Judge Derpy Von Bonehead...
How does not wanting to negotiate with a troll indicate "wrong-doing"? We don't negotiate with terrorists -- does that mean we're hiding something? Extend this logic and it quickly becomes clear it's completely absurd: If every negotiation that broke down indicated "wrong-doing", diplomacy would basically amount to the childhood game of "If you don't say _____, you're gay!" It becomes a game of trying to trick your opponent into a no-win situation, rather than negotiating in good faith to avoid costly litigation, wars, divorce or... worst of all, winding up living in the suburbs.
Although... it would make these court trials less boring if they consisted of "I know you are, but what am I!" and other highly sophisticated legal deductions.