suppose HM's diary is suddenly looking too crowded

      I don't think Trump is too worried. He might just crown himself and pay himself a visit.

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Tipover of the ICEberg

    Flock's spreading dystopian ecosystem of snoop-enabling stalkerware for (by and large) spying on individuals without their knowledge or consent should be court-ruled just as illegal as Fleming's pcTattletale imho. That and the unspeakable barbarity of ID-less masked thugs' arbitrary kidnapping of folks right off the street, and straight-up shooting them dead on the spot ... human life is awfully cheap to these psychopathic wankers; state-sponsored January-6-style domestic terrorists in full sedition battle gear, same goals, same targets, way more money. A boots-on-the-ground version of DOGE brownshirts. Maduro would've loved such extrajudicial militia ...

    What's next? ICE Putin-style defenestrates journalists? ICE Prigozhin-style sledgehammer-bludgeons opponents to death? ICE Novichok-slaps folks in airports? ICE Khashoggi chops critics to bits on plastic-lined floors? ICE Tehran-style beats protesters to a pulp and detains them without medical attention until death does them part? Where is the red line? Do we have to self-immolate ourselves by fire to stop this lawless state-sponsored fascist insanity? Extraordinary rendition?

    The insistent perverted voyeurism that underlies all this is where totalitarianism meets surveillance capitalism in forcing normative alignment of behavioral surplus through the sausage extruder of manufactured consent imho; ultra-transforming purported critical thinking into the insipid industrialized conformity of the reactionary so-called "alternative rebellion" of empty skullcaps and hair extensions, fortified by such zero-impact artificial pseudo-deviance substitute as having killed one's dog, goat, (neighbors?), wow! Pretty vacant.

    We need more ICEbreakers, defrock DOGE and chihuahuas, and empty the orange banana republican's fruitcake basket case imho! ;{

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Tipover of the ICEberg

      Man from Mars, is that you?

  11. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    America is falling

    To the many go the spoils.

    Especially to those who cleverly injected fake news via their enemies own technology.

    1. Roland6 Silver badge

      Re: America is falling

      I expect “play the long game” China will be the ultimate winner…

This topic is closed for new posts.