
Type your comment here.
Nikola Tesla obsessively fed them, the Queen keeps hundreds at Sandringham, and Charles Darwin was enthralled by what they could teach us about natural selection. But for most of us, they're little more than rats with wings. And now one has only gone and shat on a three-month-old's face. We're talking, of course, about pigeons …
Oh, I do. I just didn't think it was particularly standout as articles go. Didn't even crack a smile or make me say "Huh?" An article bereft of WTFs. Didn't involve anyone famous either. Birds crapping on people is common as muck, really.
Now if it was an article from a local newspaper about, say, sci-fi stalwart and taken-too-soon Elisabeth Sladen vomiting on Tory MP Edwina Currie, then I could appreciate the inclusion in El Reg a little more.
Each to their own, I suppose.
although not on the IT angle.
1) Stop thinking of them as "pigeons", as if their existence needs to be justified in strictly human terms, and you'll find yourself better for it. Their technical description is "Rock dove", and if you tell yourself that name rather than 'pigeon' when you see them, you'll actually smile at yourself. :)
2) I don't see anything unusual about birds pooping on people. Happened to one of my teachers 40 years ago whilst I was standing right next to him during an outdoor break. Lifted his arm - poop! Right on the elbow. Direct hit! I think they have bomb sights as built-in features :p
It is highly unlikely that they are rock doves. There are only two areas that still have pure rock doves - the Outer Hebrides and some remote parts of western Ireland. In neither case are they likely to get close to humans.
The shitters here are most likely feral pigeons; bastard cross breeds of rock doves, stock doves, wood pigeons and the other various doves/pigeons that inhabit these islands. The only one that's not worth eating is the feral pigeon.
"The shitters here are most likely feral pigeons; bastard cross breeds of rock doves, stock doves, wood pigeons and the other various doves/pigeons that inhabit these islands. The only one that's not worth eating is the feral pigeon."
Rock doves, "feral" pigeons and "domestic" pigeons are all the same base species (Columba livia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_pigeon ) , the various notations are simply subspecies ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subspecies ) which simply denote locales. Therefore, most "feral pigeons" are actually rock doves that simply are denoted by their urban lifestyle (as the photo of them in India on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rock_pigeon , shows ).
My daughter went to nurse in Michigan. Collecting her one evening I was given a long account of the 'removal' of oner of the chickens the nurses kept by a Chicken Hawk (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chickenhawk_(bird)) The bird had the good grace to settle down and eat in front of the class.
Falcons do work. Many cities seem to be trying them with varied results based on nesting availability and the number of Falcons the use.
In one small town I lived in, once a year, the local cops supervised a pigeon hunt in the downtown area (no buildings over 3 stories.. I said it was a small town). Seemed to work for them until the snowflakes got upset about dead birds falling out of the sky and sound of shotguns.
I was going to suggest the Goliath birdeater but it seems it only occasionally eats birds. Wait, can they spare a few pelicans from the park?
That's just going to start a wave of people complaining about their sparrows being eaten. Peregrine Falcons take the odd rock dove - but a having twice been near the killing zone of a PF i can tell you the noise made by the raptor coming in at over 150mph to take a bird by surprise will take you by surprise - and that's a lot more volume than a pigeon dropping!
When I first read this comment I read what disease you "can't" catch from a feral pigeon and I thought about STD's. Maybe some people interact with pigeons in unusual ways.
Rereading the comment I think you can catch psittacosis.
From Wikipedia
Psittacosis—also known as parrot fever, and ornithosis—is a zoonotic infectious disease in humans caused by a bacterium called Chlamydophila psittaci and contracted from infected parrots, such as macaws, cockatiels, and budgerigars, and pigeons, sparrows, ducks, hens, gulls and many other species of birds.
"I may draw the line at eating feral pigeons as they can carry twice as many life threatening diseases as rats."
Pigeon pie was a relatively common recipe until fairly recently. If you were likely to die from eating pigeon, it would have become a proscribe food centuries ago. People generally learned about what is good or not good to eat back in the hunter/gatherer days.
Shoot them, trap them, scare them, block their perches and nesting areas, release raptors to snack on them, use drones to harass them - all of these have been done with varying degrees of success for similar problems elsewhere. What is called for here is something a bit different... something unique. To that end, please vote on the following or suggest your own solution that may in some way have a connection to the issue (or not).
1) Microwave blasts to fry the flying beasts while in the air. Not as far-fetched as you might think. Radar will accomplish this if used (in)correctly.
2) Declare war on the bastards! I know declaring war on things is more of an American thing, but it has worked fairly well for us. Stage a WWII re-enactment themed fumigation the entire area. There must be some vintage aircraft that could be used to drop gas canisters onto the benighted area.
3) Open the town as a cat sanctuary while running a simultaneous campaign to encourage cat ladies from all over the world to bring their pussies to have a good time. If only one or two decide to do this, the problem of roaming cats will quickly displace that of dive-bombing pigeons. Dogs next, followed by goats, cows and horses.
@Helpmann
Start singing:
I knew an old lady who swallowed a fly
I don't know why she swallowed a fly.
I knew an old lady who swallowed a spider
That wriggled and wriggled and tickled inside 'er
She swallowed the spider to catch the fly…
I knew an old lady who swallowed a bird
How absurd, to swallow a bird
She swallowed the bird to catch the spider…
I knew an old lady who swallowed a cat
Well fancy that, she swallowed a cat…
I knew an old lady who swallowed a dog
What a hog, to swallow a dog…
I knew an old lady who swallowed a horse
How very coarse, to swallow a horse…
I knew an old lady who swallowed a cow
I don't know how she swallowed a cow…
Being friendly is an option and feed them at a particular place.
I had issues a year ago with agressive seagulls. They were nesting on my roof and saw anyone in the garden as fair game for an attack. So last year, I started feeding it, at the same time every day. The seagull stopped attacking and waited patiently near the back door for food and saw us as a food provider rather than a threat.
At one point, it even let its chick in my garden and we were able to be in the garden and not get attacked. Easier summer for all.
About two years ago we had a barn owl move into the local stream/park valley. The park is about a klick away, but he/she/it seems to have a patrol range of about 4 or 5k. There's been a dearth of pidgeons, seagulls and starlings since. Although it seems the crows like to give the owl a hard time.
Huge bird, and quite handsome.
No wonder the place is infested with the flying rats. Plenty of roosting opportunity and probably plenty of food sources around from people littering. Whomever thought it would be a good idea to mount those aircon units outside the flat like that deserves to live there for the rest of their lives. Only way to solve it now is to put proper boxes around them with steeply sloped tops and all access holes sealed up properly. The only other solution is to shoot the f%^kers, but that tends to get the treehugging crowd riled up and is difficult to do safely in a residential area.
The only other solution is to shoot the f%^kers, but that tends to get the treehugging crowd riled up and is difficult to do safely in a residential area.
I was once a member of an old gentleman's shooting club (in the UK) and a very old member related that when working for a particular company they were doing some manufacturing work that required very tight tolerances. They did it, put it in the storage space and a pigeon splattered it. The acid in the pigeon poop was enough to put their work outside of the accepted standard (we were talking in the micrometer range) and it all had to be redone at extreme cost.
The management promptly decided to eradicate the pigeons to ensure there was no further occurrence of this problem.
A bird of prey was hired along with it's handler during the day. However, letting the bird of prey kill and eat the problem is now considered to be inhumane, so the bird of prey was shackled to the handler to prevent it from going and killing them. This simply upset the pigeons a lot, and the handler suggested that it would upset their breeding patterns.
The management then asked Mr good old fellow to deal with the problem ye olde way. That evening he came in and shot all of the pigeons. He did a body shot with .22, however the pigeon survived this, so he switched to headshotting the pigeons with an air rifle to kill them cleanly and humanly. Some while later he cleaned up the pigeon carcasses and went home and (almost) nobody was any the wiser for how the pigeons had been dealt with.
As a result, the staff not in the know believed that the bird of prey frightened the pigeons away and were convinced that this had been dealt with in an incredibly humane and progressive manner, far superior to the primitive notion of the old timers of just shooting or poisoning the pigeons, which of course wouldn't have worked. The chap owning the bird of prey used the site as a reference in advertising material for how effective his method could be.
Next time a pigeon came back, our chap was quietly asked to do a couple of hours overtime.
Jeebus H Christ, what sort of idiots inhabit the area? Spikes only work when the whole top surface is covered, not just a single row on the edge, and someone who says she was "in floods of tears" because of kakasplat needs shooting more than the flying rats. And line up the ones who don't understand how to cover "sensory equipment" beside her.
Hey hey hey, dont you go trying to bring your ladi-da European "solutions" into this here Blighty. We do things our own way. No means No. etc etc.
Bloody Frenchies pushing their disease control and pigeon wrangling. The Pigeons are probably foreigners, anyway, no self respecting British pigeon would go pooing in a kids mouth. It's outright rude. I mean its just not cricket...
the Surrey Comet* to provide a variety of solutions.
*mundane story, epically silly comment thread
I know of a couple of lads at a certain council who every so often work night shifts at various sites around the city. Each takes a council owned air rifle and 100 pellets with them.
One brings back an average of 98 pigeons.
The brings back an average of 102.
Even though they put up signs, notify police with names, copies of photo id, serial numbers etc well in advance and are driving vans marked with the council logo, the police have to send an armed response unit whenever somebody sees them and dials 999. Officially the ARU are not allowed to have a go themselves...
"the police have to send an armed response unit whenever somebody sees them and dials 999. "
I got chatting with a Rentokill guy at the couriers a few years ago. AT some point, as we were leaving, he decided to show me the rifle he uses for killing certain vermin. As he's waving it around I quickly pointed out that the big warehouse-like building next door with all the high fences topped with barbed wire is the local police firearms training centre. He very quickly realised that showing off his rifle probably wasn't a good idea considering who might be in the cars driving past in full view of him and his rifle.
Rent a hawk every so often. Various places round London do that -- they remain pigeon-free for quite a while. No pigeon sh*t, no fuss. And a rather lovely bit of history.
First time I saw it was in Leadenhall Markets mid-afternoon (empty). Chap with a dirty great gauntlet stood in the middle, looked up and there's a dirty great hawk parked on a high crossbeam down the other end, he lifted the gauntlet and the thing just dropped then whump out come the wings about 5foot off the ground and it shot down the length of the market. Got talking to him, he said it's fairly common, and as he pointed out "you never see a pigeon round here do you?"
You can have birds of prey and pigeons in proximity.
In the UK there has been a rapid rise in peregrine falcons nesting on tall city buildings as their population now in full on major recovery mode after crashing with DDT side effects decades ago.
They like to eat pigeons.
However, you still find pigeons near their nesting sites even though the birds hunt regularly...
It's a numbers game - you would need a huge number of falcons to eradicate the pigeons
They do have a few effects - pigeons are more vigilant (which has knock on effect of making feeding more awkward, but in most messy UK cities waste human food is easily found)
Just before Christmas we had a grey-hair holiday in Madeira.
We allowed ourselves to get suckered into a 'Hotel Holiday Club" presentation in one of the largest hotels in Funchal. (basically for the freebie* that inevitably comes along if you sit all the way through it).
In the lounge/foyer was a youngish lady wearing a Belstaff type jacket and big gloves.
On her arm a raptor. The hotel uses it to keep the pigeons and gulls away from the balconies and pools..
Ironically as were leaving, the lady was on her knees attempting to remove raptor poo from the carpet.
*We got a bottle of Madeira and a 3 hour dolphin watching cruise on a catamaran. (and no, we didn't join)
We had a major pigeon problem round our area.
A guy came and put up cages with food, the stupid birds just walk in over and over again.
The guy comes and takes them away. We haven't really asked what he does with them, but I suspect that they get their necks broken.
You can't just take them away and release them, the buggers either come back or become someone else's problem.
Your only practical solution is to kill them really, as quickly and painlessly as possible.
Here in Spain I have seen big buzzard shaped kites on a length of cord at the end of a 4 or 5 metre fibre glass pole, even the seagulls tend to stay away from them.
As an alternative; back in the '70s a mate of mine worked for a commercial freezer installer, their warehouse was infested with pigeons whose poo was causing thousands of pounds worth of damage to the freezers stored there.
The boss paid my mate and I to go there with air rifles three weekends in a row to shoot as many as possible.
The first weekend we took out over a hundred birds, the second weekend they knew who we were and flew out of sight, we found the answer was to tie a couple of pallets to the forklift, one driving the other on one of the pallets and hiding behind the other then raise the pallet over the eaves, shoot a bird and drop back down, probably got about half the number of the first weekend as it was slower. The third weekend I think the pigeons had sussed out that weekends were unhealthy and there were hardly any when we turned up but still plenty in the week, pigeons are fast learners, shooting them may reduce numbers but the best thing is to remove all food sources and put anti bird goo and spikes everywhere they could possibly settle.
Nuking from space might work.
Air rifle.
The people who complain about such measures do not live in an area blighted by pigeons. Of course, should they ever suffer that problem, after the first bought of hand-wringing and failed "humane" solutions, they tend to 'regretfully' propose using an air rifle.
The other point is that those handwringers tend to live in houses not flats, cul-de-sacs not estates, and the council responds to their issues in far less time than three years....
Been there, seen it, done it.
The people who complain about such measures do not live in an area blighted by pigeons. Of course, should they ever suffer that problem, after the first bought of hand-wringing and failed "humane" solutions, they tend to 'regretfully' propose using an air rifle.
The other point is that those handwringers tend to live in houses not flats, cul-de-sacs not estates, and the council responds to their issues in far less time than three years....
Been there, seen it, done it.
I had this problem a few years ago when I moved in to a new house. there were pigeons everywhere, pooping on everything. Here in the states they don't consider an air rifle a fire arm and pigeons are considered small game birds in most states, so I solved the problem with a hunting license and this.
https://www.amazon.com/Gamo-611006325554-Whisper-Fusion-Rifle/dp/B01APG0VFC/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1549047280&sr=8-3&keywords=gamo%2Bsilent%2Bcat%2Bair%2Brifle&th=1
My neighbors were not very happy, as they had been feeding the damn things, and called the cops on me. the cops showed up to see what was going on, I showed them my license and my air rifle and the state hunting proclamation that shows them as small game birds, so there was nothing they could charge me with. We had a bit of a laugh over it. One of the officers asked where I got the air rifle. so I am sure he went and did the same thing at his house. I went on to kill dozens of the damn things and my neighbors quit feeding them to prevent me from killing more of them.
From what I hear, you can eat pigeon and supposedly it is quite tasty. I have not tried it, but I might the next time the pigeons population gets out of control. Additionally, since I got rid of the pigeons, we have had a resurgence of other birds, like greckles, humming birds, sparrows, etc., which I don't mind. they still poop on stuff, but not like pigeons do.
anonymous coward because I don't want the wrath of PETA or the tree huggers and rock lickers coming down on me, not to mention the anti-gun nuts.
When I was a teenager, my sister's BF lived on Portland. We used to go down (from London) to stay during the summer, and some days we used to take a 16 bore shotgun down the disused railway line and pot a few rabbits and pigeons. BF's Dad made a superb rabbit and pigeon pie, but you had to be a bit careful to spit out the lead shot embedded in the meat.
Pigeons - rats with wings. At least with rats, they can be trained and can be clean, but pigeons are the scum of the earth - along with seagulls.
You never see a baby pigeon, they must come out of their eggs fully grown and ready to eat anything. I have seen pigeons with missing toes on one foot and maybe one toe on the other, they walk around quite easily. Its as if they don't need toes to walk around with, I have also seen pigeons with only one leg, and it still hops around. There are pigeons who have dive-bombed the pigeon spikes and survived, and the only thing that has happened is that the spike has gotten flattened, so when one does it, the others watch and do it too and soon the pigeon spikes are all flattened and new spikes are needed. I, personally, think these spikes should be poisoned or electrified so kill the buggers.
Pigeons are the ONLY flying bird that would rather run away from you than fly away.
As to a solution for pigeons, if you don't want to use poison or electrification is to get the rats, teach them to eat pigeon eggs and adult pigeons. You do this by putting a rat into a large bin filled with pigeons and their eggs, after some time they will only eat pigeon eggs. I know this is a little bit Sky-Fall, but the principal is correct, and it should work. And to get rid of the rats, you get a Scottie (West Highland Terrier) doggie. Its best to get one of these little white fluffy dogs which has an attitude problem, they will rip any rat apart.
I know this is a "non-tech" solution, but from experience old tech or non-tech sometimes works better than these new fangled devices what some boffin comes up with.
You never see a baby pigeon, they must come out of their eggs fully grown and ready to eat anything.
Having had mourning doves nest in one of the wife's planters on a long weekend while we were away, I assume they develop similarly, perhaps it may provide a reason why you never see a baby pigeon. As best I could tell with the doves is that they went from eggs one day to totally fledged and gone inside of two weeks. I tried to get snaps every day and from the last picture of an egg I caught to when they were largely fully developed and nowhere to be seen was 13 days. I can't say for certain which day they hatched but it was clear they had hatched 10 days before they left which gives a 3 day window and I'd wager the exact time depends on things like food availability. In short, about a week to week and a half to bulk up and another 2-3 days for the flight feathers to completely grow in and they are nearly indistinguishable from their parents.
If you don't have to worry about the law then an air gun works wonders. They really don't like being shot at because even a .177 pellet can kill them. Unfortunately in the UK you're likely to get a flood of birds of the 'black helicopter' sort if anyone sees you (surprisingly where I live in the US isn't that much different). Raptors might work but I don't know if they like the Great Taste Of Pigeon -- also its surprisingly difficult to catch a pigeon on the wing (I've seen a pigeon evade a diving hawk, they're pretty manoeuvrable when they need to be).
I suspect the problem is that, like rats, they congregate where the food is. If you're neighbours are careless with trash and litter then you can expect all sorts of nuisances, and not just the ones you can readily see.
Finally, looking on the bright side ..... they could be seagulls. They're like larger and more aggressive (and louder) pigeons.
You going to start killing dogs and cats too?
https://www.cdc.gov/healthypets/pets/dogs.html
https://www.cdc.gov/healthypets/pets/cats.html
https://www.cdc.gov/rodents/diseases/direct.html
https://www.cdc.gov/healthypets/pets/birds.html
Funny that at the bottom of the list is actually birds (the count being 21,16,11 and 4 in that order).
I couldn't even be bothered to count the diseases humans can give each other.....
This post has been deleted by its author
When my sisters and I escaped from our mother we rented the top floor of an old house in Vancouver. There were pigeons nesting in a triangular alcove of the roof beside a dormer. There was a giant pile of pigeon poop at the opening of this alcove. What animal shits where it rests? One result of this was a surfeit of those flies that fly around in random patterns inside the house.
Years later I was working on the opera The Cunning Little Vixen (an animal allegory) by Janacek in a Welsh Opera production that at one point featured several housewife chickens in housedresses and aprons leaning on brooms, smoking and cackling. Putting these together my image of pigeons ever since has been of avian rubbies with cigarettes dangling out of their mouths, walking around the sidewalks saying "Got any bread crumbs, bud?"