PopBox 3D set-top media player

Now that playing digital files from USB keys, or streaming them over a network, is a feature built into many TVs and almost every new gadget that plugs into one, it's inevitable that standalone players will become cheaper. The PopBox sits at the bottom of Syabas Technology’s Popcorn Hour range of media players. Popcorn Hour …

[Tim Hale 1]

Not surprised

I tried out a Popcorn Hour A-210, trying to connect it to a Windows home server and it was terrible.

Lots of people think they're wonderful and maybe it's my fault but I found it to be horrendous. Hanging while reading meta data, getting stuck in loops of error messages, freezing on MKVs that played back perfectly fine elsewhere. Not to mention that the whiz-bang interface only supports one network share! I had that 'beta software' feeling, not that '£200 of quality, dedicated, device' feeling.

Companies need to understand this should work out of the box with an easy to use, attractive, accurate, interface and not a list of network locations and filenames or mismatches.

Media Browser on the PC is a good example. Tell it where your stuff is and it'll never bother you with the detail again.

[Anonymous Coward]

Interface wasn't the USP..

I'm using a Popcorn Hour A110, which I've had for a couple of years.

The interface wasn't the USP for me - it was the ISO support.

I use a set of scripts published on one of the many forums that links with some movie database software to generate an index for my 400+ DVD rips that are housed on a WHS (and yes I do own the original disks).

They are somewhat fiddly to setup but *touch wood* my setup has been pretty robust for the past year at least..

Rather disappointed to see that Syabas seem to be dropping ISO support.

[Anonymous Coward]

Popcorn aint that bad

@Tim Hale, Can't comment on your messages and errors as I don't suffer any, but your comment about Network shares only supporting 1 is tosh. I have 3 Nas's and several PC's connected to various SMB/NFS and Upnp locations, thats 5tb of stuff and nothing fails to play, I admit the interface is a bit old hat but press RED on the recent firmware and you get the whizzy Thumbnail/Cover "graphical" interface, which is cool, but I prefer my own front end. yamj (Its skinnable u know)

Popcorn isn't a saint but its not as bad as you care to flag.

[Alan Edwards]

Boxee Box

The Boxee Box costs a bit more (£190 compared to £140) but it's a lot more stable, data scraping for the most part works, and you can build your own NFO files for stuff it doesn't know about.

It worked first time with my ReadyNAS, and has played everything I've thrown at it so far - XVID, DIVX, M4V. MKV and DVD ISO. Only issue is my power line ethernet kit being marginal for 720p/AC-3 5.1 MKVs.

[Anonymous Coward]

Best of a bad bunch...

I decided to make space in my living room by ripping all my DVDs/Blurays to a NAS. I then started looking for a network streamer - my requirements:

1) User interface simple enough to be operated by signifcant other

2) Plays all my video files without stuttering

3) Supports iPlayer access

So far I've tried a PS3, an Apple TV (with FireCore hack), a WD Live TV, and a PopBox. The PopBox is the only device that fits the bill. It seems to have excellent codec support, competently playing anything you throw at it (even 40Mbps 1080p Bluray rips) and the iPlayer app is the best I've seen outside of a desktop - looks great on a large screen and easy to navigate.

My only gripe is that the UI isn't as polished as it could be, especially for initial config. Getting the PopBox to see your SMB shares is a painful process - e.g. you can't just browse shares on a given server, you have to type in the correct share address/directory name. It feels like the admin/config functionality just hasn't been finished yet.

[Lamont Cranston]

Can we please have a box (or a TV)

with integrated iPlayer, itvPlayer, 4oD and Demand5? That's really all I want (along with the usual PVR functions, but I've no chance of getting that built into a TV) - on demand films/streaming off a network/playback from USB is icing. Even Vista Media Centre can't handle this, which is beyond disappointing.

I get the feeling that I'll end up having to build my own HTPC, but that it'll fail the family acceptance test, as no one wants to fire up a web browser just to catch up on a missed programme.