back to article Sun Java piggybacks Microsoft searchbar, divorces Google

Sun is now distributing Microsoft's Live Search toolbar atop its Java Runtime Environment, after parting ways with Google's browserware. According to Sun's press release, Internet Explorer users downloading Sun's JRE "have the option" of downloading the MSN toolbar too. But it's worth noting that the install-Microsoft-app …


This topic is closed for new posts.
  1. vincent himpe

    no wonder

    i saw a whole flock of pigs fly by this morning... After Micro$oft now we also have $un

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Thumb Down


    All extraneous software/services should be OPT-IN. Anything else is malware and loading due to uninformed consent.

    Christ, Sun, Apple, Google and Microsoft are as bad as each other some times!

  3. Anonymous Coward
    Thumb Down

    "...and you have Internet Explorer installed"

    Can we please have a guesstimate how many Windows machines DON'T have Internet Explorer installed??!! Go on, take a stab in the dark there :-\

  4. borat

    opt-out should always be opt-in

    It totally sucks that so many of these common applications (e.g. flash player, java JRE etc.) come bundled with "opt-out" installers for unrelated programs. The amount of times I sit at someone's PC and see shortcuts to "install openoffice" and the stinking yahoo toolbar that primarily, the customer does not want.

    Sure they should have un-checked the box on install, but this "opt-out" mentality preys on the novice user who just click next -> next -> next without reading anything and ends up in the customer's PC being cluttered with stuff they didn't ask for and don't want.

  5. hj

    i wonder

    how much this has to do with google taking openoffice out of google pack?

  6. Anonymous Coward

    Average user too stupid to understand a tick box

    <RANT> I repair PCs in the home. So see normal, dumb, lusers. And my God is the average user dumb. No one has ever taught them how to use a PC, and generally they are scared to change ANYTHING.

    So the average home PC has two or three toolbars already. (Client last week had SIX!!!) Adobe Acrobat installs Google, And now we have Sun whacking MSN (Or is it Yahoo?) onto the machines. Gawd only knows where the "ASK" toolbar is poopping up from.

    These adverts should be OPT-IN only. i.e. the user should have to tick the box if he\she wants the item. Then, if they don't understand what it is, they are not forced to install it. (Or pointlessly download OpenOffice when they also don't want that)

    And why does Java NOT remove it's old versions? The average home luser machine is covered with multiple installs of Java, and multiple versions of the installer. All eating into disk space.

    These companies forget who own these machines. It's not as if I drive into a petrol station, and then drive out again towing advertising hoardings.... but that is near enough what they force on people with this crud.

    </RANT> (Where is the "steam from ears" icon?) Anon 'cos I know my clients are reading. And I shouldn't really complain - if it wasn't for id10t lusers, I wouldn't have a job.

  7. Anonymous Coward

    @AC - average user

    Gawd only knows where the "ASK" toolbar is poopping up from.

    I think you meant pooping.

  8. Anonymous Coward

    Re: "...and you have Internet Explorer installed"

    I'm pretty sure that it will only install the toolbar if you are using IE to connect, not if you just have IE installed. The Yahoo tool bar goes to Firefox users.

  9. Ian Michael Gumby

    No Wonder Where Sun is getting their *other* revenue from!


    That would explain their MySQL and Other software services bringing in 34+ million last qtr.

    Note that they were trying to give the impression that it was MySQL revenue, however, this "opt-out software download" isn't free to Microsoft. They *are* paying Sun per each download where the user accepts the install.

    Just goes to show you how desperate Sun is to get revenue ...

  10. Darren B
    Thumb Down

    Why do we need these toolbars anymore?

    Erm, don't most "latest version" browsers have the functions these provide built in? I am sure most punters running JRE will be upto date with their Firefox/Opera/IE* delete as appropriate.

  11. Mike

    Go for it Sun

    Java's a fine product that they're giving away. If that is how they want to monitize it, then I say good luck.

    If you don't want the software, uncheck the box. If your time is too valuable to spend reading a line of text on an installer, then by all means, let the browser tool be an indication for others of what kind of person you are. Or hire someone who knows what they're doing to do things for you.

    If I am using a computer that has lots of toolbars on the browser, then I know the person doesn't know what the hell they're doing. In that sense, the toolbars provide great information if you know how to use it.

  12. Craig

    Mention Microsoft and suddenly people get out their pitchforks

    Sheesh, for bloody years companies have been using this 'checked by default' subterfuge to install third-party software, and it's only when a Microsoft add-on is involved that someone decides to write an article intended to incite the pitchfork wielding plebians...

    Drop the bigoted attitudes, hell it's not even bigoted, it's more like racism in the software industry! If you're going to bitch and whine when checkboxes are enabled by default then bitch and whine with equal ferocity at ALL software developers.

  13. mittfh

    Toolbars are only half the problem...

    How about boxes with no AV protection whatsoever? Either (a) they haven't got any installed, or (b) the three month trial of SAV has expired...

    Oh, the joys of when I worked on a helldesk - remoting over to their computer, killing every process and service I don't recognise, installing a proper AV client, then grabbing a coffee whilst Spybot (small download, useful for getting a rough idea of how trashed their system is) racks up all the usual suspects - before it gets anywhere near the cookies folder (the classic way some anti malware over reports - count every tracking cookie as an infection!)

    Half an hour later, getting peed off because I've got other calls to do, inform them they'll need a chargeable engineer visit...

    Meanwhile the other day I discovered a luser who'd decided to get rid of SAV (yay!) - only to replace it with AVG Free (oh dear!) - but still thought Windows Defender was a proper firewall (this gets worse!) And the luser? A former school ICT Coordinator...from a business background...

  14. Tom

    Enough with the toolbars

    Toolbars are at best, adware, and at worst, spyware. Intelligent individuals know how to type,, or even into their browsers and they know how to set bookmarks and their home pages if needed often enough. Intelligent individuals do not want crap clogging up their operating systems, browsers, or other oft used applications. Finally, intelligent individuals do not want a toolbar monopolizing their search engine experience.

    On the other hand, ignoramuses thoughtlessly install any old crap riding the coattails of anything else they thoughtlessly install. Without ignoramuses we wouldn't have a world full of zombie computers spewing viagra, mortgage, and poker spam.

    Isn't it time to require operator's licenses for computers?

  15. Ceiling Cat

    This'll teach people . . .

    absolutely nothing.

    I still wind up having to remove at least 2 toolbars a year from the systems I repair.

    You'd think that for what they pay me to fix their broken systems, my users would learn . . . but they don't.

    The penguin, because my (l)users are scared to death of it.

  16. Nano nano


    I've never had an answer from Sun as to why the Java Update scheduler widget under Windows runs continuously - whereas it could just run each time at startup and then die.

    Just another annoyance ...

  17. Richard
    Thumb Up

    Invalid License

    Has anyone else noticed the license agreement for the Yahoo toolbar is skipped? It specifically says "By clicking 'I Agree' below..." but do you see such a button?

    License-free yahoo toolbar anyone?

    -- Richard

  18. B

    Second rate Safari browser

    You mean the browser that was the first one to pass the latest Acid test? The one that adhere's to web standards? The one Ballmer recently verbally toyed with adopting?

    Just because you didn't like the fact that Apple included it in its download (which it shouldn't have done) doesn't make the browser second rate. Get over your ridiculous anti-anything-Apple bias.

  19. Turgut Kalfaoglu

    ruling needed

    I wish there was a law about NOT installing programs that are not necessary for the programs you are installing. It is what a trojan program does, and it reduces the value of the program being installed - and reduces the consumer confidence in that company.

  20. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    @ WRONG

    "Christ, Sun, Apple, Google and Microsoft are as bad as each other some times!"

    OK, we've got the Jesus phone, but surely that's as close as Christ gets to being as bad as the others. It's Christian (funda)mentalists that piggyback bigotry, extreme right wing politics et al on the back of a message of peace and love, not the Guv'nor.

  21. Yfrwlf

    first off..

    @B: Safari isn't noted as being one of the best browsers, that's pretty widely accepted, I know many Mac users who easily choose Firefox over it, so maybe you're the one who needs to get over it, but, you know, use what you like. I just prefer a browser that didn't crash a lot is all, and that was my experience with it, not to mention I just don't care about Safari any way and like Firefox and it's features and plug-ins much better, but to each their own.

    @Darren B: I like your response the best. Who in the hell ever installs these stupid toolbars any way? I'm very capable of clicking on my Firefox quick search box thank you, I don't need a massive bar taking up page real estate, let alone ads if any.

    Penguin, cause it's shit like this that I love not having to deal with, but I'm sure it's only a matter of time before I have to start complaining too as Linux becomes more ad targeted. ;)

This topic is closed for new posts.

Other stories you might like