back to article Man sues Uber for a BEEELLION dollars over alleged theft of concept

Uber is being sued by the founder of a small wireless business who claims Uber stole his idea for a ride-sharing app. Kevin Halpern, founder of a company called Celluride Wireless, is suing Uber and its CEO Trevor Kalanick, along with several other early investors in the company, accusing them of having misappropriated trade …

  1. phil dude
    Facepalm

    so many idiots, so little time...

    Last night I was at a local pub with a friend, who pushed the Uber button and the map appears.

    "I love the way the cars move around", says my buddy.

    I would be interested if any *taxi* firms, had a competing product...

    Otherwise I file this under noise, which every reasonably obvious innovation gets hit with.

    P.

  2. Eddy Ito

    misappropriated trade secrets and being in breach of contract

    I'm sure he has a signed copy of that contract, right? As for the trade secrets, in this particular case as soon as you make the app public what do you really have for secrets?

  3. wolfetone Silver badge

    You know what, I had the same idea around the same time. I'm not suing though, because Uber did it better than me and it was inevitable a service like Uber would come in to existence.

  4. AlbertH

    Just another patent troll

    This Halpern character is just one of the many trolls that turns up when a good idea goes global. As the holder of a few patents myself, I've seen this sort of nonsense many times - never for this kind of insane amount, but often for a million or two. Since the most I've ever made from a patent is a few tens of thousands, my legal eagle tells me just to laugh at them and file them as spam!

    These are just the modern equivalent of the "begging letters" that every football pool and lottery winner receives.

    1. tom dial Silver badge

      Re: Just another patent troll

      Too lazy to search out and read the complaint, and don't want to wast the time to watch the Youtube flic. Is there a patent here (the article didn't say so) or is Halpern simply an idiot who found a lawyer to take on a contingent fee lawsuit figuring that 40% of a $1B with a probability of approximately zero might be worth a few hours and a filing fee to get a mention or two in the press?

  5. Sebastian A

    It's really a brilliant strategy.

    Pitch random ideas all over the place, get someone else to develop it and run the financial risks, then if/when the business takes off, claim to have been the original inventor and sue their balls off.

  6. tom dial Silver badge

    Sanity check

    1. Halpern created the Uber business model and founded Celluride in 2003, some four years before the iPhone was released.

    2. In 2006, after three years doing nothing (?) with the idea, he let it slip to Trevor Kalanick.

    3. In 2009 Kalanick and Garrett Camp started Uber, Halpern having spent another three years doing nothing significant with "his" idea.

    Halpern's suit probably is due for a quick and unfortunate end unless he has signed documents from Kalnick acknowledging his precedence. If he is lucky, his lawyer hired on for a contingent fee and the risk of court censure for wasting a judge's time.

  7. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Theft of IP

    "Halpern's claim indicates that, at the time, he was developing his own mobile-based, private-car-hailing service, and that one of the few parties that Halpern trusted with the details of his company was Trevor Kalanick, who later went on to found Uber."

    Yep - looks like he was ripped off.

    I came up with the idea of rating tradesmen based on user experience (like TripAdvisor but for people instead of places). The fact that someone else got it off the ground and built the product that people wanted to use means they win and I lose. I'm not going to cry a river - that's how business works.

    1. Thorne

      Re: Theft of IP

      "I'm not going to cry a river - that's how business works"

      You hire a lawyer and make enough mud stick to gain traction in court. You drag it out in court until it is costing the company massive amounts and you offer to settle for an amount cheaper than running the court battle. The company pays up and the lawyer buys a new BMW

      That's how lawyers work.......

    2. salerio

      Re: Theft of IP

      Hardly the same thing. Unless you told the developers of TA about the concept - if you did and they developed your idea and cut you out you might well feel aggrieved. This has been gone through once already with Facebook

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Just wait...

    ... until Rapists starting suing Uber on similar grounds.

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    By Rights this...

    ...should be in the public domain. There is an informal transport business in Puerto Rico called the "Publico." Anyone with a car can carry anyone needing a ride for an agreed upon fee.

  10. Adrian Tawse

    Idiot

    If you chat about your brilliant idea with the chap next door you have given it away. You are an idiot and you have no one to blame but yourself. Trade Secrets are called that for a good reason, they are supposed to be secret, i,e, don't tell the man next door.

  11. Tezfair
    Unhappy

    people have ideas

    I remember 'inventing these' donkey years ago (in my head)...

    - Method of tracking mileage when driving a private car for business use, with a method of seperating business from private mileage for tax purposes.

    - Combining a CCD with a flash memory stick to enable recording of events whilst driving

    - Putting Windows on a memory stick so when you plug it into a base PC, 'your' Windows then boots and runs with all your data available.

    People can have ideas, but may not always follow it up.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like