back to article Cryptology boffins’ association to re-run election after losing encryption key needed to count votes

The International Association for Cryptologic Research will run a second election for new board members and other officers, after it was unable to complete its first poll due to a lost encryption key. As explained in November 21 election update, the association (IACR) used an electronic voting system called “Helios” to run its …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    You couldn’t make this situation up

    fdFfTu744yGGtt5UhUBGvvvHhHBiuiIh7uyytJj7

    1. Jedit Silver badge
      Joke

      Re: You couldn’t make this situation up

      Well, now you've posted the missing key I'm sure they'll be able to get on with it.

  2. Giles C Silver badge
    Trollface

    This reminds me of an old joke

    Clairvoyant meeting cancelled due to unforeseen circumstances

    Honestly this could have been run on the 1st April…

  3. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
    Headmaster

    IACR shouldn't have accepted Baldrick as a member...

    let alone as one of the three trustees holding one of the three rings of power encryption keys.

    A cunning plan: he probably wrote his portion of the key under the third sheet of a roll of toilet paper where no one would look.

    One only hope that Melbourne, Australia is where the conference will actually be organised and not Melbourne, Florida. ;)

    1. Like a badger Silver badge

      Re: IACR shouldn't have accepted Baldrick as a member...

      Well,looking to the positives, somewhere a wife is saying "About bloody time Graham! I'm glad I threw out that post it note on your monitor and you've had to resign, all because it needs three cryptologists to add up a few numbers! The time you've wasted on that bloody cryptology society nonsense! And i still haven't forgiven you for my birthday card that was in ROT13. Then there was the time we got thrown out of the bank after you demanded that two other employees needed to vouch for the cashier, and then the same for those other two employees. It was even worse than when you were Grand Moose in the Masons and were asked to leave for pointing out 37 logical flaws and 11 continuity errors in the third degree ritual of craft masonry. What is it about you and secret societies meeting in sheds? Anyway, now you can fix the dripping tap in the bathroom and put up that shelf you said you would"

  4. Richard 12 Silver badge

    Important learning experience

    It's apparently taken until now for these boffins to realise that the Real World exists, and people are human.

    Security systems that rely on human perfection cannot possibly work. They must be designed to continue to function when the squishy bits make mistakes. That means recovery options, alternatives etm.

    Because if they aren't, then workarounds will be found. Usually at short notice, and by people who don't really know what the consequences might be.

    1. SVD_NL Silver badge

      Re: Important learning experience

      Well, lesson not entirely learned, because they're still a bit stuck in their own cryptology bubble. They could've looked at the world around them and realised that if you're doing an election with possible conflicts of interest you could just get an independent party to conduct the election and verify the results.

  5. Like a badger Silver badge

    That is one top notch sub-heading

    That was all.

  6. Guido Esperanto

    It's certainly egg on their face,

    The upshot is the voting record is completely secured....

    Useless to anybody...but secured.

    It's about striking that balance between security and useability - clearly the lever was tipped too far one way.

  7. Richard Boyce

    Two out of three

    Isn't "no two trustees could collude" undermined by the new system? Indeed there are three possible ways that two can collude, and push the other under a bus. The BOFH would approve.

    1. steviesteveo

      Re: Two out of three

      This is the one thing we didn't want to happen

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon