back to article Metro Bank in schoolboy email error snafu

Metro Bank, the newly established UK retail bank, has irked its customers with a schoolboy email error. The latest marketing missive from the bank was sent using all the email addresses in to To: field instead of using the bcc (blind carbon copy) field. In the process, the bank disclosed the email addresses of around 1,200 …


This topic is closed for new posts.
  1. Anonymous IV

    Not bad going!

    First they don't use the BCC field, then they try to use Recall - which doesn't work unless the recipient is on an Exchange server, and quite often not then.

    The usual answer by a bank, "Additional training has been scheduled..."

    1. Anonymous Coward

      Re: Not bad going!

      Clueless manager: "What? You mean not everyone is on Exchange? I thought the Internet needed Exchange to work!"

    2. Anonymous Coward

      Kindle too

      Recall also works on Amazon's Kindle.

    3. Anonymous Coward

      Total Recall

      I can't see a likely situation where you'd benefit from honouring external recall requests. Certainly anyone with an email archiving system will probably have a copy stored off Exchange anyway as soon as it hits their borders.

  2. hitmouse

    Schoolboy snafus never die

    I don't think a month goes by when I don't get an email listing all recipients from an organisation that should know better. Beyond a doubt the worst must be the University of Sydney which runs so many of its public talks through distribution from various administrative officers' email addresses as a more-or-less ad hoc affair. There's no point trying to educate one of them, as temp staff often step in and repeat the same mistake the following month/talk.

  3. Anonymous John

    Britain's first new High Street bank in over 100 years

    Four branches near London is not my idea of a High Street bank.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward


      The Cooperative bank is the first new high street bank in 100 years, and they actually have branches - get this - in the high street of many towns...

    2. Magnus Ramage

      Probably not true

      Somehow they got this phrase out in their launch marketing, and the media have propagated it since. I agree that four branches in London doesn't make a bank, and I strongly doubt the claim it's the first for 100 years. But memes will spread. I've not spent the time to try to find counter-evidence. The Co-op Bank traces its corporate history back to 1872 ( so probably doesn't count.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Thumb Down

    £50 Domino's Pizza voucher

    Value of said pizzas in ingredients and staff time preparing them: probably about £5.

    Also, what a clever way to encourage your most-complaining customers to die sooner of clogged arteries and stop being a customer support burden...

  5. Anonymous Coward

    Bank slaps forehead, can customers slap them in the face?

    "Rest assured there is no need for any concern as no other information was sent."

    What could possibly be wrong with lots of people you don't know being given your email address without your consent? Exactly, nothing, so there's absolutely no concern whatsoever. Case closed.

  6. Anonymous Coward

    I'll still bank with them

    I'm a customer and didn't receive the email. Doesn't particularly bother me - have seen it from numerous other companies which usually don't make the same mistake again.

    If you live in London and travel overseas then it's worth opening an account with Metrobank, as unlike the vast majority of UK banks, they don't charge any commission or exchange rate markup on overseas debit card withdrawals. I just transfer money in before going overseas.

    I don't use them for day to day banking as their online banking website is pathetic.

    1. Anonymous Coward

      Re: I'll still bank with them

      Have you checked their interest rates. Remember TANSTAAFL ... if they're opening sundays and bank holidays you have to pay for that convenience somehow

    2. Marvin the Martian

      "I'm a customer and didn't receive the email."

      What's your point --- you honestly thought your bank had about 1200 customers, namely the recipients of said mail??

  7. Rob Worth

    Not unusal

    The other day I was sent an email from O2 with 80 other people's emails in the CC field. If The Reg posted a story every time this happened they wouldn't write about anything else.

    Still shouldn't happen.

  8. Tom Wood


    they send "your statement is ready" emails manually using Outlook?! Who designed their IT systems, a work experience student?

    Why is it that the name "Metro bank" makes me think of the Metro newspaper, which is handed out free at train stations, good to keep you occupied for about 10 minutes, and generally is a nice idea but not something to take too seriously?

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      That's nothing

      Their banking engine is an Excel spreadsheet (ducks...)

      1. Anonymous Coward

        Re: That's nothing

        With Excel, they're only a step away from recreating the "old bloke writing in a ledger with a fountain pen" style of banking.

  9. Anonymous Coward

    No Email, but the IB is hopeless

    Yep. No Email from them, but the Internet banking is useless, not to mention I think its just a off the shelf script as it occasionally re-directs to a blank page with a "Your Bank" Logo on it. Oh and it does not work correctly in anything but FF and IE.

  10. Mark Jan

    Not a Schoolboy Error!

    How many children would commit such an error having grown up with email and the internet?!

    1. Anonymous Coward


      if it's my daughter, it's all facebook, twitter and SMS/MMS.

      Emails are only for crappy things like homework and sending stuff to granny & grandad.

    2. hitmouse

      Quite a few of them

      ..who are completely unaware of privacy issues as they despatch everything to their 5000 Facebook "friends".

  11. Dave Murray Silver badge

    Britain's new High Street bank?

    "Metro Bank opened last year as London's first new High Street bank in over 100 years. It has four branches within the M25 corridor,"

    Fixed that for you.

    1. El Richard Thomas

      Loving all the northerners getting uppity

      What would you do with a new bank anyway? London's got all your money ;-)

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Whats this not london business?

      It's co-op bank who only have 1 or 2 branches in London (Ealing and the square mile).

      Metro bank have one in Holborn (zone 1) and earls court (zone 1/2 border).

      Besides how often do you go to the actual bank.. each time you cash your pension?

      1. Joe 3


        Holborn is where one of the other Co-op banks is, and there's another at Angel. You're right about rarely visiting a branch though, if only my customers would stop sending damn cheques, realise it's 2011 and make a transfer instead!

  12. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    First new bank?

    Wouldn't the Cooperative Bank claim the first new bank in a hundred years line see:

    While the bank formed in 1872, it wasn't a registered company until 1971 - which I believe is when it started taking customes outside of coop group. In 1975 was the first new member of the clearing banks in 40 years.

  13. Jeff 11

    Schoolboy error? Idiot-proofing failure, more like

    The real error is allowing marketing people to email customers direct, en masse, instead of via a dedicated distribution app or service... for a bank, this is doubly cretinous.

    1. Anonymous Coward

      May not be the error

      They may be even more stupid than that and had a app made for it but did not properly test it and it used the TO instead of BCC is some cases ... come to think of it that would still be less stupid than allowing users send out mass emails from outlook.

  14. CASIOMS-8V

    The pizza company

    Care more about you than your bank.

  15. Alan 6 Bronze badge

    How to lose customers

    I think we can deduce from this that on Friday Metro Bank had 1,200 customers. Today they have somewhat less than this amount...

  16. Anonymous Coward


    Just need to xref with the PSN details. Quids in :)

  17. John G Imrie

    1200 emails.

    Well it happens. I think what's worse is that their IT is so windows centric they thought that the recall button would work.

    1. Fred Flintstone Gold badge


      I think what's worse is that their MANAGEMENT is so windows centric they thought that the recall button would work.

      There, fixed that for you..

  18. Joe 3


    Surely this hints at deeper IT issues at Metro Bank? Some marketing wonk is getting a list of customers' email addresses and pasting them into Outlook - that this is even possible suggests to me that they don't operate the principle of least privilege.

    Why does anyone in marketing need to see a customer's details? Surely they should be entering their text into a template which the system then fills in with customer data?

  19. Sean Donnellan 1

    M25 corridor

    How many corridors go in a (poorly designed) circle?


    M4 corridor, yes

    M25, No.

    1. Anonymous Coward


      A famous example would be the ones in the Pentagon, there's quite a few recent schools in the UK with them, and our own GCHQ too...

  20. David Gosnell

    Prior art

    I remember a mobile phone retailer falling foul of its own similar snafu about ten years ago, when they forgot to use "Bcc" to notify the very small number of exclusive winners of a competition to win a free phone. Only went out to several thousand recipients. Needless to say the phone wasn't really free at all. No compensation there, equally needless to say, just a whole drove of potential customers (some of them hitting "reply all") insisting something about sticking pins in their eyes rather than buy anything from the culprits.

  21. Marco van Beek

    Why is a user sending what should be an automated email anyway

    If all the email said was "your statement is ready", why was it being sent out by a human in the first place. Surely that should be done by a cron script, one email to each customer, one at a time?

    Sounds to me like they do not have a proper grasp of their server back-end. Imagine how much admin time this must take to do by hand.

  22. Alan Brown Silver badge

    The logo....

    ... is virtually identical to Manila's Metro bank. (Same font, same colour, etc)

    Reverse colonisation?

  23. Stuart Halliday

    oh hoo!

    This is what happens when management thinks it can do an IT engineer's job.

    A lot of IT jobs have potentially annoying or security implications that untrained or immature people just don't think about.

    This email should have been sent via a mailing list so there is no chance of a human doing what they did.

    This just exposes the bad and disorganised practises going on behind the scenes at this bank.

This topic is closed for new posts.

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020