back to article OpenWrt gets update in face of FCC's anti-flashing push

The open router Linux disto OpenWrt, 15.05 “Chaos Calmer”, has hit the intertubes. One highlight of the release is an update to Version 3.18 of the Linux kernel, and security has been upgraded with ed25519 package signing support, and support for jails and hardened builds. However, the big news – at least according to the …

  1. gerdesj Silver badge

    Poor show

    "The release is named after a cocktail, apparently, but The Register's networking desk has neither gin nor Grenadine syrup on hand to test it."

    Gin is a basic. Grenadine is only optional if space is really tight and vodka or whisky would need to be excluded to fit it in.

    Clearly the Vulture Networking Desk of Networking that covers Networking whilst Networking needs to get its act in order if it is to continue functioning effectively.

    1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

      Re: Poor show

      The release is named after a cocktail, apparently, but The Register's networking desk has neither gin nor Grenadine syrup on hand to test it. ®

      Try the Special Projects/Iberian Bureau - they are bound to have some

      1. gerdesj Silver badge

        Re: Poor show

        It's a really poor show when you have to go to Spain to get your Dutch fix 8)

        1. billse10

          Re: Poor show

          it's a really poor show when you've already run out by 9:30am on a Monday, too :)

          1. Frumious Bandersnatch Silver badge

            Re: Poor show

            it's a really poor show when you've already run out by 9:30am on a Monday, too :)

            The gin, yes, but running out of grenadine? It's non-alcoholic, isn't it?

            Also, minor quibble... all the OpenWRT releases are named after cocktails. The splash screen (motd) when you log in has always given the recipe on any release I've ever used.

    2. Velv

      Re: Poor show


      See last weeks article about business continuity and why this article should have been written in the pub

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    It's almost as if...

    ...they don't want you to run a secure router.

    The track-record of proprietary vendor firmware with regards to security is hardly stellar. This is one of the principal drivers for those seeking a bit more reassurance from the front-door of their network.

    Call me paranoid, but it would be mightily handy to have more buggy, insecure firmware out there when the need comes to break down that front-door...

    1. gerdesj Silver badge

      Re: It's almost as if...

      Aye: I'll be recommending to my more security conscious customers to buy their routers from Taiwan or China or wherever, basically not the US. Then put a custom ROM on it.

      Oh, I do that already.

      Actually it's not that simple: All systems that might be used as routers are suspect and frankly so are all others. Your hard disc has enough stuff on it to run an OS (Linux has been booted on an HD). Anything with a iDRAC/iLO/whatever is probably pwned or could be as required by a suitably funded org. As a security consultant I am under no illusions that whilst I can keep the run of the mill baddies out and some of the more determined naughty people, I have no chance against the pre-embedded govt level stuff.

      Luckily, I have nothing to hide.



      PS If you missed how dreadful that last line really is, then cancel your next order for tin foil.

    2. jjcoolaus

      It's more like...

      ...they want routers that have backdoors, and logs that are verbose enough for US authorities to drop by and have a poke around if they need.

      The point around security is a good one though, especially as most vendors are pretty careless about keeping their routers up to date, and most don't have an automatic update function that happens without the user triggering it.

      The thing around WiFi bands is a convenient excuse to hide the fact that what they really want is control over the point of internet connection in every home across the US.

  3. David Roberts

    Raspberry Pi?

    Not much point in locking down router firmware if you can build your own from a Pi!

    1. Dan 55 Silver badge

      Re: Raspberry Pi?

      Ah, but only turrists will want to do that.

  4. Conundrum1885 Bronze badge

    Re. Raspberry Pi?

    Interesting idea.

    Seeing as the CPU in the Pi is essentially a lower end Broadcom router chip, this could work.

    I did have thought about "harvesting" the 5 GHz chip and surrounding antenna circuitry from dead routers and making an add-on card that way (would need serious skill, they are fragile) but it could work.

    The router here (defunct, turned off during FW upgrade) actually has separate 2.4/5 GHz antenna clusters so can be easily repurposed if the pins going to the BCM43224 can be accessed.

    Fortunately they are on the side so its a matter of tedious though feasible soldering with 30 gauge and wirewrap wire.

    1. Decade

      Re: Raspberry Pi?

      No, a stupid idea.

      The CPU in a Raspberry Pi is not a router chip. The Raspberry Pi is built around a TV/set-top box processor. Its network I/O, frankly, sucks.

      Besides code signing (see how Google OnHub has a TPM chip that prevents third-party firmware from running), the major issue is device drivers. The 5 GHz chip in a typical router is a PCIe add-in chip, and it looks like a lot of the router SoC can also act as PCIe wireless adapters.

      If you want extreme customization, I think it's best to get a dedicated board with some PCIe slots, maybe something from Soekris, and carefully research the wireless adapters to find ones with working open-source drivers that support master mode.

  5. Dan 55 Silver badge

    US firmware? What US firmware?

    Most routers let you choose where you are anyway. If you want to be able to use another channel outside of the mandated channels where you are just go to settings and switch it to Japan or something.

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Fuck 'Em

    We don't all live in the US so are not subject to their crazy regulations.

    Nothing's going to prevent me from modding anything I want out here in Asia.

  7. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward


    Don't - do not - do anything terrible like upgrading and controlling your own WiFi (although we'll reserve the right to hold you accountable for any actions done over it if people download illegal stuff and you cant prove it). What was that you asked? Why, yes, of course. You can buy firearms over the counter in that shop over there, sir.

  8. CAPS LOCK Silver badge

    What is this OpenWrt of which you speak?

    I had not heard of it until this fuss. I shall investigate as it's clearly something interesting, like, for example an aerial photo of Barbra Streisand's house...

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020