The Register Home Page

back to article OpenAI could go from AI pioneer to AI's BlackBerry, says Forrester

OpenAI may be headed for Wall Street, but one analyst firm is already warning enterprise customers not to get too attached. In a note published alongside OpenAI's confidential IPO filing, Forrester urged companies to keep their AI options open, arguing that today's market leader could easily become tomorrow's cautionary tale. " …

  1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    WeWorks

    The lock-in warning rather assumes there'll be something worth locking into. Plenty of enterprises are already past the honeymoon and into the hangover phase, where the maths gets uncomfortable. Frontier models cost more than the engineers using them, and because the output is voluminous and inconsistent (adaptive reasoning being a polite term for "different answer every time"), you end up hiring more humans to scrutinise what the machine produced. At which point someone in finance asks the obvious question.

    So the quiet trend is reversion: humans doing the work, AI used conservatively at the edges. That's a problem for vendors who've capitalised themselves on the assumption of exponential consumption. Until inference costs fall by an order of magnitude, they're sitting on warehouses of depreciating silicon that nobody can afford to run at the advertised scale.

    Which rather explains the sudden enthusiasm for IPOs. It's not a victory lap, it's a liquidity event before the music stops. Forrester worries OpenAI might be AI's BlackBerry. But BlackBerry was killed by a better product. The less flattering scenario is that there's no iPhone coming, just a row of WeWorks with GPUs.

    1. Bebu sa Ware Silver badge
      Coffee/keyboard

      Re: past the honeymoon

      > Plenty of enterprises are already past the honeymoon

      And now only waiting for the maintenance orders to turn up. ;)

    2. This post has been deleted by its author

    3. vtcodger Silver badge

      Re: WeWorks

      "Until inference costs fall by an order of magnitude, they're sitting on warehouses of depreciating silicon that nobody can afford to run at the advertised scale."

      You reckon one order of magnitude is enough? It's not like we plebs have any idea at all what the actual cost of AI inference is. I wouldn't be shocked to discover that the AI mongers don't know either.

  2. Paratiritis

    Commoditization

    Considering that the services provided by the rival AI companies are so similar and that they all follow standards, it seems inevitable that they will eventually become commoditized and the companies, as they stand, would become utility providers. The rush to the monetization, which would be the means to enhance their services and to diversify, through the IPOs, looks like an indicator that this is fast approaching.

    1. cyberdemon Silver badge
      Coffee/keyboard

      Re: Commoditization

      > AI companies would become utility providers

      I almost choked on my lunch with that one!

      Utility providers indeed.. where the utility is negative..

      That's almost like saying if the human population suffered an epidemic of brain-worms that caused people to go gaga and empty their wallets into the brain-worm benevolent fund, the brain-worms would be utility providers..

      1. Paratiritis

        Re: Commoditization

        The Utility Provider mention is very often used to indicate that a provided service will eventually become so ubiquitous and similar between different providers that it becomes similar to water and electricity.

        As an example of AI already being served as a service is in your IDE, which already allows you to select whichever AI provider you want for coding assistance.

        The persistence or not of such a model or any individual provider will depend entirely on the demand and willingness to pay for the service they provide.

        Indeed the quality of the service, which you mention with relation to AI, is always one of many factors involved, in the selection of one service or other, or indeed the continuation of the type of service altogether. For example, electric cars were built in the 1890s but for various reasons were eclipsed at the time.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Commoditization

          This is effectively the premise of the Canadian programme of “AI for All”

          To provide a national AI service for the country as a utility.

          Obviously it cannot happen all at once but the model is there - as always it will come down to implementation i.e. money

    2. Cubbie Roo

      Re: Commoditization

      @Paratiritis

      That would be fine if the SW provided by the big 3 actually worked well enough for predictable & cost effective results. They don't. Most folk realise it's just a snake eating it's own tail, and quite amusing the VCs are -apparently- the last demographic to realise this.

  3. amanfromMars 1 Silver badge

    Two outta three aint bad and AI aint no dumbass fools' useful tool

    The firm [Forrester] argues that OpenAI faces what it calls a "trifecta" of challenges: persuade consumers to use its agents instead of rivals', convince enterprises to build around its technology, and stay ahead in the race toward AGI.

    I'm calling out MRDA on Forrester ..... for they would say that, wouldn't they ...... however, in the same way that one does not need to persuade consumers to use/buy into a Bentley rather than a Rolls Royce, or a Porsche rather than a McLaren, and once the technology realises the bold in-house requirement that develops and releases simple tools that effectively target, address and remedy enterprise problems, will the race to stay ahead be run and won in the enterprise sector ...... with the race ahead toward a personal AGI assistant next to be considered convenient for anyone and/or everyone worthy of assistance ........ although that number may not be as great as one might have reasonably expected it to be ..... for humanity in general has a long and sad and mad history evidencing its squandering, perversion and corruption of almighty gifts.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Two outta three aint bad and AI aint no dumbass fools' useful tool

      Not sure the almighty has much to do with this.., even more so if s/he’s a Jehovah’s Witness

  4. Arkitekt

    Except...

    Difference being... Blackberries are infinitely more useful.

  5. a_yank_lurker

    WeWork not Blackberry

    WeWork is a better example for OpenAI than Blackberry. Blackberries were a profitable product before the iPhone. Sam the Scam's fraud is a money loser right now and probably will never turn a profit. Much like WeWork was basically a scam that imploded when its IPO hit. In fact, none of the AI frauds are profitable and probably will never turn a profit.

    1. Clausewitz4.1 Bronze badge
      Devil

      Re: WeWork not Blackberry

      Sam is already rich enough, he managed to divert some funds doing partnerships or receiving stocks from other business.

  6. _wojtek

    OpenAI is passé

    I don't remember when was the last time I actually used ChatGPT and not the (better) competition...

  7. Groo The Wanderer - A Canuck Silver badge

    They're all going to become "cautionary tales" about how foolish it is to believe a pyramid scam's fraud and hype. But the investment community won't learn a damned thing; they'll chase the next hype bubble in 5-10 years with the same abject ignorance about how what is being sold actually works and what it really can do vs. the empty promises of corporate advertising and media posts.

  8. DS999 Silver badge

    How much AI will be running on device and therefore "free"?

    Microsoft has Copilot, Apple has Siri, Google has Gemini. The more useful AI becomes the greater the on-chip resources that will be devoted to running local models to handle most of your needs. There will be a role for off device AI for stuff where on device resources are insufficient but even there it isn't clear who wins.

    Even once you move off device some businesses might prefer to set up their own AI cluster running open source models to insure none of their proprietary data escapes and to reduce monthly AI bills. Open source models probably will remain behind proprietary ones, but as both gain capability is there a point where diminishing returns are reached and open source models are "good enough".

    These trillion dollar valuations are assuming a lot about what the future will look like - just like those who assumed future smartphones would look a lot like Blackberry/Palm/Windows Mobile with a built in keyboard.

    1. Groo The Wanderer - A Canuck Silver badge

      Re: How much AI will be running on device and therefore "free"?

      You underestimate the greed with which to lock in is being performed. And you're also under the delusion that AI is "useful" instead of a source of more problems and issues with code that you don't understand 'cause you never did understand why it was coded the way it was. You're not a programmer; you're a babysitter for a machine.

      Don't forget, Microsoft is even thinking about making the operating system a subscription service! All of the AI companies are trying to do the same thing - force you to pay, and pay through the nose.

    2. Groo The Wanderer - A Canuck Silver badge

      Re: How much AI will be running on device and therefore "free"?

      Also, don't forget that even with local application software, it is common to have to pay subscription and licensing fees to use it. Just because it's on your local device does not make it "free" in any way.

  9. Zzxap

    Was chatting with Gemini (natch) about the future of AI companies. Claude has been integrated into Oracle. Copilot is on every Microsoft product. Gemini, owned by Google is about to land in millions of iPhones in a Siri hat. Who does ChatGPT with that sort of backing have?

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    We can hope. And cheer.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon