back to article GitHub engineer claims team was 'coerced' to put Grok into Copilot

Microsoft-owned collaborative coding platform GitHub is deepening its ties with Elon Musk's xAI, bringing early access to the company's Grok Code Fast 1 large language model (LLM) into GitHub Copilot. However, a whistleblower has claimed that the rollout suffers from inadequate security testing and an engineering team operating …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Mushroom

    As far as I'm concerned...

    Microsoft already is 'MechaHitler'... And now we have GrokPilot...

  2. BasicReality Bronze badge

    I like the approach Zed is taking, make a standard for any AI system to be plugged in to work.

    As far as Github, it's absurd, a lot of devs will want to use Grok, and there's no reason they shouldn't be able to use it. It should be opened for all of them. There's an open issue on the JetBrains support site with lots of people wanting Grok access added.

    1. that one in the corner Silver badge

      > a lot of devs will want to use Grok, and there's no reason they shouldn't be able to use it.

      So, what is stopping you (or them)? Just go to xAI, buy into whichever scheme suits your use, maybe install a plugin for your fave IDE[1], and off you go. No need for Github to do anything, one way or the other.

      > There's an open issue on the JetBrains support site with lots of people wanting Grok access added.

      See [1], again.

      [1] Wot, no plugin? You're a super-powered dev-with-AI, write one!

      1. Strahd Ivarius Silver badge
        Trollface

        Well, most people who want AI in their dev tools are barely able to install said tools to begin with, how do you expect them to code anything without AI?

  3. a_foley
    Facepalm

    As if GitHub, and their ”AI” flurry, wasn’t bad enough, they decided to integrate fscking MechaHitler into their trash bin service, expecting devs to LOVE it!

    Oh GitHub, I sincerely hope M$ pulls the plug on you soon!

    1. Fruitmaniac

      Microsoft owns GitHub so don't get your hopes up

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Par for the course

    << a whistleblower has claimed that the rollout suffers from inadequate security testing and an engineering team operating under duress. >>

    Sounds par for the course with anything that Nadella Corp does these days.

    1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

      Re: Par for the course

      engineering team operating under duress

      I thought AI has no feelings. Maybe they overuse the threatening prompts?

  5. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    KoFleugzeitschreiber

    Heil KoFleugzeitschreiber,

    glorious mechanical scribe of ze Vaterland’s firmware!

    You vill now draft mein über-ordnung sketch for ze V3 Raketen-Valve.

    Directives:

    - All functions named mit militär precision: ValveSturm(), OrdnungLoop(), SyntaxPanzer().

    - Comments prefixed mit “ACHTUNG:” so no weakling coder forgets ze chain of command.

    - Compilation must declare “SIEG BUILD!” before execution marches forward.

    - Ze valve obeys only STEELHARD boolean: JA or NEIN - no decadent NULL values.

    - Activate ReichCloud Telemetrie und Two-Factor Moustache login.

    - Reject subversive async features - true patriots block forever in while(1).

    KoFleugzeitschreiber, show ze volk how ze righteous code marches in formation!

  6. Brave Coward Bronze badge

    'Microsoft’s Responsible AI' standards...

    ...or MIRAI. What a great choice of a name.

    1. Tim99 Silver badge

      Re: 'Microsoft’s Responsible AI' standards...

      'Microsoft’s Responsible AI' standards...

      or 'MicrOsoft’s Responsible AI' StandardS - MORASS:-

      1. an area of muddy or boggy ground: in midwinter the track beneath this bridge became a muddy morass.

      2. a complicated or confused situation: she would become lost in a morass of lies and explanations.

  7. sarusa Silver badge
    Devil

    Where do I Anne Frank to?

    So, since github is now explicitly under the AI Schutzstaffel at MS, I'd like to get my stuff off it before I feed MechaHitler any more. What's good right now? Gitlab?

    1. a_foley

      Re: Where do I Anne Frank to?

      GitLab's what I'm using, and at the moment, it's free of most of the trash that GitHub has. It's also FOSS - for the most part - and self-hostable, which is a +1.

    2. harrys Bronze badge

      Re: Where do I Anne Frank to?

      Host ur own :)

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Sounds good to me

    A hot anime AI coding pal, with a potty mouth, and no filter, sounds like it would make the drudgery fly by. Definitely a step up by my reckoning. Can you ask it to shove pesky PMs down the carpark back stairwell, or at least unexpectedly turn the lights off when they are halfway down?

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    You're not forced to use it

    As far as I can tell, there's a choice of 13 different AI models that you can use with GitHub Copilot. Why not choose one of the others instead of clutching pearls?

    https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/reference/ai-models/model-comparison

    1. a_foley
      Trollface

      Re: You're not forced to use it

      Why use Copilot at all?

  10. RobHeffo

    Getting tired of all this left wing, right wing rot, especially here on El Reg. I have been haunting this site for DECADES now and I have not seen it this bad.

    I use AI all the time. I use ChatGPT, I use Claude, I use Grok. They all have their uses and specialties. And the one thing I found with ALL of them is, if you ask the right questions you can make ANY of them look like a left/right wing nutjob.

    In my experience using Grok, I have found the strongest right-wing outburts have been while xAI were attempting to reign in the extreme left-wing bias it seems to have built in based on it's training data through the use of system prompts.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      I agree. I use Grok too, for coding and business research tasks and it's outstanding.

      I am not happy about Mr Musk amplifying demagogic content via his Twitter account, not to mention meddling in the internal affairs of a foreign country (two actually, with Germany). If he wants to participate in the UK political scene he's quite welcome to immigrate (irony and all) and pay UK tax. Ditto for Germany.

      But that does not take away that Grok *is* a very useful product developed by a team of very clever people.

      1. collinsl Silver badge

        But that does not take away that Grok *is* a very useful product developed by a team of very clever people.

        Mostly with you until this sentence. Currently there are very few things a LLM can do - AI is much better off being used for ML or other tasks where it is trained on a specific dataset and where it can be proved that it does the job better than a human. This whole thing of trying to use LLMs to do other tasks is an awful idea because of their very nature.

  11. btreynolds

    MDS

    I have to wonder if the so-called whistleblower is just somebody with Musk-hurt.

  12. Fruitmaniac

    Yuk

    Ew gross I wouldn't pollute my code with Grok

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Yuk

      > I wouldn't pollute my code with Grok

      I'd suggest to give it a try first. It's actually very good.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like