The Register Home Page

back to article Network scans find Linux is growing on business desktops, laptops

It might not be the year of the Linux desktop just yet, but ongoing cyberattacks and a general desire for a more secure posture are driving some businesses to the way of the penguin, according to asset manager Lansweeper. Woman in ret hat photo via Shutterstock Lansweeper finds a lot of CentOS Linux out there READ MORE On …

  1. DJO Silver badge

    Coluld be good, could be bad

    "It is certainly more down to the hardening of systems," he told us, pointing to cybersecurity concerns and a seemingly relentless increase in vulnerabilities. To be clear, Linux is not immune to vulnerabilities...

    The paucity of attacks on Linux systems is probably as much to do with the relatively small attack surface as any inherent security in Linux. If the market penetration significantly increases expect the naughty people to put more effort into finding Linux attack vectors. Android is not short of attacks and that's basically Linux so a few of those bad folk already have the right sort of experience.

    Or maybe not, I try not to be overly cynical, but in the world today that seems to be an impossible and pointless task.

    1. LionelB Silver badge

      Re: Coluld be good, could be bad

      > Android is not short of attacks and that's basically Linux

      "Basically" Linux, insofar as it uses a (modified) Linux kernel. But how many of those exploited Android vulnerabilities are actually kernel vulnerabilities?

      You may be correct about the attack surface issue, but then again doesn't Linux already present a massive -- and, you'd have thought, tempting -- attack surface in, e.g., the server, networking and IOT domains?

      1. doublelayer Silver badge

        Re: Coluld be good, could be bad

        Not a lot of those are kernel vulnerabilities, but few of the attacks on desktop Linux need to be kernel vulnerabilities either. It often starts with user vulnerabilities which may not need any tech vulnerabilities at all but rely on convincing users to do things that the OS was intended to allow but cause problems. But there's a large stack of software above any kernel which can be attacked and people will do it.

        And there already are people attacking in the domains you listed, but the problem will get larger with desktop Linux because the attack surface gets larger. People attack Linux servers incessantly and successfully. Linux-based IoT devices find themselves in botnets routinely, and one category of those that's particularly targeted is networking devices. It happens, and it will continue happening.

      2. AndrueC Silver badge
        Pirate

        Re: Coluld be good, could be bad

        You may be correct about the attack surface issue, but then again doesn't Linux already present a massive -- and, you'd have thought, tempting -- attack surface in, e.g., the server, networking and IOT domains?

        But one that is inherently harder to attack than desktop computers, especially from outside of the LAN that hosts the machine (okay, so perhaps not IoT devices). Any exposure to the outside world will be through carefully controlled and guarded IP ports. Servers are looked after by (mostly) highly skilled operators. They are locked up tighter than a gnat's arse.

        Desktop machines are largely operated by numpties who know little and probably care less about security. Whilst they are generally behind a firewall their numpty operators often leave them unattended, logged in and not locked. These numpties use their desktop computer to visit questionable websites, read dodgy emails and click on the links they find in both cases without a care or a thought in the world.

        Even Linux security is going to struggle in the face of the kind of asinine things desktop users get up to.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Coluld be good, could be bad

          Exactly.

          The biggest risk is the users, and what they install, or do, with their computers.

          The biggest growth of Linux use we see in my workplace is amongst developers. They are for the most part NOT operators. They are utterly clueless about secrutiy, and they keep borking their Linux machnes all the time, because they don't know what they are doing, or at least the consequences of their actions. They also want god-mode on every single server, network or device there is, and leave it wide open. They try to poke holes in the firewalls in all ways and places possible, and in general destroy decades of work in mere minutes if not stopped. In short, they act like teenagers - full of confidence, utterly lacking experience and knowledge.

          I can't wait for "AI" to improve so we can lay off most of the developers and keep those few that actually are needed to quality-check the code and fix the mistakes of "AI". Maybe given a few years of training some of those developers can be turned into operators.

          Ohh, and as you correctly said - the servers are locked down, not directly on the Internet, and the users logged in every now and then are usually skilled. No developers allowed on production servers.

        2. BobChip
          Facepalm

          Re: Coluld be good, could be bad?

          Sadly, ANY security is at risk once a system gets into the hands of users. I doubt that any system can ever be made both truly useful AND completely user-proof.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Coluld be good, could be bad

      Android handset manufacturers are responsible for their own system updates. The prevalence of vulnerabilities often comes down to manufacturers not pushing updates in a timely manner, if at all.

      Most reputable Linux distros (for desktop or laptop) push updates quite fast - on average, much faster than Windows equivalents.

      1. AndyMTB

        Re: Coluld be good, could be bad

        And the updates install a LOT more quickly, and painlessly, than Windows. How often do you need to reboot linux after updates? - probably once every couple of months, with most updates just installing in the background. I only have one Windows instance, it runs in a linux-hosted VM. My wife has some specialist software that will only run under MS, drives me crazy when it's doing it's "...please do not turn off" business. Must say though, it does seem quite stable in a VM!

      2. Flocke Kroes Silver badge

        Re: Creative counting

        Years ago Microsoft said Windows was more secure than Linux because it needed fewer security updates per year. They achieved this important statistic by delaying all security updates until next Tuesday.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Linux

    Can't wait to see the figures...

    After Win10 becomes EOL...

    1. TonyJ

      Re: Can't wait to see the figures...

      In an awful lot of corporate settings, it already has. They tend not to wait until the current OS has gone EoL before rolling out the next one as it takes time to ensure it works across different hardware models, applications etc etc.

    2. This post has been deleted by its author

    3. Chz

      Re: Can't wait to see the figures...

      The newest machines that can't (or rather, won't) run Windows 11 are 8 years old. I don't think it's going to affect the Commercial sector all that much; any given company rarely has anything that old. That being said, converting the users over to 11 is still an ongoing headache where I am. Home users are unlikely to give a damn whether or not they still get updates, to our detriment more than theirs.

  3. Boothy
    Thumb Up

    Linux Desktop at work

    So far my only experience of using Linux in a work desktop environment, was a very positive one.

    This was a few years ago now, I was working in a UK government office (as a consultant), along with a small team of Java developers (also from the same consultancy). Can't say which uk gov department, or any specifics of what we were delivering.

    We'd been brought in to do some software development, specifically Java, I was acting as lead dev/designer (plus help with things like building local scripted/automated test environments for unit testing).

    When we got there, we were supplied with client provided laptops (nothing unusual there), but it turned out these all had Ubuntu installed, which was a first for us!

    I was already familiar with Linux myself, I'd used various flavours at home for years (including Ubuntu), desktop, servers, header-less etc, and I'd cut my teeth on AIX boxes years earlier, so this was a pleasant surprise for me. But it turned out no one else on our team had ever touched Linux desktop before, or even command line on servers etc. (We were almost entirely Windows back then, including servers).

    But it seems the client had pushed adoption of Open Source. So all Laptops and servers were Linux, all tooling (build/deploy/manage etc) was OSS, although they did still use Outlook for email (this MS usage was gov wide, whereas OSS was specific to just this department). Outlook etc was via the web versions.

    I became the defaco Linux SME for the team, and walked them through the differences compared to Windows etc. (It's also how I ended up doing all the automation side of things, as I was already familiar with things like shell scripting etc).

    Within a few days, the whole team had adapted to using Linux, with the devs realising that many of the tools they'd used via a bit of a cludge under Windows, were just native under Linux. Even the IDE the team used (one of the Eclipse based ones) was also Linux native, so no learning curve there.

    About 6 months later, when the project came to a close, the team were actually sad to see their Linux laptops having to go back!

    This is so far, unfortunately, my only experience of Linux desktop in a professional environment, in over two and a half decades!

    1. coderguy

      Re: Linux Desktop at work

      The last few firms I've worked at, have just handed out Windows Laptops. They put all the developers on their own network and let them Install whatever is needed.

      Includes replacing the corporate image with whatever works best.

      The only caveat being, the developers manage their own devices (except hardware issues).

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Linux Desktop at work

        Sounds grand. The last big dumb companies I worked at were rigorous and adamant in their deployment of Windows as The Approved Corporate Desktop[tm].

        Irony is, the first one actually shipped products based on BSD, and Linux. For a long time, engineers had Sun workstations and/or Linux PCs, but IT always resisted or outright refused to help. Not that they actually were much help anyway; they would sometimes blame the most ridiculous unrelated problems on "well if you weren't using non-standard systems..."

        Eventually the place stopped being an engineering company with engineering-focused leadership, and the new big bosses let Corporate IT make the rules they'd likely been campaigning for all along. Since all they knew was Windows, that's all you got.

        The other place has been nothing but Windows forever. Trying to use Linux there was an exercise in futility, even when they said they needed people with Linux skills.

        Small wonder those companies aren't doing so well anymore and have had a big drain of experienced talent.

        1. C R Mudgeon Silver badge
          Pint

          Re: Linux Desktop at work

          "Windows as The Approved Corporate Desktop[tm]."

          W ATACD. I don't know whether that was intended or chance. Either way, have a TGIF beverage.

      2. collinsl Silver badge

        Re: Linux Desktop at work

        That sounds like a good idea to me, with 2 important caveats:

        1. Those machines are on a PHYSICALLY separate network that only has internet access. Not even logical separation can prevent some attacks these days and I'd not want to risk someone taking control of one of these machines and launching constant attacks against the corporate network.

        2. The machines are actively blocked from connecting to ANY corporate network - ideally via 802.1x or similar so only authorised machines are on the network anyway. Again to prevent any possibility of attacks.

  4. IGnatius T Foobar !

    <oblig>

    Maybe the real year of the Linux desktop was the friends we made along the way.

  5. retiredFool Silver badge

    Security

    No one should be surprised. Historically *nix was a multi-user system where even in the 60's you worried about could a different user on the system access your files, could a user bring down the system by being a resource pig, ... Windows began as a PC (Personal being the operative word) that initially did not even support networking. Well, sneakernet. It was kind of a big deal in the early 90's I think it was when cards started getting available for microsoft PC's to get on the LAN. So not surprised a system that was never designed to be secure has had trouble while a system designed to be secure has better security.

    1. AndrueC Silver badge
      Boffin

      Re: Security

      So not surprised a system that was never designed to be secure has had trouble while a system designed to be secure has better security.

      Windows NT was designed to be secure and it can be very secure. The problem is that desktop users don't like security. It gets in the way of all the stuff they are trying to do. Windows tries to be friendly and helpful because that's what most of its users need. You can modify it's security settings and permissions to make it safer but users won't like it.

      1. werdsmith Silver badge

        Re: Security

        It's so true. The first thing I do with Windows is set up an admin user and run everything as administrator.

        The firs thing I do with linux is set up a sudo user and mess with that file so that it run everything as sudo without needing a password.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Security

          You probably let agenic AI run riot on it too with 100% success.

      2. aks

        Re: Security

        Windows 2000 was based on Windows NT, not 98.

      3. Taliesinawen Bronze badge

        Re: Security

        > Windows NT was designed to be secure and it can be very secure.

        “NT and its successors .. were not initially designed with Internet security in mind as much”

        1. AndrueC Silver badge
          Boffin

          Re: Security

          I think perhaps we should quote the entire sentence, don't you? And for the sake of balance I'll highlight the bit you omitted.

          "Furthermore, although Windows NT and its successors are designed for security (including on a network) and multi-user PCs, they were not initially designed with Internet security in mind as much, since, when it was first developed in the early 1990s, Internet use was less prevalent".

          The NT Kernel was very much designed with security in mind. Its chief architect, Dave Cutler, was responsible for the design and implementation of VMS which is itself a secure OS. NT was C2 certified back in the 1990s.

          To be honest I'm not really sure what "not initially designed with Internet security in mind as much" even means. The Kernel's object based and ACL controlled security model ought to have been good enough for anything.

          1. Andrew Scott

            Re: Security

            if i remember correctly even the video drivers for NT were initially user space for security, but they were moved to kernel space for performance reasons.

  6. Blackjack Silver badge

    Can you say "Windows Recall"?

    The fact there is no easy way to turn that thing off for real is a security nightmare.

    1. Sudosu Silver badge

      I hear Brave Browser will block Recall, at least for your surfing.

      1. Blackjack Silver badge

        Unfortunately people and companies use Windows machines for more that just web browsing.

  7. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I think you may find it's Windows 11 driving the shift.

    1. TonyJ

      To a large extent.

      All the people and especially all the companies that have invested heavily in Windows 10 devices that then wont run or install Windows 11 despite being perfectly operational devices... that is a bitter pill to swallow for some.

      And lets face it the single biggest stumbling block to mass migration is an inability to run native MS Office (and no...for an awful lot of users, the web versions or LibreOffice et al do not cut it). In my current testing, I have found OnlyOffice to have superb compatibility, but I suspect it's ties to Russia (which they also try to obfuscate) worry most adopters.

    2. Jurassic.Hermit

      And Android. And Chrome OS. And iOS. And Mac.

      Everyone out there using everything but Windows in their daily lives, they eventually realise they don't need to put up with all of the crap and inconvenience which bored Richmond marketers and devs decide to throw upon them just to justify keeping themselves in a job.

      Windows 11 is a shitfest, I'm going to Mint permanently next year.

      1. M.V. Lipvig Silver badge

        Why wait? That minty fresh future could be yours today.

  8. steelpillow Silver badge
    Mushroom

    Randomised ratshit

    There does seem to be a sea change in the air.

    10 years ago I would moan about MS gobshite. All the pointy-haired managers would smile condescendlingly and trot out stock platitudes as to an irritating child.

    Today I an once again moaning about said vomit. The new breed of PHM smile wryly and offer guarded whines in sympathy.

    IMHO MS have cocked up royally, even for them. The move from desktop to 365+SharePoint has been so appallingly orchestrated and executed that the UX has become the counter-productive and untameable beast that is beginning to bring them down. I even find myself wishing for a good old Win 2000 + Office 2002 or whatever it was, rather than today's randomised ratshit. But "because security" is so much easier to thrust down the throat of the illiterate beancounter.

  9. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

    "the trend was more along the lines of exponential"

    Make that sigmoidal. Unfortunately by the time it gets to anything like mass acceptance the pottering about will have made it as opaque as Windows and the cognoscenti will have moved to BSD.

    1. steelpillow Silver badge
      Joke

      Did you mean "the Poettering about"?

    2. collinsl Silver badge

      Well based on that projection now's the time to invent the replacement for BSD then that people can move to in 10-15 years, best get cracking!

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Driven

    I believe the change will be driven by home users, many of whom refuse to ditch their hardware just to please Microsoft's quarterly outlook. Many will seek alternatives to keeping their hardware running and will most likely end up switching to Linux Mint. And liking it.

    Businesses are more conservative and except for the specific groups mentioned aren't willing to ditch their decades of investment in Microsoft technology. For now.

    1. Richard 12 Silver badge

      Re: Driven

      Home users just won't.

      They'll stay on Win10 until their machine actually breaks, or Chrome or Steam won't run.

      1. M.V. Lipvig Silver badge

        Re: Driven

        I am a home user, and bought a Win11 machine with the sole intention of making it a Mint box. And, it is now a Mint box.

        1. collinsl Silver badge
          Joke

          Re: Driven

          Surely there's some more cost-effective wooden options to store your leaves?

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Driven

        No they won't. Years of conditioning (mostly by Microsoft itself) has made them skittish about not being able to update their machines to prevent vulnerabilities. They'll start looking for alternatives and Linux Mint is where they'll end up.

        Mind you that once Microsoft drops support many applications will also drop support for Windows 10. Including web-browsers like Firefox and Chrome, which are much more likely to have serious vulnerabilities.

  11. gerryg

    Munich

    Nothing to do with the software everything to do with the politics.

  12. theOtherJT Silver badge

    Not just security but reliability.

    We've had an absolute nightmare trying to get Windows laptops to play nice in our environment. Now admittedly, we're an odd duck, seeing as we were basically 99% Apple to start with for weird historical reasons. We were slowly transitioning into using Windows - mostly because as the business has grown buying multi-thousand dollar macbooks for everyone was getting way too expensive given that most of them didn't need them, but also because we were collecting a growing number of bits of software that were required for business purposes that just didn't have a MacOS version available.

    We are now reversing that trend and where we don't have to use Windows for software compatibility reasons, we're picking up Linux machines instead because they just work better and I get how insane that sounds, but it's been true. Damn near everyone who bitched about MacOS and wanted a Windows laptop asked to go back to Mac once the Windows 11 rollout started. Why? It's constantly changing things and pissing people off.

    Random new applications show up in the start menu without you asking for them. Adverts pop up in front of people while they're trying to work. When they open some application Microsoft would like to gently suggest that maybe they'd prefer to use something else. Hey - have you tried our AI? It's very nice. Please try our AI. No? Ok, I'll ask you again tomorrow, no sorry, there's no "Never ask again" button - or at least, if there is, it'll only work until the next software update. Basically it's annoying the end users to the point that they're happier using Ubuntu because it's more like what they expect Windows to be than Windows is. Couple of Gnome-shell tweaks to put the taskbar down on the bottom of the screen and the "Start" button on the Left and half our admin staff wouldn't be able to tell the difference anyway.

    Given that we didn't have a big Microsoft deployment in the first place, investing heavily in Windows infrastructure (be that cloudy or otherwise) to manage a bunch of laptops basically entirely for the purpose of preventing Microsoft from randomly messing about with them without asking us is less cost effective than deploying Ubuntu and leaving it alone. I don't need a massive stack of powershell being deployed by intune to strip out all the random new shit that came with this months "bug fixes" because Ubuntu - for all its faults, and I admit it has many - doesn't do that.

    Linux has become easier than Windows - especially for people who are now very comfortable doing everything in a browser. Word? In the browser. Excel? In the browser. Outlook? In the browser now too. We just take sudo powers off them for anything that's not apt update or apt upgrade and they're hard put to damage the things either.

    Sure they're not for everybody - Most of our more technical staff still run Macs because we can properly control those as endpoints whilst also letting them have a great deal more power than we let the regular Joe. But hey, if the Linux numbers keep climbing it might be worth putting a bit of money into a managed endpoint solution for that and then maybe we can let the technical staff have Linux machines as well. Most of them would prefer it, but for various security compliance related reasons we can't let them right now. It'd certainly be cheaper than buying into the Microsoft ecosystem and given the general trajectory at Microsoft at the moment it looks like it'd be more reliable.

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    The infamous case of the German city of Munich

    Ballmer personally visit Munich’s mayor, Christian Ude, attempting to persuade the mayor to stick with Microsoft’s Windows. Microsoft offered substantial financial incentives to keep Munich on its platform. Microsoft launched a massive lobbying campaign to retain Munich’s business. Microsoft moved its German headquarters to Munich and other financial incentives.

  14. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Most users don't want Linux, and so Windows has dominated. But . . .

    Trump (yes Trump) is making all dealings with the US, and US companies, problematic.

    What if Trump adds a tariff or a surcharge to foreigners using US software, for any country he currently dislikes?

    What if trump outright bans sales of US software to countries he currently dislikes? (As he has done for some processor chips).

    It's crazy talk, yes. But Trump *is* crazy.

    Linux *might* become a way to de-risk IT supply in non-US countries. If only users could tolerate Linux, this could be the start of something.

    Note that this isn't limited to Microsoft. AWS, Google, Apple, MS and others are all US companies.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: But Trump *is* crazy.

      The combination of the system potentially recording everything and having an AI built in and the company that updates it being subject to the Patriot act could be worrying if there ever were a US president, who understood what this meant and was happy to play fast and loose the rules.

  15. mickaroo

    I was there first...!

    I've been running Linux on the desktop in various flavours (Corel, SUSE, PCLOS, Mandriva, Mint) since when I still had hair.

    And I finally killed my M$365 account this month. I feel so liberated...

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like