The Register Home Page

back to article China uses Mars orbiter to snap interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS

China has matched the European Space Agency’s feat of taking a snapshot of interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS from a Mars orbiter. Astronomers spotted 3I/ATLAS in July and the Minor Planet Center noted its “highly eccentric, hyperbolic orbit” that suggested it came from outside our solar system. Later analysis confirmed that theory, …

  1. xyz Silver badge

    Oh gawd is there no escape..

    massed zombie scientists all going "it's a comet, it's a comet" vs Avi Loeb and his "might be ALIENS!!!" bitch fest. Anyhoo, anyone got the snaps that NASA took on the 3rd Oct? They're still missing as are the Chinese pix. At least ESA doled out a couple of snaps of a white dot but apart from that tumbleweed since the Mars pass until last night.

    1. Eclectic Man Silver badge

      Re: Oh gawd is there no escape..

      NASA's 'snaps' may be delayed from publication due to the continuing US Government 'shutdown' due to US Congress not agreeing a budget. NASA's 'Astronomy Picture of the Day' has not been updated since the shutdown started:

      https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap251002.html

      1. Snowy Silver badge
        Black Helicopters

        Re: Oh gawd is there no escape..

        The shutdown is part of the coverup!!

      2. xyz Silver badge

        Re: Oh gawd is there no escape..

        yeah but the uni of Arizona and JPL are still functioning and the uni has a state law up it's ass to make stuff publically available with 24 hours unless it's been classified.

    2. iRadiate

      Re: Oh gawd is there no escape..

      Atlas image captured by the high-resolution camera of the Tianwen-1 orbiter.

      Is that one of the missing pics?

    3. xyz Silver badge

      Re: Oh gawd is there no escape..

      09 Nov, a friend took these snaps of it

      https://medium.com/@liena.dreams/3i-atlas-after-perihelion-phenomenal-images-tell-a-different-story-f8f3d9481048

      it's a comet.

  2. cookieMonster
    Alien

    Captain

    There are Klingons on the Starboard bow

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Captain

      Instead of "Star-trekking across the universe", we have "A rock moving in from t'heliosphere..."

    2. segfault188
      Coat

      Re: Captain

      There are Klingons literally on the Starboard bow.

      Steer the ship violently and see if they can still cling on.

      1. Alan Brown Silver badge

        Re: Captain

        Failing that, a few quick orbits of Uranus might help

    3. KayJ

      Re: Captain

      Starboard bow?

      1. ovation1357

        Re: Captain

        https://youtu.be/FCARADb9asE?si=UuBjZqZKGnaQsXlU

        You're welcome.

  3. Paul Herber Silver badge

    This interstellar object is small, that one is far away, small and moving very fast.

    1. Chris 239

      COWS IN SPAAACEEE!!!!

      1. Spherical Cow

        You rang?

  4. Primus Secundus Tertius

    What next?

    Three probes in eight years. The b*st*rds are on to us. Fear for the worst!

    1. Brewster's Angle Grinder Silver badge

      Re: What next?

      Can you tell them to hurry it up please? It could save me a few mortgage payments.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: What next?

        You don't need aliens for that...

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: What next?

      Mars attacks!

  5. Richard_Sideways

    For what it’s worth, Japan’s space agency last week sent fresh fruit into orbit.

    *ahem* FIIIIGS IN SPAAAAAAACE!

    1. Anonymous Custard Silver badge
      Alien

      Re: For what it’s worth, Japan’s space agency last week sent fresh fruit into orbit.

      Well they didn't confirm exactly what hit the Shenzhou-20 beyond "space debris"...

      Orbital yuzu?

      (No, I'm not even going to try and outdo figs in space. That pun prize is already won)

  6. renniks

    It's a real shame it isn't aliens come to virus bomb Earth

    1. wolfetone Silver badge

      You know when you drive through a part of town that's a bit rough? You put the windows up, lock the doors, and speed up every time the traffic light goes orange so you don't have to stop at a red?

      That's exactly what they're doing because they know Earth's around. They don't want to know.

  7. frankvw Silver badge

    Not bad

    All the joking aside, the point here is the the Chinese are well on their way to match (and soon surpass) the achievements of NASA and ESA. Mars orbiters, Martian and lunar rovers, an orbital space station... If I were a betting man I'd put money on them welcoming the US to the moon once (if ever) Uncle Sam finallly gets there.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Not bad

      Blueprints and manuals are very helpful, aren't they.

      1. frankvw Silver badge

        Re: Not bad

        "Blueprints and manuals are very helpful, aren't they."

        They are. NASA has had them since the 1960s.

        The point, in case you missed it, is not China's tendency to imitate, copy, reverse-engineer and use espionage. (Which is very real, no argument there.) Doing this in the 2020s rather than the 1960s also helps: there's so much advanced tech available off-the-shelf today then there was back then. Look no further than SpaceX: their progress would have been unthinkable in the previous century. But that's not what I'm trying to say here.

        What I'm getting at is that the difference lies in China having the will do do it and and the way they are are currently putting their backs into it.

        Blueprints and manuals are invaluable. NASA has had them for years. Yet the idea of having American boots back on the moon in this decade is pipe dream. Unless they do something really ass-backward, like breaking out those old blueprints and essentially recreating Apollo hardware with a new-looking paint job simply to beat everyone else. But I doubt that, because the don't have the budget to splurge on a PR stunt that won't move the US space program forward in any way.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Not bad

          All this inter-planetry space stuff just reduces the money available for war.

    2. mcswell Bronze badge

      Re: Not bad

      The US has been ON Mars since 1976, with numerous landers, rovers and orbiters. China has precisely one mission to Mars, with orbiter, lander and rover since 2021. They've done well, but they're hardly about to surpass the US in Martian exploration. As for manned space stations orbiting in LOE, the US first launched one in 1973; the ISS (a multi-nation space station) has been in orbit since 1998, with long-term inhabitants since 2000. And of course Uncle Sam was on the Moon in 1969.

      Now I'll agree that the current American administration could mess things up completely, but with no disrespect for China, I don't see them surpassing us in the next few years (unless, as I say, Donald Trump lets them).

  8. spold

    C'mon

    I could make an image like that using some black paper, a lamp, and some pins....

    1. Surreal Estate

      Re: C'mon

      Ah, but could you do it from Mars orbit?

  9. Anonymous Anti-ANC South African Coward
    Thumb Up

    Rendezvous with Rama by Arthur C Clarke

    The Ramans do everything in threes.

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Disappointment

    I saw some higher res pictures of 3IAtlas and I was very dissappointed. Where were the aliens waving from the windows? Where were the high tech thrusters and light speed warp producers? It just looked like a large rock. Oh well bring on project blue bleam, I guess that's all we'll get. There I was hoping someone would come and save us from our governments. Or perhaps unite mankind in a Hollywood like epic where we beat aliens, despite them having the technology to cross the galaxy, using a computer virus, because their computers will be just like ours. Or maybe they have no resistance to covid despite their identical to human biology, evolved in another world, and all wither and die HG Wells like. Better still it's the predators come back to hunt us and Jason Statham gets called in to save us.

    I'll go put the coffee on, take an aspirin and contemplate the bugs in my code.

    1. Anonymous Anti-ANC South African Coward

      Re: Disappointment

      Or we can do an ID4, get a virus on their purdy compootas to drop their shield, then deliver an explosive package.

      Wait, Jason Statham can do that, can he?

    2. David Hicklin Silver badge

      Re: Disappointment

      > It just looked like a large rock

      that's what they *want* you to think

  11. FuzzyTheBear
    Flame

    Top dog

    China is making good use of the opportunity Trump is giving them. While he cuts research budgets and imposes restrictions on funding , China is going full steam ahead and is the new leader in all fields of science. Scientists are flocking to China and leaving the USA and other countries to join them. China is the new leader and the USA lost the race. I do not doubt a second that China will land on the moon or do things the USA just can't do for reasons of infighting. The finger is pointed in one direction.

  12. Chris 239

    A space telescope in Mars orbit?

    Perhaps SpaceX could use one of the early starship demo flights to Mars that they are surely planning to deploy a space telescope to Mars orbit.

  13. chololennon
    Joke

    Meanwhile, Avi Loeb...

    ...(for incomprehensible reasons) sees green martians in the Chinese picture :-P

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon