UK's non-emergency police and NHS Vodafone systems go titsup NATIONWIDE Britain's non-emergency telephone numbers for the police (101) and the NHS (111) have collapsed nationwide. Vodafone engineers are currently attempting to bring the services back to life. A number of police forces confirmed the outage on Twitter, where they reminded folk not to "misuse" the 999 emergency number just because …
Of course it doesn't apply in Wales. The devolution referendum was years ago, and Health is a devolved matter. That's why we get free prescriptions here and the English NHS patients don't. I assume you don't visit the doctor very often.
The NHS is a National service, i.e. the Wels nation has a national health service, ditto, the English nation and the scottish nation, and I assume the people of the north of Ireland.
Errr, I know that, that, that, and errr that.
And I said "independence", not "devolution", making a tongue-in-cheek jibe at the number being referred to as *National* in the context of "the whole country"
Anyway, why "of course" does it not apply to Wales? Scotland has it, and we get it next year, which shows that your unnecessary lesson on the devolved NHS (which everyone with half a brain knows already) is entirely irrelevant.
I had the misfortune to have a blowout 5 minutes into a 4 hour RAC outage earlier this year. They blamed 'Vodafone'. I told them I thought it was pretty unsatisfactory, given that their entire business model is answering the phone and dispatching patrols that they didn't have a backup.
For instance, I could have tweeted them my location. At least they could have announced their outage on their website and I wouldn't have waited several hours before giving up and calling a taxi. I was also amused that they told me 'coordinates don't work' when I told them my location.
Still, before I ramble off about that, my point is this: what is all this single-point-of-failure nonsense and could it possibly have anything to do with 'corporate cost control' being all the rage rather than an emphasis on achieving the business' publicly stated goals?
"Anyone else would have fitted the spare and carried on..."
Since you appear so interested: I attached the tube of Tipp-Ex thoughtfully provided by Audi; attached the 12V inflator as instructed; and it all blew out of the tire all over the road. Obviously there are other circumstances that could have been impossible for a driver to even attempt a repair.
If you are *really* interested, the situation was complicated by the fact that it is a company car, operated by Lex, whose 24 hour line goes straight through to the defunct RAC number. So I can't just call the AA, tell them the RAC are tossers and that I want to change membership. I can't have the car towed by A N Other contractor as I have no authority to do so, and no-one to contact to get that authority. It is a cabriolet, in the middle of nowhere, at 02:00 on a freezing cold winter night. I have two phones on two different networks, a blanket, water, chocolate. I think the idea that I was unprepared is ludicrous - my only mistake was giving the RAC so long to answer the phone before calling a cab, but I knew it was going tobe more than £100, and hard to reclaim (it was -- actually, I still haven't got it back).
I did walk past someone the other day who was watching while the AA man replaced their tire, with what looked very much like the spare (it was a newish Ford Fiesta, which I assume have a full size spare).
I was very close to stopping and asking why they hadn't done it themselves.
The thing about these telephony control systems is that they are resiliant... up to a point. Typically they have active/inactive sides. But, ya know what.... both sides are usually running the same software and share the same database and call states.. So good for physical breaks but not so good at application layer issues...
Well at least in Spain!
The usual cause of lack of service is because their computer has decided that you haven't paid the bill/ paid it fast enough/ paid enough of it etc , it will then cut you off.
To have the service re-instated you will have to pay another, inflated bill, and then they will mull over reconnection over the next few days while telling you the service HAS been re-instated.
I dread to think of the results if they ran the 999 service, if that happens buy some carrier pigeons, much more reliable and faster than paying a kid with a forked stick to run to the police/fire/hospital to tell them where you are having your emergency.
Surely they don't rely on a single call routing database? As far as I can see the only thing that could cause an outage of NGN routing on this scale would be the loss of the database that ties the non-geographic numbers to ordinary directory numbers - depending of course on the source number. That being the case it makes you wonder why it took so long to get it back on line.
Well, it's a bit more complicated for 111 and 101. Depending where you are in the country (which can be down to which London Borough you are currently in, only a few square miles) the 111 call needs to be routed to a different provider (111 is technically commissioned locally by CCGs for some reason, it's only 'national' in Scotland).
In this case, they activated a (version of) the backup plan, slammed all 111 calls through to the Scottish service, where a recorded message told you (in a scottish accent) to call the national backup number operated by the HSCIC at 0300 020 0155.
Luckily, the 999 system is much more resilient, and (as of this year) Vodafone (the ex Cable and Wireless bit) are no longer providing the Operator Assistance Centres that handle and route the calls.
Did you read my post? The lookup is for the dialled number and the originating number. Destination and source. This is very common and not unique to 111 & 101. Plenty of businesses will try to route you to your local office in a similar way.
The lookups for 999 as every source DN must have an address lookup for 999 (not mobiles of course). It's up to the service provider to supply these details.
We've just had a 24-hour Vodafone (nee C&W) landline outage. Interesting points appeared to be:
a) Calls to landlines failed, no error tones etc. Calls to Vodafone mobiles continued working. Calls to other mobiles were part-working.
b) Reporting the problem out-of-hours got sympathy but nothing useful. Reporting the problem in office hours resulted in our being told that the operations centre was offshore. My suspicion is that the only time anything can be done is a very limited window when *both* UK and offshore technical staff are available... I don't want to speculate but the problem both occured and was fixed in the 21-23:00 GMT timeframe.
So the real question is: have the police and others put all their eggs in a basket being carried by somebody who can only undertake corrective action for a few hours every day? And if so, what's to be done about it?
The Register 
Biting the hand that feeds IT
Copyright. All rights reserved © 1998–2025
