The Register Home Page

back to article China slaps 1-hour deadline on reporting serious cyber incidents

Beijing will soon expect Chinese network operators to 'fess up to serious cyber incidents within an hour of spotting them – or risk penalties for dragging their feet. China digital fingerprint China ponders creating a national 'cyberspace ID' READ MORE From November 1, the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) will …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    1 hour?

    I guess a company's only possible action is to report, via api, that every bit of information on every system has been compromised every minute. The only other alternative appears to be to not get hacked...

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: 1 hour?

      The other 'safer' option is that you report 'I have been hacked' then 'I made a mistake, I have not been hacked' on a rotating schedule of 59minutes 5seconds (allowing 55 seconds for the report to be logged as CCP central !!!)

      You will be correct & mistaken multiple times but demonstrating a eagerness to comply with the directive from 'on high' !!!

      (It is always best to be 'seen' to be trying to comply !!!)

      :)

    2. munnoch Silver badge

      Re: 1 hour?

      "other alternative appears to be to not get hacked"

      Sharpening minds in the direction of that option sounds like a good thing to me. The response in the UK usually being particularly lackadaisical. "Oh yeah we forgot to mention all your shit got leaked a few weeks/months back but its not really our fault because it was a third party system". 1 hour does sound like a bit of a stretch though.

    3. NoneSuch Silver badge
      Devil

      Re: 1 hour?

      The Chinese government wants identify the Zero Days being used, so they can use them themselves.

  2. DavCrav2

    "outages that take key government or news websites offline for more than 24 hours."

    Yes, I will report within 30 minutes that an outage has happened that will take out a website for the next 24 hours.

    1. Reggiester
      FAIL

      "Estimated Resolution Time" is the logical and quite reasonable interpretation. Unless you were being intentionally dim, in which case, guffaw away.

  3. wolfetone Silver badge

    People mocking this, then ignoring the stone wall silence coming from M&S, Co-Op, JLR and TCS after their hacks since Easter.

    1. stiine Silver badge
      FAIL

      The closest M&S is 6770km from me. I don't know who Co-Op, JLR or TCS are, and I don't celebrate easter.

  4. Paul Herber Silver badge

    Meanwhile a different country relaxes the notification rules if only customer data is involved, or if there could be a detrimental effect on the stock price.

  5. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Not entirely impossible

    I note that they have at least been sensible to include the 'when noticed' condition, because some of these infections can linger for days before it becomes evident that something is amiss - especially the smaller shops don't have the tools and resources to immediately spot anomalies.

    The 1 hour window is rather short, though, if the required reporting requires a long shopping list of questions to be filled out, but it does prompt for more speed than the IMHO too leisurely approach of 3 days after you spot a problem. OTOH, that does leave you with more time and resources to first put out the fire so it's a mixed bag.

    Bonus points for including 'responsible people', it means executives who decide that bonus payments are more important than decent cyber defence and personnel may end up with a problem when consequences arrive. I've only seen that in Europe with DORA and NIS2, before that decision makers could hide behind the company.

    In summary, possibly harsh but IMHO not without merit.

    1. Helcat Silver badge

      Re: Not entirely impossible

      Pre-written report will sort out the problems with the 1 hour window.

      The other option is to simply not look for nor monitor for hacks. If you only need to report from when you became aware: Ignorance is suddenly your best buddy. Anything goes wrong: It's tech. Hardware, software or just your system being slow. Repair it. But don't think for one minute, that it was a cyber incident! Nope: No hacking here. Just a glitch. Or bug. Or hardware failure. That'd cover it!

      Obviously the head in the sand approach won't survive for long, so pre-writing a report that's vague enough but covers key points is the better way to go, with updates as and when you can actually get the information to put into the report. After all: You've done what you can within that 1 hour window... you just made a few mistakes.

      Or AI: Get AI to do the report. There: Sorted! Can also get it to monitor for breaches, too. Makes me wonder, though, if that's actually what this is about: To get more businesses in China to employ AI to monitor their systems...

  6. tiago.pelicari

    It's fun that a 100 million citizens means 10 times Portugal whole country while it also means less than 10% of China population.

  7. ajadedcynicaloldfart

    I'll say this for China

    and I can say a lot. about the shit they get up to, at least they go after managing directors and the board of the companies deemed to have done wrong.

    Compare that with the pathetic slap on the wrist (if any) that the west rolls out companies with security (if they bother with security at all) so rubbish that it is almost daily that a major company has had their I.T. systems broken into.

    Or it maybe that the "highly sophisticated" malware that western companies are attacked with are way more "highly sophisticated" than the Chinese attacks... ?

    Ishy

  8. steviebuk Silver badge

    Or face being disappeared

    All so Winnie The Pooh can block up the holes to stop the people of China being able to peek out and see the free world.

    1. beast666 Silver badge

      Re: Or face being disappeared

      Free world.

      Lol

  9. Sparkus

    As is should be.....

    it's useful to remember that China has their 'social credit' scheme backed up by the classic 9mm headache to keep their citizenry in-line and compliant with CCP directives.

    However rapid and accurate reporting of vulns is important.........

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like