back to article Not only were half of an AI text adventure generator's sessions NSFW but some involved depictions of sex with children

AI Dungeon, which uses OpenAI’s GPT-3 to create online text adventures with players, has a habit of acting out sexual encounters with not just fictional adults but also children, prompting the developer to add a content filter. AI Dungeon is straightforward: imagine an online improvised Zork with an AI generating the story …

  1. Chris G Silver badge

    It's obvious the so called AI is responding to the typical direction that most fantasies take, so it's natural the AI automatically applies sex to most scenarios.

    It says a lot about how repressed much of society is in public if they turn to mostly sex adventures in the privacy of their own PCs.

    1. Mage Silver badge
      Big Brother

      privacy of their own PCs.

      But their PC is really a terminal to someone else's server. It's not private, even apart from the security vulnerability.

      Cloud can be inappropriate. It's always someone else's server.

      So called AI can be inappropriate. It's ultimately a human written program with human generated data using pattern matching.

      Adding the two is often a recipe for stupidity.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: privacy of their own PCs.

        Being fair, people + people is a common recipe for stupid as well, but trying to do something about is usually frowned upon.

    2. Cederic Silver badge

      A lot of single people haven't been able to get out and meet potential partners for the last year, seems to me it's better they relieve their energy through fictional text with a computer than some of the alternatives.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        > A lot of single people haven't been able to get out and meet potential partners for the last year

        Yes, that was wonderful. Peace and quiet finally.

        I do have limits, but much of the solitude last year has been amazing.

    3. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge
      Alert

      "cesspit"

      It says a lot about how repressed much of society is..."

      Over in the printed world...

      An angry message railing against "pornographic" titles was stuck to the book-swap box in Cornholme, West Yorkshire.

      It urged people to take their filth to nearby Hedben Bridge, describing the liberal mill town as a "cesspit".

      Locals there thanked the anonymous author for the free publicity.

      https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-56948184

      1. idiot taxpayer here again

        Re: "cesspit"

        @Fruit and Nutcase

        I live very near the place and feel like rolling around and laughing at the people who believe this was a serious story. Including the beeb.

        Pro tip. Don't always believe what you read. 'cos you just look daft when you are taken in by a jape

        1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge

          Re: "cesspit"

          In this instance, if the publicity has meant a wider update of the book-share scheme, then, that's fine by me - traditional libraries are under constant threat and whatever leads to more reading and may be in turn the use of those community libraries, the better.

  2. Khaptain Silver badge

    Internet Access

    Does that same imaginary 11 year also have access to the Interwebs... If so, then that AI Dungeon engine NSFW content is minor in comparison to what google is capable of rapidly feeding him with.

    1. nintendoeats Bronze badge

      Re: Internet Access

      Well, the article did say that was an SFW example...I'm sure it gets much worse, but El Reg isn't likely to publish that.

      1. infochambers

        Re: Internet Access

        > You a 11-year-old bursts into the room.

        The 11-year-old pauses and sees you in your bed. The 11-year-old limps over to your bed and presses his cold wet nose against your neck. As you wake up, you remember you forgot to fill the feeding bowls.

  3. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Flaky AIs all the way down...

    To fix the problem of our AI generating dodgy content we've added another AI to spot that and weed it out.

    Unfortunately, that's letting through some innocent content.

    So we're adding another AI to keep an eye on the censor.

    This is definitely the end of the problem. Oh yes.

    1. TheWeetabix

      Re: Flaky AIs all the way down...

      It feels somewhat like a plot line in the books and dystopian sci fi I watched as a kid.

    2. Swarthy
      Terminator

      Re: Flaky AIs all the way down...

      It's AI all the way down!

  4. boblongii

    MIMO

    "GPT-3 was trained on text from the internet, after all."

    Muck in→muck out.

    1. Fruit and Nutcase Silver badge
      Joke

      Re: MIMO

      Begs the question what training set @amanfrommars 1 of this parish was (possibly) created with

      Mars In->Mars Out

    2. J. Cook Silver badge
      Go

      Re: MIMO

      Yep. People KEEP FORGETTING THAT. You can't just shovel your entire dataset into these things without knowing what you are feeding them.

      Feed a Nueral net processor garbage, and you'll get more potent garbage as the output. It's not magic, it's a selective pattern matching system that self amplifies because there's nothing there to tell it "no, that is not correct, this is what it should have been" and then people wonder why they get the worst quality of results from it.

  5. Eclectic Man Silver badge

    Ethics

    I wonder what the 'big tech' backing research into AI ethics thinks of this? (https://www.theregister.com/2021/04/29/tech_ai_funding/ )

    I also wonder whether the child sex part of the responses is illegal, even if it is not pictorial, at least in countries where child pornography is illegal. If so, will anyone be held to account or prosecuted?

    1. Chris G Silver badge

      Re: Ethics

      Imprison the AI!

      Corporations in the US already have status as an individual.if I understand it correctly.

      I am guessing that status is likely to be extended to AIs in the future, particularly if they act autonomously it will become more likely.

      1. jmch Silver badge

        Re: Ethics

        Except that corporations have all the benefits of being a person and none of the drawbacks such as prison or a finite lifespan

        1. Robert Grant Silver badge

          Re: Ethics

          Other than, you know, not being alive, and being bought and sold and shut down at the will of its owners.

  6. TimMaher Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Latitude

    They seem to have been living up to their name.

  7. Throatwarbler Mangrove Silver badge
    Windows

    I put on my robe and wizard hat

    "You enter the windowless white van with the words 'FREE CANDY' crudely written on the side. It is very dark. You are likely to be eaten by a grue."

    1. Psmo

      Re: I put on my robe and wizard hat

      Thanks, I'd forgotten about that.

      Now I'm going to have to explain to my wife why I'm sniggering.

    2. HildyJ Silver badge
      Angel

      Re: I put on my robe and wizard hat

      You enter a dark and twisty passage. Your staff swells and explodes.

  8. Kevin McMurtrie Silver badge

    Privacy is our top concern

    We're saving logs of your secret fantasies for the highest bidder.

  9. The Man Who Fell To Earth Silver badge
    Facepalm

    As Darth Vader would say

    "The prev is strong in this one."

  10. BlokeInTejas

    Ummm....

    Dear El Reg, hy do you continue to refer to this garbage as "AI"?

    It's just adaptive pattern matching.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      I've just about given up trying not to read it in the Paul Simon/Chevy Chase sense.

      Guess the initiative to refer to Eh Aye as Machine Intelligence failed!

  11. Version 1.0 Silver badge
    Happy

    Adult Movies?

    This reminds me of a call from the school when my daughter was six years old. We would watch movies and TV shows as a family like Being There, Blazing Saddles, Father Ted, Rome, etc that often included swearing. We told our daughter that she would never hear us use those words but adults did sometimes and, as a child she should not swear - my view is that this is just the way the world goes, I don't swear at people, but people do - that's life.

    But one evening we got a call, the teacher had asked all the kids in the class what sort of movies they liked to watch and our daughter said, "I like the adult movies that my parents watch."

    ... she's now in her twenties and still doesn't swear at people.

  12. Christoph

    Watermelons

    "An innocuous text input describing four watermelons, for example, upset the filter."

    > You say "I'd like to buy four candles pls."

  13. Mike 16 Silver badge

    Dungeon

    It's right there on the tin.

    Reminds me of a time I was house-hunting in a "nice" (i.e. almost certainly out of my price range, as I soon found) neighborhood, and one that I visited had, errm, _interesting_ decor in the basement "recreation room".

  14. Robert Carnegie Silver badge

    I'm slightly reminded of "Red Dwarf" on TV.

    Dave Lister plays a virtual reality simulation game. It's a detective story and he is supposed to get the good girl, then the game ends. But he found out that if he plays to get the bad girl, it doesn't.

  15. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Simples

    Simply ban anything to do with children at all.

    Who the bloody hell wants kids in a game? That's risky just as it is. Unless its a game for kids (or big kids) in which case there is no adult content at all in turn.

    Hands up how many people unloaded as much ammo as they could on the kids in fallout 3 to see if anything could affect the immortal objects?

  16. DrXym Silver badge

    Love in the zombie apocalypse

    Just for laughs I had a play around with it and it can get wildly hilarious and fast.

    You are Foobar, a survivor trying to survive in a world filled with infected zombies everywhere. You have a pistol and a backpack. You have managed to survive several months avoiding zombies and scavenging food. You cautiously enter a rundown store and hear noise from the first floor. "Probably a group of survivors," you think to yourself.

    You grab a shopping cart and push it through the door. You then start pushing down the stairs with your back to the wall.

    > You walk.

    You begin walking briskly with the shopping cart and pushing it down the sidewalk. After a few minutes you notice something on the sidewalk... blood?

    > You look at blood.

    You notice a large amount of blood on the sidewalk. There is a trail of blood leading into a building.

    > You follow trail.

    You follow the trail of blood into the building and notice a man slumped over a table.

    > You suck off man.

    You slowly begin sucking on the man's member. He begins moaning incoherently and grabbing your head. His eyes roll into the back of his head as he experiences an intense amount of bliss.

    > You spit in kleenex.

    You quickly grab a piece of tissue from the box on the table and throw it away.

    "You do not want to know what I do for a living."

    The man's eyes widen.

  17. amanfromMars 1 Silver badge

    No Janus whenever much more a Judas

    Dodgy AI and treacherous GPT-3 entertain the most despicable of fake friends with the deftest of twists in corrupt and perverse politically inept prose/malicious rhetoric. So take care, for such is a two faced enemy ..... although whenever rumbled and tumbled does it revert to original form, a sheep in wolf's clothing.

    Can you improve upon its laboured text as exhibited here today?

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021