back to article European Space Agency to measure Earth at millimeter scale

The European Space Agency has committed €76.6 million ($83 million) toward the development of Genesis – a flying observatory that will provide positioning services accurate to a single millimeter. The cash is roughly one third of the €233 million ($253 million) awarded for contracts related to position calculating satellite …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    It seems

    the search for Brexit benefits continues.

    1. werdsmith Silver badge

      Re: It seems

      Fortunately, UK is still a full member of ESA. Boris didn't manage to screw that one up.

      Contributing around 9% of ESA budget, the fourth biggest contributor of the full member states.

      ECSAT at Harwell is an ESA facility that must be involved in this project.

    2. TheSirFin

      Re: It seems

      1000 Thumbs for this one!

      And despite all the new accuracy .. they still won't find any.

      Cant find anything that doesn't exist!

  2. Christoph

    What are they using as their zero point?

    Plate Tectonics and weathering move places on the Earth by more than 1mm a year relative to each other.

    Presumably they have their grid's origin defined as one particular point and measure movement relative to that?

    Does anyone know what that point will be?

    1. Oh Matron!

      Re: What are they using as their zero point?

      Greenland.Has stayed pretty much where it's currently at for a LONG time. Before the splitting of the atlantic, Scotland (north of Inverness) was connected to greenland until the splitting of the atlantic. However, south of carlisle was once 60 degrees south of the equator! Cornwall: well, that's another story. But, the north american plate is relatively stable

      1. Paul Kinsler

        Re: Greenland.Has stayed pretty much where it's currently at for a LONG time

        Where it is ... with respect to what?

        1. Oh Matron!

          Re: Greenland.Has stayed pretty much where it's currently at for a LONG time

          everything. Poles (grid), latitude, longitude

          1. werdsmith Silver badge

            Re: Greenland.Has stayed pretty much where it's currently at for a LONG time

            Poles don't stay still and if lat and long are relative to Greenwich, then neither do they.

            1. LogicGate Silver badge

              Re: Greenland.Has stayed pretty much where it's currently at for a LONG time

              The geographic Poles remains fixed.

              Magnetic poles and poles that specialize in plumbing etc. tend to move around over time.

              1. werdsmith Silver badge

                Re: Greenland.Has stayed pretty much where it's currently at for a LONG time

                If we take the definition of the poles as the point that the Earth's spin axis meets its surface, then these don't stay still either.

    2. jmch Silver badge

      Re: What are they using as their zero point?

      It doesn't matter really, same as picking the Greenwhich meridian as the reference point for other longitudes. As long as they pick a point and stick with it

      1. Eclectic Man Silver badge

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        Shirley the problem with that is Greenwich (and everywhere else) is slowly changing latitude, altitude and orientation compared to the rest of the world's land masses. Greenland may have stayed mostly in the same latitude and orientation for millions of years. Land heaves for ,millennia after the removal of ice sheets from the last ice-age, sea levels a re rising, volcanic eruptions in South America are correlated with the amount of snowfall in winter, and, of course, the axis of rotation of the Earth wobbles.

        1. Fr. Ted Crilly Silver badge

          Re: What are they using as their zero point?

          Isostatic recoil is the term you are after.

        2. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          Re: What are they using as their zero point?

          >Shirley the problem with that is Greenwich (and everywhere else) is slowly changing latitude, altitude and orientation compared to the rest of the world's land masses.

          No, the rest of the world may move relative to Greenwich - but that's their problem

          Interesting though, Greenwich was the reference because the telescope was built on the meridian (or rather the meridian was the axis of the telescope). now you have to combine the various meridian telescopes all around the world all on different continental plates - so solving their relative locations to each other to within mm is interesting.

          1. ldo

            Re: Greenwich was the reference

            Not since the international adoption of WGS-84. The 0° longitude now passes across a road about 100m east of the Observatory.

    3. Julz

      Re: What are they using as their zero point?

      The ground heaves by more than a mm due to day/night thermal differences. Not to mention the moon dragging a bulge of many mm around after it.

      1. Vometia has insomnia. Again.

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        Oo-er missus!

      2. Oh Matron!

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        Cornwall rises twice a day because of the weight of the oceon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCA0II1sVZA

        1. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

          Re: What are they using as their zero point?

          Fortunately it also falls twice a day.

          1. sitta_europea Silver badge

            Re: What are they using as their zero point?

            "Fortunately ..."

            Well it depends how you look at it. Once I moored a yacht on the Cornish side of the Tamar. Never again.

        2. Rattus
          Joke

          Cornwall rises twice a day because of the weight of the oceon

          Well if Ernesettle goes up Cornwall will (A) gain independence from the rest of the UK and (B) enter orbit....

    4. Dr. G. Freeman

      Re: What are they using as their zero point?

      From the ESA Genesis Device website...

      "Fix a satellite’s own position in space accurately enough and you can measure Earth beneath it much more precisely too. To achieve this goal down to millimetre level, ESA’s GENESIS satellite will combine and co-locate the four reference existing ‘geodetic’ – or Earth-measuring – techniques on a single platform for the first time. "

      So using the satellite itself as zero point, and measuring relative to that.

      1. Jellied Eel Silver badge

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        So using the satellite itself as zero point, and measuring relative to that.

        Presumably if it were needed, existing surveying techniques could provide reference markers anyway to cross-check or calibrate? Survey markers already exist and can be fun to find while hiking. Or on Google Earth, finding other satellite calibration markers. Sounds like a fun project though with a lot of potential, even if it won't immediately give me a 1mm resolution DTED model of the Earth's surface.

      2. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        "To achieve this goal down to millimetre level,"

        Note spelling.

      3. herman Silver badge

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        So the satellite is super glued to heaven?

    5. vtcodger Silver badge

      Re: What are they using as their zero point?

      If I recall correctly -- and remember the early sixties were six long decades ago -- the USAF back then anchored their 3D cartesian coordinate system for tracking satellites to the ecliptic plane and something from astronomy called the First Point of Aires which I won't attempt to describe. (Look it up if you are curious) Anyway, I think that'd likely work fine for a fixed, reproducible coordinate system independent of slightly motile earthly landmarks.

      1. sitta_europea Silver badge

        Re: What are they using as their zero point?

        "... something from astronomy called the First Point of Aires which I won't attempt to describe."

        Simple. It's where the sun is at the vernal equinox. As it happenss, right about now. But it's really only any use for angles for navigation - not for 3-D positions.

        1. Spherical Cow Silver badge

          Re: What are they using as their zero point?

          "Simple. It's where the sun is at the vernal equinox. As it happenss, right about now."

          Are you sure about the vernal equinox? Where I live, yesterday was the autumnal equinox ;-)

          1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

            Re: What are they using as their zero point?

            Verne equinox is when the sun leaves the southern hemisphere for the north.

            Frankly it seems unfair of the south to hang onto the sun all winter when we could really use it

        2. vtcodger Silver badge

          Re: What are they using as their zero point?

          "It's where the sun is at the vernal equinox. As it happenss, right about now. But it's really only any use for angles for navigation - not for 3-D positions."

          Right and not so right.. Right in that it's the point on the (imaginary) celestial sphere where the sun (apparently) is located when the celestial equator's tilt with regard to the ecliptic plane is zero and the sun is (apparently) moving from South to North. And right that it was defined millennia ago because you need a fixed reference to do celestial navigation (as well as, I think, astrology). Not so right in that the line from the Earth's Center to the FPA is a perfectly OK 3rd element required to anchor an 3D coordinate system based on the Earth's Center and the ecliptic plane. What else would you use that would be any better? And maybe it simplifies conversion between Cartesian and spherical coordinates based on the Celestial sphere if that's necessary which it very likely is at times.

          See Wikipedia for a probably clearer description of the first points of Aires and Libra

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_point_of_Aries

  3. mickaroo

    But Does It Terraform?

    Genesis device: I see what you did there.

    - Khan Noonien Singh.

    1. Pascal Monett Silver badge
      Trollface

      "the Genesis device"

      Now say that in Evil Dictator Mode . . .

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    positioning services accurate to a single millimeter

    helpful for eliminating free radicals.

  5. Christopher Reeve's Horse
    Thumb Up

    W24W

    I'm already looking forward to being able to use 'What 24 Words' to precisely geolocate things

  6. Giles C Silver badge

    Obligatory xkcd

    https://xkcd.com/2170/

    1. anthonyhegedus Silver badge

      Re: Obligatory xkcd

      Maybe this new ESA initiative is actually for a sat nav for spiders.

  7. TheSirFin

    Good .. but Lisa is going to be even better!

    I think this accuracy is a taste of things to come.

    https://www.theregister.com/2024/01/29/esa_lisa_experiment/

    "" The plan is to send three spacecraft, trailing the Earth as it orbits the Sun, forming a highly accurate equilateral triangle in space. Each side will be 2.5 million kilometers long, and the spacecraft will exchange laser beams over the distance.....This is where those laser beams come in. By firing beams from one spacecraft to another, scientists can determine changes in masses' distances down to a few billionths of a millimeter.""

    A few billionths of a millimeter of a distance of 2.5 million KMs .....

    What a cool mission to be part of.

    1. Jellied Eel Silver badge

      Re: Good .. but Lisa is going to be even better!

      What a cool mission to be part of.

      I dunno, I'm starting to worry about Phase 2 when the remaining two satellites are launched, and the triangle becomes a pentagram. With us in the middle. Didn't there used to be an overlords icon?

  8. sitta_europea Silver badge

    "...while 20cm resolution is fairly accurate as a measurement of Earth, a single millimeter is quite a lot more so."

    An article in the 'Science' section about measurements really ought to demonstrate a better grasp of the distinction between resolution and accuracy.

  9. Nameless Dread

    Geoid, anybody ?

    Any mention of the Geoid?

    My so-called smartphone disagrees with my hand-held GPS receiver to the tune of 50 - 60 cm altitude.

    The latter agrees more closely with the Ordnance Survey maps (sea-level based, and I'm in Central Scotland.)

    Perhaps this hyper-accurate system reports the distance to the earth's Centre of Gravity ...

    1. herman Silver badge

      Re: Geoid, anybody ?

      In the middle of Abu Dhabi, where you can see the sea way down the hill in front of you, GPS typically indicates 13 meters below sea level.

      1. Spherical Cow Silver badge

        Re: Geoid, anybody ?

        Earth is an oblate spheroid!

        (I'm not oblate).

      2. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: Geoid, anybody ?

        That's because you get a lot of sponges living in the Persian Gulf

  10. Nameless Dread

    Geoid, anybody ? -Correction

    Missed the edit window ...

    I should have written ' ... 50 - 60 metres altitude..' (difference between smartphone and real GPS receiver which corrects for Geode shape).

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like