back to article Pony Ma tells employees Tencent is ordinary and replaceable in company meeting

Tencent CEO Pony Ma Huateng referred to his Chinese multinational company as "ordinary" and replaceable in a leaked company speech given at the 2021 end of year employee meeting. A woman looks at the sky while walking through the streets of Shenzhen against the backdrop of the Tencent Building A woman looks at the sky in …

  1. MiguelC Silver badge

    The last thing tech billionaires in China want is to be seen - by the government - as making any kind of waves. They got the message loud and clear, if you kowtow the party line, the future will be bright; if you don't, well, ask Jack Ma where he spent those months far away from public view...

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    "...have your humility leaked to the press."

    ...maybe leaked intentionally?

    Guerilla marketing is world wide.

  3. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    No one and nothing is irreplaceable in China....

    .... but Xi Jinping, of course...

  4. Brewster's Angle Grinder Silver badge

    I wouldn't want to live in China, but they could teach us a few things about dealing with monopolies and over powerful corporations.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Except where that that monopoly and over-powerful entity is the "people's" government…

      Free elections, multi-party democracy, fair voting systems, nah, you don't want any of that…

      1. Snake Silver badge

        Is it any worse than the corporatism that so much of the capitalist world has fallen into?

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Yes, that you can't change it without tanks running over you... Tienanmen docet.

        2. llaryllama

          This kind of smug self-deprecating whataboutism will be the fall of western style democracy and you'll soon learn that authoritarian pseudo-communism is really no fun.

          I've lived in enough places to know that flawed democracy is always better than pretty much any other style of government. Even good people become corrupted after holding power for too long. The liberal democratic model is full of cronies, corruption, bribes and all that good stuff but at its core is a stable foundation that allows the bad apples to be picked off.

        3. Cliffwilliams44 Silver badge

          There's a word for that, except many today do not understand its real meaning due to 70 years of mis-information. It's called Fascism!

  5. Lucy in the Sky (with Diamonds)

    Seen this somewhere before...

    "I am making this speech out of my free will. I am treated well, and not been harmed in any way. I have been assured, that I will be released once the demands are met. Glory to the glorious nation of <insert name of captors' nation here>!"

    1. sanmigueelbeer

      Re: Seen this somewhere before...

      USS Pueblo, the crew were beaten black-n-blue before they were paraded to the worldwide TV interview. They were further beaten up when one of the crew flashed a "bird", captured on TV, and told the NK that it was a sign of "good luck".

  6. DS999 Silver badge

    Sounds like a hostage video

    He's clearly been beaten into submission.

    Can you imagine the CEO of Apple, Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon or Intel standing up on a stage and telling employees "We aren't doing anything anyone else can't do. All our products and people are replaceable and nothing special. Now go out there and be ordinary, and don't rock the boat!"

    I think the days of worrying that Chinese companies will move into the western world and push out western ones are over. Western companies may be selling Chinese made products (at least until that gets expensive enough they offshore to somewhere cheaper) but Chinese companies will not be making the big leaps into new product categories.

    You can't change the course of an industry or create one like the iPhone or Facebook or eBay or etc. etc. with conformist thinking and fear of risk taking.

  7. Snowy Silver badge


    Been buying quite a lot of stuff outside China, almost as if they want to leave China altogether?

    1. DS999 Silver badge

      Re: Tencent

      They have strict capital controls to prevent their billionaires from moving all their money outside of China, but if your company simply expands outside China you could one day abandon the in-China part of the company down the road if/when things get too dicey.

  8. W.S.Gosset Silver badge
    IT Angle

    He's alive?!?

    Or was it more:

    Hi everybody, I'm P-P-P-Po-Po-Pony M-M-Ma-X Headroom

    1. W.S.Gosset Silver badge

      Re: He's alive?!?

      MaXi Headroom, in this case

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like