The Register Home Page

back to article Zed's dead, baby. Zed's dead? No, wait – it's on Windows

Zed Industries has released a public beta of its code editor for Windows, marking a significant milestone for the Rust-based VS Code alternative that has until now been limited to macOS and Linux users. Zed running on Windows in the new beta version Zed running on Windows in the new beta version The move addresses a …

  1. that one in the corner Silver badge

    "Having a snappy, responsive editor makes coding so enjoyable,"

    Which some of us have been enjoying, even on Windows, for decades. Or DOS (you had to be typing pretty damn fast to get ahead of BRIEF on a 4.77 MHz Intel 8088).

    What on earth have people been doing to make *any* editor non-snappy, non-responsive, in these days of 16GB-plus RAM, multi-core CPUs running at ludicrous speeds? And why have people making comments like that been choosing to use whatever monstrosity rather than look for anything better - oh, wait, let me guess, none of the editors with a long history are New and Exciting.

    1. m4r35n357 Silver badge

      Re: "Having a snappy, responsive editor makes coding so enjoyable,"

      Those memory usage figures are obscene. The files were clearly <22MB (notepad++).

    2. Irongut Silver badge

      Re: "Having a snappy, responsive editor makes coding so enjoyable,"

      I recall being able to type faster than Word for Windows 1.0 but that was a very long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.

      1. GNU Enjoyer
        Angel

        Re: "Having a snappy, responsive editor makes coding so enjoyable,"

        It seems you haven't used any recent versions of microsoft software (good), as if you can operate a computer at a reasonable speed, you spend most of your time waiting for software to load, install and/or process, during which you can't really do much else.

    3. rg287 Silver badge

      Re: "Having a snappy, responsive editor makes coding so enjoyable,"

      What on earth have people been doing to make *any* editor non-snappy, non-responsive

      Electron. Writing desktop apps in a web framework instead of natively is always going to murder the UX.

    4. Rich 2 Silver badge

      Re: "Having a snappy, responsive editor makes coding so enjoyable,"

      I’ll still stick with vim. It starts up before my finger fully lifts off the keyboard after typing “vim”. And it shuts down and gets out of my way equally fast.

      Most of the “GUI-type” editors I’ve seen take several seconds (at least) to put their ducks in order to the point where you can actually use them. And somehow this is (apparently) “acceptable”. Baffling considering (as you point out) the ludicrous speed of a modern PC

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    "dead? No, wait – it's on Windows"

    The difference being ?

    No slight on Zed intended. I am sure Zed's quality is far too good to be forced to run under Windows. Pearls and swine etc

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: "dead? No, wait – it's on Windows"

      Shurely ... Perls and Wine ... sounds almost the same !!!

      :)

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: The difference being ?

      The tone of the smart arse comments? Code is "forced to run on windows"? How frightful for the poor code.

  3. Irongut Silver badge

    Very nice but

    If I want a code editor I'll use a full fat IDE thanks.

    What I want is a good text editor that launches in a fraction of a second and has useful features for editing text which may or may not be code. I don't want an Electron frankenweb app, Git integration, AI support, multi-agent collaboration, etc, etc. I also don't want to know what language it was written in because if you're that desparate to tell me then it was a religious choice, not a technical one.

    So far Sublime is the best I've found but they too can't resist the kitchen sink approach to adding pointless features.

    1. ICL1900-G3 Silver badge

      Re: Very nice but

      Agreed, Sublime was brilliant, getting bloated. I mainly use Vim, but I'm like that.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Very nice but

        Time for the Emacs vs Vi[m] Wars to be continued for another generation or two !!!

        :)

        1. Mike007

          Re: Very nice but

          Pfft. I use butterflies.

        2. Rich 2 Silver badge

          Re: Very nice but

          I’m vim all the way but even I would prefer emacs to anything like this

      2. toomanylogins

        Re: Very nice but

        Why Sublime bloated. It launches in no time easily the best one Ive found and worth paying for.

  4. jlturriff

    I don't think I've seen a product whose "documentation" more inspired me to run away screaming.

  5. sabroni Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Since then they've "embraced AI".

    Oh well, I don't need a new IDE anyway.

  6. m4r35n357 Silver badge

    Kill your browser

    https://zed.dev/

    Nice going!

  7. rg287 Silver badge

    No Electron?

    ...then wrote our own GPU-accelerate UI framework to transcend the limitations of Electron."

    What?!? Someone wrote a desktop app that wasn't just a webapp wrapped in Chromium? Is such a thing even possible? It's amazing what they can do these days! Not f-ing surprised it launches into <200MB instead of the bloated mess you get with anything using Electron.

  8. NATTtrash
    Pint

    @Tim Anderson

    +1!!!

    Do you mind if I have some of your tasty beverage to wash this down?

  9. Rich 2 Silver badge

    “…yet Windows remains the workhorse for nearly half the profession: 49.5 percent of professional developers“

    I can’t help thinking that many of that 49.5% are only using windows because their employer insists on it. It seems to be an increasingly common scenario where the first thing any software dev does with a new windows box it to stick a VM on it running Linux. You know - to actually do the actual work you’re being paid to do

    1. skswales

      Flip side being - many moons ago a outfit I knew was bought out; new parent company policy was Mac only, so out went all the old PCs. The embedded toolchain only ran on Windows.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like