back to article US Department of Defense will stop sending critical hurricane satellite data

Satellite data used for hurricane forecasting was to be abruptly cut off from the end of June due to "recent service changes," but the department in charge has now put the date off another month. The data in question comes from the US Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (DMSP), and the termination was announced via a …

  1. Eclectic Man Silver badge

    There isn't a hurricane on the way

    Well, that's what I think Mr Fish said.

    I realise that some people do not believe in Global Warming, but surely they understand that weather still happens anyway?

    1. Baird34

      Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

      You're one of those sheeple aren't you. There's no such thing as weather, it's just a way for communist scientists to control us, duh.

      (Hope I don't need a /s)

    2. The man with a spanner Silver badge

      Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

      Its all right, don't panic. God will protect the land of the free now they are ridding thenseves of Queer, Trans, Imigrant Commies.

      Weather only happens to deviants. Now, what is the definition a deviant?

      1. Eclectic Man Silver badge
        Unhappy

        Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

        Ahem, being one of 'the LGBTQIA+ community'* (a more disparate 'community' would be hard to imagine), your statement does not console me.

        *1: I refer to myself as 'gay, male', but honesty I am so inept at it I might as well not bother.

        2: No, I don't know what all the letters mean either, and as for the colours on the flag, just do not ask.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

          Lesbian Gay Bi Trans Queer Intersex Asexual, and + is for anyone else who considers themselves somehow part of, or allied with, the community.

          1. xyz123 Silver badge

            Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

            So basically it'll eventually just be ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUWXYZ1234567890!"£$%^&*()-+

            To cover every possible scenario.

            1. Dan 55 Silver badge

              Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

              There's a new one (to me) which is FLINTA*. Just when I finally more or less managed to remember the old one.

              1. Jamesit
                Thumb Up

                Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

                FLINTA is a lot easier to say.

                1. Dan 55 Silver badge

                  Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

                  Don't forget the *.

              2. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

                Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

                Oh wow, that's even worse. It seems the only people excluded from FLINTA are straight males. Maybe they could have a special committee meeting, decide to add straight males and we can all go back to just including all of humanity as "people", without any separation or segregation and all live happily ever after in harmony :-)

            2. Swiss Anton

              Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

              And let's not forget the Æ community

              1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

                Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

                Is that just Elon's kids - or has there been an Anglo-Saxon name resurgence post-Brexit ?

                1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

                  Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

                  No, kids have been known by Anglo Saxon nick-names for generations, as in "come in ya little fucker, it's dinner time", and similar affectionate terms for children :-)

            3. sebacoustic
              Linux

              Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

              just call it the .+ community and be done with it

              using the tux icon but sure there are some windows or even macOS (gasp) users versed in regular expressions

              1. Jellied Eel Silver badge

                Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

                just call it the .+ community and be done with it

                Don't call it anything because a) community members will tell you or b) 97% of the time it won't really matter, or c) there be monsters.

                In which I had some FUN! after diving into body modification, then diving deeper into more extreme body modification. Then finding an interesting community that had either physically removed their gender, or just wanted to be genderless-

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-binary#Agender

                Which I found fascinating as I've always been interested in identiy, and identy politics. But that also had some very heated debates because someone was lobbying hard for that group to be known as 'neutrois', which they'd come up with as a catchy name for a 3rd gender. Which also rather missed the point because the people in that community didn't want a gender lable. It was a small group, and the person pushing the lable wasn't in it. This was also around the time of Labour's ID card and from memory 78 or so bits of data 'needed' to make up someone's identity. So then how to reflect the choice of a genderless person when systems wanted mostly binary choices.. Or now I guess a drop-down list with 'N/A' for sex/gender when people didn't want those lables. I think now they're lumped into the 'A' category, but the ones I keep in touch of it mostly try to stay out of the politics.

        2. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

          Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

          "and as for the colours on the flag, just do not ask"

          I always understood to to be a simple representation of a spectrum as an analogy to a spectrum of sexuality. Them they started adding letters onto LGB and eventually started adding colours to the flag. That latter being an odd move because adding new colours to represent "new" additions to the community would imply that the original flags colours represented specific groups, which they never did. As a straight male, I'm now feeling left out and marginalised because there's no colour in the flag for me :-)

      2. CowHorseFrog Silver badge

        Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

        Funny that you mention weather only affects deviants, because the states that get slammed by hurricans are all red voters.

        1. This post has been deleted by its author

        2. Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

          Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

          This.

          I imagine that the decision will be reversed when Florida or Texas get slammed by a big storm.

      3. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

        >Weather only happens to deviants

        That explains Florida then

    3. Boris the Cockroach Silver badge
      Facepalm

      Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

      And theres no evil FEMA forcing you into 'recovery' camps and asking which way you vote before giving democrat supporters $700

      All hail the idiot king.

      1. FrankAlphaXII

        Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

        As an Emergency Management professional, I hope people are individually prepared because King Cheeto won't do shit except say how great he is for authorizing some paper towels for brown people.

        You get what you vote for.

        1. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

          Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

          "You get what you vote for."

          Sometimes. And sometimes you get what other people voted for.

          1. C R Mudgeon
            FAIL

            Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

            "sometimes you get what other people voted for."

            As one of the 95ish percent of the world's (human) population who weren't even eligible to vote, with sadness, anger and horror I agree.

        2. snowdogu7

          Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

          It's important to recognize that when people been forced into poverty and terrible education by corruption and targeted oppressive policies. If you, your friends, and your family have all gotten a shitty education your critical thinking skills have likely been hampered. If you're living paycheck-to-paycheck you're most likely going to be spending all your energy on survival.

          Those two things, among many others, make for a voting base that's easier for politicians to lie to because you have to have the energy and critical thinking skills to see through easy answers in order to see through their lies. There is a reason for the positive correlation between getting a good education and voting for liberal candidates, and that correlation means there's a strong incentive for politicians on the right to keep their constituents from getting one.

          We've been told to blame each other for the way we vote. It's important to think about why we've been told that.

          1. nobody who matters Silver badge

            Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

            That sounds a very plausible theory, but in practise, I don't think it is entirely supported by the evidence.

            There are a great many very well educated people who are not liberal minded at all.

            Neither do you have to be a liberal to be against the establishment of an extreme right wing authoritarian dictatorship; and you don't need a good education or a great deal of intelligence to see that is precisely the direction in which the USA is currently being driven. Indeed, it is almost there (after only 6 months!)

            Education is I think, only part of the story.

            1. nobody who matters Silver badge

              Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

              Four people who are blind?

              Or are they simply poorly educated, or perhaps simply unintelligent?

          2. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: an easy voting base

            "Those two things, among many others, make for a voting base that's easier for politicians to lie to "

            I understand this, and also why people are angry.

            But if you willingly vote for a person who promises to deport 11 million people at gun point, my compassion is limited.

            If you vote for violence against others, don't be surprised if it hits you instead. In the end, you will be treated as you treat others.

          3. SundogUK Silver badge

            Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

            "...people been forced into poverty and terrible education by corruption and targeted oppressive policies."

            Yeah, those Democrats are complete bastards aren't they?

        3. Andrew Scott Bronze badge

          Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

          no the wealthy got what they paid for.

    4. Gary Stewart Silver badge

      Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

      Per Moronodon I, nothing that a few hydrogen/thermonuclear bombs can't fix.

    5. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

      Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

      Didn't the hurricanes arrive via the Gulf of Mexico? Now it's the Gulf of Idiocy America they'll behave themselves and go elsewhere.

      1. CowHorseFrog Silver badge

        Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

        I think Trump renamed the Gulf of Mexico, because he wanted the hurricans to ONLY destroy the worthy red voters of America.

        Those non americans in communist cuba and other counties can buy and pay for their own hurricanes.

    6. nobody who matters Silver badge

      Re: There isn't a hurricane on the way

      "There isn't a hurricane on the way

      Well, that's what I think Mr Fish said."

      That was the gist of what he said, and he was technically correct - the wind speeds didn't reach hurricane force, even though it felt like it to those of us who experienced the weather that night.

  2. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Krasnov

    If you were running the US government on behalf of Russian interests, this is exactly the kind of move you’d make: degrade critical civilian infrastructure, hobble disaster preparedness, and do it under the thinnest bureaucratic excuse possible. Cutting off high-value satellite data during hurricane season, with no replacement and zero transparency, isn’t just negligent - it’s hostile.

    Who benefits when US hurricane forecasts get dumber, slower, and less reliable? Certainly not coastal Americans. But it sure helps anyone looking to showcase US dysfunction, sabotage global climate science cooperation, or stir up domestic chaos after a preventable disaster.

    And what better way to do it than cloaking the decision in "security concerns" while letting aging satellites rot and new ones remain unused - textbook sabotage by omission. The collapse doesn’t need to be loud. It just needs to look like “cost-cutting.”

    1. Eclectic Man Silver badge

      Re: Krasnov

      Who benefits when US hurricane forecasts get dumber, slower, and less reliable?

      Not just US hurricane forecasts, the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasting and other meteorological organisations will have been using data from those satellites too.

      1. Roland6 Silver badge

        Re: Krasnov

        >” the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasting and other meteorological organisations will have been using data from those satellites too.”

        That explains it, “the EU” ripping off America, can’t have that.

        Fortunately, the US funded this via the defense budget… So we in Europe can seize the opportunity and put our own (fully SI units compatible) weather satellite network up and attribute the spend to the increase in our defence budgets.

        I wonder when the US will switch off NAVSTAR…

        1. cookieMonster

          Re: Krasnov

          Interesting….. maybe he’ll order GPS switched off to countries he no longer likes or won’t make a “deal”

          1. veti Silver badge

            Re: Krasnov

            There are at least two working alternatives to GPS already up and running. For precisely that reason.

          2. Charlie Clark Silver badge

            Re: Krasnov

            Even if he doesn't switch them off, simply not replacing them will degrade the service pretty quickly and this has been happening for a few years, because, by being completely free, there's no revenue stream for maintenance, just the government budget. Russia has GLONASS, Europe's Galieo is nearly complete, and I think China has what it needs.

    2. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Krasnov

      What's even crazier is that to a one, all those "coastal" states affected by severe hurricanes in the US vote republican. He's screwing his own people. But as far as the ones in those states who actually did vote for him, I have no sympathy. We tried to warn you what Trump was and you didn't listen. Now you will live (or not) with the consequences of your vote.

      And since he's basically dismantled FEMA they won't get any help after the storm. And once the "big beautiful bill" passes a lot of hospitals in those states that are only kept going via Medicaid funding will be closing so if they get injured they might have a long ambulance ride to take them to the nearest hospital, and be out of pocket for it if they rely on Medicaid but are one of the 16 million who will be dropped to save money for tax cuts for billionaires.

      1. JLV Silver badge

        Re: Krasnov

        And apparently, it's not just those satellites. The regional weather offices in (Rep) places like Tornado Alley? Nah, not really necessary...

        At least he's consistent. Those big cuts in food stamps? Well, they're hitting the poorer states worst, like the Deep South.

        Some seriously whacko thinking all around. At this rate, I wonder what will be left of the Republican party by 2028. Or of the USA. Or of elections.

        1. Thought About IT

          Re: Krasnov

          The way the Supreme Court and Republican politicians are colluding with Trump, I can only conclude that they don't intend to lose the next election - by whatever means necessary!

          1. DS999 Silver badge

            Re: Krasnov

            Sadly I'm coming to the same conclusion.

            If they allow Trump to impose nationwide "citizenship tests" for voting, where the US government is the sole arbiter of who is a "citizen" it will be really easy to strip millions of voters from the rolls. When after the election there's widespread proof of many many citizens being stopped from voting (mysteriously most of them being non-white) it'll be blamed on an unspecified clerical error, but of course there will be no way to correct the bogus results of a "red wave" that give huge republican majorities everywhere. Then in 2028 it will "somehow" happen again, after which the opposition will become disillusioned and realize there is no longer a democracy to save.

            Fortunately for me I'm in a position where if that happens I can leave the US behind and watch Trump burn it down from a safe distance, but it will suck for those who lack that option.

        2. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: Krasnov

          "Those big cuts in food stamps? Well, they're hitting the poorer states worst, like the Deep South."

          The lack of fizzy drinks, salty snacks and candy bars is going to push the unemployed over the edge.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Krasnov

            Fortunately the SNAP changes were eliminated from the BBB.

      2. Zoopy

        Re: Krasnov

        > What's even crazier is that to a one, all those "coastal" states affected by severe hurricanes in the US vote republican.

        Maybe I'm not understanding, but that seems factuality wrong.

        Hurricanes can hit the entire east coast (and Gulf coast) of the US. I'm the 2024 presidential election, about half of those votes against Trump.

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidential_election

        1. JLV Silver badge

          Re: Krasnov

          Yes, but the real hot spots are further South. Inland and going North the wind speeds trend down and you get a lot of rain. But less risk of 250km/h winds.

      3. mcswell

        Re: Krasnov

        Look at the bright side: one of those hurricanes could target Mar-a-Lago!

        1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

          Re: Krasnov

          Unfortunately, Trump would have vacated Mar-a-Lago/Florida to one of his properties further north before hurricane season.

          And, if it does get damaged, he's sure to wrangle state funds for the repairs/rebuild

          1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

            Re: Krasnov

            Yeahbut, without the data , will anyone know it's coming? Or will he just stay away through the entire season? On the other hand, what is the "season"? With a changing climate, the season may change, but he doesn't believe in climate change so might get caught out. And it'll all by Bidens fault :-)

    3. Fred Dibnah

      Re: Krasnov

      ”Who benefits when US hurricane forecasts get dumber, slower, and less reliable?”

      Fox News and Mail Online, to name just two media channels that will have more hurricane disaster material to show.

      1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: Krasnov

        And Boeing. If you are now flying into hurricanes with no weather forecast you are going to increase demand for aircraft

    4. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

      Re: Krasnov

      "or stir up domestic chaos after a preventable disaster."

      ...and after decades of Hollywood "end of the world" and "zombie" movies, everyone now knows exactly how to handle themselves in the aftermath of the devastation. Loot and shoot.

  3. Philo T Farnsworth Silver badge

    Elections matter

    77,302,580 people voted1 for this, whether they knew it or not, and a substantial portion of them are living along the Eastern Seaboard and the Gulf Coast.

    It's a good thing there's no such thing as karma.

    _____________

    1 Wikipedia: 2024 United States presidential election

    1. Eecahmap

      Re: Elections matter

      It's a good thing there's no such thing as karma.

      There is on Reddit. . . .

      If the Buddhists are right, there is karma, but the payoff in this case doesn't come quickly enough.

      1. Philo T Farnsworth Silver badge

        Re: Elections matter

        There is on Reddit. . . .

        Rule 34.1: If it exists, there's a subreddit for it.

        1. KarMann Silver badge
          Holmes

          Re: Elections matter

          That isn't actually very helpful, since the whole question at hand is whether it exists, and that's not an 'if and only if', nor could it realistically be; there are certainly subreddits for things that don't exist.

  4. robert lindsay
    WTF?

    Not as bad as it looks.

    I'm the person who submitted the original links. From further conversations on reddit, it's not coming from the WH or even top of DoD, it more of a "opps" level somewhere down the line. Apparently their are talks to restore the data, as usual its just a matter of finding who pays for it. and with all the money going to the peace shield^W^W golden dome its a mess.

    1. Spamolot

      Re: Not as bad as it looks.

      Obviously the Golden Dome has been upgraded to include the Tornado v.01 and Hurricane v0.05 repentant/mitigation patch so who needs forecasts? Elon and Thiel will keep the Eastern seaboard safe - right!

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Not as bad as it looks.

      Budget related more than likely. Heard a lot of buzzing about folks within crunching budgets down to the last penny since Congress is drooling on itself. Again

  5. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Sharpies at the ready

    Herr Trump is on the case!

    1. Ashentaine

      Re: Sharpies at the ready

      Just mention that this puts Mar-A-Lago at risk of being sunk into the Atlantic, and he'll have a replacement system up and running by the end of next month.

      Actually, might be a useful way to distract him from everything else he's been mucking up so far...

      1. Eclectic Man Silver badge

        Re: Sharpies at the ready

        Check out what happens to Florida after a mere 20 meter sea level rise at: https://www.floodmap.net/#google_vignette

        Of course it will not happen during our lifetimes (I expect).

        1. ITS Retired

          Re: Sharpies at the ready

          At least the not entire 20 meters. Just a few meters would do it.

          1. seven of five Silver badge

            Re: Sharpies at the ready

            As the US aren't metric, this won't affect them!

            /s

        2. JLV Silver badge

          Re: Sharpies at the ready

          Look what happens to Miami at 80cm is more like it. The ground is saturated with water, storm drains work in reverse at high tide and the entire area is, by design, criss-crossed with canals so people can bring their powerboats to their backyards.

          Let's say they build a dike. Great. Now you have a drainage ditch in your backyard and hopefully you moved your flamingo-colored powerboat out to sea before they finished building it. And for those on the actual waterfront, let's just say a dike can be a tad of a bummer.

          But people are still stupid enough to buy there. The funny thing about coastal real estate is how there is a neat little mechanism to look far ahead in time.

          If you buy now, you need to look at 2055 which is your time horizon for your mortgage (low 30 yr lock-in rates with interest tax deductions FTW), when you presumably will be in the market for selling it.

          But your buyers in 2055 will have their own calculations to do, looking at when they can resell. So, 2055+30, meaning 2085.

          As soon as people get the implication of sea level changes timelines vs real estate timelines sentiment could turn rather quickly as demand will drop, marginally at first, faster later. And, yes, individuals can have ideological blinders, that's true: witness the 2024 elections. But banks will soon enough see the implications of financing mortgages for houses that will literally go under water. So will insurers and that's also another mechanism putting anticipatory pressure on real estate.

          The insurance companies are already starting to bite and in De Santis' state of glorious and unfettered capitalism the solution has already been found: mutualizing the risk at taxpayer expense by increasingly bringing in the State of Florida as the insurer of last resort on rich folks' coastal villas.

          1. PB90210 Silver badge

            Re: Sharpies at the ready

            Not to worry, the orange one said...

            "rising sea levels from climate change is a good thing because it'll create more beachfront property."

            1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

              Re: Sharpies at the ready

              Except, of course, it's not "more", it's just in different places. I wonder if the Trump family have large, very cheap land-holdings a little inland as future beachfront investments?

        3. stiine Silver badge
          Facepalm

          Re: Sharpies at the ready

          Not unless you plan on living for 1000 years.

          1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

            Re: Sharpies at the ready

            Some of the tech bros are hoping for that

            1. Dan 55 Silver badge
  6. Andy Tunnah

    What thin skin

    I guess Trump is still angry that the hurricane didn't go where he wanted that time he modified the map, he'll never let it happen again.

    I'm only half joking.

  7. CowHorseFrog Silver badge

    Arent the primary victims of hurricans the same RED voters that love trump ?

    Said it before and will say it again, those red voters wanted to fuck others for a few more dollars and it appears they are the ones being fucked for everything by their glorious leader.

    Talk about karma.

  8. Panicnow

    Alternatively

    The US govt are prioritising the US over RoW, by restricting data to RoW .

    The data can and is used for other purposes, including military intelligence.

    These satellites are obsolete, retiring them was always going to happen.

    1. Spazturtle Silver badge

      Re: Alternatively

      "These satellites are obsolete, retiring them was always going to happen."

      It was also announced that DMSP would be ending by the mid 2020's back in 2019 so I am not sure at the surprise.

      And the replacement program has already started with the first of the new satellites in orbit (Weather System Follow-on Microwave-1).

      1. Jellied Eel Silver badge

        Re: Alternatively

        It was also announced that DMSP would be ending by the mid 2020's back in 2019 so I am not sure at the surprise.

        And the replacement program has already started with the first of the new satellites in orbit (Weather System Follow-on Microwave-1).

        Don't let facts get in the way of all the lefty Trump bashing. But there may have been some suprises-

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Meteorological_Satellite_Program#NOAA_16_and_17

        Like they blew up. Pesky batteries. But interesting because the DMSP birds were typically multi-instrument, not just the AMSU sensors. So also things like Argos DCS-2 that was intended to collect data from the Argo floats and other instruments.

        But it has little to do with El Presidente, and everything to do with budgets. Like DoD funded some, NOAA operated, NASA launched, and multiple data users. And like you say, other instruments are available, both from the US, EU, Japan etc. I think the WSF progam is interesting given it also has the ECP sensor, which could test theories like Svensmark, and any role in charged particles in cloud formation, and thus weather effects.

        (And just for conspiratorial fun, NOAA cancelled AMSU sensors because their data had an annoying habit of contradicting climate models.. )

  9. Version 1.0 Silver badge
    Boffin

    So start using the Windy app

    You can estimate and expect what will happen if you just look at the wind rotations and the overall movement. The Windy app and a lot of other weather apps will help you guess what's likely to happen. But that other side of this is that since "Climate Change" appeared then the original monthly storm environment in the Atlantic has become a lot lower.

    Originally hurricanes appeared multiple times every year and the storms moved into the Gulf, but that's only happened a few times for years now.

    Climate Change is observable, not predictable for years yet, Climate Change is a lot bigger than government intelligence.

  10. Philo T Farnsworth Silver badge

    Just for the record. . .

    The Associated Press reports that the cutoff has been slipped a month. Maybe sense will prevail. Or not.

    See the AP story here.

    Small favors.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like