
The Cotswolds
A right den of thieves and villains.
A 23-year-old Gloucester IT worker is to stand trial after allegedly stealing more than £30,000 worth of Amazon vouchers before selling them on eBay. Jack Walden, of Cranham Close, Abbeymead, appeared before Cheltenham magistrates on 6 January facing three charges: two of fraud and one under the Computer Misuse Act. …
Although there are often frustrated calls for updates to the Computer Misuse Act, claiming that it's outdated and that it doesn't account for modern technologies, it does generally seem to work reasonably well.
Someone does something obviously naughty, gets prosecuted, receives appropriate sentence.
I'm not going to pretend that it shouldn't be updated, but hope that any changes retain the primarily proportional and balanced implementation we have now.
Don't mistake lack of appropriate punishment from the judiciary for a failure in the law they so often fail to enforce sufficiently. Assault or robbery get light or suspended sentences (especially if committed against emergency services personnel, it seems) but being rude to the judge in court gets you sent down for Contempt.
It is not the law that needs adjusting, it is the people involved in trying the cases and sentencing the criminals who need to be addressed.
The problem is that the proposed updates to the Act are unlikely to make it any more effective in prosecuting wrongdoing, but instead will allow it to be used to further erode our privacy, and to prosecute people who are doing things that are merely inconvenient to government authorities. As you correctly point out, the existing Act is perfectly adequate, and I have not heard of any example of an action that would be seriously wrong but which could not be prosecuted due to a limitation in the present computer misuse Act.
Found an issue with gift cards at the company I worked for about 10 years ago that essentially let me make them with any amounts. Did the right thing and reported it as any retail staff could also do the same, wasn't even any record in the logs and very simple a non-IT staff member would have figured it out. Literally showed them a blank card then the process any cash register could use to put any amount on them, took about 20 seconds.
Result, nothing changed. Decided to move on a few months later. Sometimes they don't want to know I guess. Still my morals were untarnished.