back to article NSW plods panned for illegal surveillance

A Sydney magistrate has called “criminal” a vindictive operation in which NSW police snooped on someone's private Facebook posts. Exactly why a senior constable called Daniel Moss decided to get himself an invitation under a fake identity to see the private posts of “Rhys Brown” (in real name Rhys Halvey) isn't given in this …

  1. Sanctimonious Prick
    Big Brother

    What I Read Is...

    Corruption. Men's Club.

    1. David Roberts Silver badge
      Linux

      What I Read Is...

      Miley Ray Cirus. Twerking!!!

      Why have your eyes gone so large, Pengy?

    2. Mark 65

      Re: What I Read Is...

      ...and then they have the cheek to complain when the public won't help them! So many people in positions of power have glossed of the fact that, fundamentally, their position is one of public servant and not "he who must be obeyed". Why would the police act any different when their political masters act with such authoritarianism?

  2. Winkypop Silver badge
    Devil

    A “criminal” vindictive operation (by Police)

    So no biggie then?

  3. big_D Silver badge

    Real names policy?^

    I thought it was real names on Facebook... So a cop using a fake name made friends with somebody using a fake name... :-S

    I guess it is only if the names aren't "normal" that they are banned,

  4. dan1980

    This incident, while seemingly trivial is a perfect example of why all these surveillance and data retention laws are so dangerous.

    In fact, it's precisely because this is so (seemingly) trivial that it is also so very, very important because it shows that there are those in our police forces who have truly dreadful judgement when it comes to what is a reasonable use of their powers.

    I accept that there are bad eggs/apples in all lines of work and do not wish to judge the entire force by the actions of one vindictive, thin-skinned creep on a power trip.

    But . . . there are two very important points that must be noted here. First, even an individual police officer, acting alone, has a huge level of trust placed on him/her and has the power to make life very unpleasant for anyone they have an issue with. This huge potential impact means that it should be a high priority for the police force to identify any such individuals and either correct their behaviour or remove them from positions where they can be dangerous.

    The second point is that even if we assume that such police officers do act alone in the first instance, the police culture seems to ensure that they are backed all the way to the courts. Officers abusing our trust in this fashion are not only not disciplined but are actively supported by the establishment.

    There is a hugely unequal power relationship between a police officer and a normal citizen and the result of this is that even one problematic constable can cause a great deal of pain and upset and inconvenience and embarrassment for a person. And this is why, despite the overwhelming majority of police officers being good, decent people, we simply cannot trust them - as a group - to exercise their own judgement in these matters.

    That an individual officer would do this proves you can't trust individual officers to excercise good judgement in these matters and so must go through approval and oversight. That the police force backed him up proves that they are not a suitable source of that approval and oversight.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Do the Police suffer from loss of morals after time in the force?

      Sadly seeing the damage that an ex-copper can do.

      Morality and fair dealings, no. Running the fine legal limit (ie not legal, but too hard to prosecute, without sufficent evidence in a civil matter ), fraud, malfesance, theft, dishonesty, tax evasion.

  5. Youngone Silver badge
    Mushroom

    NSW Police

    I'm not sure if anything has changed since This

    Perhaps a member of Vulture South can enlighten us.

    Of course, there's always This which might just be worse.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021