back to article UCAS website collapses - on results day

'A' level students looking to find a university place through the UCAS website had better get on the phone instead - the organisation has shut down its own website. Despite widespread predictions that this year would be a particularly busy clearing process, UCAS (Universities & Colleges Admissions Service) has been caught on …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Quote of the day:

    > Michael Allen, Director of Application Performance Management Solutions at Compuware said: “In this day and age, there’s no reason why increased traffic should cause a website to crash."

    Michael Allen, Director of Hasn't Got a F***ing Clue About the Realities of Running a Website

    1. kissingthecarpet
      FAIL

      Maybe I'm missing something

      but surely if anything is "crashing", rather than just unavailable due to the number of connections, then its buggy & needs fixing. I don't run webservers, so I don't know - maybe they do crash at the drop of a web connection. But all media outlets *always* state, without exception, that so-and-so's site has "crashed" when its unavailable. Sounds like unmitigated shite to me.

    2. Geoff Campbell Silver badge
      FAIL

      @AC

      You might want to look at Compuware's selection of APM products before announcing that you don't know jack shit about the market, perhaps?

      GJC

  2. The Mole

    Slightly harsh

    The quote about UCAS being in a good position to predict the traffic seems slightly harsh.

    Predications aren't exactly easy to make, presumably student numbers are pretty similar to last year yet the quote from UCAS says they are getting 4x the peak load - would they have been able to predict that? Double maybe, but 4 times?

    1. Just Thinking

      Not hard to see

      I don't know exactly how much information UCAS have access to, but they probably know which A levels people are taking, which courses they have applied for, and what offers they received.

      Presumably they also knew in advance what grades everyone got.

      So they could have known last week exactly how many people failed to secure a place.

      A week isn't long. But surely some trends must have been visible for months - more applicants (less people taking a gap year because of the fee increase next year), people applying for more substantial courses which might actually lead to a job (but more difficult to get the grades), etc.

      Were all these factors static and the extra traffic came as a bolt out of the blue?

  3. Tom Chiverton 1 Silver badge

    Umm

    "no reason why increased traffic should cause a website to crash"

    I can think of many. Money, time, resource coming to mind before incompetence. Too much benefit of the doubt ?

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Headmaster

    Don't know why they're rushing for

    everyone passes these day don't they?

    1. Peter Gathercole Silver badge
      FAIL

      You obviously don't know what UCAS is for.

      See title.

    2. Ru
      Boffin

      It is very important to know

      whether you got 4As, 4A*s, or 4A**s, as this can seriously affect your choice of university.

  5. Andy ORourke
    Joke

    Clearing......

    "Importantly for applicants, the ability to choose a Clearing place will not be impacted, and this function will open late afternoon as planned."

    Should read

    "Importantly for applicants, the ability to choose a Clearing place will not be impacted, and this function will crash later this afternoon as planned."

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Pirate

    Anonymous Kiddies

    I wonder how many of the Anonymous kiddies are now panicing that they wont be able to goto uni! Oh Noes! Denial of Service!

  7. keithpeter Silver badge
    Black Helicopters

    I was wondering....

    ...if this isn't a preventative measure?

  8. irish donkey
    Facepalm

    Disaster Recovery Plan

    Obviously their Disaster Recovery Plan worked well.

    'Pull plug and wait for everything to calm down'

    1. tmTM

      Not that simple.

      I believe the full plan reads:

      "Turn off switches, hide under desk until tomorrow"

    2. The Fuzzy Wotnot
      Happy

      Don't laugh

      Hey don't laugh, that's how most UK Gov DR scenarios are set up!

  9. deshepherd

    4x load?

    Well, there's someone bleating on the Guardian forums that they can't get through even though they've had all 4 members of their family on different computers trying to connect all morning!

  10. Arrrggghh-otron

    DDoS!

    I hope the police will be tracking down and arresting all those nasty evil hackery type students for participating in a DDoS attack!

  11. Nader
    FAIL

    Same thing as happened in Norway

    Why won't they ever learn

    1. tmTM

      Education?

      They're in the business of teaching, not learning - thats the students job.

  12. melt
    Angel

    cloud

    Need to serve simple database content to very bursty levels of users? Sorry for the buzzword, but this should've been a prime candidate for hosting "in the cloud".

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Thumb Up

      8olloux

      Examples of the cloud going down are on this site regularly.

      Ohh the cloud will cure all ills until the internet connect between you and cloud goes and then you are stuck with your thumb up your..... cloud.

      1. melt

        Re: 8olloux

        I think if the internet connection between you and "duh internet" was down, you'd have problems accessing UCAS's normal website as well...

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Thumb Up

      Why the downvote?

      No sure why your post got downvoted. Hosting on Amazon or something elastically scalable is exactly what UCAS needs to be. Unfortunately this would mean rewriting a lot of their applications. (Although that is something that should be done anyway!)

      1. mark 63 Silver badge

        rewrite applications?

        Unthinkable! according to my customers , hence i look after 500+ Win2k machines that cant have OS upgraded, only have LJ4 print driver installed , require lpt1 "capturing" , and applications that fall over and have to be "unlocked" if there is a millisecond lapse of network connectivity.

        All development and coders left years ago.

  13. tmTM
    Paris Hilton

    Unexpected load?

    Who'd of thought, with university places costing 3 times less this year than next year that people might try to get one while they can still afford one.

    Paris for this one, because even she could have seen this comming.

  14. Mike Flex

    Who could have predicted such massive traffic?

    Well, I for one, would have been more impressed with all these declarations of how easy it was to predict UCAS outages if this article had appeared yesterday rather than with the benefit of hindsight.

    Would those commentards that successfully maintain a website that gets hammered one day a year without bankrupting their organisation with excess kit/service charges care to step forward and reveal how they do it?

This topic is closed for new posts.