back to article Elon Musk has beef with Bill Gates because he shorted Tesla stock, says biographer

Elon Musk's Weltanschauung isn't so much "forgive and forget" as it is "resent and remember" – then post a nasty meme on the internet about the person who "wronged" you. In April 2022, Musk had us sniggering at an unflattering snap of Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates along with the caption "in case u need to lose a boner fast" …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I get that he'd be pissed off that Gates was shorting the stock (though I do wonder if it's pot calling kettle) but seriously, mocking Gate's appearance?

    Just another example of how childish Musk is.

  2. b0llchit Silver badge
    FAIL

    Getting Musk pissed off is a too easy achievement. There are no points to gain from getting Musk being pissed off. You Xcreete, Musk is pissed off. You sneeze, Musk is pissed of. You keep to yourself, Musk is pissed off. You allow yourself to be known, Musk is pissed off.

    Just give it up already. And Musk will be pissed off at that too and Xcreete his inner feelings to show how pissed off he is, again.

    1. aerogems Silver badge

      Was reading some article the other day and the author was asking whether, at this point, even Mars would be far enough away for Twitler to fuck off to. I'd propose a galaxy far, far away, but that seems like a great way to start an intergalactic war if there's any intelligent life that has mastered long-distance space travel. So, where's the nearest black hole we know of? Or even a neutron star would suffice.

      1. b0llchit Silver badge
        Mushroom

        I'd suggest he receive a mandatory one-way ticket to meet our central fusion based energy provider. Also, he should use his own rocket.

        1. aerogems Silver badge

          You're forgetting a very important life lesson: Don't shit where you eat. Granted we now know that black holes can sometimes "burp" up contents and do eventually evaporate, because of the intense gravity and corresponding warping of time, we effectively sequester him for millions, maybe billions, of years. Then all that would be left are the shredded atoms that constitute his being presently. If there are any malevolent cosmic deities out there that reconstitute him, then any humans surviving at the time can just toss him into another black hole.

      2. Bebu
        Big Brother

        whether, at this point, even Mars would be far enough away for Twitler to fuck off to.

        Immediately brought to mind how Angel Islington in Gaiman's Neverwhere was disposed of by Door (?).

        The other side of the Universe I think would a good start. The eternal umpire would have pulled up stumps by the time either Islington or Xitler got back.

  3. The Man Who Fell To Earth Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Shorting Tesla

    Shorting Tesla on the scale of Gates purchase doesn't hurt Tesla. The risk for the person doing the shorting is that they get stuck in a short squeeze, which Gates did which is why he lost $1.5B. Had Tesla stock dropped in price & Gates sold, Gates holdings would not have materially driven the stock price lower & so it's effect would be in the noise. Both of these men know all of that. What this really tells you is Musk (surprise! surprise!) simply doesn't like viewpoints not aligned with his own.

    1. Peter2

      Re: Shorting Tesla

      But it's hardly surprising that Gates thinks that Tesla is overvalued. Practically everybody rational thinks that Tesla is sitting in a stock bubble; the only real question is when the bubble is going to burst.

      Tesla is nominally worth 10x Ford, despite shipping fewer cars and making a smaller profit.

      1. The Man Who Fell To Earth Silver badge
        Pint

        Re: Shorting Tesla

        Agreed. Tesla has a PE Ratio of almost 80, vs Ford's of about 12, GM's of about 5, Mecedes's about 5, BMW about 6. If you properly price Tesla as a car company, the proper value for it's stock is about $17 per share, not $274. Even if you want to delude yourself into thinking it should be more like Ford, you'd still only be at about $30. Gates made the right call but got caught in a short squeeze.

        1. Ruisert
          Flame

          Re: Shorting Tesla

          I made a nice bit of profit from the recent Tesla run up - bought in at 213, out at 264 in less than a month. Planning to short it when this latest spike starts to falter. Hope dear Elon doesn't get wind of that!

          I mean, I'm not doing it for any other reason than to make a few bucks. Tesla's stocks have been doing a pretty regular cycle - and the way the price fluctuates means there's some big money moving in and out, over and again.

          I do find it laughable that Elon thinks Tesla is the best solution to climate change, though, especially if those EV's keep catching fire...

          But, seeing 2 of the wealthiest men on the planet getting into a pissing contest (and Bill losing $1.5B) over shorting Tesla, is my kind of entertainment. Proof that neither man is the genius people make them out to be.

      2. MachDiamond Silver badge

        Re: Shorting Tesla

        "Tesla is nominally worth 10x Ford, despite shipping fewer cars and making a smaller profit."

        Another really good test is to look at all of Ford's assets, tooling, IP and a large installed base to sell parts/service to. Whatever your transportation needs, Ford is likely to have a model that fits the order. Tesla has 2 luxury models and one mass market vehicle in two sizes. The 3 and Y are very similar that I often have to look really hard to determine which is which or see them side by side. The Semi is shipping to Frito-Lay and the Cybertruck feels to me like one the too radical designs that may do well for a couple of years and then drop almost to zero once there's so many on the road that aren't pointing at them anymore. No estate, no van, no fleet optimized model and still no Roadster 2.0. If the tech is so good, why no skateboard so bespoke builders can create niche vehicles with Tesla underpinnings? The electric double decker busses in London are built on top of a BYD chassis that shows up and is driven off of the delivery trailer (man, that looks so weird).

    2. MachDiamond Silver badge

      Re: Shorting Tesla

      "Shorting Tesla on the scale of Gates purchase doesn't hurt Tesla. "

      Arguably, once a company has sold shares and they are traded on the public markets, in a certain sense their value can be external to company's fortunes. Selling short is just taking a position that a stock is going to lose value where purchasing shares is a bet that the stock will rise. With Tesla's market cap so out of quilter the the company's finances and assets, a well timed short could be a good way to make money. Even a lot of money.

      I'm going to have to pirate a copy of that biography. I haven't wanted to buy a copy since I've been too worried that it would just be yet another puff piece.

  4. Charlie Clark Silver badge

    Short-selling is part of capitalism

    I'm no great fan of short-selling but it's just as much as part of capitalism as the kind of debt-bingeing or "over-selling" that Musk has repeatedly engaged in to finance keep his businesses from failing. In fact, it's a necessary corollary. Musk goes to the capital markets offering his shares in his dreams as collateral for cheap cash, Gates and the like act to stop this being a one-way bet.

  5. trevorde Silver badge

    Missed opportunity

    Pity Xitter is now private as it would've been brilliant to short

  6. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

    Should that be "sometime" rather than "former" squeeze?

    Looks like there's another mini-Musk...

    https://news.sky.com/story/elon-musk-reveals-third-child-with-grimes-and-the-babys-unusual-name-12958525

    1. Howard Sway Silver badge
      Gimp

      Ah yes, Techno Mechanicus, who I believe is named after a range of knock-off Lego kits that you can buy in Poundland.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Techno Mechanicus, or Tau for short.

        Tau (or tore, short for tore-his-clothes) or Two-Pi (or two-pee): that kid's school days are going to be hell.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      I'd give you 3:1 odds that Lonnie discretely owns a sperm bank, and has hundreds of unwitting offspring. Make sure you are up on popcorn futures when they start getting "My First DNA Test" for their birthdays.

  7. YetAnotherXyzzy

    When quizzed by Isaacsson on why he had shorted the stock, "he explained that he had calculated that the supply of electric cars would get ahead of demand, causing prices to fall." Pressed to clarify, he admitted that it was to "make money." Old habits die hard.

    Well of course the intention was to make money. That's the usual intention behind all investing, whether it be your money (e.g. in the stock market) or your time (e.g. in improving your skills). Why is that something shameful to "admit" to?

    1. GruntyMcPugh

      And the thing is, if Gates had profited from the short, he'd probably have used the money for some philanthropical purpose eventually, whereas it's a rather tenuous claim that Tesla is leading the charge against climate change.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Perhaps shorting Oracle... Is that philanthropy?

  8. TheMaskedMan Silver badge

    Another cafe fight looming?

    Bill was just as much of an asshole in his day as his Muskiness is right now. It's just the way these people are, I guess. Unfortunate if you get in their way, but entertaining to watch.

    1. This post has been deleted by its author

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      I don't get the impression he was. He was a hard nosed businessman to his competitors, but I can't recall anything vaguely like the pedo guy episode, welching on contracts, welching on undertakings and legal obligations to twitter staff, actively encouraging kind of pathetic racist behaviour in Tesla factories. The list just goes on.

      Or for that matter Jobs' wage fixing collusion, IBM's HR modus operandi, the Ebay CEO pigs head death threats, etc etc.

  9. aerogems Silver badge
    Windows

    TL;DR Version

    Giant man-baby [Twitler] throws tantrum because someone [Gates] said things he didn't like.

  10. DS999 Silver badge

    Musk is such a crybaby

    Just when you think you can't think less of him, you read something like this.

    1. aerogems Silver badge

      Re: Musk is such a crybaby

      Never underestimate the ability of Twitler-level assholes to do their best Sarah Palin impression and "drill baby, drill!" If they hit bedrock, they'll find a way to drill into it. They hit a molten core, they'll find some way to overcome that. Whatever would have stopped a non-asshole will be nothing more than a minor impediment to a Twitler-level asshole.

      1. DS999 Silver badge

        Re: Musk is such a crybaby

        What is it about crybabies who play the victim card constantly but think they are tough guy bullies like Musk and Trump? I don't understand how such an obviously false persona appeals to so many people. How do they attract so many fanboys who excuse past lies and happily believe the next lie as the gospel truth?

        Maybe some people are as attracted to cognitive dissonance as others of us are repelled by it.

        1. Elongated Muskrat Silver badge

          Re: Musk is such a crybaby

          It's because people who are total bullshitters themselves see someone who is a total bullshitter who has done well, and elude themselves into thinking that they can be just as "successful".

          Musk has succeeded due to a combination of starting off with money, being in the right place at the right time, being ruthless, and being a good liar. None of these are really things anyone can, or should aspire to. I mean, I'd love to start off with money, or completely luck out, but "aspiring to" it ain't going to make it happen.

        2. aerogems Silver badge
          Holmes

          Re: Musk is such a crybaby

          It's one of those age-old questions. My personal thought is it has to do with that "critical thinking" thing that everyone says we need more of, but few are willing to put in the work to cultivate. If you have a robust critical thinking ability, Trump and Twitler are rather transparent in their efforts, but if you're the sort who is accustomed to just accepting whatever a talking head on Fox News or talk radio happens to say, it's easier to be taken in by the facade.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Musk is such a crybaby

            There are people who like, or crave, being in a pecking order.

            It gives them some sort of sense of security or something I never really fathomed, and they adore these transparently awful people who posture as the capstones of the implicate order.

            They'll slot in somewhere and peck on those below while tolerating the head honcho shagging their wives.

            At least Musk doesn't prey directly on poor people like some new-church leaders....

  11. Philo T Farnsworth Silver badge

    Congrats, Elon. . .

    You've made me sympathetic to Bill Gates. . .

    Words I never thought I'd ever find myself writing.

    1. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Congrats, Elon. . .

      I'm only sympathetic to Gates for having met Musk once. It is on him for choosing to engage with him subsequently.

    2. Ruisert

      Re: Congrats, Elon. . .

      I wouldn't go quite that far. I'm not sympathetic to anyone with the kind of money these clowns have.

  12. that one in the corner Silver badge

    Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

    As they are, and always have been, the only suppliers of an alternative to ICE vehicles, with their range of sensibly-priced, minimalist electric cars that eschew any kind of frippery for the sake of maximising the efficient use of the stored energy.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

      So what, Polestar, Rivian, Ford/GM, Volvo and Audi et al don't exist on the planet you live on?! (Added bonus - These manufacturers actually know how to build cars and don't have panel gaps the size of my pinkie finger off the production line).

      1. that one in the corner Silver badge

        Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

        Ok, ok, next time I'll up the sarcasm and add the clearly necessary /s tag.

        Sorry to have misled you.

      2. blackcat Silver badge

        Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

        Have you seen the Rivian build quality?

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

          But feel the width..

        2. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

          "Have you seen the Rivian build quality?"

          Rich "rebuilds" has a Rivian and pointed out that the entire side of the pickup is one stamping. I never noticed that and it means that there is no buying a new quarter panel to fix an accident. On my first mini pickup I had something happen to a front quarter panel (not admitting to anything) and was able to take is off, give it a good beating, fill and paint job. With a Rivian, a section would have to be cut out and a new donor piece welded on, smoothed and repainted. Muy expensive in labor and skills.

    2. MrReynolds2U

      Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

      I think you missed the sarcasm indicator there

      1. DS999 Silver badge

        Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

        Anyone posting sarcasm to an audience of primarily IT people such as at the Reg should expect at least half the people reading it will have a broken sarcasm detector.

        1. abend0c4 Silver badge

          Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

          There was a time when that would not have been true, but today's commentards do seem a little more... let's say "earnest".

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

            Yeah it is surprising. In my experience a masters in sarcasm was a prerequisite for IT 101.

        2. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

          "at least half the people reading it will have a broken sarcasm detector."

          With Elon and Tesla, there are so many rabid fans that assuming something is sarcasm has a good chance of it not being that at all.

    3. that one in the corner Silver badge

      Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

      PS

      /s

      Had hoped that the "minimalist" and "eschew frippery" were the clue, but sadly not. Hey ho.

    4. Elongated Muskrat Silver badge
      Flame

      Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

      Not only do they maximise the efficient use of stored energy, they are known to occasionally maximise its efficient release as well, through the emission of heat, light, and smoke.

    5. Elongated Muskrat Silver badge

      Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

      The problem here, is that whilst you posted that sarcastically, nobody could tell whether it was sarcasm, or one of the ubiquitous "Acolytes of Musk" who genuinely believe such things.

      1. that one in the corner Silver badge

        Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

        Even with the use of "minimalist"? What do those Acolytes think a flash car has? A spa? Two storeys and an Orangery? Antigravity?

        Hey ho.

        PS

        /s on the Orangery - almost didn't, but I'm learning!

        1. Gort99
          Joke

          Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

          Orangery? Is that where Trump goes to top up his tan?

      2. Michael Wojcik Silver badge

        Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

        Oh, I think plenty of us could tell it was sarcasm. Even Muskolytes wouldn't describe Tesla's iPads-on-wheels as "minimalist".

        At least we can all agree that climate change is entirely caused by people driving existing ICE cars, though, and will be completely solved by making everyone buy a new electric vehicle.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Tesla, the company doing the most to solve climate change

          With the teensy little boot opening, no jack or anything to fix a flat tyre, and inability to take a roof-rack, Model 3's seem functionally minimalist compared to a Trabant or Morris 1100

  13. Kristian Walsh

    Short-selling = negative feedback = stabilisation = good

    If you look at a stock market as a control system for finding the correct price of one share of a company’s stock, then short-selling is a fundamental requirment. Long options (the kind Musk likes) are a way of buyers indicating that the current price is too low. Short options are the opposite: by setting a future sale price below the current value, option-takers are indicating that the current price is too high.

    Between them, these two signals act as the error in a closed-loop control system, and the price, theoretically, settles on a reflection of the demand for the stock. Without a negative feedback signal, the price would rise uncontrollably until it crashed. (See the Dutch Tulip Bubble for an example of a market that had no shorting).

    Or that’s the theory, anyway. The problem with the stock market as a control system for finding a correct price is that the system makes it easier to send the long signal than the short one. To short a stock, you need the strike price, plus a lot of money to cover your potential losses; to go long, all you need is the price of the shares you’ve bought. This biases the feedback towards increasing prices, and it’s not really an error, but rather a designed-in part of the system.

    Musk, like nearly all VCs (Musk’s role in both Tesla and SpaceX was as an early-stage investor), exploits this bias by hyping stocks, thus transferring the risk of failure to small investors who will buy and hold the shares post-IPO. The reason he’s so against short sellers is that a short-selling run is the only thing that can really correct the price of an overvalued stock, and like every other VC, he needs overvalued stock to keep other ventures afloat.

  14. Bebu
    Headmaster

    (Public) school boy antics

    Metaphorically Gates debags Musk who in turn gives Gates a wedgie.

    Master observing same: "Do grow up gentlemen!"

  15. Groo The Wanderer

    Oh, so if Musk doesn't like something you did, he'll post mean pictures and make fun of you?

    There's a couple of words for people like that, you know:

    Bully. Thug.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like