back to article SPACE FARMER 'nauts arrive safely at International Space Station

Three fresh 'nauts have arrived at the International Space Station, bringing it up to its regular complement of six - and clearing the way for the first off-Earth farming. The arriving 'nauts are NASA astronaut Kjell Lindgren, Russian cosmonaut Oleg Kononenko and Japanese astronaut Kimiya Yui. The trio took off from Baikonur …

  1. This post has been deleted by its author

  2. dotdavid

    " if humans start spending serious amounts of time off Earth, they will have to take to using their own excrement for this purpose"

    Or pigs in spaaaace, and use their fertiliser. Then they can have space bacon butties.

    1. dotdavid

      Also they would be flying* pigs which is cool.

      * More accurately falling pigs maybe?

    2. Dwarf

      Zero-G Bacon

      Imagine the smell of cooking bacon wafting around the space station, with nowhere to go. That's got to be a real positive motivator.

      But then if someone passes wind in an enclosed space ...... :-(

      1. Mark 85

        Re: Zero-G Bacon

        The smell od bacon would go well with the smell of freshly made espresso, don't you think? The coffee part is solved (unless it's been returned to Earth)... Onward to bacon!!!!!!

  3. Grikath

    You'd need a serious set of bioreactors to process faeces ( and non-edible parts of plants, and...) to plant food. The equipment simply isn't present on the station, and given the cost of launching stuff it's probably more efficient to simply lift a suitable nitrate mix to where it's needed than a load of tanks and piping.

    Farming in space ( and the associated problem of closed ecosystems) is a terribly complicated and technically challenging issue, and indeed well worth researching.

  4. Sporkinum

    freeze dry

    I wonder if they could freeze dry the poo by exposing it to space? Exposure to UV and vacuum would sterilize it I think.Then it could possibly be a compact powdery fertlizer.

    1. Anonymous Blowhard

      Re: freeze dry

      It would be better to reclaim the water from the faeces, otherwise you're gradually losing water from the system. For a closed system, or at least one with minimal input required, this would be pretty important.

      Also it seems that bacteria are pretty hard to kill so the combination of UV and vacuum may not make it safe for use:

      Looks like they need to develop a compact sewage plant after all.

      1. Pascal Monett Silver badge

        Re: freeze dry

        Interesting link. I had no idea bacteria could survive the brutal radiation conditions of outer space.

        1. phil dude

          Re: freeze dry

          I believe that is one of the "accidental" things they discovered from the Apollo missions. Bacteria survived on some of the cameras they had use on the moon (and were brought back to Earth).

          In my own experiments, E.coli can survive in glucose and the high vacuum and radiation of an electron microscope.....though it does tend to get chunks blown out of its membrane.


  5. Dan Paul

    Composting @Grikath

    Have you ever heard of composting? Takes complex organics and breaks them down into soil. The Chinese and Japanese have used "Nightsoil" for centuries to supplement poor soils and add organic fertilizer. No reason that couldn't happen on the ISS if properly accommodated. The only issues are the personal taboo's of the astronauts. If they drink recycled urine, there shouldn't be many left. Speaking of which, the leftover minerals from distilling the urine would be a good addition to the hydroponic fluid.

    1. Grikath

      Re: Composting @Grikath

      I'm quite aware of composting, yes. A compost heap is, in fact, a bioreactor. It does not, however, present nitrogen and to a lesser extent potassium, sodium, sulfur and magnesium ( your ultimate goal, after all.. ) in a way plants can actually use. The same goes for the urea left over from the urine distillation: plants cannot metabolise it directly. For hydroponic fluid you ideally want the pure salts as an addition. Soil is a very complex ecosystem, which major output is "plant food" in the form of those salts, but if it was easy to duplicate every greenhouse would have a bloody big reactor, sorry, "compost heap", next to it already..

      Incidentally, not using human faeces for human food production is not a taboo, but rock-hard science. Something to do with the nastier shades of pathogenic colon bacteria being spore-formers and the inevitable end result of bouts of explosive diarhhea, or worse. Which you most definitely do not want to happen in a space station.

  6. Unep Eurobats


    Vegetable extra-geosphere garden ingestion experiment.

    It's got to be better than the seaweed bacon.

    1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

      Re: Backronym

      Versitile Ecology Grows Giant In Exo-farm.

      I think we need some sort of test to make that any returning astronauts are actually the same ones we sent up there.

      "Look, you fools, you're in danger! Can't you see?! They're after you! They're after all of us! Our wives, our children, everyone! THEY'RE HERE, ALREADY! YOU'RE NEXT!"

  7. x 7

    "Astronauts will be allowed to eat half of the second crop of lettuce in the Veggie investigation, freezing the other half for a return to Earth"

    any gardener will tell you that freezing lettuce doesn't end up with green goo

  8. saif

    Lettuce?...could do much better

    Romain lettuce is probably the least useful food source unless you have the gut bacteria to digest cellulose.. Of the mass of leaf, less than 2% is usable carbs and about the same amount of protein. Better would be perhaps algae. Sugarcane or potatoes probably even better but less practical. But more significantly, these plants presumably are not exposed to sunlight...instead one imagines solar power is used to charge batteries and then this is used to power lights shining on the plants...a terrific waste of energy to produce nearly no energy. If the earth's ecosystem is a good example...then one should be trying to cultivate phytoplankton and krill in fermentation chambers exposed to filtered sunlight.

    1. choleric

      Re: Lettuce?...could do much better

      I would love to see what shapes are produced when sugar cane is grown in zero gravity conditions. There must be a website devoted to speculation on the matter, excuse me for a minute ...

    2. wdmot

      Re: Lettuce?...could do much better

      Red romaine lettuce was used in the previous Veg-01 experiment. The current Veg-03 experiment ( will use Tokyo Bekana cabbage. Looks like lettuce but is a brassica.

      And apparently VEGGIE part of the ISS recreation programme: "Through numerous tests the VEG-03 science team has refined the pillow concept and selected growth media and fertilizers, plant species, materials, and protocols for using the pillow concept in Veggie to grow healthy plants that can provide crew with food and recreation."

      Interesting research, but I am certainly glad I don't need to worry about the microbes on my garden produce -- a simple rinse is generally sufficient.

  9. Your alien overlord - fear me
    Paris Hilton

    I think it strange they'll let the 'nauts eat some of the lettuce but will only check it after ity comes back to earth. What about DNA mutation and such like, it could evolve into a brain-controlling parasite which would then infect planet earth.

    This insanity must stop now.

    Paris, brain = a natural togetherness !!

    1. MrXavia

      Not the first time they've grown it according to another poster here, so they're pretty certain its safe...

      The risk is they are not sure what will happen with different plants, consider that tomatoes are a member of the deadly nightshade, family, so you really want to make sure the zero-g doesn't end up making them a poison for the crew!

  10. Santa from Exeter


    "using the pillow concept in Veggie to grow healthy plants that can provide crew with food and recreation"

    I didn't realise they were growing Weed as well!

    1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

      Re: Interesting

      "We don't want pod people on Earth!"

      Well, not "officially" of course. Apparently the Russians are planning for potatoes next. To go with the illicit vodka still...

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like