back to article X marks the drop for European users

Everything is super, over at X (the social media service formerly known as Twitter), which has shed around 10 percent of its European users in the past six months. anti x poster in camden uk An anti X poster in London's Camden Town urges people to ditch their accounts – click to enlarge The figures were revealed in X's …

  1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Online Safety Bill

    This is prime example why this bill is a nothing burger.

    Xitter openly spreads disinformation, terrorist content and other carp.

    UK government> We have the strongest bill in the world, protecting British people from miscreants!!!

    People> Use it then!

    UK government> Ah not like that!

    People> Like what then?

    UK government> Did your aunt say something hurty? We are on it!

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Online Safety Bill

      Whereas Facebook, Insta and other sites also post misinformation, but as long as it’s about white people not “minorities” (when white people globally are a minority despite what government would have you think), that’s fine.

      Two tier moderation, just like British policing nowadays!

  2. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

    Just wanted to delete my account

    Oh, it has already been deleted! Looks like i did not pay enough - let alone use it enough before. Problem solved on its own!

    1. neilg
      Facepalm

      Re: Just wanted to delete my account

      Same here.

      Think I'll go and make models of matchsticks from bits of the Taj Mahal..

      Thanks Python

    2. Uncle Slacky Silver badge

      Re: Just wanted to delete my account

      I deliberately got myself suspended instead (by publishing Stonetoss' real name - Hans Kristian Graebener, of Spring TX, btw).

      1. beast666 Silver badge

        Re: Just wanted to delete my account

        How stunning.

        How brave.

        1. Uncle Slacky Silver badge

          Re: Just wanted to delete my account

          Found the nazi.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Just wanted to delete my account

            TIL that pointing out slacktivism is an objective indicator of fascism.

        2. Casca Silver badge

          Re: Just wanted to delete my account

          Good right wing moron. Have a cookie.

      2. Grunchy Silver badge

        Re: Just wanted to delete my account

        Whatsa Stonetoss, is that somebody? I never heard of the person.

        (I resisted twitter for YEARS because it's a bunch of "twits", then set up an account so I could communicate with these nice folks who used to own an iPhone that they left in a e-recycling bin, and left their twitter details on the phone, and HOUNDED them online until they "released the iPhone", and then the account stagnated for a couple more years, and then Musk threatened to buy the twitter and I was like "THAT's ball game!" and I've been outta there since like, before or whenever.)

        I still have the iPhone, it's grand! I think it was all worth it. Good experience.

        1. Jedit Silver badge
          Boffin

          "Whatsa Stonetoss, is that somebody?"

          Stonetoss is a cartoonist who uses a meme style so people who share memes will share his cartoons. Some of his cartoons are perfectly innocent and can even be funny from time to time, but the intent of them is as a gateway to get people looking for more of his work. If you do, you'll find that most of his output is full on Nazi.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: "Whatsa Stonetoss, is that somebody?"

            Stonetoss is a cartoonist ...most of his output is full on Nazi.

            Here I was imagining it was a chap getting his jollies pulling on his rock.... apparently pretty much on the money.

    3. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Just wanted to delete my account

      I know I’ll get downvoted for this but I for one really miss Twitter.

      I had joined Twitter years ago because it was one of the best online sources for learning about computer security and forensics.

      It was a who’s who of well known and respected security researchers that were very friendly and willing to answer questions and share tips and techniques and also freely shared scripts and programs they created to help reverse engineer malware and malicious obfuscated JavaScript.

      We would collaborate on creating Yara rules to detect the latest threats and even got NameCheap to turn over a new leaf and they would take down a malicious site just by tagging them in a tweet that showed what the site was up to.

      No more long and tedious online abuse forms to fill out.

      I left before Elon destroyed Twitter and I had never experienced any of the racism or politicized crap that I heard he turned it into.

      And now all I experience is watching him and his leader destroy my country.

      I was much happier back then.

  3. IGotOut Silver badge

    Keep it up...

    What really need is our politicians to grow some.

    If every single European politician, government department and public funded body moved to Blue sky, dumping Twitter, that would send a huge message.

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      Re: Keep it up...

      Well, you're right... I'm not someone important, but created an account now.

      1. EricB123 Silver badge

        Re: Keep it up...

        Ah, a fellow pawn!

    2. Handlebars

      Re: Keep it up...

      I'd like them to just run their own websites, with RSS if they really think a notification system is needed.

    3. MachDiamond Silver badge

      Re: Keep it up...

      "If every single European politician, government department and public funded body moved to Blue sky, dumping Twitter, that would send a huge message."

      They've all been advised that they need to be present on all Social Media. So they have accounts and some have staff to monitor them, file complaints against other users and petition the companies to delete posts/comments they find detrimental to their remaining in office/being re-elected.

      I question why they believe the must have SM accounts. The most prominent can have a simple blog site that they control and can do anything they want with and rest assured that whatever they post will be copy/pasted everyplace else for them.

    4. Charlie Clark Silver badge

      Re: Keep it up...

      Why the need for a single privately owned service? This is just what Silicon Valley loves.

      There are plenty of services out there for official communication, cherry-picking only one is the greatest disservice to citizens.

      1. MachDiamond Silver badge

        Re: Keep it up...

        "There are plenty of services out there for official communication"

        Official communications should never be communicated through only social media. Companies and governments should have a means to post via their own web sites and refer to that as "official" with any social media posts as "supplemental". SM companies can edit, truncate, delete, strip links or hold postings at their discretion. Who wants access to official government information controlled by gatekeeper Musk or some blue-haired activist moderator?

    5. Simon M

      Re: Keep it up...

      Blue Sky isn't the answer.

      Europe political class were complicit in the uptake of the US hosted social media platforms. (Allowing government departments and state media to advertise Facebook and Twitter for free, "Follow us on Twitter")

      If European politicians want to promote commercial businesses for free, particularly those with the power to spread mass propaganda, I'd really hope those businesses were European and subject to European law in full.

      1. Uncle Slacky Silver badge
        Thumb Up

        Re: Keep it up...

        Agreed, they should be using Mastodon instead (via instances they own/control).

    6. ChrisElvidge Silver badge

      Re: Keep it up...

      Add in our august media organs, too - looking at you Reg!

  4. ComputerSays_noAbsolutelyNo Silver badge
    Thumb Up

    Nicely done

    TheReg demonstrates a real world example for the use of AI in corporations that is actually good, well, not shit.

    Instead of getting newspeak responses from corporate PR people, Grok tell it how it is ... until that gets enshittified away.

    But right now, definitely in improvement over the shit emoji auto-reply.

  5. DS999 Silver badge

    10% down, 90% to go

    They won't ever ALL leave, because you have your own small infestation of right wing nutjobs, but all organizations should leave it behind. There's zero reason for the Euro press for instance to be supporting Musk. Those of you who live there and pay for subscriptions should check and see if they're on Twitter and tell them you want to them to leave Twitter or you'll reconsider your subscription. And press your governments to drop Twitter too.

    Musk may have a favorability rating in the 30s here in the US still, but I have to think that it is a fraction of that in the EU since his extreme right wing views and nazi salutes have to be a much bigger problem with the typical EU citizen than they are in the much further right and more racist US.

    1. disgruntled yank

      Re: 10% down, 90% to go

      >> the much further right and more racist US

      Much further right, so far.

      More racist? I would never claim that the US is great on racial stuff, but it has worked on this and made changes over the last 70 years. I have limited experience of Europe (and all of it as a white guy). But I'd be interested to hear how (for example) the descendants of the Windrush would grade the UK, or immigrants from Francophone Africa would grade France.

      1. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

        Re: 10% down, 90% to go

        disgruntled yank,

        Back when we were in the EU - the UK regularly came top of the Commissions annual survey of least racist places to live. Not that we don't have racism here, but the UK is probably one of the least racist places around. On this we even beat the Scandinavians, who are the perennial class goody-two-shoes - for having the best social services, education, and being the happiest as well - the total bastards!

      2. DS999 Silver badge

        Re: 10% down, 90% to go

        I'd be interested to hear how (for example) the descendants of the Windrush would grade the UK, or immigrants from Francophone Africa would grade France

        A whole lot better than brown people would rate the US since Trump's ICE was unleashed to live out their darkest jackboot fantasies, that's for sure!

  6. mark l 2 Silver badge

    It sounds like Grok needs a bit of an update on what Elon has been up to since it seems to be unaware of him endorsing Trump, the Nazi salute, him hoovering up all the data from government depts in his new job as unelected US prime minister as other potential reasons why people are leaving Twitter.

    1. veti Silver badge

      It wasn't asked "What has Elon Musk done lately?", it was asked "why are Europeans leaving X?".

  7. trevorde Silver badge

    Updated Grok response

    "Why are Europeans leaving X"

    People who leave X are LOONY LEFT LOSERS! Truth Social is the BEST social network EVER. FACT! We are going to post some BIGLY numbers when covfefe

    -- Donald J Trump, President

  8. Grindslow_knoll

    Bsky

    Is Bluesky that much better?

    I liked mastodon's virtual village model where each instance serves as a self-regulating community and no algorithmic skewing, is bluesky similar?

    1. hedgie

      Re: Bsky

      I don't actually know, haven't touched it, myself. My ex (whose opinion I tend to respect) recommended it to me, at least in terms of something to read to see what people were actually saying.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Bsky

      Mastodon has "villages" that are filled with extremists who are the other cheek of the same arse. There's still villages full of idiots.

    3. MONK_DUCK

      Re: Bsky

      Well so far on bluesky I've not seen regular posts from user accounts saying, exactly what they thought should happen to non-whites, women and lgbtq people. From that prospective it does feel very different.

  9. Charlie Clark Silver badge
    Stop

    The decline started earlier

    Twitter was always a company with an "eventually we'll come up with a business model" strategy. Good marketing to its main users – lazy journalists – saw it become popular for celebrities, subsequently followed by politicians craving publicity, but never with a convincing business case and caught between the Silicon Valley, or perhaps more specifically San Francisco, bubble and the real world. It had great user numbers but no good way of making money from them. Moderation kept the most active engaged and companies looking to advertise their brand, but came with high personnel costs. Then along came the SAFA, and I think I'm using the term correctly here, narcissist, who wanted to be king of the dump. He certainly cut costs, but removing moderation encouraged long-standing users to leave and many advertisers left, not to return because creating a positive brand image is difficult in a torrent of hate speech.

    But the biggest problem was maintaining a value proposition in a changing market. From the start it was susceptible to bots and I'm proud to know my port of ifyoulikeitsomuchwhydontyoulivethere.com to a bot is still in existence, though inactive since it switched to OAuth! Evgeny Morozov amongst others highlighed the problems with echo chambers on social media, but Facebook then Instagram then TikTok and others found ways to swallow their conscience and earn lots of money anyway. But Twitter stayed pretty much as it was, remaining the darling of the chatterati but failing to attract the right kind of advertisers to pay for them. Even the laziest journalistst got the hint and started quoting from other services: Mastodon, Bluesky, Telegram, et al. It's going to be folded in Musk's AI business but this is now for PR purposes – I mean which self-respecting LLM wants to be based on content that has been largely machine produced for over a decade?

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I’d leave too

    But I’ve never signed up.

    Shame.

    Maybe Europeans just have a bit of a problem with literal Nazis.

    Good for them.

  11. Jedit Silver badge
    Headmaster

    "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

    More than that - Musk has been focusing Tesla on the Cybertruck. That's been a millstone round the company's neck in Europe and the UK because due to various factors of the design, it's illegal to have one on the road in those regions.

    1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

      Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

      Meanwhile BYDs promises 2000km range and less than 2.5l/100km in its new compact hybrids. For less than € 20,000.

      1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

        Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

        Sound more legit than FSD from T.

      2. MachDiamond Silver badge

        Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

        "Meanwhile BYDs promises 2000km range and less than 2.5l/100km in its new compact hybrids."

        I suppose if you live really far away from a petrol station, having that much range could be useful. Even on a really long trip, I'd have to stop for a pee long before needing to fill up. Several times in fact.

        1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

          Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

          The range is a consequence of the increased fuel efficiency.

          1. MachDiamond Silver badge

            Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

            "The range is a consequence of the increased fuel efficiency."

            Yes, but it also implies a larger fuel tank. A larger fuel tank is heavier (heavier still when full), takes up more space and drags down that efficiency. The competition cars have wee petrol tanks that have been optimized down to minimums. A bit crazy for a daily driver, but there isn't much real world return on having more range past a certain point. Most ICEV's are in the 400mi category. That's a once per week fill up for the bulk of people and 6-7 hours of highway driving with a bit of margin on a long haul. 4-5 hours starts pushing the iron-bladder class and it's roughly the usual time between feeds. I tend to plan my stops to eat, refuel and pump bilges for really long trips. As the years go on, I stop for my comfort more often. I'm also not doing cannonball runs where I try to get from point to point as fast as possible. Flying is at least half a day and often close to a full day so any driving trip that's longer than that with no other goal than A to B is something of a waste.

            1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

              Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

              No, it's from the efficiency of the engine, which is around 43%, this is how you get the lower litre/100 km (= higher MPG) using a standard tank. This is done using very high compression and higher RPM.

              For me, it's not about how far I can travel without stopping for fuel on a single trip – our current car does around 1000km which is more than enough for any single day – but on how often we have to fuel at all. Cars like that suggested by BYD would mean filling maybe only once a month, or possibly only once every two months if we get a wallbox fitted.

              I was looking for the original video where I saw the details, but I couldn't find it quickly and it took a long time to make its points. As I said, let's see what they really offer.

      3. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

        “BYDs promises 2000km range“

        That’s some claim. Science says they’re bullshitting.

        1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

          Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

          I think it's right to be sceptical, and the compact is so far only available in China, but the tech is already in an SUV:

          https://bydautomotive.com.au/sealion-6

          As for the science, I think it's certainly possible by pushing this kind of design – as I've been arguing myself for a while – by optimising the petrol engine for the electric drive train and improving the batteries. In the real world, I don't think it matters whether you really get 2000 km, but 1500 km would really put the pressure on existing manufacturers, who have too often focussed on upmarket guzzlers for their EVs.

      4. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: "This may also be because Tesla's vehicle lineup looks a little stale"

        2000km range LMFAO - not on your life. Was that what the TEMU ad said ;)

  12. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Surprised that so many European were still on Xitter

    106m in 2024 which out of EU pop. of 449m which is roughly 22% which even adding the oddities of Norway and Switzerland or multiple accounts for both natural persons and corporations is rather high. Even adding the ex-EU UK only brings that down to 20%.

    The ~10% drop in both "active recipients" and signed in accounts seem to correlate.

    I don't imagine the Europeans (and incidentally many Commonwealth citizens) are too amused by Musk's fascists antics and the hard core fascists infesting X, the hectares of war graves and cenotaphs bear testimony of the dreadful cost of previously having to deal with this abomination.

    Perhaps boycotting corporations and organisations that still use X to communicate with their clients might hasten the demise of the platform.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like