back to article Sunak's defunct SaaS scheme spent seven percent of budget designed to help 100,000 SMEs

A local software subsidy scheme launched by UK PM Rishi Sunak, designed to help struggling small businesses following the pandemic, has spent less than seven percent of its £300 million budget. After last week's Spring Budget, officials from the Department for Business and Trade said initial analysis of the Help to Grow: …

  1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Hot Air

    I wonder if this was even consulted with struggling businesses.

    As usual with Sunk, this seems to have been just another hot air tick the box feel good deliver nothing policy.

    Someone who has designed it has no idea about what SMEs are struggling with.

    1. AMBxx Silver badge

      Re: Hot Air

      On the plus side, they can just piss it away on the extension of the NHS app.

  2. jdiebdhidbsusbvwbsidnsoskebid Silver badge

    It was just accounting software, big deal?

    From what I recall, the scheme was just about accounting software and similar generic business management stuff. It didn't include software and services that enabled anyone to actually do science and engineering.

    If I were more cynical, if say it was a scheme by the government to help SMEs correctly pay their taxes to the treasury, not to actually conduct or grow their business.

    1. AMBxx Silver badge

      Re: It was just accounting software, big deal?

      Probably find that the voucher covered what would normally be the free initial period!

      1. simonlb Silver badge

        Re: It was just accounting software, big deal?

        The voucher was probably like a Groupon one where the actual terms for redeeming it are highly restrictive and therefore useless to 97% of the target audience.

  3. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    One for the how not to text books

    It was a text book mess. The consultation was pretty much just a refusal to listen , often delegated to subcontractors with no interest in the main issues or overall design. ‘We’re doing the UI can we talk to some of your disabled people’. Literal quote. I suspect someone in HMT announced a voucher scheme and the Dept was happy as that meant they had control of the budget.

    We had central government civil servants deciding what sort of software SMES should buy. The voucher was claimed by the vendor and just competed with vendor discounting and was not a level playing field and restricted SME choice. The combination of obfuscated, random and high eligibility that required pre application by the vendor and then a protracted process to claim the voucher just was not worth it to the vendor. Value added resellers who have the actual experience to help SMEs were excluded and if the vendor used VARs they could not claim either. It only supported online retail basically. No implementation help or support was covered.

    Give the support directly to the SMEs preferably via a nudge supertax credit and include skills and training as well.

    The only thing they got right was that it should included SaaS so was opex not capex.

    1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

      Re: One for the how not to text books

      People need to understand that strong SMEs are not in the interest of far-right.

      Tories create a façade, an impression that they are on the side of SMEs, but that is only to get votes of the gullible.

      It is the same playbook the Nazi party used to gain votes of workers, small and medium businesses only to have them shafted.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: One for the how not to text books

        This was just a classic bureaucratic cock up

        1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

          Re: One for the how not to text books

          Once maybe. But there is a pattern of behaviour that you cannot attribute to incompetence.

          1. Sam not the Viking Silver badge

            Re: One for the how not to text books

            You need to provide evidence when you imply there is a department which might be displaying competence.

            I think it is all attributable to incompetence.

            1. LyingMan

              Re: One for the how not to text books

              They have abundant incompetence but that's eclipsed by corruption

          2. Ken Hagan Gold badge

            Re: One for the how not to text books

            Surely incompetence is exactly what leads to a pattern of behaviour? Or did you believe them when they said "Lessons will be learned."?

    2. Roj Blake Silver badge

      Re: One for the how not to text books

      Were Infosys on the approved vendors list, by any chance?

  4. Zibob Silver badge

    Standard government fare

    Been this way for as long as in remember. Promise the world, deliver nothing. As long as it sounds good and keep them.elected who cares

    1. Terry 6 Silver badge

      Re: Standard government fare

      This brings to mind the home insulation fiasco- which had a similar trajectory. Public had to apply for a voucher in a complex and complicated scheme (e.g. You could only get the payment for some items as a "secondary" when you were having other ones done- but often those required the full amount of the grant). Then you had to get quotes from (supposedly a number of) approved contractors- but there weren't nearly enough contractors approved in time for the start. And many of those didn't even bother to quote, because it costed them money and anyway they already had more work on than they could cope with. So most of the potential applicants couldn't get on the scheme and the scheme collapsed. The only people who got the insulation were the ones who moved really quickly* in the first days ( or hours) after the launch.

      *I was online within minutes to get my application accepted.. Because I'm a cynical sod- I knew how it was going to go. And I still struggled to get quotes. I got two, one of which was taking the piss. But that was OK. Because it made the one I wanted sound good. And I did get the much needed insulation done. But not many people did.

  5. Howard Sway Silver badge

    budget designed to help 100,000 SMEs

    Ah no, the budget was designed to get big headlines in the press when the big announcement was made and impress the public. As usual, there was no proper follow up to make the thing actually work, and they quietly abandoned the thing when the news could be buried in a small story on page 23 when everybody was otherwise distracted.

    I doubt that there was any intention of actually letting that much money be spent from the very beginning.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: budget designed to help 100,000 SMEs

      i think your being unfair, they did want the money spent.

      But only where it filled tory mates pockets.

  6. heyrick Silver badge

    Unicorn Kingdom, huh?

    As a Scot, I find that interesting...

    1. LogicGate Silver badge

      Re: Unicorn Kingdom, huh?

      Scotland would be the Pictsie Kingdom.

      ..Pictsies eat unicorns for lunch.

      ACH CRIVENS!

      Edit:

      Oops.. Queendom?

      Noo:"Nae quin"

      Maybe Keldadom?

      1. Bebu
        Windows

        Re: Unicorn Kingdom, huh?

        《Pictsies eat unicorns for lunch.》

        And doubtless lions for dessert.

        "Nae king! Nae quin! Nae laird! Nae master! We willnae be fooled again!

        "They can tak' oour lives but they cannae tak' oour troousers!

        "Crivens! I kicked meself in ma ain heid!

        Some the funniest lines Terry Pratchett's from Discworld were from the nac mac feegles.

        I sometimes wonder whether the Tiifany Aching stories or the Ramtops stories will ever be filmed. I can imagine an opportunity to portray Granny Weatherwax would attract the most talented.

        1. Michael Wojcik Silver badge

          Re: Unicorn Kingdom, huh?

          Yes, I might be able to get my older granddaughter interested in The Wee Free Men this summer; she's of an appropriate age. Never hurts to encourage the development of First Sight and Second Thoughts.

    2. Bebu
      Windows

      Re: Unicorn Kingdom, huh?

      《As a Scot, I find that interesting...》

      Well, well... I never realized the horned beastie on the coat of arms was Scots.

      Scots politics might have it moments but absolutely nothing compared to the current mindless antics of Whitehall where even Jarry's king Ubu would be embarrassed.

      I can understand why the mythical creature might want to throw off the chains and to hoof it from the coat of arms. Would look better on a azure background surrounded by a circle of a dozen golden stars. :)

  7. Snowy Silver badge
    Coat

    How much

    How much would a company have to spend in order to get the full 5K discount?

  8. Necrohamster Silver badge

    I'm just suprised...

    ...Rishi didn't give his Infosys-stake-holding wife a cushy consulting gig.

    Too bad Tories don't know anything about the day-to-day running of small businesses.

  9. BebopWeBop
    Facepalm

    Cynic, moi?

    Dare I suggest that this was a paper grant, never expected or intended to achieve it's goals and constructed to be cancelled quiely?

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    You'd better reduce business taxes for the same amount

    And fire those busy working on the redistribution side, saving 5x more in salaries and benefits.

    Besides, instead of making managing business more complex, simplify it.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like