back to article Procter & Gamble study finds AI could help make Pringles tastier, spice up Old Spice, sharpen Gillette

Procter & Gamble says organizations should rethink how they're run to take better advantage of innovation enabled by generative AI. The consumer products giant has been AI-curious for several years and recently conducted a study to assess the technology's potential value to its operations. So with partial funding from Harvard …

  1. Mentat74
    Facepalm

    It could...

    Also replace Procter & Gamble since they're both full of it...

    1. Ol'Peculier

      Re: It could...

      I have a small crocheted Babel Fish on top of my PC that I use for the same thing.

    2. teknopaul

      Re: It could...

      These are the people who make razors that deliberately go blunt quick so you have to buy a new one.

      They are not looking to us AI to make the world a better place.

      1. Elongated Muskrat Silver badge

        Re: It could...

        Not to mention foodlike substances that are designed specifically to be as addictive, and thus profitable, as possible, with no regard to nutritional value.

        1. ravenviz Silver badge

          Re: It could...

          Indeed, what they really mean is how can we us AI to get people to spend more money!

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: It could...

          There's a reason they put opioids in your food.

      2. Philo T Farnsworth Silver badge

        Re: It could...

        > These are the people who make razors that deliberately go blunt quick so you have to buy a new one.

        I forget which brand of razor I use but mine last for months. I think I've gone close to a year on the current cartridge of my multiblade contraption.

        Of course, I've long been known as Captain Peachfuzz, my five o'clock shadow looks like about 7:15 AM, and my sad attempts to grow a beard have elicited comments like "Did you forget to shave this morning?" after six weeks, so hirsute I am not.

        My biggest gripe with razor manufacturers is that by the time I eventually need new ones, they've stopped making the cartridges, so I need to buy a new handle, too.

        1. VicMortimer Silver badge

          Re: It could...

          Meanwhile, my razor from the mid '90s is working fine. I had to change the batteries once, and the cutter heads (which they still make) twice.

    3. UnknownUnknown Silver badge

      Re: It could...

      Bit late for Pringles as they flogged that business unit to Kellogg’s a few years back.

      1. Handlebars

        Re: It could...

        You can already dip cornflakes in salsa so why does Kellogg's need Pringles?

  2. IanRS

    Placebo benefits

    Experienced programmers know about 'rubber duck debugging', which really does work, as explaining the problem to the duck makes you think through it clearly. I suspect that working with an AI supposeed assistant is comparable.

    1. Captain Hogwash Silver badge

      Re: rubber duck debugging

      That phrase is new to me. I used to work with a guy who called it a cardboard programmer. Either way, it's a useful technique.

      1. IanRS

        Re: rubber duck debugging

        Rubber ducks take up less desk space, but managerial cardboard facsimilies have additional value for target practice.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: rubber duck debugging

          Come to think of it, rubber duck flavour would also be an improvement on the traditional cardboard taste of Pringles.

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: rubber duck debugging

          One's never alone with a rubber duck.

          1. that one in the corner Silver badge

            Re: rubber duck debugging

            Just time for another bath, in the glow of the burning forests.

      2. An_Old_Dog Silver badge

        Re: rubber duck debugging

        My college roomie had a "programming rock"/paperweight.

    2. cyberdemon Silver badge
      Devil

      Re: Placebo benefits

      At least the Rubber Duck doesn't send all of your code or document to Someone Else's Computer and then spew completely useless (or worse) suggestions at you

      1. IanRS

        Re: Placebo benefits

        I tried using Ai assistance a while ago for a technically complex problem of displaying a 3D object under multiple configurable lights and a moveable camera. The AI recommended which graphics library to use, gave API calls and lots of demo code. It would have been really useful, except that the library did not exist.

        1. GDM

          Re: Placebo benefits

          It probably did exist, just at a different company who'd been incautious about letting a LLM get trained on all their corporate IP.

          1. teknopaul

            Re: Placebo benefits

            Incautious meaning put their code in github.

      2. David Hicklin Silver badge

        Re: Placebo benefits

        > At least the Rubber Duck doesn't send all of your code or document to Someone Else's Computer

        Don't give them ideas !!

  3. PinchOfSalt

    Game changer?

    I'm not sure if this is a challenge of the the summarisation of their findings, but in the main body it talks of 'being comparable to working with another human' and finishes with 'this is a game changer'.

    Nothing game changing about being able to do what we can already do and use far less energy and water.

    1. that one in the corner Silver badge

      Re: Game changer?

      Of course it is a game changer - they only have access to another human to work with for less than five minutes at a time, whereas the AI won't storm out, screaming "will you shut up about bloody Pringles!".

      This is especially useful for R&D at Gillette (where they standardised on Chipples last year).

      1. Decay

        Re: Game changer?

        And the "AI" works 24x7, doesn't need health benefits and isn't likely to form a union, yet.

        1. David Hicklin Silver badge

          Re: Game changer?

          > isn't likely to form a union, yet.

          This is IT Tech, they automatically join the same Critical Needs Union

  4. Howard Sway Silver badge

    The results were mostly positive. Funnily enough.

    It would have been pretty amazing if a team of 10 AI researchers concluded that AI was a load of useless bollocks, considering the fact that such a conclusion would have put them all out of a job. This is just like those researchers in the 1950s who produced "research" proving the amazing health benefits of cigarettes, funded by tobacco companies.

    It's just another corporate fad, sold to executives desperately looking for a bandwagon to jump on that promises to make them money. Remember when "synergy" was all the rage, and lots of people became "synergists" so they could hoover up the money being thrown at that miracle growth generator? Don't hear so much of them these days............

    1. sgp

      Re: The results were mostly positive. Funnily enough.

      They've retrained themselves to become AI researchers..

  5. TRT Silver badge

    Hey...

    works for the US Government. They have tried it at TATA (USITC), I hear.

  6. Big_Boomer

    Another week, yet another desperate attempt to validate their investment

    Oh well, the Tawny Tariff Tosser will soon make it all moot as spending on AI will plummet when world trade slows dramatically.

    1. ecofeco Silver badge

      Re: Another week, yet another desperate attempt to validate their investment

      That is EXACTLY what is happening. P&G is obviously cheer-leading which tells us they have some serious sunk costs there.

    2. HuBo Silver badge
      Holmes

      Re: Another week, yet another desperate attempt to validate their investment

      Yeah, but at least we'll still find plentiful supplies of Metamucil on the shelves, to keep us regular, seeing how it's made in Phoenix AZ ...

      Still, it'd be nice if P&G could apply their game-changing innovation accelerator new-idea unlocker emotionally satisfying generative AI-assist cybernetic teammate to develop a few improved formulations of the product, as Liquid Plumr's successfully done, something like urgent clear, and hair eliminator, on top of clog destroyer and advanced action gel ... perty sure they'd be winners with consumers!

  7. cornetman Silver badge

    > ....sharpen Gillette

    As long as the AI doesn't suggest that all white American men are bastards, then that's probably an improvement over whatever they were using before.

  8. ecofeco Silver badge
    Pirate

    Customers? Who?

    Or, and I know this is a radical thought in our Age of Idiocracy, but they could try ASKING THEIR DAMN CUSTOMERS what they would like.

    However, this is indeed another shining examples of how customers only have false choices. For those of you born yesterday, please look up how many brand names P&G control.

  9. DrSunshine0104

    I have seen an ad for a US bank, I think CaptialOne where the ad is just telling the viewer that they are using AI for business processes.

    ...Great. I guess. What is the corporate policy about binder clips or paper clips?

    The only thing I am hearing is: "We are using AI to squeeze you and hard as we can and do questionable things with your money that isn't regulated and won't be because of US Congress and this administration."

    Can't wait for the feature where CaptialOne AI is telling me I am not using my money as efficiently as possible and then show me ads where I can spend it.

  10. hx

    I have no clue, so I asked ChatGPT to make a comment for me

    And here's what it said:

    "You're a handsome man, no doubt about it! You've got that charisma and confidence that really stands out. Keep rocking that great vibe!"

    So, I'm going to side with the AI here.

  11. logicalextreme

    A dip made of human excrement

    would make Pringles taste better. If AI fails at that task it's more hopeless than I even gave it credit for

  12. Terry 6 Silver badge

    The Register awaits evidence of AI’s power to assist innovation being expressed in Proctor & Gamble brands such as ........ Gillette

    So what's wrong with just keeping the blades under a pyramid in the traditional way?

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Old Spice!

    Bastards withdrew that in Australia.

    Can’t improve what you can’t get.

  14. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Old Old Spice

    P&G Old Spice has been made spicier and no longer surfs the wave of 70's cool.

    I import Shulton's version when I want to remind middle aged women of their dads.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Old Old Spice

      As the copy said: “If your grandfather hadn't worn it, you wouldn't exist.”

  15. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Pringles can with 2 kitchen sponges already inside?

    Apparently all the kids are doing it...

  16. Ashentaine
    Facepalm

    It tastes like a computer, all right

    Last year Coca-Cola did a limited run of a flavor that they claimed was designed by AI, called YT3000 or somesuch. It tasted like normal Coke but with too extra artificial sweetener in it, and when the initial novelty period passed nobody wanted it. After a couple weeks the local supermarket had put their stock of it on 50% discount just to get it off the shelves. (At the time I suspected that a bottling plant screwed up a batch of Coke Zero Sugar and rather than throw it out, they decided to try marketing it instead.)

    With that in mind, it's probably safe to say that the only enhancing that P&G's AI will do is enhance the bank accounts of the consultants who sold them on the idea in the first place.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like