The Register Home Page

back to article Brit tech tycoon Mike Lynch cleared of all charges in US Autonomy fraud trial

Mike Lynch, founder and CEO of Autonomy, has been acquitted of criminal fraud and conspiracy charges arising from the 2011 sale of the British software company to Hewlett-Packard. On Thursday, a federal court jury in San Francisco cleared Lynch of all 15 charges – 14 counts of wire fraud and one count of conspiracy. Co- …

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Hilarious

        Lesjak should have resigned but did not. What's the point of a CFO who is OK to oversee $8bn of shareholder value being pissed away? Worthless.

        1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

          Re: Hilarious

          I guess that depends on how someone in the C-suite values their principles over their pay packet. The C-suite usually have large portions of their pay packet tangled up in shares, options, bonuses and other tax-twisting schemes that might make it costly to just quit on a point of principle rather than wait it out, hoping it blows over.

    1. Missing Semicolon Silver badge

      Re: Hilarious

      Previous experience made this a wise move.

    2. Vulture@C64

      Re: Hilarious

      He had the money to employ sufficient lawyers to get the job done properly, most of us wouldn't have anywhere near enough cash to do that so we'd sink without sight in the US system faced with similar charges.

      1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge
        Joke

        Re: Hilarious

        May be Trump will ditch his legal team for Lynch's

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Hilarious

          The biggest problem with Trump's legal team is almost always going to be that they have Trump for a client.

          That might sound like a joke, but it isn't really.

          1. Michael Wojcik

            Re: Hilarious

            This is true, but Trump also has a weakness for rubbish lawyers who stroke his ego, and a tendency to fire or lose the competent ones. His legal teams have been weighted toward terrible lawyers. (Legal Eagle did a good breakdown a while back.)

        2. Dave@Home

          Re: Hilarious

          They clear said "He had the money to employ sufficient lawyers to get the job done properly..."

          now, all evidence at the moment....

      2. ShortLegs

        Re: Hilarious

        "He had the money to employ sufficient lawyers to get the job done properly, most of us wouldn't have anywhere near enough cash to do that so we'd sink without sight in the US system faced with similar charges."

        Moot, as none of us here would be in the position to sell a company for £11billion anyway.

      3. Peter 6

        Re: Hilarious

        To be fair though, the average man in the street doesn't mastermind sales of companies to big multinationals to the tune of billions so that point doesn't really make sense.

    3. Jamie Jones Silver badge

      Re: Hilarious

      When the unlikely happens, it doesn't negate the unlikelyness.

    4. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

      Re: Hilarious

      "I don't know whether Lynch is guilty, but I recall all the histrionic wailing about Lynch being extradited and the doom fortold about how he would never see justice in America and instead spend the rest of his life unjustly imprisoned in a grim federal Supermax trading blowjobs for cigarettes. How are we feeling now, fellas?"

      Surprised :-)

      Remember, the opinions you described were based an past experience of cases in the US justice system. And those opinions were sometimes from US residents, so it's not just uninformed outsiders looking in who see a (sometimes) bias in that system.

  1. ANymoos

    Amazed it got this far given a jury reached a not guilty verdict so quickly.

    Almost like US prosecutors were acting as an arm of a big US tech company.

    1. Tam Lin

      The US prosecutors missed out on a really cushy job

      HP pays their lawyers a lot better than the Feds do - although why HP even employ lawyers is weird, inasmuch as they never listen to them.

  2. AlanSh
    Pint

    Good decision

    It was always 'buyer beware' in situations like these. HP should never have begun this travesty.

    Time for --------->

    1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

      Re: Good decision

      Popcorn futures just dropped of a cliff.

  3. Jason Hindle

    It had the whiff of corporate arse covering from the start

    And I'm guessing a case like this has a high bar for conviction.

    For those saying we should have had more faith in the US justice system… The way prosecutors behave there makes the system incompatible* with ours. I will always treat extradition requests with scepticism.

    * Strong arming confessions of guilt through a system of plea bargaining? FFS!

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: It had the whiff of corporate arse covering from the start

      Even in investigation our systems differ wildly - in the US police officers can lie during an investigation as long as it does not “shock the conscience of the court or the community", whereas here there's a number of laws which basically mean we're not allowed to. For example you can't sit there saying "Look mate, we got it all on CCTV from everywhere" when you catch them wanking in a bush outside a church or whatever.

      I guess it comes down to the difference between interrogations and interviews!

    2. John Sager

      Re: It had the whiff of corporate arse covering from the start

      That does happen here. A case on TV recently had a couple of guys charged with attempted murder who pled guilty to GBH with intent. Avoided a life sentence.

    3. RegGuy1

      Re: It had the whiff of corporate arse covering from the start

      Isn't that what our wonderful Post Office Ltd did to its postmasters --say you stole it (although you claim you didn't) and we'll go easier on you. What's the difference?

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: It had the whiff of corporate arse covering from the start

        That was a "private" prosecution - for some probably historical reason the PO were able to prosecute people themselves.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    In a few years' time...

    ...this will be repeated by whatever AI company HP is about to waste a tonne of money on...

  5. Error403

    Definitely the right decision

    Attempting to paint Mike Lynch as "Dr Evil", which is what the prosecution tried to do, backfired completely. When I heard that he was going to take the stand himself (opening himself up to cross-examination, hence a risky tactic), I knew he'd have a chance of being found not guilty. Having met him myself on many occasions, the worst you can say about him, is that he's blunt. My impression of him is just what he says he is, a visionary technologist with a very good business instinct.

    1. amanfromMars 1 Silver badge
      Pint

      The Worthy Payback of Just Revenge, ... a Future Model Cloned for Autonomous Success

      My impression of him is just what he says he is, a visionary technologist with a very good business instinct. ..... Error403

      What he plans to focus his very good future business instinct interest on, should he again wish to strap himself into a leading visionary technology vehicle, will be more than just interesting news to more than just an interested and interesting few.

      Bravo, Mike. Have a well deserved beer on me. You certainly earned it .

    2. Michael Wojcik

      Re: Definitely the right decision

      I have to say that I haven't seen much evidence for the "visionary technologist" bit.

  6. CorwinX

    Caveat Emptor...

    ... the principle that the buyer alone is responsible for checking the quality and suitability of goods before a purchase is made.

    Someone should have clued HP up on that.

    1. Pascal Monett Silver badge

      Re: Caveat Emptor...

      It's been a long time since HP had a clue.

  7. CorwinX

    Also...

    Surely HP should have sent their own auditors into Autonomy to delve into its financials before writing the cheque?

    Perhaps it's them they should be sueing.

    1. Boris the Cockroach Silver badge
      Happy

      Re: Also...

      They did

      And they paid up. cant remember the name of the auditers HP employed , but I guess when you're the CEO of HP and determined to pay whatever for a company, you're not going to listen anyone who nay says..... then you get fired.....

      1. Michael Wojcik

        Re: Also...

        It was KPMG, and Apotheker fired them after they delivered the preliminary report, and admitted he didn't read even that in its entirety.

    2. Cruachan Silver badge

      Re: Also...

      A settlement was agreed

      https://www.theregister.com/2021/03/29/deloitte_settled_hpe_lynch_lawsuit_45m/

      Deloitte were also fined for some of their failings at a tribunal, however most of the HP bigwigs were forced to admit on the stand that they had (at best) only glanced at the reports anyway.

      1. ecofeco Silver badge

        Re: Also...

        It was ALWAYS this.

        HP was hoisted by its own petard.

        Some of us said so from the beginning.

        1. Michael Strorm Silver badge
          Trollface

          HP no longer stands for Hewlett Packard, so...

          > HP was hoisted by its own petard.

          ...I think we just figured out what HP stands for now.

          1. John Sager

            Re: HP no longer stands for Hewlett Packard, so...

            On holiday in France years ago I bought a T shirt with a slightly modified HP logo. The wording underneath was Hors Service.

      2. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

        Re: Also...

        Deloitte were Autonomy's auditors. And so got fined for irregularities in their job of doing that.

        HP themselves couldn't send auditors in - because this was a takeover under British rules - which are a lot less friendly. In US takeovers it's pretty common to got quite wide access to a company's books and data, in exchange for a large fee if the takeover falls apart. In the UK it's traditional to get a lot less information. You send people in to ask questions, you might not always get answers. If you don't like the lack on info, you can always walk away. You're supposed to be able to trust the figures you're given - because they're audited. But you're less likely to see the underlying books.

  8. alain williams Silver badge

    Does Mike Lynch get compensation ...

    for having wasted 13 years of his life being chased, and having his liberty infringed, by HP ?

    1. Gordon 10

      Re: Does Mike Lynch get compensation ...

      It aint over. Likely will never be until Lynch is dead or bankrupt.

      HPE are still after compo (£4bn?) in the UK for winning the UK civil case.

      1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

        Re: Does Mike Lynch get compensation ...

        "HPE are still after compo (£4bn?) in the UK for winning the UK civil case."

        Were they actually awarded compo is that something still being talked about? If the award hasn't been finalised, I suspect this result will severely impact any award based on the civil case outcome. It might even be less than Lynches counter suit for defamation.

  9. Altrux

    Auto-know-better

    I worked for his horrible company for a while, in the Cambridge HQ. Honestly the worst place I've ever worked. The classic "burn you out like matchsticks" corporate culture. I've never felt happier than when I escaped. Lynch and his henchmen never bothered meeting junior employees. Far too conceited and up themselves. Watching this very, very long case has been incredibly cathartic, whatever the final outcome!

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Auto-know-better

      Are there many companies of any sort of scale where the board bothers itself with junior staffers? Honest question. And also, being conceited isn't illegal or deserving of being dragged through the US Federal justice system.

      1. Altrux

        Re: Auto-know-better

        Richard Branson provides a good example here. Plenty of companies understand how to make a good culture, but too many still don't.

    2. Dave@Home

      Re: Auto-know-better

      Being a prick isn't a crime, thankfully

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Surprise of the Year !!!

    Don't know Mike Lynch or have any connection with HP/Autonomy *but* this IMO is the right result.

    HP did not perform 'Due Diligence' due to greed and desire to gain Autonomy before anyone else.

    Autonomy gained the best price it could get !!!

    HP had 'buyers remorse' and tried via every means possible to blame someone else.

    So surprised that a US of A court was able to find in favour of the *not* US of A company !!!

    HP need to give up the fight at this point before it costs yet more money ... but I expect an appeal which always seems to be possible *if* you have enough money .... See Trump for this in action !!!

    :)

    1. ecofeco Silver badge

      Re: Surprise of the Year !!!

      HP did not perform 'Due Diligence' due to greed and desire to gain Autonomy before anyone else.

      Autonomy gained the best price it could get !!!

      HP had 'buyers remorse' and tried via every means possible to blame someone else.

      Sums it up perfectly.

  11. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Federal acquittals are extremely rare

    It’s worth noting that vanishingly few people fight federal criminal cases, and even fewer of them succeed. According to Pew, in 2022, only 1.4% of federal defendants went to trial, and only 0.4% of defendants were acquitted. Most people plead guilty.

    Whatever you think of Lynch, he had brass balls to take on the US government and win.

    I think the SFO needs to urgently explain why it ceded authority to the US, when it had concluded there was no realistic prospect of convicting Lynch in the UK. At the time it stated, “In order not to undermine the US-based investigation we are unable to go into further detail at this stage regarding the basis of these decisions”.

    1. diodesign

      Re: Federal acquittals are extremely rare

      This is a really good point. Yes, vast majority of US DoJ cases are won by Uncle Sam.

      Not just the trial, Lynch had to go through extradition too. And won. That speaks for itself. Just that damages case in England to go.

      C.

    2. Androgynous Cupboard Silver badge

      Re: Federal acquittals are extremely rare

      The SFO has managed to bring about 10 cases in the last 20 years, barely, and has lost some important ones in the process. They're not really fit for purpose. Private Eye has been kicking them for years, it's quite eye-opening.

    3. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Federal acquittals are extremely rare

      The defendents' legal representatives are going to being finding their professional reputations lit up in stars. After pulling this result off (and, as you say, very much against the prevailing course of events), there's a good chance that they'll become the "go to" lawyers for any business person with a tricky altercation with the authorities to survive.

      There's surely going to have to be questions on both sides of the Atlantic as to "how has it come to this?". Criminal charges rejected by a jury so quickly suggests there was not much to the charges in the first place. I don't really care about Mike Lynch as such, but if US prosecutors and British courts combined are unable to weigh up the merits of a case with reasonable accuracy then the extradition system is undermined. There's much to criticise about current UK / US extradition arrangements.

      It'd be no good the judicial / prosecutorial authorities here or there pointing to an acquital as evidence that the extradition was sound, no harm done. No matter if you're a billionaire businessmen or a just an ordinary Joe, extradition is not a zero-cost, zero consequence process. Far from it. Extradition should happen only if it needs to happen, and this case is a hard to ignore indicator that the authorities either side of the pond have ****ed this one up. Next time, pretty much the same people could be making pretty much the same kind of arguments about a case involving you.

      I suspect that in this case the extradition process and the people who carry it out (US prosecutors, British courts) have probably been skewed by the "it's a lot of money" angle. If that's true, then that's an extremely bad thing. The "how much money?" angle should matter only when it comes to sentencing - if it gets that far. It should not play a part in the merits of the case and whether the case goes ahead or not.

      As a Brit, I'll be extremely interested to see if the British Judiciary ask themselves any questions about what they got wrong. I doubt they will; the judiciary seem not to be too keen in looking at the effectiveness of their own activities. The Post Office Horizon scandal is another example. There's a lot of inquiries going on into what's gone wrong there, but so far as I know none of them are asking why the Judiciary themselves did not spot that 700+ court cases, all very similar, had come before them to be heard. The Judiciary are there in part to ensure that cases are run safely, yet they demonstrated little by way of curiosity as to why hundreds of cases, all very similar, all very "computer says so" in nature, were suddenly being brought before them. Seven hundred. I mean, how disinterested can the judiciary get? Law and order depends entirely on the rule of law, but it's been ruling rather ineptly of late.

      p.s. I've no connection to any of the effected parties in HP vs Lynch et al, or to anyone involved in the Post Office scandal.

  12. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Good. Onus was alway on HP to do due diligence. They failed.

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    You’d have to be a morin…

    You’d have to be a moron to pay over market for an AI company in 2011. That stuff was never going to take off..

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like