back to article China could be doing better at censorship, think tank finds

China's censorship regime remains pervasive and far reaching, but the bureaucratic apparatus implementing it is unevenly developed and is not always well funded, according to a report released on Tuesday. The report, titled Censorship Practices of the People's Republic of China," was commissioned by the US-China Economic and …

  1. Lurko

    Joined up policy in action

    You have to wonder what the point of tech sanctions is when a US government agency is funding a US corporation to publish a helpful guide for the CCCP "here's all the censorship stuff you're doing inefficiently and could tighten up on".

    Seems that in both China and the US, the left buttock doesn't know what the right buttock is doing.

    1. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

      Re: Joined up policy in action

      The Chinese aren't stupid. They're perfectly capable of working this stuff out for themselves. However you can't formulate policy if you don't understant both your opponents strengths and weaknesses.

      It's also an advantage of democratic systems that they're more open to change. Even in open societies, organisations don't like being told they're doing it wrong, and people don't like to admit they've buggered it up and try to fix it. But that's much worse in dictatorships - where bosses have many more ways to punish dissent. This is only going to get worse in China in the next few years. Before they had a flexible system, of changing half the Party leadership every 5 years, and so the whole leadership team every 10. Thus any official policy position taken by the General Secretary of the Party could easily be changed within 5 years, without too much loss of face. Or if they made it when Prime Minister (the junior leadership position), at worst it would take a decade before they were retired and things could be changed with little loss of face.

      1. ldo

        Re: The Chinese aren't stupid.

        People may individually be smart, yet their individual actions can still have the consequence of collective stupidity. Traffic jams are the obvious example.

        This can happen to entire corporations (e.g. Microsoft), and even to entire countries (e.g. the US, China).

  2. that one in the corner Silver badge

    Was starting to feel sympathetic towards the censors

    The article painted an all too familiar picture: a large organisation, nobody seems to be actually taking overall control (but are basking in the claims that they are in total control), resources being spent over here to duplicate effort whilst over there is lacking the necessary to get the job done.

    Then was finally reminded at the end, nope, just for once, this is what we *want* to have happen, we don't want an efficient censorship.

    Still have a bit of fellow feeling for the grunts at the bottom, just trying to get the day's work done, despite it all.

    1. HuBo

      Re: Was starting to feel sympathetic towards the censors

      "a bit of fellow feeling for the grunts at the bottom"

      Especially as haphazard-plagued interbureaucratic-redundant suboptimally-mismanaged overworked part-time workers face exacerbated-adherence under the growing threat of "outsourced censorship teams"! Time for the PRC censors to send an S.O.S. to the world, as thankfully prewritten by SOS International defense contractor's messaging in a bottled report (someone call the Police!)!

      (Sorry ... sorry ... with such beautiful words in the OP, just couldn't help this amanfromMars1-ism!)

      1. MyffyW Silver badge

        Re: Was starting to feel sympathetic towards the censors

        Very good ... now, Don't Stand So Close To Me ... the censors are watching Every Breath You Take

        1. HuBo
          Thumb Up

          Re: Was starting to feel sympathetic towards the censors

          Right on Roxxxxxxaaaaaaannnnnnne! Put out the red light ...

    2. ldo

      Re: Was starting to feel sympathetic towards the censors

      Until you realize that people are being arrested, jailed, tortured, killed as a result of their actions. They may be inefficient, but they are no less malevolent for that.

  3. jmch Silver badge

    Unfunded mandates

    ""The practice of imposing unfunded mandates on [government entity] has resulted in suboptimal [results]"

    So politicians are the same the world over, and no matter what political system they are under, when it comes to them wanting unrealistic implementation of their utopian policy. Who'd have thunk it??

  4. Tron Silver badge

    The USCC...

    Helping dictators censor their citizens one troubleshooting report at a time.

    All of this is readily transferable to the West of course. Our halfwits need the Chinese to perfect censorship, so they can copy it.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like