Blimey
Seems a bit of a faff for not much return. If I do use Windows, the run dialogue is very useful but I'm not sure a slightly wider bar makes much difference. It's usually cut'n'paste into it or total muscle memory without looking. How odd.
The Windows 11 Run dialog box is one of the oldest pieces of user interface still in use. It works just fine, but it has an aesthetic that harkens back to earlier versions of Microsoft’s operating system. Now, that’s set to change. Redmond is testing a new version of the Run dialog box, if you have one of the latest Beta or …
You missed its primary function: obscure control elements while in use and thus reduce the usability of Microsoft products once more. As a well known chain in the UK keeps repeating: "every little bit helps" (in this case to prove to shareholders that their customers are locked in so tightly they'd even accept it to work only 25% of the time, probably the aim for 2026).
Honest question, does anyone even use this thing besides scammers? If I want to run something I either search for the program itself or I open Terminal. I think I've only exclusively seen this used by scammers to trick people into opening Internet Explorer or to paste in some nasty PowerShell script that got auto-inserted into the clipboard from a malicious website. Literally, never once I have ever seen it used outside of that context. Not with friends, not in videos, never.
WFW311 was easier to use than Win10. OK, no start menu or pinned icons and no right click context menu. Win32s even runs some 32 bit Windows programs. They deliberately added some APIs on Win95 for Office 95 to stop people running Office 95 on WFW/Win 3.1x. It made it fail on NT 3.5, so we got a free upgrade to NT 3.51. Not sure if everyone did. There was an Explorer Shell preview for NT 3.51 and you could run NT 32 bit FileManager on NT4.0 instead of using Explorer Shell File Explorer, which still is maddening.
To scratch this particular itch, I wrote a trivial C# WPF applet that sits pinned on the taskbar, and when clicked, pops up a dialog in the centre of the screen with a timer progress bar - and a large, prominent, "cancel" button that aborts the shutdown timer if clicked. That way I can shut down/hibernate my PC with one click but cancel it if I change my mind.
Happy to share the code with anyone who wants it, but it really wasn't more than 5 minutes' work.
The IT chap at my last job used it a lot: some tweak was needed on your PC for whatever arcane reason. A nice lad, overall, but:
He tended to scowl when at my desk, because of the lack of a "Windows" key on my beloved keyboard.
And looked blankly when I just alt-tabbed to the inevitably already open cmd.exe window; maybe ther *is* some oddity in the execution environment between the "Run" dialogue and a generic cmd.exe session, but I never found out what it is...
So no Browse button or drop down list? What is it with the current crop of big tech devs that they always replace a working feature with a new, less capable and not fit for purpose version?
I'd have given this such a scathing code review that the incompetant snowflake responsible would need therapy!
"Note that this covers over the Start button and taskbar icons if you have your Start menu aligned to the left."
Which of course, in my view, irritates many users as its entirely sane to return the start menu back to the left after Win11 tries to go all 'Mac' on you.
What a pointless change.
I've setup ahk so that alt-F12 drops down a command window from the top, just like yakuake does on Linux ( or like ~ does in gzdoom or quake, whence the name )
I honestly don't remember why I ended up choosing alt-F12 rather than ~ maybe because alt-F12 works when focus is on a terminal and ~ doesn't?
It's honestly been so long that I think on windows this is done by spawning Konsole.
Not to worry about this being just an aesthetic change, this is just a preview after all. By the time it appears in a production version, the Run dialog will have sufficient AI assistance - no more direct execution of a specific program, it will be "agentic" Run instead that will deduce what you really want to do and run that instead.
The branding of the feature will also change somewhat. The current leading candidate is "The Runs".