back to article Biden stopped ICE from buying Israeli spyware, but Trump admin allows it to proceed

ICE may soon have a new weapon in its arsenal. The White House has reversed a Biden-era decision to suspend the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)'s purchase of software from commercial spyware maker Paragon Solutions. Israel-based Paragon Solutions' contract with ICE was signed in September of 2024, but quickly placed …

  1. IGotOut Silver badge

    Hands up anyone that's surprised?

    How's that Freeeedumb going MAGA supporters?

    1. Wang Cores Silver badge

      Re: Hands up anyone that's surprised?

      MAGA loves Israel. It's a permanent army base filled with murderous settlers shooting (unarmed - no fair if they can shoot back!) mostly young brown people.

      1. Empire of the Pussycat Silver badge

        Re: Hands up anyone that's surprised?

        They're not settlers, they're terrorists.

        If Palestinians copied them, they's exactly what the Israeli Death Force would call them as it mowed them down, together with their children.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Hands up anyone that's surprised?

        Ditto UK politicians and their "friends of Israel" groupings - more like Israeli govt run and controlled front groups

  2. Tron Silver badge

    Listen very carefully, I shall say this only once.

    The Resistance, erm, Democrats are going to have to start writing to each other in code.

    The entity that will target you the most is always your own government.

    1. Wang Cores Silver badge

      Re: Listen very carefully, I shall say this only once.

      The resistance isn't going to be democrats.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Listen very carefully, I shall say this only once.

        https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_War_(film)

        More like this, though TBH can’t see Texas being part of the Western Alliance until Abbot is Ousted

        It does however give a plot for Top Gun 3.

        1. TimMaher Silver badge
          Unhappy

          Re: civil war

          As I pointed out in another post, on Trump and NASA.

          Good film.

          It got downvoted quite a bit.

          1. Wang Cores Silver badge

            Re: civil war

            >It got downvoted quite a bit.

            Yeah because it's nuts to suggest democrats should conduct themselves in such a way. The factors to conducting and winning a civil war is so anathema to the few tent poles of the Democrats it would be suicidal to enter into conflict as them.

            A) Guns. Democrats have spent decades disarming their partisans and the zeitgeist is mocking the militia types, forgetting that even weekend warrior types can be used to occupy territory.

            B) Lack of financial power. Now that big tech has fully defected to be another big business supporting Republicans there's no real financial base for a liberal operation.

  3. DS999 Silver badge

    Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

    What about other parts of the US government? If the FBI etc. were still free to buy it and all that's been changed is that ICE can buy it too I don't see this making things much worse than they already are.

    It is hard to imagine how ICE would use this, especially with Trump's lackeys prioritizing numbers - you don't need to decrypt Whatsapp messages to know going to farms, meatpacking plants and Home Depot are fertile grounds for round-ups of people who are here illegally but aren't "violent criminals" or the "worst of the worst". They get the numbers up the those so they can meet Steven Miller's aggressive goals.

    1. IGotOut Silver badge

      Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

      Nah, they'll use it to target journalists, politicians, judges, and anyone else that opposes them.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

      ICE is very rapidly becoming Trumpler's private army, he's done a twofer on this, given them the ability to hack the phones of opponents and stuck it to "the libs" by reversing a Biden ban.

    3. Just Enough

      Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

      If you think ICE is going to contain its efforts to immigrants, you really haven't been paying attention to history.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

        Maybe not just "first generation" immigrants because there are a lot of bad people who are born there, I hear.

        Also the first peoples, some of them aren't even US citizens.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

        This would seem to be exactly what the 2nd amendment is for.

        Unfortunately most of the assholes who want their guns pried out of their cold dead hands probably ha e wet dreams about joining ICE

    4. mark l 2 Silver badge

      Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

      The way the current US administration is going ICE is basically becoming the US secret police, and in decades time will be talked about along side organisations such as the Gestapo or KGB.

      People need to wake up to the fact that once all the 'criminal illegal aliens' have been got rid of, they won't stop there and start going after anyone else they dislike, LGBT people, liberals, activists etc.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

        Secretly I'm sure you're very happy that Graham Linehan has been arrested.

        1. Ken G Silver badge
          Unhappy

          Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

          No, not happy, I loved Father Ted and the IT crowd. I really am disappointed in him, he's let himself and his country down by posting threats and incitement of violence.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

            Except he did none of those things. He tweeted out what is considered one of the common self-defence techniques that women are taught.

            1. I am David Jones Silver badge
              Facepalm

              Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

              Yeah…. commonly taught as self-defense against physical threats or violence, not “self-defense” against merely being near someone you find objectionable.

              1. Anonymous Coward
                Anonymous Coward

                Re: Biden stopped *ICE* from buying it

                You forget that 'words' and 'silence' have now been redefined as 'violence' and as such this is now a perfectly appropriate response to pretty much anything.

  4. 45RPM Silver badge

    I find it very depressing that the far right has successfully weaponised objection to the Zionist government of Israel, conflating it with anti-semitism. The problem, of course, being that most Jews (and certainly all the Jews I know) object to the behaviour of the Israeli government and the concept of settling Palestinian lands. They might not go quite as far as calling these settlements lebensraum (and yet that is what they are), or recognising the irony of the Israeli government acting in a demonstrably fascistic manner and visiting the sins perpetrated by the Nazis against the Jews upon their Muslim neighbours, but they still recognise the sins that Israel is committing now. And, to be honest, I can understand why they might not want to make that uncomfortable connection - after all, if someone in my family was a Farage supporter or a Trump supporter I’d still love them, and I might shy from recognising that they were fascists too.

    So this is what it has come to. The press, oil companies, weapons manufacturers are propping up fascist governments in the United States, Israel, Russia etc (and trying to do the same in the United Kingdom amongst others), and those right wing governments are banding together to ensure that policies are enacted which is in the best interests of their supporters (filling their pockets) whilst making life demonstrably worse for the poor gullible mugs who voted for them.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Take a gander at Alien Earth where the movie arc sub-plot about Weyland-Yutani mega/evil corporation has grown legs to 6 corporations controlling the Earth.

      It’s at the opposite end of the spectrum to Star Trek:TNG and Statfleet/UFP … though recognising there was a World War 3 in the back narrative.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      "successfully weaponised objection to the Zionist government of Israel"

      I think you will find that there are supporters of this approach on both sides of the aisle in the US govt. Actually I'd say that this is more prevalent amongst those with a D by their name.

      https://www.npr.org/2025/03/15/nx-s1-5075324/sen-chuck-schumer-discusses-his-new-book-antisemitism-in-america

      And then there is the ACLU and SPLC. They all sing from the same sheet.

      1. 45RPM Silver badge

        Sadly, I fear that you’re right. The same applies to the (supposedly centre left, but actually far from) Labour Party in the UK.

        The axis of oil / media / weapons / (anti)‘social’ media has utterly fucked up this planet. The good news is that we can defeat it through the application of critical thinking and tactical voting…

        Oh.

        Oh dear.

        No - we really are screwed.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          "The same applies to the (supposedly centre left, but actually far from) Labour Party in the UK"

          Jeremy Corbyn laying a wreath on the graves of people believed to have carried out, or at least orchestrated, the 1972 Olympics massacre was not exactly the best optics. The kneejerk reaction and the investigation was also far from good optics.

  5. that one in the corner Silver badge

    Will they get an unlimited use licence

    Or will you be charged every time they install it on all your devices as you move across the US borders?

    Will that fee just be rolled into your airline ticket price or will you have to tap to pay on arrival?

    1. Neil Barnes Silver badge
      Mushroom

      Re: Will they get an unlimited use licence

      Free burner phone with every plane ticket?

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Will they get an unlimited use licence

        At my last 2 companies (over the last 15 years) it has been policy for staff to take a mobile from the pool (in the previous company) and now a 'personal' mobile (with a US contract) that is turned on only when in the US. They are loaded with a few company contact phone numbers when supplied and are otherwise as new. We have laptops from a pool if we really need to take one, that are wiped and reimaged on return, and if we need data it is loaded via VPN when we are in the US. The image contains wiper software that is meant to be run on any data before leaving the US.

        Exactly the same rules as visiting any other rouge surveillance state.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Will they get an unlimited use licence

          Depending how paranoid I felt on a given day, I'd probably want to keep an image of the BIOS flash, EC and possibly the fingerprint reader. Or just buy burner laptops that can be shredded after use.

        2. Irongut Silver badge

          Re: Will they get an unlimited use licence

          What if you have to visit a green surveillance state?

          Or maybe a rogue one?

          1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

            Re: Will they get an unlimited use licence

            By the time Trump is done with enacting his masters plan, all the States will be rouge. There will be no blue or any other colour allowed. All head gear (mandatory) will be rouge MAGA hats :-)

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    ICE rebrand

    Due to poor public perceptions ICE will be rebranded as NICE.

    I wonder what the N stands for?

    1. Brave Coward Bronze badge

      Re: ICE rebrand

      NICE is Not ICE.

      1. druck Silver badge

        Re: ICE rebrand

        I GNU you were going to say that!

  7. codejunky Silver badge

    Erm

    "President Trump has made no secret of his desire to go after political enemies using the government"

    I am guessing the reg didnt wish to use the example of the weaponised government going after Trump for the last decade? Intelligence services squealing as their classified documents are declassified showing the terrible corruption and the DOJ being forced to look into participants.

    "and ICE was seen as a massive domestic surveillance operation before Trump even took office for the second time"

    The article you link to being 2022. Under Biden the border dissolved and sanctuary cities were doing everything they can to shelter the gangs and criminals flooding over the border. Some democrats have made it their mission to show the party in a terrible light by being as public and vocal about protecting actual criminals over their own people, not helped by Judges of the left leaning persuasion hiding, homing and protecting criminals.

    If the concern is that ICE has this facility then maybe the rest of the agencies need to be looked at too. Surely there cant be more concern about this than the FBI obtaining warrants for surveillance using what they knew to be fabricated evidence? I wont be surprised if this malware is installed on illegals phones as they get picked up to help locate more of them.

    1. WeeHeavy

      Re: Erm

      I won't be surprised when it get installed on YOUR phone either.

      1. codejunky Silver badge

        Re: Erm

        @WeeHeavy

        "I won't be surprised when it get installed on YOUR phone either."

        In the UK not US and havnt been for years. But I can understand the concern, but genuine concern would not be limited to just ICE.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Trollface

          Re: Erm

          In the UK not US and havnt been for years.

          Did they offer you residency?

          Even if not, they will still hold records on you.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Erm

      I hope nobody forgot what was going on under Obama:

      https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/us-security-agency-spied-merkel-other-top-european-officials-through-danish-2021-05-30/

  8. frankvw Silver badge

    Domestic?

    "Restored deal reignites domestic global spying worries"

    The whole point of this spyware is that it enables the US Gov't to conduct surrepticious surveillance on anyone with a device that will support it. (Which will also benefit anyone else who can get their hands on the data acquired which, given how US cyber security has been decimated in the past 6 months or so, will be much easier than it used to be.)

    So why would that be limited to deployment within US borders? Expect it coming soon to a device near you!

    1. Sudosu Silver badge

      Re: Domestic?

      Unless it is already on your device...

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Trust?

    I wouldn't trust the Israeli government as far as I could throw the entire Knesset. This may be the only thing I agree with Biden on!

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Paragon’s Proliferating Spyware Operations

    Paragon Solutions Ltd. was established in Israel in 2019. The founders of Paragon include Ehud Barak, the former Israeli Prime Minister, and Ehud Schneorson, the former commander of Israel’s Unit 8200. Paragon sells a spyware product called Graphite, which reportedly provides “access to the instant messaging applications on a device, rather than taking complete control of everything on a phone,” like NSO Group’s Pegasus spyware.’

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like